HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein zinc finger structures induce tRNA(Lys,3) structural changes but are not critical for primer/template annealing.

Retroviral reverse transcriptases use host cellular tRNAs as primers to initiate reverse transcription. In the case of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), the 3' 18 nucleotides of human tRNA(Lys,3) are annealed to a complementary sequence on the RNA genome known as the primer binding site (PBS). The HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NC) facilitates this annealing. To understand the structural changes that are induced upon NC binding to the tRNA alone, we employed a chemical probing method using the lanthanide metal terbium. At low concentrations of NC, the strong terbium cleavage observed in the core region of the tRNA is significantly attenuated. Thus, NC binding first results in disruption of the tRNA's metal binding pockets, including those that stabilize the D-TPsiC tertiary interaction. When NC concentrations approach the amount needed for complete primer/template annealing, NC further destabilizes the tRNA acceptor-TPsiC stem minihelix, as evidenced by increased terbium cleavage in this domain. A mutant form of NC (SSHS NC), which lacks the zinc finger structures, is able to anneal tRNA(Lys,3) efficiently to the PBS, and to destabilize the tRNA tertiary core, albeit less effectively than wild-type NC. This mutant form of NC does not affect cleavage significantly in the helical regions, even when bound at high concentrations. These results, as well as experiments conducted in the presence of polyLys, suggest that in the absence of the zinc finger structures, NC acts as a polycation, neutralizing the highly negative phosphodiester backbone. The presence of an effective multivalent cationic peptide is sufficient for efficient tRNA primer annealing to the PBS.

Species-specific differences in amino acid editing by class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase.

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are a family of enzymes responsible for ensuring the accuracy of the genetic code by specifically attaching a particular amino acid to their cognate tRNA substrates. Through primary sequence alignments, prolyl-tRNA synthetases (ProRSs) have been divided into two phylogenetically divergent groups. We have been interested in understanding whether the unusual evolutionary pattern of ProRSs corresponds to functional differences as well. Previously, we showed that some features of tRNA recognition and aminoacylation are indeed group-specific. Here, we examine the species-specific differences in another enzymatic activity, namely amino acid editing. Proofreading or editing provides a mechanism by which incorrectly activated amino acids are hydrolyzed and thus prevented from misincorporation into proteins. "Prokaryotic-like" Escherichia coli ProRS has recently been shown to be capable of misactivating alanine and possesses both pretransfer and post-transfer hydrolytic editing activity against this noncognate amino acid. We now find that two ProRSs belonging to the "eukaryotic-like" group exhibit differences in their hydrolytic editing activity. Whereas ProRS from Methanococcus jannaschii is similar to E. coli in its ability to hydrolyze misactivated alanine via both pretransfer and post-transfer editing pathways, human ProRS lacks these activities. These results have implications for the selection or design of antibiotics that specifically target the editing active site of the prokaryotic-like group of ProRSs.

Incorporation of lysyl-tRNA synthetase into human immunodeficiency virus type 1.

During human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) assembly, tRNA(Lys) isoacceptors are selectively incorporated into virions and tRNA(Lys)3 is used as the primer for reverse transcription. We show herein that the tRNA(Lys)-binding protein, lysyl-tRNA synthetase (LysRS), is also selectively packaged into HIV-1. The viral precursor protein Pr55gag alone will package LysRS into Pr55gag particles, independently of tRNA(Lys). With the additional presence of the viral precursor protein Pr160gag-pol, tRNA(Lys) and LysRS are both packaged into the particle. While the predominant cytoplasmic LysRS has an apparent M(r) of 70,000, viral LysRS associated with tRNA(Lys) packaging is shorter, with an apparent M(r) of 63,000. The truncation occurs independently of viral protease and might be required to facilitate interactions involved in the selective packaging and genomic placement of primer tRNA.

Mechanism for nucleic acid chaperone activity of HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein revealed by single molecule stretching.

The nucleocapsid protein (NC) of HIV type 1 is a nucleic acid chaperone that facilitates the rearrangement of nucleic acids into conformations containing the maximum number of complementary base pairs. We use an optical tweezers instrument to stretch single DNA molecules from the helix to coil state at room temperature in the presence of NC and a mutant form (SSHS NC) that lacks the two zinc finger structures present in NC. Although both NC and SSHS NC facilitate annealing of complementary strands through electrostatic attraction, only NC destabilizes the helical form of DNA and reduces the cooperativity of the helix-coil transition. In particular, we find that the helix-coil transition free energy at room temperature is significantly reduced in the presence of NC. Thus, upon NC binding, it is likely that thermodynamic fluctuations cause continuous melting and reannealing of base pairs so that DNA strands are able to rapidly sample configurations to find the lowest energy state. The reduced cooperativity allows these fluctuations to occur in the middle of complex double-stranded structures. The reduced stability and cooperativity, coupled with the electrostatic attraction generated by the high charge density of NC, is responsible for the nucleic acid chaperone activity of this protein.

