Lipid loss and compositional change during preparation of liposomes by common biophysical methods.

Liposomes are widely used as model lipid membrane platforms in many fields, ranging from basic biophysical studies to drug delivery and biotechnology applications. Various methods exist to prepare liposomes, but common procedures include thin-film hydration followed by extrusion, freeze-thaw, and/or sonication. These procedures have the potential to produce liposomes at specific concentrations and membrane compositions, and researchers often assume that the concentration and composition of their liposomes are similar to, if not identical, to what would be expected if no lipid loss occurred during preparation. However, lipid loss and concomitant biasing of lipid composition can in principle occur at any preparation step due to nonideal mixing, lipid-surface interactions, etc. Here, we report a straightforward method using HPLC-ELSD to quantify the lipid concentration and membrane composition of liposomes, and apply that method to study the preparation of simple POPC/cholesterol liposomes. We examine many common steps in liposome formation, including vortexing during re-suspension, hydration of the lipid film, extrusion, freeze-thaw, sonication, and the percentage of cholesterol in the starting mixture. We found that the resuspension step can play an outsized role in determining the overall lipid loss (up to ~50% under seemingly rigorous procedures). The extrusion step yielded smaller lipid losses (~10-20%). Freeze-thaw and sonication could both be employed to improve lipid yields. Hydration times up to 60 minutes and increasing cholesterol concentrations up to 50 mole% had little influence on lipid recovery. Fortunately, even conditions with large lipid loss did not substantially influence the target membrane composition more than ~5% under the conditions we tested. From our results, we identify best practices for producing maximum levels of lipid recovery and minimal changes to lipid composition during liposome preparation protocols. We expect our results can be leveraged for improved preparation of model membranes by researchers in many fields.

Choice of buffer in mobile phase can substantially alter peak areas in quantification of lipids by HPLC-ELSD.

Evaporative light scattering detectors (ELSD) are commonly used with high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to separate and quantify lipids, which are typically not easily detectable by more conventional methods such as UV-visible detectors. In many HPLC-ELSD methods to analyze lipids, a volatile buffer is included in the mobile phase to control the pH and facilitate separation between lipid species. Here, we report an unintended effect that buffer choice can have in HPLC-ELSD analysis of lipids - the identity and concentration of the buffer can substantially influence the resulting ELSD peak areas. To isolate this effect, we use a simple isocratic methanol mobile phase supplemented with different concentrations of commonly used buffers for ELSD analysis, and quantify the effect on peak width, peak shape, and peak area for seven different lipids (POPC, DOPE, cholesterol, sphingomyelin, DOTAP, DOPS, and lactose ceramide). We find that the ELSD peak areas for different lipids can change substantially depending on the mobile phase buffer composition, even in cases where the peak width and shape are unchanged. For a subset of analytes which are UV-active, we also demonstrate that the peak area quantified by UV remains unchanged under different buffer conditions, indicating that this effect is particular to ELSD quantification. We speculate that this ELSD-buffer effect may be the result of a variety of physical phenomenon, including: modification of aerosol droplet size, alteration of clustering of analytes during evaporation of the mobile phase, and mass-amplification or ion-pair effects, all of which could lead to differences in observed peak areas. Such effects would be expected to be molecule-specific, consistent with our data. We anticipate that this report will be useful for researchers designing and implementing HPLC-ELSD methods, especially of lipids.

Viral Size Modulates Sendai Virus Binding to Cholesterol-Stabilized Receptor Nanoclusters.

Binding to the host membrane is the initial infection step for animal viruses. Sendai virus (SeV), the model respirovirus studied here, utilizes sialic-acid-conjugated glycoproteins and glycolipids as receptors for binding. In a previous report studying single virus binding to supported lipid bilayers (SLBs), we found a puzzling mechanistic difference between the binding of SeV and influenza A virus (strain X31, IAVX31). Both viruses use similar receptors and exhibit similar cooperative binding behavior, but whereas IAVX31 binding was altered by SLB cholesterol concentration, which can stabilize receptor nanoclusters, SeV was not. Here, we propose that differences in viral size distributions can explain this discrepancy; viral size could alter the number of virus-receptor interactions in the contact area and, therefore, the sensitivity to receptor nanoclusters. To test this, we compared the dependence of SeV binding on SLB cholesterol concentration between size-filtered and unfiltered SeV. At high receptor density, the unfiltered virus showed little dependence, but the size-filtered virus exhibited a linear cholesterol dependence, similar to IAVX31. However, at low receptor densities, the unfiltered virus did exhibit a cholesterol dependence, indicating that receptor nanoclusters enhance viral binding only when the number of potential virus-receptor interactions is small enough. We also studied the influence of viral size and receptor nanoclusters on viral mobility following binding. Whereas differences in viral size greatly influenced mobility, the effect of receptor nanoclusters on mobility was small. Together, our results highlight the mechanistic salience of both the distribution of viral sizes and the lateral distribution of receptors in a viral infection.

