The Emerging Role of Tertiary Lymphoid Structures in Breast Cancer: A Narrative Review.

This narrative review aims to clarify the role of tertiary lymphoid structures in breast cancer. We examine their development, composition, and prognostic value, and current ways of recognizing them. A comprehensive literature review was performed using the PubMed/Medline, Scopus, and EMBASE databases. A significant area of interest in breast cancer research involves targeting immune checkpoint molecules, particularly in the triple-negative subtype, where treatment options remain limited. However, existing biomarkers have limitations in accurately predicting treatment response. In this context, tertiary lymphoid structures (TLSs) emerge as a prognostic biomarker and also as a promising predictive marker for response. TLSs are ectopic lymphoid formations or neo-organogenesis that can develop after prolonged exposure to inflammatory signals mediated by chemokines and cytokines. Their presence is inversely correlated with estrogen receptor (ER) and/or progesterone receptor (PR) expression, but positively associated with a higher pathologic complete response rate and improved overall survival. In certain scenarios, TLS-positive tumors were associated with improved outcomes regardless of the presence of PDL-1 (programmed cell death ligand 1) expression or TILs (tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes).

EasyEyes - A new method for accurate fixation in online vision testing.

Online methods allow testing of larger, more diverse populations, with much less effort than in-lab testing. However, many psychophysical measurements, including visual crowding, require accurate eye fixation, which is classically achieved by testing only experienced observers who have learned to fixate reliably, or by using a gaze tracker to restrict testing to moments when fixation is accurate. Alas, both approaches are impractical online as online observers tend to be inexperienced, and online gaze tracking, using the built-in webcam, has a low precision (±4 deg). EasyEyes open-source software reliably measures peripheral thresholds online with accurate fixation achieved in a novel way, without gaze tracking. It tells observers to use the cursor to track a moving crosshair. At a random time during successful tracking, a brief target is presented in the periphery. The observer responds by identifying the target. To evaluate EasyEyes fixation accuracy and thresholds, we tested 12 naive observers in three ways in a counterbalanced order: first, in the laboratory, using gaze-contingent stimulus presentation; second, in the laboratory, using EasyEyes while independently monitoring gaze using EyeLink 1000; third, online at home, using EasyEyes. We find that crowding thresholds are consistent and individual differences are conserved. The small root mean square (RMS) fixation error (0.6 deg) during target presentation eliminates the need for gaze tracking. Thus, this method enables fixation-dependent measurements online, for easy testing of larger and more diverse populations.

Emotions of subject and object affect beauty differently for images and music.

What role do the emotions of subject and object play in judging the beauty of images and music? Eighty-one participants rated perceived beauty, liking, perceived happiness, and perceived sadness of 24 songs, 12 art images, and 12 nature photographs. Stimulus presentation was brief (2 seconds) or prolonged (20 seconds). The stimuli were presented in two blocks, and participants took the Positive and Negative Affect Score (PANAS) mood questionnaire before and after each block. They viewed a mood induction video between blocks either to increase their happiness or sadness or to maintain their mood. Using linear mixed-effects models, we found that perceived object happiness predicts an increase in image and song beauty regardless of duration. The effect of perceived object sadness on beauty, however, is stronger for songs than images and stronger for prolonged than brief durations. Subject emotion affects brief song beauty minimally and prolonged song beauty substantially. Whereas past studies of beauty and emotion emphasized sad music, here we analyze both happiness and sadness, both subject and object emotion, and both images and music. We conclude that the interactions between emotion and beauty are different for images and music and are strongly moderated by duration.

Beauty isn't special: Comparing the information capacity of beauty and other sensory judgments.

