Some aspects of additives effects on retention in supercritical fluid chromatography studied by linear free energy relationships method.

This work is dedicated to the investigation of additives effects on retention mechanisms in supercritical fluid chromatography. Additives are compounds which are added to the mobile phase in small quantities and greatly affect retention factors, peak shape, separation selectivity and other chromatographic parameters. Linear free energy relationship (LFER) method with an expanded set of descriptors including the ones taking ionic interactions into account was used to probe the effect of four types of additive: trifluoroacetic acid, diethylamine, ammonium acetate and water - on retention on four polar stationary phase bearing different functional groups: bare silica, cyano, 2-ethylpyridine and zwitter-ionic sulfobetaine. Effects of all additives were shown to be complex, involving different intermolecular interactions and not uniform. The direction and magnitude of retention change depends not only on additive concentration, but on all other component of a chromatography system: type of a stationary phase, mobile phase composition and the nature of the solute. Various subtle effects were registered, the most peculiar among them being the fact that diethylamine and ammonium acetate provide identical changes of LFER constants. We hypothesize that this is caused by the convergence of diethylamine into a methylcarbamate via reaction with carbon dioxide and methanol, which then behaves as a salt additive.

Unusual effect of flow rate on retention in analytical supercritical fluid chromatography exemplified by polyethylene glycol separation.

We report a case of a peculiar effect of flow rate on retention in a separation of polyethylene glycol oligomers via supercritical fluid chromatography. During method development, we tested flow rate gradients and notices that for some PEG oligomers retention times at flow rate gradient were lower than at constant flow with the largest flow rate value used in a gradient. For instance, at BEH stationary phase and CO2-MeOH gradient from 10 to 35% at 20 min a PEG oligomer having mass of 1225 Da has a retention time 14 min at 1 mL/min flow rate, 10.3 at 2 mL/min and 9.5 min at 1-2 mL/min flow rate gradient. The effect is not unified for all PEG oligomers, it occurs only starting from a particular PEG molecular weight which depends on the stationary phase type and/or mobile phase conditions. We believe that such an unusual flow rate effects can happen in SFC on various occasions, not exclusively for flow rate gradients, and thus should be taken into account during method development or method transfer.

Evaluation of temperature and pressure effects on retention in supercritical fluid chromatography on polar stationary phases.

Four polar stationary phases (ethylene-bridged hybrid silica, cyanopropyl, 2-ethylpyridine, and zwitterionic sulfobetaine) have been characterized in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) by linear free energy relationships (LFER) method with an extended set of Abraham's descriptors. Temperature (25-55 °C) and pressure (110-180 bar) effects on analyte retention, separation selectivity and LFER-coefficients of chromatographic systems have been studied using the 89 test compounds of various chemical classes and carbon dioxide - methanol (9:1 v/v) binary solvent as a mobile phase. It was found that for the selected stationary phases temperature and pressure had only moderate effects on selectivity. The retention times of all analytes decrease, as can be expected, if the pressure rises at the isothermal conditions due to the increase of the fluid density and its eluting power. The effect of temperature on retention is complicated and depends both on the chemical class of analyzed compounds and the stationary phase type. Temperature and pressure variations lead to small changes in the LFER-coefficients, and general trends observed do not depend much on the stationary phase type. It may be difficult to interpret the LFER-analysis results because of the evident, more significant chromatographic phenomena.

Unexpected separate elution of cation and anion of an ammonium salt in supercritical fluid chromatography.

Amines are frequently used as additives in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). They allow eluting basic analytes with reasonable retention times and less distorted peak shapes. Since amines are chemically active compounds, their introduction into SFC mobile phase always raises a question on whether they can react with analytes or mobile phase constituents and, if so, can it affect chromatography separation. Primary and secondary amines are known to react with carbon dioxide, also all amines, being bases, can interact with CO2-alcohol mixtures which are known to be slightly acidic. In this work, we report a case of separate elution of an ammonium salt, salbutamol sulfate, anion and cation in SFC. Retention time of a peak which molecular mass registered by mass-spectrometry in ES(-) mode corresponds to HSO4- differs substantially from the retention time of a peak corresponding to salbutamol [M+H] registered in ES(+) regime. Moreover, sulfate anion retention time depends both on amine additive type and concentration whereas salbutamol retention time doesn't. Similar effect is observed on other columns as well as with other ammonium salts. We suppose that such behavior is caused by the exchange chemical reaction happening between ammonium salt analyte and amine additive. An additive converts a salt into a free base form and turns into a salt form itself. If this hypothesis is true, it might be important to take the possibility of such interactions into account during preparative SFC work since the compound injected might not be equivalent to a compound eluted.

A case of Z/E-isomers elution order inversion caused by cosolvent percentage change in supercritical fluid chromatography.

A case of elution order inversion caused by cosolvent percentage change in supercritical fluid chromatography was observed and investigated in some detail. Z- and E-isomers of phenylisobutylketone oxime experience an elution order reversal on most columns if the mobile phase consists of CO2 and alcohol. At lower percentages of alcohol Z-oxime is retained less, somewhere at 2-5% coelution occurs and at larger cosolvent volume elution order reverses - Z-oxime is eluted later than E-oxime. We suppose inversion with CO2-ROH phases happens due to a shift in balance between two main interactions governing retention. At low ROH percentages stationary phase surface is only slightly covered by ROH molecules so oximes primarily interact with adsorption sites via hydrogen bond formation. Due to intramolecular sterical hindrance Z-oxime is less able to form hydrogen bonds and consequently is eluted first. At higher percentages alcohols occupy most of strong hydrogen bonding sites on silica surface thus leaving non-specific electrostatic interactions predominantly responsible for Z/E selectivity. Z-oxime has a much larger dipole moment than E-oxime and at these conditions it is eluted later. Additional experimental data with CO2-CH3CN, hexane-iPrOH and CHF3-ROH mobile phases supporting this explanation are presented.