Single-virus assay reveals membrane determinants and mechanistic features of Sendai virus binding.

Sendai virus (SeV, formally murine respirovirus) is a membrane-enveloped, negative-sense RNA virus in the Paramyxoviridae family and is closely related to human parainfluenza viruses. SeV has long been utilized as a model paramyxovirus and has recently gained attention as a viral vector candidate for both laboratory and clinical applications. To infect host cells, SeV must first bind to sialic acid glycolipid or glycoprotein receptors on the host cell surface via its hemagglutinin-neuraminidase (HN) protein. Receptor binding induces a conformational change in HN, which allosterically triggers the viral fusion (F) protein to catalyze membrane fusion. While it is known that SeV binds to α2,3-linked sialic acid receptors, and there has been some study into the chemical requirements of those receptors, key mechanistic features of SeV binding remain unknown, in part because traditional approaches often convolve binding and fusion. Here, we develop and employ a fluorescence microscopy-based assay to observe SeV binding to supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) at the single-particle level, which easily disentangles binding from fusion. Using this assay, we investigate mechanistic questions of SeV binding. We identify chemical structural features of ganglioside receptors that influence viral binding and demonstrate that binding is cooperative with respect to receptor density. We measure the characteristic decay time of unbinding and provide evidence supporting a "rolling" mechanism of viral mobility following receptor binding. We also study the dependence of binding on target cholesterol concentration. Interestingly, we find that although SeV binding shows striking parallels in cooperative binding with a prior report of Influenza A virus, it does not demonstrate a similar sensitivity to cholesterol concentration and receptor nanocluster formation.

Modulating the Influenza A Virus-Target Membrane Fusion Interface With Synthetic DNA-Lipid Receptors.

Influenza A virus (IAV) binds to sialylated glycans on the cell membrane before endocytosis and fusion. Cell-surface glycans are highly heterogeneous in length and glycosylation density, which leads to variations in the distance and rigidity with which IAV is held away from the cell membrane. To gain mechanistic insight into how receptor length and rigidity impact the mechanism of IAV entry, we employed synthetic DNA-lipids as highly tunable surrogate receptors. We tethered IAV to target membranes with a panel of DNA-lipids to investigate the effects of the distance and tether flexibility between virions and target membranes on the kinetics of IAV binding and fusion. Tether length and the presence of a flexible linker led to higher rates of IAV binding, while the efficiencies of lipid and content mixing were typically lower for longer and more rigid DNA tethers. For all DNA tether modifications, we found that the rates of IAV lipid and content mixing were unchanged. These results suggest that variations in the interface between IAV and a target membrane do not significantly impact the rate-limiting step of fusion or the low-pH-triggered engagement of viral fusion peptides with the target membrane. However, our results imply that the flexibility of the viral receptor is important for ensuring that hemifusion events are able to successfully proceed to pore formation.

Kinetic Modeling of West Nile Virus Fusion Indicates an Off-Pathway State.

West Nile virus (WNV) is a prominent mosquito-borne flavivirus that causes febrile illness in humans. To infect host cells, WNV virions first bind to plasma membrane receptors, then initiate membrane fusion following endocytosis. The viral transmembrane E protein, triggered by endosomal pH, catalyzes fusion while undergoing a dimer-to-trimer transition. Previously, single-particle WNV fusion data was interrogated with a stochastic cellular automaton simulation, which modeled the E proteins during the fusion process. The results supported a linear fusion mechanism, with E protein trimerization being rate-limiting. Here, we present corrections to the previous simulation, and apply them to the WNV fusion data. We observe that a linear mechanism is no longer sufficient to fit the data. Instead, an off-pathway state is necessary; these results are corroborated by per virus chemical kinetics modeling. When compared with a similar Zika virus fusion model, this suggests that off-pathway fusion mechanisms may characterize flaviviruses more broadly.

Influenza hemagglutinin drives viral entry via two sequential intramembrane mechanisms.

