A global pharmaceutical company initiative: an evidence-based approach to define the upper limit of body weight loss in short term toxicity studies.

Short term toxicity studies are conducted in animals to provide information on major adverse effects typically at the maximum tolerated dose (MTD). Such studies are important from a scientific and ethical perspective as they are used to make decisions on progression of potential candidate drugs, and to set dose levels for subsequent regulatory studies. The MTD is usually determined by parameters such as clinical signs, reductions in body weight and food consumption. However, these assessments are often subjective and there are no published criteria to guide the selection of an appropriate MTD. Even where an objective measurement exists, such as body weight loss (BWL), there is no agreement on what level constitutes an MTD. A global initiative including 15 companies, led by the National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research (NC3Rs), has shared data on BWL in toxicity studies to assess the impact on the animal and the study outcome. Information on 151 studies has been used to develop an alert/warning system for BWL in short term toxicity studies. The data analysis supports BWL limits for short term dosing (up to 7days) of 10% for rat and dog and 6% for non-human primates (NHPs).

Selective inhibition of PDE4 in Wistar rats can lead to dilatation in testis, efferent ducts, and epididymis and subsequent formation of sperm granulomas.

Testicular tubular dilatation and degeneration and epididymal sperm granulomas were frequently seen in 4-week toxicity studies using different phosphodiesterase-4 (PDE4) inhibitors in Wistar rats, including the prototypic PDE4 inhibitor BYK169171. To investigate the pathogenesis of testicular and epididymal lesions, a time course study with BYK169171 was conducted with sequential necropsies after 7, 14, 21, and 28 days of treatment. After 7 days, a dilatation of efferent ducts and of the initial segment of the epididymis and a subacute interstitial inflammation were seen followed by a diffuse dilatation of seminiferous tubules in the testis. Dilatation and inflammation were most pronounced after 14 days. Single animals also exhibited vascular necrosis in the inflamed interstitium. Although dilatation decreased later in the study, the incidence and severity of tubular degeneration increased from 14 days onward. Sperm granulomas developed in efferent ducts and in the caput and cauda of the epididymis after 14 days. Our results demonstrate a clear time course of PDE4 inhibition-induced lesions, with dilatation preceding sperm granuloma formation. We conclude that the most likely mechanism of toxicity is a disturbance of fluid homeostasis in efferent and epididymal ducts resulting in abnormal luminal fluid and sperm contents, epithelial damage at specific sites of the excurrent duct system, sperm leakage, and granuloma formation.

A European pharmaceutical company initiative challenging the regulatory requirement for acute toxicity studies in pharmaceutical drug development.

Regulatory guidelines indicate acute toxicity studies in animals are considered necessary for pharmaceuticals intended for human use. This is the only study type where lethality is mentioned as an endpoint. The studies are carried out, usually in rodents, to support marketing of new drugs and to identify the minimum lethal dose. A European initiative including 18 companies has undertaken an evidence-based review of acute toxicity studies and assessed the value of the data generated. Preclinical and clinical information was shared on 74 compounds. The analysis indicated acute toxicity data was not used to (i) terminate drugs from development (ii) support dose selection for repeat dose studies in animals or (iii) to set doses in the first clinical trials in humans. The conclusion of the working group is that acute toxicity studies are not needed prior to first clinical trials in humans. Instead, information can be obtained from other studies, which are performed at more relevant doses for humans and are already an integral part of drug development. The conclusions have been discussed and agreed with representatives of regulatory bodies from the US, Japan and Europe.

Mesenteritis precedes vasculitis in the rat mesentery after subacute administration of a phosphodiesterase type 4 inhibitor.

Inhibitors of phosphodiesterase type 4 (PDE4) are currently exploited as potent drugs for pulmonary diseases. Some PDE4 inhibitors induce necrotizing panarteritis in the mesentery of rats, comparable to spontaneous polyarteritis nodosa in rats and vascular alterations that are induced by various vasoactive compounds, such as fenoldopam and inhibitors of PDE3. The mechanism of toxicity is unknown. In order to investigate the development of arteritis in the splanchnic vasculature of rats, a time-course study was performed with high doses of a compound (BYK169171), specifically inhibiting PDE4. Rats were treated orally for 1-28 days, and alterations in the mesentery were evaluated by histology, morphometry, and immunohistology. As early as 3 days after the onset of treatment, a mesenteritis was found, characterized by macrophage infiltration, fibroblast proliferation, neovascularization, and loss of adipocytes. Incidence and severity of the mesenteritis were low during the first 2 weeks of treatment, but increased with duration of treatment, finally affecting 2/3 of all animals. A segmental necrotizing panarteritis was detected in some rats treated for 21 or 28 days, but always followed a mesenteritis, whereas many animals with mesenteric inflammation did not have vascular lesions. We postulate that PDE4 inhibitors do not cause a primary vasculitis/arteritis in rats, but induce a non-purulent inflammation as the predominant initial toxic effect in the mesentery. This renders their toxic effect distinct from that of PDE3 inhibitors.