Information theory (bits) allows comparing beauty judgment to perceptual judgment on the same absolute scale. In one of the most influential articles in psychology, Miller (1956) found that classifying a stimulus into one of eight or more categories of the attribute transmits roughly 2.6 bits of information. That corresponds to 7 ± 2 categories. This number is both remarkably small and highly conserved across attributes and sensory modalities. This appears to be a signature of one-dimensional perceptual judgment. We wondered whether beauty can break this limit. Beauty judgments matter and play a key role in many of our real-life decisions, large and small. Mutual information is how much information about one variable can be obtained from observing another. We measured the mutual information of 50 participants' beauty ratings of everyday images. The mutual information saturated at 2.3 bits. We also replicated the results using different images. The 2.3 bits conveyed by beauty judgment are close to Miller's 2.6 bits of unidimensional perceptual judgment and far less than the 5 to 14 bits of a multidimensional perceptual judgment. By this measure, beauty judgment acts like a perceptual judgment, such as rating pitch, hue, or loudness.

EasyEyes - Accurate fixation for online vision testing of crowding and beyond.

Online methods allow testing of larger, more diverse populations, with much less effort than in-lab testing. However, many psychophysical measurements, including visual crowding, require accurate eye fixation, which is classically achieved by testing only experienced observers who have learned to fixate reliably, or by using a gaze tracker to restrict testing to moments when fixation is accurate. Alas, both approaches are impractical online since online observers tend to be inexperienced, and online gaze tracking, using the built-in webcam, has a low precision (±4 deg, Papoutsaki et al., 2016). The EasyEyes open-source software reliably measures peripheral thresholds online with accurate fixation achieved in a novel way, without gaze tracking. EasyEyes tells observers to use the cursor to track a moving crosshair. At a random time during successful tracking, a brief target is presented in the periphery. The observer responds by identifying the target. To evaluate EasyEyes fixation accuracy and thresholds, we tested 12 naive observers in three ways in a counterbalanced order: first, in the lab, using gaze-contingent stimulus presentation (Kurzawski et al., 2023; Pelli et al., 2016); second, in the lab, using EasyEyes while independently monitoring gaze; third, online at home, using EasyEyes. We find that crowding thresholds are consistent (no significant differences in mean and variance of thresholds across ways) and individual differences are conserved. The small root mean square (RMS) fixation error (0.6 deg) during target presentation eliminates the need for gaze tracking. Thus, EasyEyes enables fixation-dependent measurements online, for easy testing of larger and more diverse populations.

A Th2-score in the tumor microenvironment as a predictive biomarker of response to Bacillus Calmette Guérin in patients with non-muscle invasive bladder carcinoma: A retrospective study.

Intravesical Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) is the gold standard therapy for intermediate/high-risk non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC). However, the response rate is ~60%, and 50% of non-responders will progress to muscle-invasive disease. BCG induces massive local infiltration of inflammatory cells (Th1) and ultimately cytotoxic tumor elimination. We searched for predictive biomarker of BCG response by analyzing tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte (TIL) polarization in the tumor microenvironment (TME) in pre-treatment biopsies. Pre-treatment biopsies from patients with NMIBC who received adequate intravesical instillation of BCG (n = 32) were evaluated retrospectively by immunohistochemistry. TME polarization was assessed by quantifying the T-Bet+ (Th1) and GATA-3+ (Th2) lymphocyte ratio (G/T), and the density and degranulation of EPX+ eosinophils. In addition, PD-1/PD-L1 staining was quantified. The results correlated with BCG response. In most non-responders, Th1/Th2 markers were compared in pre-and post-BCG biopsies. ORR was 65.6% in the study population. BCG responders had a higher G/T ratio and a greater number of degranulated EPX+ cells. Variables combined into a Th2-score showed a significant association with higher scores in responders (p = 0.027). A Th2-score cut-off value >48.1 allowed discrimination of responders with 91% sensitivity but lower specificity. Relapse-free survival was significantly associated with the Th2-score (p = 0.007). In post-BCG biopsies from recurring patients, TILs increased Th2-polarization, probably reflecting BCG failure to induce a pro-inflammatory status and, thus, a lack of response. PD-L1/PD-1 expression was not associated with the response to BCG. Our results support the hypothesis that a pre-existing Th2-polarized TME predicts a better response to BCG, assuming a reversion to Th1 polarization and antitumor activity.

The intrinsic variance of beauty judgment.