Divergent adaptation of tRNA recognition by Methanococcus jannaschii prolyl-tRNA synthetase.

Analysis of prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS) across all three taxonomic domains (Eubacteria, Eucarya, and Archaea) reveals that the sequences are divided into two distinct groups. Recent studies show that Escherichia coli ProRS, a member of the "prokaryotic-like" group, recognizes specific tRNA bases at both the acceptor and anticodon ends, whereas human ProRS, a member of the "eukaryotic-like" group, recognizes nucleotide bases primarily in the anticodon. The archaeal Methanococcus jannaschii ProRS is a member of the eukaryotic-like group, although its tRNA(Pro) possesses prokaryotic features in the acceptor stem. We show here that, in some respects, recognition of tRNA(Pro) by M. jannaschii ProRS parallels that of human, with a strong emphasis on the anticodon and only weak recognition of the acceptor stem. However, our data also indicate differences in the details of the anticodon recognition between these two eukaryotic-like synthetases. Although the human enzyme places a stronger emphasis on G35, the M. jannaschii enzyme places a stronger emphasis on G36, a feature that is shared by E. coli ProRS. These results, interpreted in the context of an extensive sequence alignment, provide evidence of divergent adaptation by M. jannaschii ProRS; recognition of the tRNA acceptor end is eukaryotic-like, whereas the details of the anticodon recognition are prokaryotic-like. This divergence may be a reflection of the unusual dual function of this enzyme, which catalyzes specific aminoacylation with proline as well as with cysteine.

Use of terbium as a probe of tRNA tertiary structure and folding.

Lanthanide metals such as terbium have previously been shown to be useful for mapping metal-binding sites in RNA. Terbium binds to the same sites on RNA as magnesium, however, with a much higher affinity. Thus, low concentrations of terbium ions can easily displace magnesium and promote phosphodiester backbone scission. At higher concentrations, terbium cleaves RNA in a sequence-independent manner, with a preference for single-stranded, non-Watson-Crick base-paired regions. Here, we show that terbium is a sensitive probe of human tRNALys,3 tertiary structure and folding. When 1 microM tRNA is used, the optimal terbium ion concentration for detecting Mg2+-induced tertiary structural changes is 50-60 microM. Using these concentrations of RNA and terbium, a magnesium-dependent folding transition with a midpoint (KMg) of 2.6 mM is observed for unmodified human tRNALys,3. At lower Tb3+ concentrations, cleavage is restricted to nucleotides that constitute specific metal-binding pockets. This small chemical probe should also be useful for detecting protein induced structural changes in RNA.

Evolutionary coadaptation of the motif 2--acceptor stem interaction in the class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase system.

Known crystal structures of class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases complexed to their cognate tRNAs reveal that critical acceptor stem contacts are made by the variable loop connecting the beta-strands of motif 2 located within the catalytic core of class II synthetases. To identify potential acceptor stem contacts made by Escherichia coli prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS), an enzyme of unknown structure, we performed cysteine-scanning mutagenesis in the motif 2 loop. We identified an arginine residue (R144) that was essential for tRNA aminoacylation but played no role in amino acid activation. Cross-linking experiments confirmed that the end of the tRNA(Pro) acceptor stem is proximal to this motif 2 loop residue. Previous work had shown that the tRNA(Pro) acceptor stem elements A73 and G72 (both strictly conserved among bacteria) are important recognition elements for E. coli ProRS. We carried out atomic group "mutagenesis" studies at these two positions of E. coli tRNA(Pro) and determined that major groove functional groups at A73 and G72 are critical for recognition by ProRS. Human tRNA(Pro), which lacks these elements, is not aminoacylated by the bacterial enzyme. An analysis of chimeric tRNA(Pro) constructs showed that, in addition to A73 and G72, transplantation of the E. coli tRNA(Pro) D-domain was necessary and sufficient to convert the human tRNA into a substrate for the bacterial synthetase. In contrast to the bacterial system, base-specific acceptor stem recognition does not appear to be used by human ProRS. Alanine-scanning mutagenesis revealed that motif 2 loop residues are not critical for tRNA aminoacylation activity of the human enzyme. Taken together, our results illustrate how synthetases and tRNAs have coadapted to changes in protein-acceptor stem recognition through evolution.

Hydrolytic editing by a class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase.

