Determinants of CRISPR Cas12a nuclease activation by DNA and RNA targets.

The RNA-guided CRISPR-associated (Cas) enzyme Cas12a cleaves specific double-stranded (ds-) or single-stranded (ss-) DNA targets (in cis), unleashing non-specific ssDNA cleavage (in trans). Though this trans-activity is widely coopted for diagnostics, little is known about target determinants promoting optimal enzyme performance. Using quantitative kinetics, we show formation of activated nuclease proceeds via two steps whereby rapid binding of Cas12a ribonucleoprotein to target is followed by a slower allosteric transition. Activation does not require a canonical protospacer-adjacent motif (PAM), nor is utilization of such PAMs predictive of high trans-activity. We identify several target determinants that can profoundly impact activation times, including bases within the PAM (for ds- but not ssDNA targets) and sequences within and outside those complementary to the spacer, DNA topology, target length, presence of non-specific DNA, and ribose backbone itself, uncovering previously uncharacterized cleavage of and activation by RNA targets. The results provide insight into the mechanism of Cas12a activation, with direct implications on the role of Cas12a in bacterial immunity and for Cas-based diagnostics.

Kinetic analysis of Cas12a and Cas13a RNA-Guided nucleases for development of improved CRISPR-Based diagnostics.

Bacterial CRISPR systems provide acquired immunity against invading nucleic acids by activating RNA-programmable RNases and DNases. Cas13a and Cas12a enzymes bound to CRISPR RNA (crRNA) recognize specific nucleic acid targets, initiating cleavage of the targets as well as non-target (trans) nucleic acids. Here, we examine the kinetics of single-turnover target and multi-turnover trans-nuclease activities of both enzymes. High-turnover, non-specific Cas13a trans-RNase activity is coupled to rapid binding of target RNA. By contrast, low-turnover Cas12a trans-nuclease activity is coupled to relatively slow cleavage of target DNA, selective for DNA over RNA, indifferent to base identity, and preferential for single-stranded substrates. Combining multiple crRNA increases detection sensitivity of targets, an approach we use to quantify pathogen DNA in samples from patients suspected of Buruli ulcer disease. Results reveal that these enzymes are kinetically adapted to play distinct roles in bacterial adaptive immunity and show how kinetic analysis can be applied to CRISPR-based diagnostics.

Single-molecule detection of transcription factor binding to DNA in real time: specificity, equilibrium, and kinetic parameters.

Specificity and temporal control of transcriptional machinery are encoded within sequence-specific transcription factors, of which there are thousands in mammalian genomes. Efforts to completely decipher this code will require an understanding of the DNA binding thermodynamic and kinetic properties displayed by each transcription factor, a daunting task given the current methodologies for measuring these interactions. Here, we present a novel methodology to quantify the binding of proteins to target DNA molecules based on single-molecule detection and real-time counting of individual free and bound fluorescently tagged molecules flowing past a detection device. Using this technology, we measured DNA binding by fluorescently tagged domains of four distinct transcription factors, namely, human early growth response protein Egr-1, vertebrate GATA-1, Drosophila GAGA factor, and lambda bacteriophage Cro repressor. These proteins represent different structural classes (zinc-finger and helix-turn-helix), quaternary states (monomeric and dimeric), and relative affinities (high, intermediate, and low). Specific binding of each protein to its cognate DNA target was demonstrated at low picomolar concentrations. The equilibrium (Kd) and kinetic (kon and koff) constants governing DNA binding by one of these transcription factors, that of Egr-1, were measured using this approach. Kd values obtained from three different types of saturation titrations were reproducible and consistent, yielding values between 10 and 14 pM that, along with the kinetic constants, agree closely with literature values. Because this methodology offers several significant advantages over other existing approaches, namely, real-time determination, requirement for small amounts of reagents, high reproducibility, exquisite sensitivity, and amenability to high-throughput analysis, it is suitable for characterizing DNA-binding proteins as well as other interacting pairs of molecules that can be fluorescently tagged.

Rapid quantitative analysis using a single molecule counting approach.

Single molecule detection of target molecules specifically bound by paired fluorescently labeled probes has shown great potential for sensitive quantitation of biomolecules. To date, no reports have rigorously evaluated the analytical capabilities of a single molecule detection platform employing this dual-probe approach or the performance of its data analysis methodology. In this paper, we describe a rapid, automated, and sensitive multicolor single molecule detection apparatus and a novel extension of coincident event counting based on detection of fluorescent probes. The approach estimates the number of dual-labeled molecules of interest from the total number of coincident fluorescent events observed by correcting for unbound probes that randomly pass through the interrogation zone simultaneously. Event counting was evaluated on three combinations of distinct fluorescence channels and was demonstrated to outperform conventional spatial cross-correlation in generating a wider linear dynamic response to target molecules. Furthermore, this approach succeeded in detecting subpicomolar concentrations of a model RNA target to which fluorescently labeled oligonucleotide probes were hybridized in a complex background of RNA. These results illustrate that the fluorescent event counting approach described represents a general tool for rapid sensitive quantitative analysis of any sample analyte, including nucleic acids and proteins, for which pairs of specific probes can be developed.