Recall memory and sequential dependence threaten the independence of successive beauty ratings. Such independence is usually assumed when using repeated measures to estimate the intrinsic variance of a rating. We call "intrinsic" the variance of all possible responses that the participant could give on a trial. Variance arises within and across participants. In attributing the measured variance to sources, the first step is to assess how much is intrinsic. In seven experiments, we measure how much of the variability across beauty ratings can be attributed to recall memory and sequential dependence. With a set size of one, memory is a problem and contributes half the measured variance. However, we showed that for both beauty and ellipticity, with set size of nine or more, recall memory causes a mere 10% increase in the variance of repeated ratings. Moreover, we showed that as long as the stimuli are diverse (i.e., represent different object categories), sequential dependence does not affect the variance of beauty ratings. Lastly, the variance of beauty ratings increases in proportion to the 0.15 power of stimulus set size. We show that the beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set is affected by the stimulus set size and not the value of other stimuli. Overall, we conclude that the variance of repeated ratings is a good way to estimate the intrinsic variance of a beauty rating of a stimulus in a diverse set.

Implementation of a virtual multicenter gastrointestinal tumor board to reduce cancer disparities in Argentina.

Given the increasing complexity of cancer care, multidisciplinary tumor boards have become essential in daily clinical oncology practice. The Project Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes (ECHO) initiative developed an innovative telementoring model using a "hub and spoke" design consisting of a team of experts (hub) that offers a full service to multiple participants (the spokes) during regularly scheduled sessions discussing patients' clinical cases. The Alexander Fleming Cancer Institute in Buenos Aires was the first hub in Latin America to implement Project ECHO for gastrointestinal tumors. In our 3-year experience, 80 patients from 37 centers were evaluated within Project ECHO and a range of three to five cases were discussed in each meeting. From our perspective, the impact of this novel approach was a remarkable strategy to reduce care disparities by equalizing access to high-quality medical knowledge in a multidisciplinary environment for medical discussions. Additionally, it was shown to have a cost-effective impact directly on the patients and the local health system, since relevant costs were saved after unnecessary treatments, studies and travel expenses were avoided.

Aesthetics: It's beautiful to me.

Beauty judgments, at least in part, determine what we wear, where we eat, and who we swipe right on Tinder. However, beauty judgments vary greatly across individuals, and a new study highlights the importance of assessing these individual differences.

Cyclin-Dependent Kinase 4/6 Inhibitor Outcomes in Patients With Advanced Breast Cancer Carrying Germline Pathogenic Variants in DNA Repair-Related Genes.

PURPOSE: In recent years, unprecedented benefits have been observed with the development of cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) 4 and 6 inhibitors for the treatment of hormone receptor-positive/human epidermal growth factor receptor 2-negative metastatic breast cancer. However, there is scarce evidence of their value in specific populations, such as patients carrying germline pathogenic variants in DNA repair-related genes. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We retrospectively studied the efficacy of CDK 4/6 inhibitors plus endocrine therapy in patients with hormone receptor-positive/human epidermal growth factor receptor 2-negative advanced breast cancer. Three cohorts were compared, including patients harboring germline pathogenic variants in DNA repair-related genes (gBRCA1/2-ATM-CHEK2 mutated), those tested without these mutations (wild type [WT]), and the nontested subgroup. Relevant prognostic factors including age, metastatic site (visceral v nonvisceral), Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group, and prior treatment with CDK 4/6 inhibitors were stratified by univariate and multivariate Cox regression models. RESULTS: Among the total population (n = 217), 15 (6.9%) patients carried gBRCA1/2 (n = 10)-ATM (n = 4)-CHEK2 (n = 1) pathogenic variants, 45 (20.7%) were WT, and 157 (72.4%) were nontested. Gene pathogenic variant carriers were younger (P < .001). Most patients (164, 75.6%) had not received prior endocrine therapy in the advanced setting. Median progression-free survival was shorter in patients with evaluated germline pathogenic variants (10.2 months [95% CI, 5.7 to 14.7]), compared with WT and nontested patients (15.6 months [95% CI, 7.8 to 23.4], and (17.6 months [95% CI, 12.9 to 22.2]; P = .002). Consistently, a worse median overall survival was observed in the subgroup with germline pathogenic variants than in the WT group (P = .006). Multivariable analysis showed that mutation status was an independent prognostic factor of progression-free survival (P = .020) and overall survival (P = .012). CONCLUSION: In this retrospective real-world study, gBRCA1/2-ATM-CHEK2 pathogenic variants were independently associated with poor outcomes in patients with advanced breast cancer treated with CDK4/6 inhibitors.

