A qualitative study of the barriers to commissioning social and therapeutic horticulture in mental health care.

BACKGROUND: Social and Therapeutic Horticulture (STH) is a process where trained practitioners work with plants and people to improve an individual's physical and psychological health, communication and thinking skills. Evidence suggests that STH can support individuals with mental ill-health, however, current commissioning of STH within mental health care is limited. This study aimed to understand the barriers to commissioning STH in mental health care and to identify potential solutions to barriers, to support more widespread availability of services.  METHODS: Individuals with a role in mental health care commissioning from across the UK were invited to take part in semi-structured interviews via zoom. Interviews explored factors influencing the mental health services they commission or refer to, their perception of the role of STH in mental health care and the barriers to commissioning STH, together with potential solutions to any barriers identified. RESULTS: Commissioners identified a lack of knowledge of STH and evidence of its effectiveness, and a culture which prioritises traditional medical models, as barriers to commissioning. Challenges for STH providers in responding to large-scale commissioning requirements were also highlighted as a barrier. CONCLUSIONS: To upscale commissioning of STH in mental health care, STH interventions need to be embedded within NHS priorities and information on STH services and their effectiveness needs to be easily accessible to practitioners. The sector should also be supported in working collaboratively to enable commissioning of services at scale.

Improving newborn screening test performance for metachromatic leukodystrophy: Recommendation from a pre-pilot study that identified a late-infantile case for treatment.

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is a devastating rare neurodegenerative disease. Typically, loss of motor and cognitive skills precedes early death. The disease is characterised by deficient lysosomal arylsulphatase A (ARSA) activity and an accumulation of undegraded sulphatide due to pathogenic variants in the ARSA gene. Atidarsagene autotemcel (arsa-cel), an ex vivo haematopoietic stem cell gene therapy was approved for use in the UK in 2021 to treat early-onset forms of pre- or early-symptomatic MLD. Optimal outcomes require early diagnosis, but in the absence of family history this is difficult to achieve without newborn screening (NBS). A pre-pilot MLD NBS study was conducted as a feasibility study in Manchester UK using a two-tiered screening test algorithm. Pre-established cutoff values (COV) for the first-tier C16:0 sulphatide (C16:0-S) and the second-tier ARSA tests were evaluated. Before the pre-pilot study, initial test validation using non­neonatal diagnostic bloodspots demonstrated ARSA pseudodeficiency status was associated with normal C16:0-S results for age (n = 43) and hence not expected to cause false positive results in this first-tier test. Instability of ARSA in bloodspot required transfer of NBS bloodspots from ambient temperature to -20°C storage within 7-8 days after heel prick, the earliest possible in this UK pre-pilot study. Eleven of 3687 de-identified NBS samples in the pre-pilot were positive for C16:0-S based on the pre-established COV of ≥170 nmol/l or ≥ 1.8 multiples of median (MoM). All 11 samples were subsequently tested negative determined by the ARSA COV of <20% mean of negative controls. However, two of 20 NBS samples from MLD patients would be missed by this C16:0-S COV. A further suspected false negative case that displayed 4% mean ARSA activity by single ARSA analysis for the initial test validation was confirmed by genotyping of this NBS bloodspot, a severe late infantile MLD phenotype was predicted. This led to urgent assessment of this child by authority approval and timely commencement of arsa-cel gene therapy at 11 months old. Secondary C16:0-S analysis of this NBS bloodspot was 150 nmol/l or 1.67 MoM. This was the lowest result reported thus far, a new COV of 1.65 MoM is recommended for future pilot studies. Furthermore, preliminary data of this study showed C16:1-OH sulphatide is more specific for MLD than C16:0-S. In conclusion, this pre-pilot study adds to the international evidence that recommends newborn screening for MLD, making it possible for patients to benefit fully from treatment through early diagnosis.

Higher precision, first tier newborn screening for metachromatic leukodystrophy using 16:1-OH-sulfatide.

Newborn screening (NBS) for metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is based on first-tier measurement of sulfatides in dried blood spots (DBS) followed by second-tier measurement of arylsulfatase A in the same DBS. This approach is very precise with 0-1 false positives per ∼30,000 newborns tested. Recent data reported here shows that the sulfatide molecular species with an α-hydroxyl, 16­carbon, mono-unsaturated fatty acyl group (16:1-OH-sulfatide) is superior to the original biomarker 16:0-sulfatide in reducing the number of first-tier false positives. This result is consistent across 4 MLD NBS centers. By measuring 16:1-OH-sulfatide alone or together with 16:0-sulfatide, the estimated false positive rate is 0.048% and is reduced essentially to zero with second-tier arylsulfatase A activity assay. The false negative rate is predicted to be extremely low based on the demonstration that 40 out of 40 newborn DBS from clinically-confirmed MLD patients are detected with these methods. The work shows that NBS for MLD is extremely precise and ready for deployment. Furthermore, it can be multiplexed with several other inborn errors of metabolism already tested in NBS centers worldwide.

The burden of disease in metachromatic leukodystrophy: results of a caregiver survey in the UK and Republic of Ireland.

