Perspective for Donor-Derived Cell-Free DNA in Antibody-Mediated Rejection After Kidney Transplantation: Defining Context of Use and Clinical Implications.

Antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is a major cause of graft failure limiting long-term graft survival after kidney transplantation. Current diagnostic strategy to detect AMR is suboptimal and requires further improvement. Previously suggested treatment regimens for AMR could not demonstrate efficacy, however novel therapeutic agents are currently under investigation. Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is a novel non-invasive biomarker for allograft injury, that has been mainly studied in the context of rejection. Its short-half-life in circulation and injury-dependent release are its key advantages that contribute to its superior diagnostic accuracy, compared to traditional biomarkers. Moreover, previous studies showed that dd-cfDNA-release is well-linked to histological and molecular features of AMR, and thus able to reflect real-time injury. Further observations suggest that dd-cfDNA can be used as a suitable screening tool for early detection of AMR in patients with donor-specific-anti-HLA-antibodies (DSA), as well as for monitoring AMR activity after anti-rejection treatment. The weight of evidence suggests that the integration of dd-cfDNA in the graft surveillance of patients with AMR, or those suspicious of AMR (e.g., due to the presence of donor-specific anti-HLA-antibodies) has an added value and might have a positive impact on outcomes in this specific cohort.

Donor-Derived Cell-Free DNA as a Companion Biomarker for AMR Treatment With Daratumumab: Case Series.

Antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is among the most frequent causes for graft loss after kidney transplantation. While there are no approved therapies, several case reports with daratumumab and the very recent phase 2 trial of felzartamab in AMR have indicated the potential efficacy of therapeutic interventions targeting CD38. Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is an emerging biomarker with injury-specific release and a short half-life, which could facilitate early diagnosis of AMR and monitoring of treatment response. We describe two cases of patients with chronic active AMR, who were treated with monthly daratumumab infusions, and in whom donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) was measured longitudinally to monitor treatment response. In both patients, daratumumab treatment led to stabilization of kidney function parameters, a strong decline of dd-cfDNA below the previously established threshold for rejection, and partial or complete histologic resolution of AMR activity. Our case series suggests that dd-cfDNA may be a useful companion biomarker for longitudinal monitoring of anti-CD38 treatment in patients with AMR.

Donor-Derived Cell-Free DNA for Kidney Allograft Surveillance after Conversion to Belatacept: Prospective Pilot Study.

Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is used as a biomarker for detection of antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) and other forms of graft injury. Another potential indication is guidance of immunosuppressive therapy when no therapeutic drug monitoring is available. In such situations, detection of patients with overt or subclinical graft injury is important to personalize immunosuppression. We prospectively measured dd-cfDNA in 22 kidney transplant recipients (KTR) over a period of 6 months after conversion to belatacept for clinical indication and assessed routine clinical parameters. Patient and graft survival was 100% after 6 months, and eGFR remained stable (28.7 vs. 31.1 mL/min/1.73 m2, p = 0.60). Out of 22 patients, 2 (9%) developed biopsy-proven rejection-one episode of low-grade TCMR IA and one episode of caABMR. While both episodes were detected by increase in creatinine, the caABMR episode led to increase in absolute dd-cfDNA (168 copies/mL) above the cut-off of 50 copies/mL, while the TCMR episode did show slightly increased relative dd-cfDNA (0.85%) despite normal absolute dd-cfDNA (22 copies/mL). Dd-cfDNA did not differ before and after conversion in a subgroup of 12 KTR with previous calcineurin inhibitor therapy and no rejection (12.5 vs. 25.3 copies/mL, p = 0.34). In this subgroup, 3/12 (25%) patients showed increase of absolute dd-cfDNA above the prespecified cut-off (50 copies/mL) despite improving eGFR. Increase in dd-cfDNA after conversion to belatacept is common and could point towards subclinical allograft injury. To detect subclinical TCMR changes without vascular lesions, additional biomarkers or urinary dd-cfDNA should complement plasma dd-cfDNA. Resolving CNI toxicity is unlikely to be detected by decreased dd-cfDNA levels. In summary, the sole determination of dd-cfDNA has limited utility in the guidance of patients after late conversion to belatacept. Further studies should focus on patients undergoing early conversion and include protocol biopsies at least for patients with increased dd-cfDNA.

Donor-Derived Cell-free DNA for Personalized Immunosuppression in Renal Transplantation.

