Chronic health conditions and their impact on the labor market. A cross-country comparison in Europe.

Objectives: To estimate the effect of having a chronic disease on the weekly working hours and the associated monetary losses. Design: Longitudinal data Survey of Health, Aging and Retirement (SHARE) in Europe. We analyzed 7 waves from 9 countries in Europe. A total of 80.672 observations. Setting: Participants who have their regular domicile in the respective SHARE country were interviewed face-to-face. Participants: Data from individuals aged between 50 and 65 years old in European countries were collected over seven years. A person was excluded from the survey if incarcerated, hospitalized or out of the country during the entire survey period, unable to speak the country's language(s) or moved to an unknown address. Interventions: Not applicable. Main outcome measurements: We applied a difference-in-differences with multiple time periods approach to estimate the effect of having a chronic condition on the number of working hours per week. We monetized the estimated productivity losses using the legal minimum wage in each country. Results: Persons with a chronic condition consistently reduced their weekly working hours compared to their healthy counterparts in the same country. This effect was more pronounced for men (6,78 hours per week or 352 hours per year) than women (3,97 hours per week or 206 hours per year). Persons with stroke, vascular, and lung disease showed the highest impact. On average, the reduced working hours represent about USD 12,80 billion annually in productivity losses in our sample. Conclusion: Having a chronic condition leads to people decreasing their working hours, which has significant economic losses. More severe health conditions showed the highest effects. This trend is observed in all the analyzed countries, highlighting the relevance of health and social systems to go beyond mortality and morbidity and the need to incorporate functioning in their target goals.

Labor market costs for long-term family caregivers: the situation of caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury in Switzerland.

BACKGROUND: Family members are key in the provision of care to persons facing disability. To undertake the role as caregivers, they face many costs, being the setback in the labor market one of the most relevant. METHODS: We analyze comprehensive data from long-term family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury (SCI) in Switzerland. Using information about their working situation before and after becoming caregivers, we estimated the reduction in working hours and the associated income loss. RESULTS: On average, family caregivers reduced their working hours by about 23% (8.4 h per week), which has a monetary value of CHF 970 per month (EUR 845). Women, older caregivers, and less educated caregivers have a much higher opportunity cost in the labor market: CHF 995 (EUR 867), CHF 1,070 (EUR 932), and CHF 1,137 (EUR 990) respectively. In contrast, family members who care for a person that works have a much lower impact on their working status, CHF 651 (EUR 567). Interestingly, the reduction in their working time is only a third of the extra work they face as caregivers. CONCLUSION: Health and social systems rely on the unpaid work of family caregivers. To guarantee their long-term involvement, family caregivers need to be recognized for their work and potentially compensated. Without family caregivers, it is very unlikely societies can cope with the increasing need for care, as professional services are limited and expensive.

Ageing, functioning patterns and their environmental determinants in the spinal cord injury (SCI) population: A comparative analysis across eleven European countries implementing the International Spinal Cord Injury Community Survey.

BACKGROUND: As the European population with Spinal Cord Injury (SCI) is expected to become older, a better understanding of ageing with SCI using functioning, the health indicator used to model healthy ageing trajectories, is needed. We aimed to describe patterns of functioning in SCI by chronological age, age at injury and time since injury across eleven European countries using a common functioning metric, and to identify country-specific environmental determinants of functioning. METHODS: Data from 6'635 participants of the International Spinal Cord Injury Community Survey was used. The hierarchical version of Generalized Partial Credit Model, casted in a Bayesian framework, was used to create a common functioning metric and overall scores. For each country, linear regression was used to investigate associations between functioning, chronological age, age at SCI or time since injury for persons with para- and tetraplegia. Multiple linear regression and the proportional marginal variance decomposition technique were used to identify environmental determinants. RESULTS: In countries with representative samples older chronological age was consistently associated with a decline in functioning for paraplegia but not for tetraplegia. Age at injury and functioning level were associated, but patterns differed across countries. An association between time since injury and functioning was not observed in most countries, neither for paraplegia nor for tetraplegia. Problems with the accessibility of homes of friends and relatives, access to public places and long-distance transportation were consistently key determinants of functioning. CONCLUSIONS: Functioning is a key health indicator and the fundament of ageing research. Enhancing methods traditionally used to develop metrics with Bayesian approach, we were able to create a common metric of functioning with cardinal properties and to estimate overall scores comparable across countries. Focusing on functioning, our study complements epidemiological evidence on SCI-specific mortality and morbidity in Europe and identify initial targets for evidence-informed policy-making.