Enveloped viruses enter cells via a process of membrane fusion between the viral envelope and a cellular membrane. For influenza virus, mutational data have shown that the membrane-inserted portions of the hemagglutinin protein play a critical role in achieving fusion. In contrast to the relatively well-understood ectodomain, a predictive mechanistic understanding of the intramembrane mechanisms by which influenza hemagglutinin drives fusion has been elusive. We used molecular dynamics simulations of fusion between a full-length hemagglutinin proteoliposome and a lipid bilayer to analyze these mechanisms. In our simulations, hemagglutinin first acts within the membrane to increase lipid tail protrusion and promote stalk formation and then acts to engage the distal leaflets of each membrane and promote stalk widening, curvature, and eventual fusion. These two sequential mechanisms, one occurring before stalk formation and one after, are consistent with our experimental measurements of single-virus fusion kinetics to liposomes of different sizes. The resulting model also helps explain and integrate previous mutational and biophysical data, particularly the mutational sensitivity of the fusion peptide N terminus and the length sensitivity of the transmembrane domain. We hypothesize that entry by other enveloped viruses may also use sequential processes of acyl tail exposure, followed by membrane curvature and distal leaflet engagement.

Detecting and Controlling Dye Effects in Single-Virus Fusion Experiments.

Fluorescent dye-dequenching assays provide a powerful and versatile means to monitor membrane fusion events. They have been used in bulk assays, for measuring single events in live cells, and for detailed analysis of fusion kinetics for liposomal, viral, and cellular fusion processes; however, the dyes used also have the potential to perturb membrane fusion. Here, using single-virus measurements of influenza membrane fusion, we show that fluorescent membrane probes can alter both the efficiency and the kinetics of lipid mixing in a dye- and illumination-dependent manner. R18, a dye that is commonly used to monitor lipid mixing between membranes, is particularly prone to these effects, whereas Texas Red is somewhat less sensitive. R18 further undergoes photoconjugation to viral proteins in an illumination-dependent manner that correlates with its inactivation of viral fusion. These results demonstrate how fluorescent probes can perturb measurements of biological activity and provide both data and a method for determining minimally perturbative measurement conditions.

pH Dependence of Zika Membrane Fusion Kinetics Reveals an Off-Pathway State.

The recent spread of Zika virus stimulated extensive research on its structure, pathogenesis, and immunology, but mechanistic study of entry has lagged behind, in part due to the lack of a defined reconstituted system. Here, we report Zika membrane fusion measured using a platform that bypasses these barriers, enabling observation of single-virus fusion kinetics without receptor reconstitution. Surprisingly, target membrane binding and low pH are sufficient to trigger viral hemifusion to liposomes containing only neutral lipids. Second, although the extent of hemifusion strongly depends on pH, hemifusion rates are relatively insensitive to pH. Kinetic analysis shows that an off-pathway state is required to capture this pH-dependence and suggests this may be related to viral inactivation. Our surrogate-receptor approach thus yields new understanding of flaviviral entry mechanisms and should be applicable to many emerging viruses.

Disentangling Viral Membrane Fusion from Receptor Binding Using Synthetic DNA-Lipid Conjugates.

Enveloped viruses must bind to a receptor on the host membrane to initiate infection. Membrane fusion is subsequently initiated by a conformational change in the viral fusion protein, triggered by receptor binding, an environmental change, or both. Here, we present a strategy to disentangle the two processes of receptor binding and fusion using synthetic DNA-lipid conjugates to bind enveloped viruses to target membranes in the absence of receptor. This permits direct testing of whether receptor engagement affects the fusion mechanism as well as a comparison of fusion behavior across viruses with different receptor binding specificities. We demonstrate this approach by binding X-31 influenza virus to target vesicles and measuring the rates of individual pH-triggered lipid mixing events using fluorescence microscopy. Influenza lipid mixing kinetics are found to be independent of receptor binding, supporting the common yet previously unproven assumption that receptor binding does not produce any clustering or spatial rearrangement of viral hemagglutinin, which affects the rate-limiting step of pH-triggered fusion. This DNA-lipid tethering strategy should also allow the study of viruses where challenging receptor reconstitution has previously prevented single-virus fusion experiments.

Influenza viral membrane fusion is sensitive to sterol concentration but surprisingly robust to sterol chemical identity.

