Getting Smaller by Denaturation: Acid-Induced Compaction of Antibodies.

Protein denaturation is a ubiquitous process that occurs both in vitro and in vivo. While our molecular understanding of the denatured structures of proteins is limited, it is commonly accepted that the loss of unique intramolecular contacts makes proteins larger. Herein, we report compaction of the immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) protein upon acid denaturation. Small-angle X-ray scattering coupled with size exclusion chromatography revealed that IgG1 radii of gyration at pH 2 were ∼75% of those at a neutral pH. Scattering profiles showed a compact globular shape, supported by analytical ultracentrifugation. The acid denaturation of proteins with a decrease in size is energetically costly, and acid-induced compaction requires an attractive force for domain reorientation. Such intramolecular aggregation may be widespread in immunoglobulin proteins as noncanonical structures. Herein, we discuss the potential biological significance of these noncanonical structures of antibodies.

Effect of backbone circularization on colloidal stability: Compaction of unfolded structures improves aggregation resistance of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor.

Aggregation of protein therapeutics can lead to immunogenicity and loss of function in vivo. Its effective prevention requires an understanding of the conformational and colloidal stability of protein and the improvement of both. Granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF), which is one of the most widely used protein therapeutics, was previously shown to be conformationally stabilized by connecting its N- and C-termini with amide bonds (backbone circularization). In this study, we investigated whether circularization affects the colloidal stability of proteins. Colloidal stability was indirectly assessed by analyzing the aggregation behavior of G-CSF variants using analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Consequently, we found that the unfolded structure of circularized G-CSF was more compact than non-circularized G-CSF, and that backbone circularization improved its aggregation resistance against chemical denaturation by guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl). The improved aggregation resistance suggests that the expansion tolerance of circularized G-CSF in the unfolded state increased its colloidal stability. Thus, backbone circularization is an excellent method for enhancing the colloidal and the conformational stability of protein with minimal sequence changes. It is therefore expected to be effective in extending the storage stability of protein therapeutics, enhancing their biological stability.

Histidine-Mediated Intramolecular Electrostatic Repulsion for Controlling pH-Dependent Protein-Protein Interaction.

Protein-protein interactions that can be controlled by environmental triggers have immense potential in various biological and industrial applications. In the current study, we aimed to engineer a pH-dependent protein-protein interaction that employs intramolecular electrostatic repulsion through a structure-guided histidine substitution approach. We implemented this strategy on Streptococcal protein G, an affinity ligand for immunoglobulin G, and showed that even a single point mutation effectively improved the pH sensitivity of the binding interactions without adversely affecting its structural stability or its innate binding function. Depending on the pH of the environment, the protein-protein interaction was disrupted by the electrostatic repulsion between the substituted histidine and its neighboring positively charged residues. Structurally, the substituted histidine residue was located adjacent to a lysine residue that could form hydrogen bonds with immunoglobulin G. Thermodynamically, the introduced electrostatic repulsion was reflected in the significant loss of the exothermic heat of the binding under acidic conditions, whereas accompanying enthalpy-entropy compensation partly suppressed the improvement of the pH sensitivity. Thus, the engineered pH-sensitive protein G could enable antibody purification under mildly acidic conditions. This intramolecular design can be combined with conventional protein-protein interface design. Moreover, the method proposed here provides us with additional design criteria for optimization of pH-dependent molecular interactions.

Engineered protein A ligands, derived from a histidine-scanning library, facilitate the affinity purification of IgG under mild acidic conditions.

BACKGROUND: In antibody purification processes, the acidic buffer commonly used to elute the bound antibodies during conventional affinity chromatograph, can damage the antibody. Herein we describe the development of several types of affinity ligands which enable the purification of antibodies under much milder conditions. RESULTS: Staphylococcal protein A variants were engineered by using both structure-based design and combinatorial screening methods. The frequency of amino acid residue substitutions was statistically analyzed using the sequences isolated from a histidine-scanning library screening. The positions where the frequency of occurrence of a histidine residue was more than 70% were thought to be effective histidine-mutation sites. Consequently, we identified PAB variants with a D36H mutation whose binding of IgG was highly sensitive to pH change. CONCLUSION: The affinity column elution chromatograms demonstrated that antibodies could be eluted at a higher pH (∆pH**≧2.0) than ever reported (∆pH = 1.4) when the Staphylococcal protein A variants developed in this study were used as affinity ligands. The interactions between Staphylococcal protein A and IgG-Fab were shown to be important for the behavior of IgG bound on a SpA affinity column, and alterations in the affinity of the ligands for IgG-Fab clearly affected the conditions for eluting the bound IgG. Thus, a histidine-scanning library combined with a structure-based design was shown to be effective in engineering novel pH-sensitive proteins.