MORPHOLOGICAL DIVERSITY OF FACIAL VIBRISSAE IN Chaetophractus vellerosus (MAMMALIA, XENARTHRA, DASYPODIDAE) AND DIFFERENTIAL MECHANOPERCEPTION.

Vibrissae are specialized and complex mechanoreceptor organs present in the skin of most mammals that respond to a diverse mechanical stimuli (e.g. tension, pressure, movement, vibrations) and provide information on distance to the object, its location/orientation, and general characteristics of its surface; also, it may play diverse roles during food acquisition and attacking potential prey. There are scarce papers on the vibrissae of armadillos, only considering their presence/absence and distribution, but no histological analyses have been made. The goal of our contribution is to perform a histological study of the head vibrissae of Chaetophractus vellerosus, identify their morphological features, the tissues that form them, interpret their possible functions, and attempt to link the characteristics with ecological aspects of this species like its digging habits. Our results suggest that Chaetophractus vellerosus possesses two types of vibrissae: macro- and micro-vibrissae. Both types are similar in gross morphology, characterized mainly by an absence of annular sinus and ringwulst, but having a trabecular sinus that extends along the entire length of the follicle; these features might be linked to a reduction of its sensory capacity. Unlike other mammals, the macro-vibrissae are in the genal, anterobital and intermandibular regions, while micro-vibrissae are distributed in the superior labial and mental regions. In addition to size differences, the macro-vibrissae possess intrinsic muscles composed of smooth muscular fibers. The genal macro-vibrissae are very close to each other, with smooth muscle fibers connecting the capsules of adjacent ones (intrinsic muscles). Those from the superior labial and mental (micro-vibrissae), show bundles of striated muscle inserted on their capsules. These muscle fibers would be part of the facial musculature and could be considered as extrinsic muscles. The mobility of these two types of vibrissae must certainly be different, given that the respective muscles (intrinsic and extrinsic) have different origins and innervation. The presence of two types of vibrissae might indicate that these mechanoreceptors have differential perception capacities that would probably be complementary, thus providing more precise information about the environment. The presence of macro-vibrissae in the genal, anteorbital and intermandibular zone would be directly related to the life habits of Chaetophractus vellerosus.

Addressing the challenges of regulatory systems strengthening in small states.

Countries should ensure equitable access to quality medicines. Regulatory systems for medicines and other health technologies are an essential part of well-functioning health systems and are a requisite for achieving Universal Health and the Sustainable Development Goals. The Pan American Health Organization, the World health Organization (WHO) regional office for the Americas, has assessed national regulatory capacities using a precursor of WHO Global Benchmarking Tool, and conducted an analysis of the data which suggests an association of regulatory capacity with population and the size of the economy. Regulatory capacity tends to decrease as population and gross domestic product decreases. This predominantly impacts the Caribbean sub-region in the Americas, which includes many states with small populations and economies. This paper will use the World Bank's term 'small states' to refer to countries with 1.5 million people or less and other larger countries that face similar challenges. The regulatory challenges of small states include small markets and limited human and financial resources. However, small states can build regulatory systems with a narrower scope that are less resource intensive and still ensure appropriate regulation and oversight. The approach should be tailored to accomplish a subset of WHO recommended essential functions, including marketing authorisation, licensing of establishments and postmarket surveillance/pharmacovigilance, depending on the need to oversee local manufacturing, which requires a comprehensive system. The approach should also include adoption of efficiencies, such as regionalisation and reliance. This model is currently being put in practice in the small states of the Caribbean Community and Pacific Islands and can inform other small states around the world.

Overexpression of PIK3CA in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma is associated with poor outcome and activation of the YAP pathway.