Editing reactions catalyzed by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are critical for accurate translation of the genetic code. To date, this activity, whereby misactivated amino acids are hydrolyzed either before or after transfer to noncognate tRNAs, has been characterized extensively only in the case of class I synthetases. Class II synthetases have an active-site architecture that is completely distinct from that of class I. Thus, findings on editing by class I synthetases may not be applicable generally to class II enzymes. Class II Escherichia coli proline-tRNA synthetase is shown here to misactivate alanine and to hydrolyze the noncognate amino acid before transfer to tRNA(Pro). This enzyme also is capable of rapidly deacylating a mischarged Ala-tRNA(Pro) variant. A single cysteine residue (C443) that is located within the class II-specific motif 3 consensus sequence was shown previously to be dispensable for proline-tRNA synthetase aminoacylation activity. We show here that C443 is critical for the hydrolytic editing of Ala-tRNA(Pro) by this class II synthetase.

Importance of discriminator base stacking interactions: molecular dynamics analysis of A73 microhelix(Ala) variants.

Transfer of alanine from Escherichia coli alanyl-tRNA synthetase (AlaRS) to RNA minihelices that mimic the amino acid acceptor stem of tRNA(Ala) has been shown, by analysis of variant minihelix aminoacylation activities, to involve a transition state sensitive to changes in the 'discriminator' base at position 73. Solution NMR has indicated that this single-stranded nucleotide is predominantly stacked onto G1 of the first base pair of the alanine acceptor stem helix. We report the activity of a new variant with the adenine at position 73 substituted by its non-polar isostere 4-methylindole (M). Despite lacking N7, this analog is well tolerated by AlaRS. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations show that the M substitution improves position 73 base stacking over G1, as measured by a stacking lifetime analysis. Additional MD simulations of wild-type microhelix(Ala) and six variants reveal a positive correlation between N73 base stacking propensity over G1 and aminoacylation activity. For the two DeltaN7 variants simulated we found that the propensity to stack over G1 was similar to the analogous variants that contain N7 and we conclude that the decrease in aminoacylation efficiency observed upon deletion of N7 is likely due to loss of a direct stabilizing interaction with the synthetase.

Identification of discriminator base atomic groups that modulate the alanine aminoacylation reaction.

Specific aminoacylation of tRNAs involves activation of an amino acid with ATP followed by amino acid transfer to the tRNA. Previous work showed that the transfer of alanine from Escherichia coli alanyl-tRNA synthetase to a cognate RNA minihelix involves a transition state sensitive to changes in the tRNA acceptor stem. Specifically, the "discriminator" base at position 73 of minihelix(Ala) is a critical determinant of the transfer step of aminoacylation. This single-stranded nucleotide has previously been shown by solution NMR to be stacked predominantly onto G(1) of the first base pair of the alanine acceptor stem helix. In this work, RNA duplex(Ala) variants were prepared to investigate the role of specific discriminator base atomic groups in aminoacylation catalytic efficiency. Results indicate that the purine structure appears to be important for stabilization of the transition state and that major groove elements are more critical than those located in the minor groove. This result is in accordance with the predicted orientation of a class II synthetase at the end of the acceptor helix. In particular, substitution of the exocyclic amino group of A(73) with a keto-oxygen resulted in negative discrimination at this site. Taken together, these new results are consistent with the involvement of major groove atomic groups of the discriminator base in the formation of the transition state for the amino acid transfer step.

Efficient aminoacylation of tRNA(Lys,3) by human lysyl-tRNA synthetase is dependent on covalent continuity between the acceptor stem and the anticodon domain.

In this work, we probe the role of the anticodon in tRNA recognition by human lysyl-tRNA synthetase (hLysRS). Large decreases in aminoacylation efficiency are observed upon mutagenesis of anticodon positions U35 and U36 of human tRNA(Lys,3). A minihelix derived from the acceptor-TPsiC stem-loop domain of human tRNA(Lys,3)was not specifically aminoacylated by the human enzyme. The presence of an anticodon-derived stem-loop failed to stimulate aminoacylation of the minihelix. Thus, covalent continuity between the acceptor stem and anticodon domains appears to be an important requirement for efficient charging by hLysRS. To further examine the mechanism of communication between the critical anticodon recognition elements and the catalytic site, a two piece semi-synthetic tRNA(Lys, 3)construct was used. The wild-type semi-synthetic tRNA contained a break in the phosphodiester backbone in the D loop and was an efficient substrate for hLysRS. In contrast, a truncated variant that lacked nucleotides 8-17 in the D stem-loop displayedseverely reduced catalytic efficiency. The elimination of key tRNA tertiary structural elements has little effect on anticodon-dependent substrate binding but severely impacts formation of the proper transition state for catalysis. Taken together, our studies provide new insights into human tRNA structural requirements for effective transmission of the anticodon recognition signal to the distal acceptor stem domain.