BACKGROUND: The long-term outcomes of solid organ transplantation remain suboptimal. Therefore, appropriate biomarkers are needed in addition to immunosuppressive drugs and other traditional approaches for graft monitoring to achieve personalized immunosuppression and reduce premature graft loss. METHODS: Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is a minimally invasive biomarker of cell death due to graft injury. It can be quantified using droplet digital polymerase chain reaction and next-generation sequencing. Fractional dd-cfDNA determination can be affected by changes in recipient cfDNA, such as those caused by leukopenia or infection, leading to false-positive or false-negative results, respectively. Absolute quantification of dd-cfDNA helps in overcoming this limitation. RESULTS: Overall, there is sufficient evidence of the clinical validity of dd-cfDNA. It detects rejection episodes early at an actionable stage and reflects the severity of graft injury without being rejection-specific. Owing to its high negative predictive value, dd-cfDNA is very useful for ruling out graft injury. Dd-cfDNA complements histological findings and can help in avoiding unnecessary biopsies. It indicates a response to rejection treatment and detects underimmunosuppression. CONCLUSIONS: Monitoring changes in dd-cfDNA over time may be helpful in adapting immunosuppression to prevent graft rejection. Moreover, serial dd-cfDNA determination may increase the effectiveness of transplant recipient surveillance and facilitate personalized immunosuppression when combined with other relevant clinical and diagnostic findings.

Donor-derived cell-free DNA as a diagnostic tool in transplantation.

There is a need to improve personalized immunosuppression in organ transplantation to reduce premature graft loss. Biomarkers are needed to better detect rejection, asymptomatic graft injury, and under-immunosuppression. Assessment of minimal necessary exposure to guide tapering and prevent immune activation is also important. There is robust clinical evidence from a large number of published studies supporting the role of dd-cfDNA for monitoring graft integrity and detection or exclusion of rejection. Dd-cfDNA indicates graft cell death without being rejection specific. It can be determined in plasma through droplet digital PCR using preselected SNPs or next generation sequencing. Changes in recipient cfDNA (e.g., by infection) can affect the results of dd-cfDNA fractional determination. This limitation can be overcome using absolute dd-cfDNA quantification. The combination of fractional and absolute determination including total cfDNA is recommended for meaningful interpretation of the results. The value proposition for the patient includes earlier transplant injury detection and intervention, less full blown rejection risk, an alternative to invasive biopsies, and personalized immunosuppression with potential for improved long-term outcome. Transplant physicians benefit from better immunosuppressive guidance and having an alternative when biopsies are refused or contraindicated. Further advantages are improved biopsy interpretation, less trial and error changes in immunosuppression, and less time dealing with complications. The laboratory medicine specialist can provide more effective services. Hospital management and insurance companies could benefit from more cost-effective surveillance of transplant recipients. Potential cost savings would result from fewer biopsies as a result of the tests' high negative predictive value, fewer re-transplantations, and less organ failure with return to dialysis. A pathway to implementation and metrics is suggested to measure the effectiveness of dd-cfDNA testing.

Elevated fractional donor-derived cell-free DNA during subclinical graft injury after liver transplantation.

Personalized immunosuppression (IS) promises to improve the balance of necessary control of alloreactivity and dose-dependent adverse effects of long-term IS such as kidney insufficiency, infections, and malignancies. The majority of liver transplantation (LT) recipients exhibit graft injuries (graft inflammation and/or fibrosis) that are not eligible for an IS reduction according to current Banff criteria, even when liver enzymes are normal or only marginally elevated. This cross-sectional study evaluated the noninvasive prediction of such subclinical graft injuries in surveillance liver biopsies via donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA). Absolute and fractional dd-cfDNA increased stepwise from patients without histological signs of rejection (n = 26) over subclinical graft injury (n = 61), including subclinical T cell-mediated rejection to clinical overt T cell-mediated rejection (n = 21). Thus, fractional plasma dd-cfDNA was significantly elevated paired to surveillance biopsies with relevant subclinical graft injury according to 2016 Banff criteria compared with those with minimal or absent histological graft injury. In contrast, the presence of donor-specific anti-human leukocyte antigen antibodies was not associated with the amount of dd-cfDNA. The sensitivity and specificity of fractional dd-cfDNA to noninvasively predict relevant subclinical graft injury was rather limited with 73% and 52% at the cutoff value of 2.1% fractional dd-cfDNA. The positive predictive value of fractional dd-cfDNA above 2.1% was 76% to noninvasively predict subclinical graft injury, calculated on the prevalence of graft injury in our prospective surveillance biopsy program, whereas the negative predictive values was not predictive (47%). In conclusion, dd-cfDNA has a rather limited diagnostic fidelity in addition to other noninvasive markers for the assessment of subclinical graft injury in personalized IS approaches after LT in a cross-sectional setting.