The economic value of long-term family caregiving. The situation of caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury in Switzerland.

Health systems rely on the unpaid work of family caregivers. Nevertheless, demographic changes suggest a shortage of caregivers in the near future, which can constrain the long-term care policy in many countries. In order to find ways to support family caregivers, a primary effort would be to estimate how much their work is worth. This paper estimates the economic value of long-term family caregivers and how these costs would be shared by the health system, the social insurances and the cared-for person in the absence of informal caregivers. We use data of 717 family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury (SCI) in Switzerland. We implemented the proxy-good method and estimated the market value of their work if performed by professional caregivers. Our results show that family caregivers in the sample spent an average of 27 hr per week caring for a relative for almost 12 years. This work, if undertaken by professional home care, has a market value of CHF 62,732 (EUR 56,455) per year. In the absence of family caregivers, these costs should be financed by the health insurances (47%), by the cared-for person (24%) and by the social insurances (29%). It is in the best interest of the cared-for person and of the healthcare and social systems to keep a sustained supply of family caregivers. One option is finding ways to recognise and compensate them for their work and make it less cumbersome.

Measuring patient satisfaction in acute care hospitals: nationwide monitoring in Switzerland.

The National Association for Quality Development in Hospitals and Clinics (ANQ) has conducted patient satisfaction measurements in the inpatient sector in Switzerland since 2009. Specifically designed for this measurement, an instrument consisting of five questions was evaluated on an 11-point rating scale. Nevertheless, the instrument showed substantial ceiling effects, which did not allow for hospital discrimination. Therefore, ANQ initiated a revision testing different scales in a pilot study. The results showed that a 5-point verbal scale displayed good psychometric properties. Compared to the 7- or 11-point scales, the 5-point verbal scale exhibited reduced ceiling effects, which was more appropriate to compare hospitals. For the national public reporting of hospitals and clinics, risk adjustment by age and self-reported health status was recommended, which was not the case for gender, principal diagnosis, type of admission and insurance status.

Unmet health care needs and inequality: A cross-country comparison of the situation of people with spinal cord injury.

OBJECTIVE: To estimate and compare unmet health care needs of persons with spinal cord injury (SCI) across countries, the causes of these shortfalls, and the role of income. DATA SOURCES: We analyzed cross-sectional data of 20 countries from the International Spinal Cord Injury (InSCI) survey, a compendium of comparable data on the living situation of persons with SCI. Data included information on high-, middle-, and low-income countries. The survey comprises information on 12,095 participants. STUDY DESIGN: We used logit regressions to estimate the probability of unmet health care needs of persons with SCI and its causes. We adjusted the results by the individuals' characteristics and countries' fixed effects. We disaggregated the results by income decile of individuals in each country. DATA COLLECTION/EXTRACTION METHODS: The inclusion criteria for the InSCI survey were adults aged 18 years and older with SCI living in the community, who were able to respond to the survey and who provided informed consent. PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: Unmet health care needs are significant for people with long-term conditions like SCI, where people in low-income groups tend to be more affected. Among the barriers to meeting health care needs, the foremost is health care cost (in 11 of the 20 countries), followed by transportation and service availability. Persons with SCI in Morocco reported the highest probability of unmet health care needs in the sample, 0.54 (CI: 047-0.59), followed well behind by South Africa, 0.27 (CI: 0.20-0.33), and Brazil, 0.26 (CI: 0.20-0.33). In contrast, persons with SCI in Spain, 0.06 (CI: 0.04-0.08), reported the lowest probability of unmet health care needs, closely followed by Norway, 0.07 (CI: 0.05-0.09), Thailand, 0.08 (CI: 0.05-0.11), France, 0.08 (CI: 0.06-0.11), and Switzerland, 0.09 (CI: 0.07-0.10). CONCLUSIONS: SCI is a long-term, irreversible health condition characterized by physical impairment and a series of chronic illness. This makes SCI a high-need, high-cost group that faces significant unmet health care needs, which are mainly explained by the costs of health services, transportation, and services availability. This situation is prevalent in low-, middle-, and high-income countries, where persons in lower income groups are disproportionately affected. To improve the situation, a combination of measures from the health and social systems are required.