Sequence-dependent conformational differences of small RNAs revealed by native gel electrophoresis.

In this study, we use native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and one-dimensional NMR spectroscopy to analyze small RNA hairpins containing a UUCG tetraloop. The aggregation state of one RNA 16-mer (5'-CGGCUUCGGUCGACCA-3') in the presence of Mg(2+) was confirmed by laser light scattering. Although it is widely known in the RNA field that some RNAs tend to aggregate, especially when present at high concentrations, the sequence elements responsible for this effect are rarely identified. In this work, we show that Mg(2+)-induced aggregation of the 16-mer RNA hairpin is sensitive to the presence of the 3'-terminal base and a specific 2'-hydroxyl group. Our study highlights the fact that even small changes in a particular RNA sequence can increase its tendency to undergo Mg(2+)-dependent aggregation in an unpredictable manner. Our analysis also shows that native gel electrophoresis is a sensitive probe of RNA conformation with the capability to detect differences apparently caused by subtle base stacking effects at the ends of helices.

Intra-tRNA distance measurements for nucleocapsid proteindependent tRNA unwinding during priming of HIV reverse transcription.

We report here the direct measurement of intra-tRNA distances during annealing of the tRNA primer to the HIV RNA genome. This key step in the initiation of retroviral reverse transcription involves hybridization of one strand of the acceptor arm of a specific lysine tRNA to the primer binding site on the RNA genome. Although the mechanism of tRNA unwinding and annealing is not known, previous studies have shown that HIV nucleocapsid protein (NC) greatly accelerates primer/template binary complex formation in vitro. An open question is whether NC alone unwinds the primer or whether unwinding by NC requires the RNA genome. We monitored the annealing process in solution by using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). Distance measurements demonstrate unequivocally that the tRNA acceptor stem is not substantially unwound by NC in the absence of the RNA genome, that is, unwinding is not separable from hybridization. Moreover, FRET measurements show that both heat- and NC-mediated annealing result in an approximately 40-A increase in the separation of the two ends of the tRNA acceptor arm on binding to the template. This large increase in separation of the two ends suggests a complete displacement of the nonhybridized strand of the acceptor stem in the initiation complex.

Transfer RNA recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases.

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are an ancient group of enzymes that catalyze the covalent attachment of an amino acid to its cognate transfer RNA. The question of specificity, that is, how each synthetase selects the correct individual or isoacceptor set of tRNAs for each amino acid, has been referred to as the second genetic code. A wealth of structural, biochemical, and genetic data on this subject has accumulated over the past 40 years. Although there are now crystal structures of sixteen of the twenty synthetases from various species, there are only a few high resolution structures of synthetases complexed with cognate tRNAs. Here we review briefly the structural information available for synthetases, and focus on the structural features of tRNA that may be used for recognition. Finally, we explore in detail the insights into specific recognition gained from classical and atomic group mutagenesis experiments performed with tRNAs, tRNA fragments, and small RNAs mimicking portions of tRNAs.

Species-specific differences in the operational RNA code for aminoacylation of tRNAPro.

An operational RNA code relates amino acids to specific structural features located in tRNA acceptor stems. In contrast to the universal nature of the genetic code, the operational RNA code can vary in evolution due to coadaptations of the contacts between aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and the acceptor stems of their cognate tRNA substrates. Here we demonstrate that, for class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS), functional coadaptations have occurred in going from the bacterial to the human enzyme. Analysis of 20 ProRS sequences that cover all three taxonomic domains (bacteria, eucarya, and archaea) revealed that the sequences are divided into two evolutionarily distant groups. Aminoacylation assays showed that, while anticodon recognition has been maintained through evolution, significant changes in acceptor stem recognition have occurred. Whereas all tRNAPro sequences from bacteria strictly conserve A73 and C1.G72, all available cytoplasmic eukaryotic tRNAPro sequences have a C73 and a G1.C72 base pair. In contrast to the Escherichia coli synthetase, the human enzyme does not use these elements as major recognition determinants, since mutations at these positions have only small effects on cognate synthetase charging. Additionally, E. coli tRNAPro is a poor substrate for human ProRS, and the presence of the human anticodon-D stem biloop domain was necessary and sufficient to confer efficient aminoacylation by human ProRS on a chimeric tRNAPro containing the E. coli acceptor-TpsiC stem-loop domain. Our data suggest that the two ProRS groups may reflect coadaptations needed to accommodate changes in the operational RNA code for proline.