OBJECTIVES: Phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase catalytic subunit alpha (PIK3CA) is commonly altered in many human tumors, leading to the activation of p110α enzymatic activity that stimulates growth factor-independent cell growth. PIK3CA alterations such as mutation, gene amplification and overexpression are common in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) and. We aim to explore how these alterations and clinical outcome are associated, as well as the molecular mechanisms involved. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Mutation and copy-number variation in PIK3CA, and whole-genome expression profiles, were analyzed in primary HNSCC tumors from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) cohort (n = 243). The results were validated in an independent cohort form the University Hospital of A Coruña (UHAC, n = 62). Expression of the PIK3CA gene protein product (PI3K p110α) and nuclear YAP were assessed in tissue microarrays in a cohort from the University Hospital 12 de Octubre (UH12O, n = 91). RESULTS: Only high expression of the PIK3CA gene was associated with poor clinical outcome. The study of gene expression, transcription factor and protein signatures suggested that the activation of the Hippo-YAP pathway, involved in organ size, stem cell maintenance and tumorigenesis, could underlie tumor progression in PI3KCA overexpressing tumors. Tissue arrays showed that PI3K p110α levels correlated with YAP nuclear localization in HNSCC tumors. CONCLUSIONS: High expression of PIK3CA in HNSCC primary tumors identifies patients at high risk for recurrence. In these tumors, progression could rely on the Hippo-YAP pathway instead of the canonical Akt/mTOR pathway. This observation could have important implications in the therapeutic options for patients.

Jaw biodynamic data for 24 patients with chronic unilateral temporomandibular disorder.

This study assessed 24 adult patients, suffering from severe chronic unilateral pain diagnosed as temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorder (TMD). The full dentate patients had normal occlusion and had never received an occlusal therapy, i.e., were with natural dental evolution/maturation. The following functional and dynamic factors were assessed: (1) chewing function; (2) TMJ remodeling or the condylar path (CP); and (3) lateral jaw motion or lateral guidance (LG). CPs were assessed using conventional axiography, and LG was assessed by K7 jaw tracking. Seventeen (71%) of the 24 (100%) patients consistently showed a habitual chewing side. The mean (standard deviation [SD]) of the CP angles was 47.90 (9.24) degrees. The mean (SD) of the LG angles was 42.95 (11.78) degrees. Data collection emerged from the conception of a new TMD paradigm where the affected side could be the habitual chewing side, the side with flatter lateral jaw motion or the side with an increased CP angle. These data may lead to improved diagnosis, therapy plans and evolution in TMD patients.

High Histologic Grade and High Ki-67 Expression Predict Phenotypic Alterations in Node Metastasis in Primary Breast Cancers.

PURPOSE: Several studies have shown that estrogen receptor (ER) and progesterone receptor (PR) expression and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) expression may vary during tumoral progression. We aimed to describe and compare ER, PR, and HER2 expressions in primary breast tumors and synchronic axillary nodal metastases, and evaluate phenotypic correlations between them. METHODS: Patients were identified prospectively through surgical procedures between September 2013 and July 2016. The status of ER, PR, HER2, and Ki-67 were pathologically analyzed in breast cancers and axillary nodal metastases; these patients were classified based on the breast cancer phenotypes into five subgroups. RESULTS: Synchronic axillary nodal metastases were observed in 127 patients. In breast cancers and nodal metastases, correlation analyses of ER, PR, and Ki-67 expression showed a statistical dependence and concordance between these samples was unambiguously demonstrated through Bland-Altman plots for each determination. Primary breast tumors were classified as follows: luminal A, 41.6%; luminal B, 40.0%; luminal B/HER2, 9.6%; HER2, 2.4%; triple negative, 6.4%. Alterations in phenotype were observed in 28% of patients. The most frequent phenotypic alteration was from luminal B to A (36.4%). Ten cases (30.3%) showed alterations with therapeutic implications; six gained HER2 overexpression, and four, hormonal receptor (HR) expression. A moderate strength of agreement (Cohen's κ coefficient, 0.59; 95% confidence interval, 0.48-0.71) was observed. In multivariate analyses, high histologic grade (odds ratio [OR], 2.79; p<0.047) and high Ki-67 expression (OR, 1.05; p<0.037) were independent factors predictive of phenotypic alterations. CONCLUSION: Strong correlations were observed in HR and Ki-67 expressions between primary breast tumors and axillary nodal metastases, and a moderate concordance was observed in their phenotypical characteristics. Nevertheless, alterations did exist, and one-third of these changes may have therapeutic implications. The nodal metastases of tumors with high grade and high Ki-67 expression may need to be analyzed, to obtain complete therapeutic information.