Health inequalities and income for people with spinal cord injury. A comparison between and within countries.

Income and health are related in a bi-directional manner, whereby level of income affects health and vice versa. People in poorer households tend to experience worse health status and higher mortality rates than people in wealthier households, and, at the same time, having poor health could restrict workability leading to less income. This gap exists in almost every country, and it is more pronounced in more unequal countries and in vulnerable populations, such as people experiencing disability. The goal of this paper is to estimate the health-income gap in people with a Spinal Cord Injury (SCI), which is a chronic health condition often associated with multiple comorbidities that leads to disability. As data on mortality is inexistent, to estimate the health-income gap for persons with SCI, this paper uses two health outcomes: the number of years a person has lived with the injury, and a comorbidity index. Data was obtained from the International Spinal Cord Injury survey (InSCI), which is the first worldwide survey on community-dwelling persons with SCI. To compare across countries, the health outcomes were adjusted through hierarchical models, accounting for country fixed-effects, individual characteristics such as age and gender, and injury characteristics (cause, type and degree). Our results suggest that for the years living with SCI, the gap varies from 1 to 6 years between the lowest and the highest income groups. The main driver of such a difference is the cause of injury, where injuries caused by work accidents showed the biggest gap. Similarly, for the comorbidity index, persons with SCI in poorer deciles reported significantly more comorbidities, forty times more, than people in richer deciles.

Professional home care and the objective care burden for family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury: Cross sectional survey.

Background: Spinal cord injury imposes high demands on family caregivers providing long-term care. Professional home care has been suggested for family caregivers' relief. However, it is not clear whether professional home care can achieve the goal of relieving family caregivers. Objective: To quantify to what extent professional home care was used as a relief or replacement for family caregivers, using the case of care for persons with spinal cord injury in Switzerland. Design: Cross-sectional survey. Setting: Community setting in Switzerland. Participants: 717 family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury living at home. Methods: Linear regression analyses were applied to investigate the relationship between care hours by family caregivers and the use of professional home care. Percentages of family caregivers that assisted in different tasks, and their time investment in the tasks, were contrasted between those with and without professional home care. Multiple logistic regression compared the likelihood of specific tasks being assisted by family caregivers dependent on whether professional home care was in place. The reasons given for not hiring more professional home care despite unmet needs were described with relative frequencies. Results: Adjusted for non-utilization, care hours of family caregivers had a positive, but insignificant, relationship with the hours of professional home care (Coef. = 0.21, 95% CI: -0.05-0.47). Assistance in activities of daily living was more frequent in family caregivers with professional home care. Eating and drinking assistance was provided by 47% of family caregivers with professional home care (versus 18% of those without professional home care). The most frequent task in instrumental activities of daily living was housekeeping (88% of family caregivers with professional home care and 83% of those without professional home care). After adjusting for characteristics of the caregivers and care recipients, significantly lower odds of assistance were found in washing feet (OR 0.39, 95% CI: 0.22-0.71), transferring to the toilet or bathtub (OR 0.53, 95% CI: 0.29-0.96), and climbing stairs (OR 0.26, 95% CI: 0.09-0.69). Higher odds of assistance were found in respiratory care (OR 2.22, 95% CI: 1.04-4.74) and bladder management (OR 1.99, 95% CI: 1.05-3.76) with professional home care in place. No significant difference was found in other tasks. Conclusion: Professional home care is a strong support to caregivers in high care demand situations, but it is not a replacement. The present study recommends further relief, empowerment, and acknowledgement for family caregivers.What is already known about the topic?• Evidence has shown that family caregivers replace paid domestic help or postpone the use of professional home care in the elderly population.• The large involvement translates into highly stressed family caregivers, for whom professional home care could serve as a relief.• Family caregivers reported low utilization of professional home care and some frustration with its use.What this paper adds• Family caregivers' time investment and involvement in tasks were adjusted based on the care demand of the care recipients.• Despite the presence of professional home care, family caregivers still invested a considerable amount of time and were heavily involved in activities of daily living.• Professional home care provided strong support for family caregivers in instances of higher care demand.

