Systematic review of adoption, reporting and impact of health-related quality of life in phase III non-inferiority trials of systemic oncology treatments.

BACKGROUND: Quality of life (QoL) assessment and patient-reported outcomes appear to be crucial in the rationale and interpretation of non-inferiority (NI) trials. The aim of this study was to assess the inclusion of QoL among endpoints in phase III NI oncology trials and the relevance of QoL results in the reporting and interpretation of these studies. MATERIALS AND METHODS: By PubMed search and hand-search of 11 selected journals, we identified phase III NI trials in adult patients affected by solid tumours, published between 2012 and 2021. Trials were classified according to 4 NI strategies: (1) different drugs; (2) alternative drug administration routes; (3) shorter treatment duration; (4) "deintensification" of treatment schedule. Three main endpoints were: (1) the proportion of publications including QoL among endpoints; (2) the proportion of primary publications reporting QoL results; (3) the proportion of trials with available QoL results actually favoring the experimental treatment out of trials declaring NI. RESULTS: 106 publications were eligible. QoL was included among endpoints in 59 studies (55.7%), and QoL results were available in 40 primary publications (37.7%). In the 73 trials testing the NI of different drugs, QoL was included in 43 trials (58.9%) and QoL results were present in 31 publications (42.5%). Among the 74 trials formally demonstrating NI, only 19 trials (25.7%) had QoL results actually supporting the experimental treatment. CONCLUSIONS: In many NI trials in oncology, assessment and reporting of QoL are deficient. Furthermore, most trials formally claiming NI cannot count on QoL results actually supporting the experimental arm.

Accuracy and Limitations of the Growth Hormone (GH) Releasing Hormone-Arginine Retesting in Young Adults With Childhood-Onset GH Deficiency.

Background: Re-testing for GH secretion is needed to confirm the diagnosis of GH deficiency (GHD) after adult height achievement in childhood-onset GHD (COGHD). Aim: To define the cut-off of GH peak after retesting with GH-releasing hormone plus arginine (GHRHarg) in the diagnosis of permanent GHD in COGHD of different etiology. Patients and methods: Eighty-eight COGHD (median age 17.2 y), 29 idiopathic GHD (IGHD), 44 cancer survivors (TGHD) and 15 congenital GHD (CGHD) were enrolled in the study; 54 had isolated GHD (iGHD) and 34 had multiple pituitary hormone deficiencies (MPHD). All were tested with insulin tolerance test (ITT) and GHRHarg. IGHD with a GH response to ITT ≥6µg/L were considered true negatives and served as the control group, and patients with a GH response <6µg/L as true positives. Baseline IGF-I was also measured. The diagnostic accuracy of GHRHarg testing and of IGF-I SDS in patients with GHD of different etiologies was evaluated by ROC analysis. Results: Forty-six subjects with a GH peak to ITT ≥6µg/L and 42 with GH peak <6 µg/L showed a GH peak after GHRHarg between 8.8-124µg/L and 0.3-26.3µg/L, respectively; 29 IGHD were true negatives, 42 were true positives and 17 with a high likelihood GHD showed a GH peak to ITT ≥6µg/L. ROC analysis based on the etiology indicated the best diagnostic accuracy for peak GH cutoffs after GHRHarg of 25.3 µg/L in CGHD, 15.7 in TGHD, and 13.8 in MPHD, and for IGF-1 SDS at -2.1 in CGHD, -1.5 in TGHD, and -1.9 in MPHD. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that the best cut-off for GH peak after retesting with GHRHarg changes according to the etiology of GHD during the transition age. Based on these results the diagnostic accuracy of GHRHarg remains questionable.

Role of MRI T2-DRIVE in the assessment of pituitary stalk abnormalities without gadolinium in pituitary diseases.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the role of T2-DRIVE MRI sequence in the accurate measurement of pituitary stalk (PS) size and the identification of PS abnormalities in patients with hypothalamic-pituitary disorders without the use of gadolinium. DESIGN: This was a retrospective study conducted on 242 patients who underwent MRI due to pituitary dysfunction between 2006 and 2015. Among 135 eligible patients, 102 showed eutopic posterior pituitary (PP) gland and 33 showed 'ectopic' PP (EPP). METHODS: Two readers independently measured the size of PS in patients with eutopic PP at the proximal, midpoint and distal levels on pre- and post-contrast T1-weighted as well as T2-DRIVE images; PS visibility was assessed on pre-contrast T1 and T2-DRIVE sequences in those with EPP. The length, height, width and volume of the anterior pituitary (AP), PP height and length and PP area were analyzed. RESULTS: Significant agreement between the two readers was obtained for T2-DRIVE PS measurements in patients with 'eutopic' PP; a significant difference was demonstrated between the intraclass correlation coefficient calculated on the T2-DRIVE and the T1-pre- and post-contrast sequences. The percentage of PS identified by T2-DRIVE in EPP patients was 72.7% compared to 30.3% of T1 pre-contrast sequences. A significant association was found between the visibility of PS on T2-DRIVE and the height of AP. CONCLUSION: T2-DRIVE sequence is extremely precise and reliable for the evaluation of PS size and the recognition of PS abnormalities; the use of gadolinium-based contrast media does not add significant information and may thus be avoided.