Expresión de E-cadherina y factor de crecimiento epidérmico en leucoplasias orales / Expression of E-cadherin and epidermal growth factor in oral leukoplakia

Introducción: se define a las leucoplasias orales como una placa blancaque no puede desprenderse por raspado y que no puede clasifi carse comoninguna otra lesión. Son lesiones con potencial maligno, relacionadascon la presencia de displasia epitelial. Estos cambios preneoplásicospueden ser evidenciados histológicamente como también a travésde técnicas que pongan en evidencia los diferentes cambios a nivelmolecular. La E-cadherina es una glicoproteína membranosa quedesempeña papeles importantes en el mantenimiento de la adhesióncélula-célula, la preservación de la polaridad del tejido epitelial y laintegridad estructural. Los factores de crecimiento epidérmico son unconjunto de moléculas de naturaleza proteica, biorreguladores, cuyafuncionalidad fundamental radica en el control del ciclo celular. Elobjetivo del presente trabajo es identifi car y comparar parámetros histológicosy moleculares predictores de riesgo de transformación malignaen leucoplasias orales. Material y métodos: El estudio correspondea un diseño observacional descriptivo. Se seleccionaron muestras de26 biopsias de leucoplasias orales, las cuales fueron evaluadas contécnica histológica de rutina y tinción con hematoxilina y eosina, luegosometidas a inmunomarcación con factor de crecimiento epidérmico yE-cadherina, donde se evaluó la intensidad de tinción y cambios en laexpresión de cada marcador, así como la localización en los diferentessubtipos celulares. Resultados: De las 26 leucoplasias observadas,16 mostraron histología con cambios hiperplásicos y 10 con cambiosdisplásicos leves a moderados. La expresión de E-cadherina no mostróalteraciones signifi cativas en leucoplasias sin displasia, sólo hubopérdida de expresión en aquellas leucoplasias con cambios displásicosde alto grado, en concordancia a los hallazgos histológicos...

Introduction: oral leukoplakia is defined as a white plaque thatcannot be removed by scraping and cannot be classifi ed as any otherdisease entity. They are potentially malignant lesions related to thepresence of epithelial dysplasia. These preneoplastic changes can bedetected histologically, as well as through techniques that demonstratediff erent changes at the molecular level. E-cadherin is a membraneglycoprotein that plays a major role in maintaining cell-cell adhesion,preserving structural integrity and the polarity of epithelial tissue.Epidermal growth factors are a group of bio-regulatory proteins,whose primary function is to control the cell cycle. The aim of thisstudy is to identify and compare the parameters for histological andmolecular markers for malignant transformation in oral leukoplakia.Material and methods: The study was observational and descriptive indesign. Samples were selected from 26 oral leukoplakia biopsies, whichwere routinely evaluated for histology and stained with hematoxylinand eosin, then subjected to immunostaining with epidermal growthfactor and E-cadherin, with the intensity of staining and changes inthe expression of each marker being evaluated. Results: Of the 26leukoplakia examined, 16 showed hyperplastic changes and 10 mildto moderate dysplastic changes. The expression of E-cadherin showedno signifi cant changes in non-dysplastic leukoplakia, while a lossof expression was found in only those leukoplakias with high-gradedysplastic changes, which was consistent with the histological fi ndings...

Regulatory convergence and harmonization: barriers to effective use and adoption of common standards.