Living situation of family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the living situation of family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury. DESIGN: Cross-sectional questionnaire. SUBJECTS: Primary family caregivers of persons with chronic spinal cord injury in Switzerland. METHODS: Cross-sectional study of family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury. For comparison, the study population was matched to family care-givers of persons dealing with long-term health conditions in the general population, using a propensity-score based algorithm. RESULTS: A total of 717 family caregivers participat-ed in the survey (35% response rate). Participants were mostly female (72%), mean age 57 years, and had spent approximately 13 years caring for their relative. A mean of 21 h/week was spent providing care and assistance. The vast majority of family care-givers reported coping well with their situation. However, support from public services was deemed inadequate. Compared with family caregivers in the general population, family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury performed more caring tasks and reported a slightly lower quality of life. CONCLUSION: Family caregivers of persons with spinal cord injury are self-reliant to cope with their situation, but report discontent with public support ser-vices. The healthcare system could provide alternative support measures, such as direct financial compensation.

Quality of Life and the Health System: A 22-Country Comparison of the Situation of People With Spinal Cord Injury.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze and compare how performance of the health system are linked to the self-reported quality of life (QOL) of people with spinal cord injury (SCI) in 22 countries participating in the International Spinal Cord (InSCI) community survey. DESIGN: Cross-sectional survey. SETTING: Twenty-two countries representing all 6 World Health Organization regions, community setting. PARTICIPANTS: Persons (N=12,591) with traumatic or nontraumatic SCI aged ≥18 years. INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOMES: Self-reported satisfaction on several indicators that include: health, ability to perform daily activities, oneself, personal relationships, and living conditions. A total score of QOL was calculated using these 5 definitions. RESULTS: The most important indicators for self-reported QOL of persons with SCI were social attitudes and access to health care services, followed by nursing care, access to public spaces, the provision of vocational rehabilitation, transportation, medication, and assistive devices. In general, persons with SCI living in higher-income countries reported a higher QOL than people in lower-income countries, with some exceptions. The top performing country was The Netherlands with an estimated median QOL of 66% (on a 0%-100% scale). CONCLUSIONS: The living situation of people with SCI is highly influenced by the performance of the health system. Measuring and comparing health systems give accountability to a country's citizens, but it also helps to determine areas for improvement.

What influences the use of professional home care for individuals with spinal cord injury? A cross-sectional study on family caregivers.

STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional survey. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study is to identify what characteristics of the family caregivers influenced the use of professional home care for persons with SCI in Switzerland. SETTING: Community setting, nationwide in Switzerland. METHODS: Questionnaires were filled out by the adult family caregivers of persons with SCI. Influence of characteristics of the caregivers was analyzed with regression models, adjusting for the characteristics of the person with SCI. Logistic regression was used for whether professional home care was used. Poisson regression was applied for the absolute and relative amount of professional home care. RESULTS: In total, 717 family caregivers participated in the study (31% response rate). Among the participants, 33% hired professional home care for 10 h per week on average. The level of dependency of the persons with SCI had a significant influence on the utilization of care. The availability and proximity of the primary family caregiver, namely being spouse and cohabiting, reduced the amount of services used, whereas caregivers who worked full time employed more services. Higher levels of education and income increased the use of professional home care. Compared with their reference groups, caregivers with older age and those with a migratory background used comparable or larger absolute amount of professional services, which, however, represented a smaller proportion of total hours of care. CONCLUSIONS: Adequate support requires consideration of the characteristics of both the caregiver and of the person with SCI. The needs of family caregivers should also be assessed systematically in the needs assessment.

Place of residence & financial hardship: the situation of people with spinal cord injury.

BACKGROUND: Even with universal health coverage, people with long-term medical conditions can face financial hardship. However, financial hardship can be not only the result of an increase in health care costs; it has other socio-economic determinants that can cause social inequalities in terms of health. This study aims to estimate the impact of the place of residence on the financial hardship of people with spinal cord injury (SCI) in Switzerland. Switzerland is an interesting case to analyze because of its political system, where each of the 26 cantons is autonomous and responsible for raising its own income (through taxes) and providing public services. METHODS: Using cross-sectional data from the Swiss Spinal Cord Injury Cohort Study (SwiSCI), this paper estimates the probability of financial hardship by place of residence. The data set, recorded between 2011 and 2013, comprises information from 1549 participants aged 16 years and older, living with SCI. RESULTS: The results show that people face different probabilities of financial hardship, depending on their place of residence. In general, people in the French-speaking cantons have a higher probability of financial hardship compared with people living in the German- or Italian-speaking cantons. People in the cantons of Geneva and Graubünden have almost five times the probability of financial hardship, compared with people in the canton with the lowest probability of financial hardship, Zug. CONCLUSIONS: The place of residence is a determinant of the financial situation of a household where a member deals with a long-term health condition. The differences might arise due to variations in health care costs, the tax burden and social support system, which are regulated and administered by each canton.

Spillover Effects of Long-Term Disabilities on Close Family Members.

BACKGROUND: Care and support of people dealing with long-term disabilities involves the entire family. OBJECTIVE: This paper evaluates the effect of living with a relative dealing with a long-term disability on the health status of all family members in the household. METHODS: Using information from the Swiss household panel from the year 1999 to 2003 (n = 18,030), a linear regression is implemented to compare the health status of family members cohabiting with individuals dealing with a long-term disability with the health status of individuals of similar characteristics in the general population. Additionally, a non-parametric graphical analysis estimates the smooth patterns of the results over time. RESULTS: Family members who cohabit with a person dealing with a long-term disability have a consistently reduced health status. The size of the impact depends on the sex and the role in the family. In general, women show the most negative effects. For children, the impact depends on the relationship with the disabled person. CONCLUSIONS: Recognizing the presence of health spillovers can help to design policies to better support families. Being the perceived health status a good indicator of the use of health services and mortality, the health system should focus on the entire family, and not only on the patient or the main caregiver.

The 2016 Earthquake in Ecuador: Zika Outbreak After a Natural Disaster.

The objective of this work was to examine the spread of the Zika virus after the destructive impact of the earthquake of April 2016 along the coast of Ecuador. Using a difference-in-difference estimation method and a unique dataset to track Zika cases at the national level, we estimated the impact of the earthquake on the reported cases of Zika in the affected region. Our results suggest that the earthquake increased the reported cases of Zika by 0.509 per epidemiologic week (data per 10,000 population), and we argue that the destroyed built environment along with other factors created a disease focus, where the virus spread easily. Because of its potential complications and devastating long-term effects, Zika represents a national threat. After a natural disaster, the health authorities, together with a multidisciplinary team and the wider community, all have an urgent responsibility to collaborate to minimize the health risks to the population.