Human lysyl-tRNA synthetase accepts nucleotide 73 variants and rescues Escherichia coli double-defective mutant.

The nucleotide 73 (N73) "discriminator" base in the acceptor stem is a key element for efficient and specific aminoacylation of tRNAs and of microhelix substrates derived from tRNA acceptor stems. This nucleotide was possibly one of the first to be used for differentiating among groups of early RNA substrates by tRNA synthetases. In contrast to many other synthetases, we report here that the class II human lysyl-tRNA synthetase is relatively insensitive to the nature of N73. We cloned, sequenced, and expressed the enzyme, which is a close homologue of the class II yeast aspartyl-tRNA synthetase whose co-crystal structure (with tRNAAsp) is known. The latter enzyme has a strong requirement for G73, which interacts with 4 of the 14 residues within the "motif 2" loop of the enzyme. Even though eukaryotic lysine tRNAs also encode G73, the motif 2 loop sequence of lysyl-tRNA synthetase differs at multiple positions from that of the aspartate enzyme. Indeed, the recombinant human lysine enzyme shows little preference for G, and even charges human tRNA transcripts encoding the A73 found in E. coli lysine tRNAs. Moreover, while the lysine enzyme is the only one in E. coli to be encoded by two separate genes, a double mutant that disables both genes is complemented by a cDNA expressing the human protein. Thus, the sequence of the loop of motif 2 of human lysyl-tRNA synthetase specifies a structural variation that accommodates nucleotide degeneracy at position 73. This sequence might be used as a starting point for obtaining highly specific interactions with any given N73 by simple amino acid replacements.

Specific atomic groups and RNA helix geometry in acceptor stem recognition by a tRNA synthetase.

Oligonucleotides that recapitulate the acceptor stems of tRNAs are substrates for aminoacylation by many tRNA synthetases in vitro, even though these substrates are missing the anticodon trinucleotides of the genetic code. In the case of tRNAAla a single acceptor stem G.U base pair at position 3.70 is essential, based on experiments where the wobble pair has been replaced by alternatives such as I.U, G.C, and A.U, among others. These experiments led to the conclusion that the minor-groove free 2-amino group (of guanosine) of the G.U wobble pair is essential for charging. Moreover, alanine-inserting tRNAs (amber suppressors) that replace G. U with mismatches such as G.A and C.A are partially active in vivo and can support growth of an Escherichia coli tRNAAla knockout strain, leading to the hypothesis that a helix irregularity and nucleotide functionalities are important for recognition. Herein we investigate the charging in vitro of oligonucleotide and full-length tRNA substrates that contain mismatches at the position of the G.U pair. Although most of these substrates have undetectable activity, G.A and C.A variants retain some activity, which is, nevertheless, reduced by at least 100-fold. Thus, the in vivo assays are much less sensitive to large changes in aminoacylation kinetic efficiency of 3.70 variants than is the in vitro assay system. Although these functional data do not clarify all of the details, it is now clear that specific atomic groups are substantially more important in determining kinetic efficiency than is a helical distortion. By implication, the activity of mutant tRNAs measured in the in vivo assays appears to be more dependent on factors other than aminoacylation kinetic efficiency.

Chemical modification and site-directed mutagenesis of the single cysteine in motif 3 of class II Escherichia coli prolyl-tRNA synthetase.

Class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS) from Escherichia coli contains all three of the conserved consensus motifs characteristic of class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. In this study, chemical modification and site-directed mutagenesis of the single cysteine located at position 443 in motif 3 of Escherichia coli ProRS is carried out. We show that chemical modification of C443 blocks the ability of the enzyme to form the activated aminoacyl-adenylate, a prerequisite for tRNA(Pro) aminoacylation. Nearly complete protection from inactivation is achieved by preincubating the enzyme with ATP or ATP and proline, but not proline alone or tRNA(Pro). Mutagenesis of C443 to amino acids Ala, Gly, and Ser resulted in significant decreases (16-225-fold) in k(cat)/K(M)(Pro) as measured by the ATP-PP(i) exchange reaction. The Ala and Gly mutations have a relatively small effect (4-7-fold) on the overall aminoacylation reaction, while the activity of the C443S mutant in this same assay is substantially reduced (80-fold). A sequence comparison of the motif 3 region of class II synthetases shows that C443 aligns with residues that have been implicated in amino acid binding specificity. The results of our study suggest that while the thiol located at position 443 of Escherichia coli ProRS is not essential for catalysis, this residue is likely to be in a buried region that forms the prolyl-adenylate substrate binding pocket.