Structure-based histidine substitution for optimizing pH-sensitive Staphylococcus protein A.

Optimizing antibody purification is crucial to overcoming a bottleneck in the costly manufacturing process for antibody therapy. To address this issue, we designed a pH-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus protein A variant that retained its innate stability and affinity toward antibody. On the basis of structural information and mutation analysis data, we identified candidate positions for accumulative histidine substitutions to cause electrostatic repulsion under acidic conditions. The histidine substitutions effectively decreased the dissociation rate under acidic conditions by three orders of magnitude. Avoiding deleterious effects of the substitutions, we successfully engineered a protein A variant that exhibited high pH sensitivity and maintained affinity, thermal stability, and alkaline tolerance. The variant was capable of serving as an affinity ligand that made affinity chromatography under milder acidic conditions possible; the elution peak shifted from pH 4.2 to 5.6. Only two substitutions were needed to achieve this pH sensitivity. This structure-based approach is applicable to other protein-based ligands.

Aggregation factor analysis for protein formulation by a systematic approach using FTIR, SEC and design of experiments techniques.

A simple systematic approach using Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and design of experiments (DOE) techniques was applied to the analysis of aggregation factors for protein formulations in stress and accelerated testings. FTIR and SEC were used to evaluate protein conformational and storage stabilities, respectively. DOE was used to determine the suitable formulation and to analyze both the main effect of single factors and the interaction effect of combined factors on aggregation. Our results indicated that (i) analysis at a low protein concentration is not always applicable to high concentration formulations; (ii) an investigation of interaction effects of combined factors as well as main effects of single factors is effective for improving conformational stability of proteins; (iii) with the exception of pH, the results of stress testing with regard to aggregation factors would be available for suitable formulation instead of performing time-consuming accelerated testing; (iv) a suitable pH condition should not be determined in stress testing but in accelerated testing, because of inconsistent effects of pH on conformational and storage stabilities. In summary, we propose a three-step strategy, using FTIR, SEC and DOE techniques, to effectively analyze the aggregation factors and perform a rapid screening for suitable conditions of protein formulation.

Thermostability of Rhodopseudomonas viridis and Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores reflecting physiological conditions.

Relationships between growth conditions and thermostability were examined for photosynthetic inner membranes (chromatophores) from Rhodopseudomonas viridis and Rhodospirillum rubrum of which morphology, lipid composition, and protein/lipid rate are rather mutually different. Signals observed by differential scanning calorimetry of the chromatophores were correlated with thermal state transitions of the membrane components by reference to temperature dependencies of circular dichroism and absorption spectra of the purified supramolecule comprising a photoreaction center and surrounding light-harvesting pigment-protein complexes that are the prominent proteins in both membranes. The differential scanning calorimetry curves of those chromatophores exhibited different dependencies on growth stages and environmental temperatures. The obtained result appeared to reflect the differences in the protein/lipid rate and protein-lipid specificity between the two chromatophores.

Optimizing pH response of affinity between protein G and IgG Fc: how electrostatic modulations affect protein-protein interactions.

Protein-protein interaction in response to environmental conditions enables sophisticated biological and biotechnological processes. Aiming toward the rational design of a pH-sensitive protein-protein interaction, we engineered pH-sensitive mutants of streptococcal protein G B1, a binder to the IgG constant region. We systematically introduced histidine residues into the binding interface to cause electrostatic repulsion on the basis of a rigid body model. Exquisite pH sensitivity of this interaction was confirmed by surface plasmon resonance and affinity chromatography employing a clinically used human IgG. The pH-sensitive mechanism of the interaction was analyzed and evaluated from kinetic, thermodynamic, and structural viewpoints. Histidine-mediated electrostatic repulsion resulted in significant loss of exothermic heat of the binding that decreased the affinity only at acidic conditions, thereby improving the pH sensitivity. The reduced binding energy was partly recovered by "enthalpy-entropy compensation." Crystal structures of the designed mutants confirmed the validity of the rigid body model on which the effective electrostatic repulsion was based. Moreover, our data suggested that the entropy gain involved exclusion of water molecules solvated in a space formed by the introduced histidine and adjacent tryptophan residue. Our findings concerning the mechanism of histidine-introduced interactions will provide a guideline for the rational design of pH-sensitive protein-protein recognition.

Crystal structure of a ten-amino acid protein.

What is the smallest protein? This is actually not such a simple question to answer, because there is no established consensus among scientists as to the definition of a protein. We describe here a designed molecule consisting of only 10 amino acids. Despite its small size, its essential characteristics, revealed by its crystal structure, solution structure, thermal stability, free energy surface, and folding pathway network, are consistent with the properties of natural proteins. The existence of this kind of molecule deepens our understanding of proteins and impels us to define an "ideal protein" without inquiring whether the molecule actually occurs in nature.