Temporary antimetabolite treatment hold boosts SARS-CoV-2 vaccination-specific humoral and cellular immunity in kidney transplant recipients.

Transplant recipients exhibit an impaired protective immunity after SARS-CoV-2 vaccination, potentially caused by mycophenolate (MPA) immunosuppression. Recent data from patients with autoimmune disorders suggest that temporary MPA hold might greatly improve booster vaccination outcomes. We applied a fourth dose of SARS-CoV-2 vaccine to 29 kidney transplant recipients during a temporary (5 weeks) MPA/azathioprine hold, who had not mounted a humoral immune response to previous vaccinations. Seroconversion until day 32 after vaccination was observed in 76% of patients, associated with acquisition of virus-neutralizing capacity. Interestingly, 21/25 (84%) calcineurin inhibitor-treated patients responded, but only 1/4 belatacept-treated patients responded. In line with humoral responses, counts and relative frequencies of spike receptor binding domain-specific (RBD-specific) B cells were markedly increased on day 7 after vaccination, with an increase in RBD-specific CD27++CD38+ plasmablasts. Whereas overall proportions of spike-reactive CD4+ T cells remained unaltered after the fourth dose, frequencies were positively correlated with specific IgG levels. Importantly, antigen-specific proliferating Ki67+ and in vivo-activated programmed cell death 1-positive T cells significantly increased after revaccination during MPA hold, whereas cytokine production and memory differentiation remained unaffected. In summary, antimetabolite hold augmented all arms of immunity during booster vaccination. These data suggest further studies of antimetabolite hold in kidney transplant recipients.

Graft-derived Cell-free DNA as a Noninvasive Biomarker of Cardiac Allograft Rejection: A Cohort Study on Clinical Validity and Confounding Factors.

BACKGROUND: Circulating graft-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is a new marker of cardiac allograft damage that is used for noninvasive rejection diagnostics. We performed dd-cfDNA (%) in heart transplant recipients during the first posttransplant year. METHODS: In 87 patients, serial dd-cfDNA determination at predefined time-points was performed in 770 single samples. dd-cfDNA fraction (%) was measured using an established universal droplet digital polymerase chain reaction method, providing same-day turn-around. Rejection was diagnosed according to clinical parameters and biopsies. RESULTS: Median dd-cfDNA (%) was high (5.36%) immediately after reperfusion and decreased to a median (interquartile range) of 0.10% (0.05%-0.24%) in clinically stable patients by postoperative day 10. Compared to dd-cfDNA (%) samples in clinically stable patients, values were higher (P < 0.001) in biopsy-proven rejection ISHLT 1R (0.42% [0.15%-0.53%]) and 2R rejection (0.84% [0.39%-0.97%]). Moreover, dd-cfDNA (%) was already significantly increased 9-30 days before biopsy-proven rejection (0.36% [0.20%-0.61%]). An as yet unknown finding was a slightly, but significantly (P < 0.0001) higher dd-cfDNA (%) value in samples of stable patients with pericardial effusions (PEs) (n = 94; 0.18% [0.07%-0.30%]) compared to samples of non-PE patients (n = 132; 0.07% [0.04%-0.17%]). Using a cutoff of 0.35%, sensitivity and specificity of dd-cfDNA for cardiac rejection were 0.76 and 0.83 (area under the curve [AUC] ROC-curve: 0.81 [95% confidence interval, 0.73-0.89]). Omitting PE samples from the control group yielded an AUC of 0.86 [95% confidence interval, 0.76-0.95]. Samples drawn <12 hours after endomyocardial biopsy showed high (0.40% [0.15%-1.21%]) dd-cfDNA values, also in ISHLT0R (0.36% [0.10%-0.60%]). CONCLUSIONS: dd-cfDNA plasma values were significantly associated with cardiac rejection. However, PE or improper sampling (eg, shortly after biopsy) should be considered as confounders for rejection diagnoses using dd-cfDNA.

Absolute or Relative Quantification of Donor-derived Cell-free DNA in Kidney Transplant Recipients: Case Series.