Objective To evaluate 1) the level of use and adoption of eight Technical Documents (TDs) published by the Pan American Network for Drug Regulatory Harmonization (PANDRH) member states and 2) identify the hurdles that can prevent countries from successfully adopting a common standard. Methods An in-depth analysis of the incorporation of PANDRH Technical Document No. 1 ("TDNo1") recommendations in member states' national requirements was carried out. Results The results illustrate the role of PANDRH in promoting convergence/harmonization among its members. Conclusions The study results show that the rate of use of TDs varied greatly by product/area and country. Timing, TD content, and product/area, and, more importantly, national capacities, are critical determinants of the level of TD guideline adoption. While PANDRH TDs have proven instrumental for the harmonization/convergence of member states' national requirements, as shown by the level of convergence across a majority of the national requirements issued for vaccine licensing, several countries had yet to incorporate common standards due, in large part, to weak national regulatory capacities. Therefore, harmonization/convergence initiatives should include the strengthening of national regulatory capacities as part of their core strategy, which will, in turn, allow for the incorporation and deployment of common standards in all participating countries.

Regulatory convergence and harmonization: barriers to effective use and adoption of common standards / La convergencia y la armonización regulatorias: barreras en el uso y la adopción eficaces de normas comunes

Objective. To evaluate 1) the level of use and adoption of eight Technical Documents (TDs) published by the Pan American Network for Drug Regulatory Harmonization (PANDRH) member states and 2) identify the hurdles that can prevent countries from successfully adopting a common standard. Methods. An in-depth analysis of the incorporation of PANDRH Technical Document No. 1 (“TDNo1”) recommendations in member states’ national requirements was carried out. Results. The results illustrate the role of PANDRH in promoting convergence/harmonization among its members. Conclusions. The study results show that the rate of use of TDs varied greatly by product/area and country. Timing, TD content, and product/area, and, more importantly, national capacities, are critical determinants of the level of TD guideline adoption. While PANDRH TDs have proven instrumental for the harmonization/convergence of member states’ national requirements, as shown by the level of convergence across a majority of the national requirements issued for vaccine licensing, several countries had yet to incorporate common standards due, in large part, to weak national regulatory capacities. Therefore, harmonization/convergence initiatives should include the strengthening of national regulatory capacities as part of their core strategy, which will, in turn, allow for the incorporation and deployment of common standards in all participating countries.

Objetivo. Evaluar (1) la medida en que se usan y se han adoptado ocho documentos técnicos (DT) publicados por los estados miembros de la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica (Red PARF) y (2) definir los obstáculos que pueden impedir que los países adopten una norma común. Métodos. Se realizó un análisis minucioso de la incorporación de las recomendaciones contenidas en el Documento Técnico No. 1 (“DTNo1”) de la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica en los requisitos nacionales de los estados miembros. Resultados. Los resultados ilustran el papel que desempeña la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica en la promoción de la convergencia y armonización entre sus miembros. Conclusiones. Los resultados del estudio indican que el uso de los DT varía enormemente según el producto o el área y el país. El momento, el contenido del DT, el producto o área y, lo que es más importante, la capacidad nacional son factores determinantes del grado de adopción de las directrices contenidas en los DT. Si bien los DT de la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica han sido decisivos en la armonización y convergencia de los requisitos nacionales de los estados miembros, como demuestra el grado de convergencia de la mayor parte de los requisitos nacionales emitidos para la concesión de licencias para vacunas, varios países no habían incorporado normas comunes todavía debido, en gran parte, a una capacidad de reglamentación nacional deficiente. Por lo tanto, las iniciativas en pro de la armonización y convergencia deben comprender el fortalecimiento de la capacidad de reglamentación nacional como parte de su estrategia central, lo cual permitirá, a su vez, que se incorporen y desplieguen normas comunes en todos los países participantes.