BACKGROUND: Metachromatic Leukodystrophy (MLD) is a rare, autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disease characterised by the progressive loss of motor function and severe decline in cognitive function. Limited information is available on the burden MLD places on patients and their families and the medical and social support these patients need. Three UK-based MLD patient organisations commissioned an online survey, and follow-up semi-structured interviews to describe and quantify these burdens across MLD subtypes, stage of disease (including end of life) and treatment status (untreated, gene therapy or hematopoietic stem cell transplant [HSCT]). RESULTS: A total of 24 patients were included in the study: thirteen late infantile (LI), six early juvenile (EJ), two late juvenile (LJ) and three adult onset (AO). Six patients had received gene therapy and one had received an HSCT. MLD patients receiving no disease modifying treatment bore a high symptom burden: 94% were wheelchair dependent, 88% required tube feeding, 88% were incontinent, 82% had lost their speech and all the children were either unable to attend education or needed specialist provision. Patients were reliant on numerous medical interventions and assistive equipment. All early-onset patients (LI and EJ) were wheelchair dependent, and tube fed, with all EJ patients having lost all speech. The caregiving responsibilities of parents impacted their employment, finances, relationships and health. Patients treated with gene therapy or HSCT were more mobile and were able to eat normally and two thirds of the children were able to attend mainstream school. CONCLUSIONS: The impact of illness that patients and their caregivers faced was extensive, and the level of care, amount of medication, number of hospital visits and educational support required were substantial. Financial constraints often brought about by inability to work also placed considerable strain on families. The study increases understanding of the burden of MLD on patients and their families, and the level of unmet need in the treatment of the disease.

Reply to Maase et al. Comment on "Jones et al. Application of a Novel Algorithm for Expanding Newborn Screening for Inherited Metabolic Disorders across Europe. Int. J. Neonatal Screen. 2022, 8, 20".

The commentary provided by Maase et al. [...].

The importance of early diagnosis and views on newborn screening in metachromatic leukodystrophy: results of a Caregiver Survey in the UK and Republic of Ireland.

Metachromatic Leukodystrophy (MLD) is a rare, autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disorder caused by a deficiency of the enzyme arylsulfatase A (ARSA). MLD causes progressive loss of motor function and severe decline in cognitive function, leading to premature death. Early diagnosis of MLD provides the opportunity to begin treatment before the disease progresses and causes severe disability. MLD is not currently included in newborn screening (NBS) in the UK.This study consisted of an online survey, and follow-up semi-structured interviews open to MLD patients or caregivers, aged 18 years and over. The aims of the study were to understand the importance of early diagnosis and to establish the views of families and caregivers of patients with MLD on NBS.A total of 24 patients took part in the survey, representing 20 families (two families had two children with MLD, one family had three children with MLD). Following on from the survey, six parents participated in the interviews. Our data showed diagnostic delay from first symptoms was between 0 and 3 years, with a median of 1 year (n = 18); during this time deterioration was rapid, especially in earlier onset MLD. In patients with late infantile MLD (n = 10), 50% were wheelchair dependent, 30% were unable to speak, and 50% were tube fed when a diagnosis of MLD was confirmed. In patients with early juvenile MLD (n = 5), over half used a wheelchair some of the time, had uncontrollable crying, and difficulty speaking (all 60%) before or at the time of diagnosis. A high degree of support was expressed for NBS among caregivers, 95% described it as very or extremely important and 86% believed detection of MLD at birth would have changed their child's future. One parent expressed their gratitude for an early diagnosis as a result of familial MLD screening offered at birth and how it had changed their child's future: "It did and it absolutely has I will be forever grateful for his early diagnosis thanks to his older sister."The rapid rate of deterioration in MLD makes it an essential candidate for NBS, particularly now the first gene therapy (Libmeldy™) has been approved by the European Medicines Agency. Libmeldy™ has also been recommended as a treatment option in England and Wales by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and is being made available to patients in Scotland via the Scottish Medicines Consortium's ultra-orphan pathway.

A New Approach to Objectively Evaluate Inherited Metabolic Diseases for Inclusion on Newborn Screening Programmes.

Newborn screening (NBS) programmes are essential in the diagnosis of inherited metabolic diseases (IMDs) and for access to disease modifying treatment. Most European countries follow the World Health Organisation (WHO) criteria to determine which disorders are appropriate for screening at birth; however, these criteria are interpreted and implemented by individual countries differently, creating disparities. Advances in research and diagnostics, together with the promise of new treatments, offer new possibilities to accelerate the expansion of evidence-based screening programmes. A novel and robust algorithm was built to objectively assess and prioritise IMDs for inclusion in NBS programmes. The Wilson and Jungner classic screening principles were used as a foundation to develop individual and measurable criteria. The proposed algorithm is a point-based system structured upon three pillars: condition, screening, and treatment. The algorithm was tested by applying the six IMDs currently approved in the United Kingdom NBS programme. The algorithm generates a weight-based score that could be used as the first step in the complex process of evaluating disorders for inclusion on NBS programmes. By prioritising disorders to be further evaluated, individual countries are able to assess the economic, societal and political aspects of a potential screening programme.

Application of a Novel Algorithm for Expanding Newborn Screening for Inherited Metabolic Disorders across Europe.

Inherited metabolic disorders (IMDs) are mostly rare, have overlapping symptoms, and can be devastating and progressive. However, in many disorders, early intervention can improve long-term outcomes, and newborn screening (NBS) programmes can reduce caregiver stress in the journey to diagnosis and allow patients to receive early, and potentially pre-symptomatic, treatment. Across Europe there are vast discrepancies in the number of IMDs that are screened for and there is an imminent opportunity to accelerate the expansion of evidence-based screening programmes and reduce the disparities in screening programmes across Europe. A comprehensive list of IMDs was created for analysis. A novel NBS evaluation algorithm, described by Burlina et al. in 2021, was used to assess and prioritise IMDs for inclusion on expanded NBS programmes across Europe. Forty-eight IMDs, of which twenty-one were lysosomal storage disorders (LSDs), were identified and assessed with the novel NBS evaluation algorithm. Thirty-five disorders most strongly fulfil the Wilson and Jungner classic screening principles and should be considered for inclusion in NBS programmes across Europe. The recommended disorders should be evaluated at the national level to assess the economic, societal, and political aspects of potential screening programmes.