BACKGROUND: Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is increasingly recognized as a valuable biomarker for acute transplant injury, with possible indications in the detection of cellular or humoral rejection and the guidance of immunosuppressive therapy. There is an ongoing debate on whether relative or absolute quantification of dd-cfDNA is more reliable for the detection of acute transplant injury. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all 22 kidney transplant recipients who underwent dd-cfDNA measurements (percentage and absolute) between April 2020 and April 2021 at our institution. Of these, 9 (41%) showed discrepancies between absolute (cutoff: 50 copies/mL) and relative (cutoff: 0.5%) quantification in at least 1 dd-cfDNA measurement. RESULTS: We report on 9 of 22 cases with discrepancies in relative and absolute quantification of dd-cfDNA, which were predominantly late posttransplant patients. We found bacterial and viral infections, as well as low leukocyte count from chronic myeloid leukaemia treatment, to be reasons for variability in total cell-free DNA (cfDNA), leading to inter- and intraindividual variability in relative dd-cfDNA quantification. When correlating dd-cfDNA quantification and biopsy results, as well as clinical course, our data indicate that relying solely on relative dd-cfDNA can lead to false-negative and false-positive results. CONCLUSIONS: In summary, these cases argue that absolute quantification of dd-cfDNA is better suited in patients with underlying conditions affecting total cfDNA levels and suggest using both absolute and relative dd-cfDNA together for higher reliability and interindividual comparability in the clinical setting. Especially for patients with chronic active antibody-mediated rejection, further studies on the use of dd-cfDNA are desirable.

Implementation of medical tests in a Value-Based healthcare environment: A framework for delivering value.

Significant variation in the utilisation of medical tests is known to have an adverse impact on health outcomes and analysis of this variation is an important tool for quality assurance in healthcare. The introduction of a new medical test into a care pathway requires two distinct processes, termed adoption and implementation. One cause of the unwarranted variation in the use of medical tests is poor adoption and implementation. Adoption is the decision to acquire a technology and make it available to the users and is supported with evidence of clinical and cost effectiveness. Implementation is delivering the benefits promised in the business case, based on evidence of the impact of a test on each stakeholder involved in delivering the care pathway. The business case will have identified the benefits delivered to all stakeholders, as set out in a value proposition, and according to the quality domains typically addressed in quality improvement, namely clinical, process and structure (resource utilisation) outcomes. The outcome measures extend beyond those of clinical and cost effectiveness required for adoption. We describe an implementation framework which is designed to document the changes to the care pathway, the resource inputs and the expected outcomes with associated quality metrics.

Liquid biopsies: donor-derived cell-free DNA for the detection of kidney allograft injury.

In kidney transplantation, the use of minimally invasive damage biomarkers that are more sensitive and specific than plasma creatinine will be crucial to enable early, actionable detection or exclusion of structural kidney damage due to acute or chronic rejection. Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA), which can be quantified, for example, through next-generation sequencing, droplet digital PCR and quantitative PCR, is a candidate biomarker with great potential for enabling comprehensive monitoring of allograft injury. dd-cfDNA has a favourable overall diagnostic performance for the detection of rejection and its high negative predictive value might be especially useful for avoiding unnecessary biopsies. Elevated dd-cfDNA levels have been shown to be detectable before graft injury can be clinically identified using current diagnostic methods. Moreover, dd-cfDNA falls rapidly to baseline levels after successful treatment for rejection owing to its short half-life. dd-cfDNA can detect graft injury caused by immune activation owing to insufficient immunosuppression and might therefore also help guide immunosuppression dosing. The fractional abundance of dd-cfDNA can be affected by changes in the recipient cfDNA (for example, due to infection or physical exercise) but the use of absolute quantification of dd-cfDNA overcomes this limitation. Serial dd-cfDNA determinations might therefore facilitate cost-effective personalized clinical management of kidney transplant recipients to reduce premature graft loss.

Personalized Therapy for Mycophenolate: Consensus Report by the International Association of Therapeutic Drug Monitoring and Clinical Toxicology.

ABSTRACT: When mycophenolic acid (MPA) was originally marketed for immunosuppressive therapy, fixed doses were recommended by the manufacturer. Awareness of the potential for a more personalized dosing has led to development of methods to estimate MPA area under the curve based on the measurement of drug concentrations in only a few samples. This approach is feasible in the clinical routine and has proven successful in terms of correlation with outcome. However, the search for superior correlates has continued, and numerous studies in search of biomarkers that could better predict the perfect dosage for the individual patient have been published. As it was considered timely for an updated and comprehensive presentation of consensus on the status for personalized treatment with MPA, this report was prepared following an initiative from members of the International Association of Therapeutic Drug Monitoring and Clinical Toxicology (IATDMCT). Topics included are the criteria for analytics, methods to estimate exposure including pharmacometrics, the potential influence of pharmacogenetics, development of biomarkers, and the practical aspects of implementation of target concentration intervention. For selected topics with sufficient evidence, such as the application of limited sampling strategies for MPA area under the curve, graded recommendations on target ranges are presented. To provide a comprehensive review, this report also includes updates on the status of potential biomarkers including those which may be promising but with a low level of evidence. In view of the fact that there are very few new immunosuppressive drugs under development for the transplant field, it is likely that MPA will continue to be prescribed on a large scale in the upcoming years. Discontinuation of therapy due to adverse effects is relatively common, increasing the risk for late rejections, which may contribute to graft loss. Therefore, the continued search for innovative methods to better personalize MPA dosage is warranted.