Regulatory convergence and harmonization: barriers to effective use and adoption of common standards / La convergencia y la armonización regulatorias: barreras en el uso y la adopción eficaces de normas comunes

ABSTRACT Objective To evaluate 1) the level of use and adoption of eight Technical Documents (TDs) published by the Pan American Network for Drug Regulatory Harmonization (PANDRH) member states and 2) identify the hurdles that can prevent countries from successfully adopting a common standard. Methods An in-depth analysis of the incorporation of PANDRH Technical Document No. 1 (“TDNo1”) recommendations in member states’ national requirements was carried out. Results The results illustrate the role of PANDRH in promoting convergence/harmonization among its members. Conclusions The study results show that the rate of use of TDs varied greatly by product/area and country. Timing, TD content, and product/area, and, more importantly, national capacities, are critical determinants of the level of TD guideline adoption. While PANDRH TDs have proven instrumental for the harmonization/convergence of member states’ national requirements, as shown by the level of convergence across a majority of the national requirements issued for vaccine licensing, several countries had yet to incorporate common standards due, in large part, to weak national regulatory capacities. Therefore, harmonization/convergence initiatives should include the strengthening of national regulatory capacities as part of their core strategy, which will, in turn, allow for the incorporation and deployment of common standards in all participating countries.

RESUMEN Objetivo Evaluar (1) la medida en que se usan y se han adoptado ocho documentos técnicos (DT) publicados por los estados miembros de la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica (Red PARF) y (2) definir los obstáculos que pueden impedir que los países adopten una norma común. Métodos Se realizó un análisis minucioso de la incorporación de las recomendaciones contenidas en el Documento Técnico No. 1 (“DTNo1”) de la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica en los requisitos nacionales de los estados miembros. Resultados Los resultados ilustran el papel que desempeña la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica en la promoción de la convergencia y armonización entre sus miembros. Conclusiones Los resultados del estudio indican que el uso de los DT varía enormemente según el producto o el área y el país. El momento, el contenido del DT, el producto o área y, lo que es más importante, la capacidad nacional son factores determinantes del grado de adopción de las directrices contenidas en los DT. Si bien los DT de la Red Panamericana para la Armonización de la Reglamentación Farmacéutica han sido decisivos en la armonización y convergencia de los requisitos nacionales de los estados miembros, como demuestra el grado de convergencia de la mayor parte de los requisitos nacionales emitidos para la concesión de licencias para vacunas, varios países no habían incorporado normas comunes todavía debido, en gran parte, a una capacidad de reglamentación nacional deficiente. Por lo tanto, las iniciativas en pro de la armonización y convergencia deben comprender el fortalecimiento de la capacidad de reglamentación nacional como parte de su estrategia central, lo cual permitirá, a su vez, que se incorporen y desplieguen normas comunes en todos los países participantes.

Effective vaccine safety systems in all countries: a challenge for more equitable access to immunization.

Serious vaccine-associated adverse events are rare. To further minimize their occurrence and to provide adequate care to those affected, careful monitoring of immunization programs and case management is required. Unfounded vaccine safety concerns have the potential of seriously derailing effective immunization activities. To address these issues, vaccine pharmacovigilance systems have been developed in many industrialized countries. As new vaccine products become available to prevent new diseases in various parts of the world, the demand for effective pharmacovigilance systems in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) is increasing. To help establish such systems in all countries, WHO developed the Global Vaccine Safety Blueprint in 2011. This strategic plan is based on an in-depth analysis of the vaccine safety landscape that involved many stakeholders. This analysis reviewed existing systems and international vaccine safety activities and assessed the financial resources required to operate them. The Blueprint sets three main strategic goals to optimize the safety of vaccines through effective use of pharmacovigilance principles and methods: to ensure minimal vaccine safety capacity in all countries; to provide enhanced capacity for specific circumstances; and to establish a global support network to assist national authorities with capacity building and crisis management. In early 2012, the Global Vaccine Safety Initiative (GVSI) was launched to bring together and explore synergies among on-going vaccine safety activities. The Global Vaccine Action Plan has identified the Blueprint as its vaccine safety strategy. There is an enormous opportunity to raise awareness for vaccine safety in LMIC and to garner support from a large number of stakeholders for the GVSI between now and 2020. Synergies and resource mobilization opportunities presented by the Decade of Vaccines can enhance monitoring and response to vaccine safety issues, thereby leading to more equitable delivery of vaccines worldwide.