Clinical Manifestations and Metabolic Outcomes of Seven Adults With Silver-Russell Syndrome.

Context: There is little information on the long-term natural history of Silver-Russell syndrome (SRS). Objective: To describe the phenotypes and metabolic status in adults with SRS. Design: Clinical and metabolic evaluations in adults with a molecular diagnosis of SRS. Participants: Seven patients (aged 18 to 46 years; mean age, 26.9 years) were studied. Two had chromosome 7 maternal uniparental disomy, three had 11p15 loss of methylation, and two had 11p15 duplication. Setting: Single tertiary university center. Main Outcome Measures: Netchine-Harbison (NH) clinical score, oral glucose tolerance test, lipid profiles, bone mineral density (BMD; lumbar spine at L1 to L4 and total body), lean body mass (LBM), absolute fat mass (kg), fat mass percentage, fat mass index (FMI), and trunk/limb fat ratio were evaluated. Results: The NH score declined in all but two patients during adulthood, and all patients but one displayed relative macrocephaly. Two patients were underweight, four patients had a normal body mass index, and one was obese. Two patients had glucose intolerance and hyperinsulinemia; two showed a high total cholesterol level with low high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol levels. BMD was within the normal range, whereas a high fat mass percentage, FMI, and trunk/limb fat ratio and a low LBM were found. The trunk/limb fat ratio showed an inverse relation with HDL cholesterol levels. Conclusions: The diagnosis of SRS seems to be reliable in adults, although some clinical signs become less pronounced with age. Glucose, lipids, and body composition should be monitored over time.

Validation of a predictive survival model in Italian patients with cystic fibrosis.

BACKGROUND: In 2001 Liou published a 5-year survival model using CFF Registry data. AIMS: To evaluate its validity in predicting survival in Italian CF patients. METHODS: In a retrospective study on 945 patients, the 9 variables selected by Liou were analyzed, vital status on December 2008 recorded and observed and expected deaths compared. To develop a new model, patients were randomly divided into a derivation (n=475) and a validation sample (n=470). RESULTS: A significant difference was found between observed and expected deaths based on Liou's model (62 vs 94), with a 34% reduction in mortality (p<0.05). A new model (based on FEV1, Staphylococcus aureus and Burkholderia cepacia complex infection, number of pulmonary exacerbations/year) was generated, that correctly predicted survival in the validation sample (31 observed vs 29 expected deaths, p=0.660). CONCLUSIONS: The Liou model did not adequately predict 5-year survival in our CF population that, compared to the one in which it was originally tested, could benefit from 10 years of improvement in treatments and practice patterns. A new generated model, based on only four variables, was more accurate in predicting 5-year survival in Italian CF patients.

Slow-release insulin in cystic fibrosis patients with glucose intolerance: a randomized clinical trial.

BACKGROUND: Early stages of glucose metabolism impairment are a period at risk in the long-term prognosis of cystic fibrosis (CF). Slow-release synthetic insulin glargine can be a therapeutic tool in this metabolic condition. METHODS: In this phase 3 multicenter, controlled, two-arm, randomized clinical study, glargine was administered up to a dosage of 0.15 U/kg/die for a period of 18 months. Primary endpoint was the improvement of nutritional status [body mass index (BMI) Z score], while glucose tolerance [hemoglobin A1c (HbA1C) and respiratory function (FEV1 predicted] improvement were the secondary endpoints. RESULTS: Thirty-four subjects (18 in the glargine arm and 16 in the control arm) were evaluated. Adherence to insulin treatment was excellent. No significant adverse events were reported. There were no significant differences in BMI, HbA1C and FEV1 values between the two groups nor within groups, except for HbA1C improvement in the glargine arm at month +18 (p = 0.04). CONCLUSIONS: Glargine treatment was well accepted and tolerated. No real efficacy in improving clinical and glycometabolic conditions was demonstrated. Further studies are necessary to test glargine at higher dosage and for a longer follow-up period.