Time-Dependent Apparent Increase in dd-cfDNA Percentage in Clinically Stable Patients Between One and Five Years Following Kidney Transplantation.

BACKGROUND: Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is reportedly a valuable tool for graft surveillance following kidney transplantation (KTx). Possible changes in dd-cfDNA(%) reference values over time have not been evaluated. For long-term monitoring after KTx, changes in host cfDNA might represent a biasing factor in dd-cfDNA(%) determinations. METHODS: Plasma samples were obtained (n = 929) 12-60 months after engraftment in a cross-sectional cohort of 303 clinically stable KTx recipients. Total cfDNA(copies/mL), dd-cfDNA(%), and dd-cfDNA(copies/mL) were determined using droplet-digital PCR. Stability of threshold values in these stable KTx recipients over time was assessed by 80th, 85th, and 90th quantile regression. RESULTS: Upper percentiles of total cfDNA showed a significant decline of -1902, -3589, and -4753 cp/mL/log(month) (P = 0.014, <0.001, and 0.017, respectively), resulting in increasing dd-cfDNA(%) percentiles by 0.25, 0.46, and 0.72%/log(month) (P = 0.04, 0.001, and 0.002, respectively), with doubling of the 85th percentile value by 5 years. In contrast, dd-cfDNA(cp/mL) was stable during the observation period (P = 0.52, 0.29, and 0.39). In parallel increasing white blood cell counts and decreasing tacrolimus concentrations over time were observed. After 5 years, the median total cfDNA was still 1.6-fold (P < 0.001) higher in KTx recipients than in healthy controls (n = 135) and 1.4-fold (P < 0.001) higher than patients with other medical conditions (n = 364). CONCLUSIONS: The time-dependent decrease of host cfDNA resulted in an apparent increase of dd-cfDNA fraction in stable KTx patients. For long-term surveillance, measurement of absolute dd-cfDNA concentrations appears to be superior to percentages to minimize false positive results.

Donor-Derived Cell-Free DNA Testing in Solid Organ Transplantation: A Value Proposition.

BACKGROUND: There is a need to improve personalized immunosuppression in organ transplantation to reduce premature graft loss. More efficient biomarkers are needed to better detect rejection, asymptomatic graft injury, and under-immunosuppression. Assessment of minimal necessary exposure to guide tapering and to prevent immune activation is also important. Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) has become available for comprehensive monitoring of allograft integrity. A value proposition concept was applied to assess the potential benefits of dd-cfDNA to stakeholders (patient, transplant physician, laboratory medicine specialist, hospital management, insurance companies) involved in solid organ transplantation care. CONTENT: There is robust clinical evidence from more than 48 published studies supporting the role of dd-cfDNA for monitoring graft integrity and detection or exclusion of rejection. The value proposition framework was used to evaluate published key evidence regarding clinical validity, economic implications, and limitations of this approach. It has been shown that dd-cfDNA testing is essential for guiding earlier transplant injury intervention with potential for improved long-term outcome. SUMMARY: Monitoring dd-cfDNA offers a rapid and reproducible method to detect graft injuries at an early actionable stage without protocol biopsies and allows for more effective personalized immunosuppression. The appropriate use of dd-cfDNA testing can provide both clinical and economic benefits to all transplantation stakeholders.

A value proposition for natriuretic peptide measurement in the assessment of patients with suspected acute heart failure.

There is robust clinical trial evidence supporting the role of natriuretic peptides [NPs] in the assessment of patients presenting with suspected acute heart failure [AHF]. Despite the fact that clinical guidelines have for some time advocated NP measurement, the availability and uptake of NP testing in acute care services remains patchy and incomplete. The reasons for this are multifactorial but are underpinned by compartmentalised management and budget structures within complex healthcare delivery organisations. This paper outlines a value proposition for NP testing in the acute care setting which crosses the continuum of services and budgets. It articulates the expected benefits to each stakeholder in terms of efficiency of processes, clinical outcomes and cost effectiveness. It describes a pathway to implementation and suggests metrics that may be used to measure the effectiveness of introduction of NP testing. It is hoped that the value proposition will facilitate the uptake of NT testing fostering collaboration between laboratory, clinical, management and finance teams and by informing the development of business cases.