Membrane orientation and position of the C2 domain from cPLA2 by site-directed spin labeling.

The C2 domain is a ubiquitous Ca(2+)-binding motif that triggers the membrane docking of many key signaling proteins during intracellular Ca(2+) signals. Site-directed spin labeling was carried out on the C2 domain of cytosolic phospholipase A(2) in order to determine the depth of penetration and orientation of the domain at the membrane interface. Membrane depth parameters, Phi, were obtained by EPR spectroscopy for a series of selectively spin-labeled C2 domain cysteine mutants, and for spin-labeled lipids and spin-labeled bacteriorhodopsin cysteine mutants. Values of Phi were combined with several other constraints, including the solution NMR structure, to generate a model for the position of the C2 domain at the membrane interface. This modeling yielded an empirical expression for Phi, which for the first time defines its behavior from the bulk aqueous phase to the center of the lipid bilayer. In this model, the backbones of both the first and third Ca(2+)-binding loops are inserted approximately 10 A into the bilayer, with residues inserted as deep as 15 A. The backbone of the second Ca(2+)-binding loop is positioned near the lipid phosphate, and the two beta-sheets of the C2 domain are oriented so that the individual strands make angles of 30-45 degrees with respect to the bilayer surface. Upon membrane docking, spin labels in the Ca(2+)-binding loops exhibit decreases in local motion, suggesting either changes in tertiary contacts due to protein conformational changes and/or interactions with lipid.

Cation charge and size selectivity of the C2 domain of cytosolic phospholipase A(2).

C2 domains regulate numerous eukaryotic signaling proteins by docking to target membranes upon binding Ca(2+). Effective activation of the C2 domain by intracellular Ca(2+) signals requires high Ca(2+) selectivity to exclude the prevalent physiological metal ions K(+), Na(+), and Mg(2+). The cooperative binding of two Ca(2+) ions to the C2 domain of cytosolic phospholipase A(2) (cPLA(2)-alpha) induces docking to phosphatidylcholine (PC) membranes. The ionic charge and size selectivities of this C2 domain were probed with representative mono-, di-, and trivalent spherical metal cations. Physiological concentrations of monovalent cations and Mg(2+) failed to bind to the domain and to induce docking to PC membranes. Superphysiological concentrations of Mg(2+) did bind but still failed to induce membrane docking. In contrast, Ca(2+), Sr(2+), and Ba(2+) bound to the domain in the low micromolar range, induced electrophoretic mobility shifts in native polyacrylamide gels, stabilized the domain against thermal denaturation, and induced docking to PC membranes. In the absence of membranes, the degree of apparent positive cooperativity in binding of Ca(2+), Sr(2+), and Ba(2+) decreased with increasing cation size, suggesting that the C2 domain binds two Ca(2+) or Sr(2+) ions, but only one Ba(2+) ion. These stoichiometries were correlated with the abilities of the ions to drive membrane docking, such that micromolar concentrations of Ca(2+) and Sr(2+) triggered docking while even millimolar concentrations of Ba(2+) yielded poor docking efficiency. The simplest explanation is that two bound divalent cations are required for stable membrane association. The physiological Ca(2+) ion triggered membrane docking at 20-fold lower concentrations than Sr(2+), due to both the higher Ca(2+) affinity of the free domain and the higher affinity of the Ca(2+)-loaded domain for membranes. Kinetic studies indicated that Ca(2+) ions bound to the free domain are retained at least 5-fold longer than Sr(2+) ions. Moreover, the Ca(2+)-loaded domain remained bound to membranes 2-fold longer than the Sr(2+)-loaded domain. For both Ca(2+) and Sr(2+), the two bound metal ions dissociate from the protein-membrane complex in two kinetically resolvable steps. Finally, representative trivalent lanthanide ions bound to the domain with high affinity and positive cooperativity, and induced docking to PC membranes. Overall, the results demonstrate that both cation charge and size constraints contribute to the high Ca(2+) selectivity of the C2 domain and suggest that formation of a cPLA(2)-alpha C2 domain-membrane complex requires two bound multivalent metal ions. These features are proposed to stem from the unique structural features of the metal ion-binding site in the C2 domain.