Influenza virions are enriched in cholesterol relative to the plasma membrane from which they bud. Previous work has shown that fusion between influenza virus and synthetic liposomes is sensitive to the amount of cholesterol in either the virus or the target membrane. Here, we test the chemical properties of cholesterol required to promote influenza fusion by replacing cholesterol with other sterols and assaying viral fusion kinetics. We find that influenza fusion with liposomes is surprisingly robust to sterol chemical identity, showing no significant dependence on sterol identity in target membranes for any of the sterols tested. In the viral membrane, lanosterol slowed fusion somewhat, while polar sterols produced a more pronounced slowing and inhibition of fusion. No other sterols tested showed a significant perturbation in fusion rates, including ones previously shown to alter membrane bending moduli or phase behavior. Although fusion rates depend on viral cholesterol, they thus do not require cholesterol's ability to support liquid-liquid phase coexistence. Using electron cryo-microscopy, we further find that sterol-dependent changes to hemagglutinin spatial patterning in the viral membrane do not require liquid-liquid phase coexistence. We therefore speculate that local sterol-hemagglutinin interactions in the viral envelope may control the rate-limiting step of fusion.

Choose your label wisely: water-soluble fluorophores often interact with lipid bilayers.

Water-soluble organic fluorophores are widely used as labels in biological systems. However, in many cases these fluorophores can interact strongly with lipid bilayers, influencing the interaction of the target with the bilayer and/or leading to misleading fluorescent signals. Here, we quantify the interaction of 32 common water-soluble dyes with model lipid bilayers to serve as an additional criterion when selecting a dye label.

Individual vesicle fusion events mediated by lipid-anchored DNA.

Membrane fusion consists of a complex rearrangement of lipids and proteins that results in the merger of two lipid bilayers. We have developed a model system that employs synthetic DNA-lipid conjugates as a surrogate for the membrane proteins involved in the biological fusion reaction. We previously showed that complementary DNA-lipids, inserted into small unilamellar vesicles, can mediate membrane fusion in bulk. Here, we use a model membrane architecture developed in our lab to directly observe single-vesicle fusion events using fluorescence microscopy. In this system, a planar tethered membrane patch serves as the target membrane for incoming vesicles. This allows us to quantify the kinetics and characteristics of individual fusion events from the perspective of the lipids or the DNA-lipids involved in the process. We find that the fusion pathways are heterogeneous, with an arrested hemi-fusion state predominating, and we quantitate the outcome and rate of fusion events to construct a mechanistic model of DNA-mediated vesicle fusion. The waiting times between docking and fusion are distributed exponentially, suggesting that fusion occurs in a single step. Our analysis indicates that when two lipid bilayers are brought into close proximity, fusion occurs spontaneously, with little or no dependence on the number of DNA hybrids formed.

Vesicle fusion observed by content transfer across a tethered lipid bilayer.

Synaptic transmission is achieved by exocytosis of small, synaptic vesicles containing neurotransmitters across the plasma membrane. Here, we use a DNA-tethered freestanding bilayer as a target architecture that allows observation of content transfer of individual vesicles across the tethered planar bilayer. Tethering and fusion are mediated by hybridization of complementary DNA-lipid conjugates inserted into the two membranes, and content transfer is monitored by the dequenching of an aqueous content dye. By analyzing the diffusion profile of the aqueous dye after vesicle fusion, we are able to distinguish content transfer across the tethered bilayer patch from vesicle leakage above the patch.

Covalent attachment of lipid vesicles to a fluid-supported bilayer allows observation of DNA-mediated vesicle interactions.

Specific membrane interactions such as lipid vesicle docking and fusion can be mediated by synthetic DNA-lipid conjugates as a model for the protein-driven processes that are ubiquitous in biological systems. Here we present a method of tethering vesicles to a supported lipid bilayer that allows the simultaneous deposition of cognate vesicle partners displaying complementary DNA, resulting in well-mixed populations of tethered vesicles that are laterally mobile. Vesicles are covalently attached to a supporting lipid bilayer using a DNA-templated click reaction; then DNA-mediated interactions between tethered vesicles are triggered by spiking the salt concentration. These interactions, such as docking and fusion, can then be observed for individual vesicles as they collide on the surface. The architecture of this new system also permits control over the number of lipid anchors that tether the vesicle to the supporting bilayer. The diffusion coefficient of tethered vesicles anchored by two lipids is approximately 1.6-fold slower than that of vesicles anchored only with a single lipid, consistent with a simple physical model.

A quartz crystal microbalance study of polycation-supported single and double stranded DNA surfaces.

A quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) was used to investigate the properties and formation of a genomic mammalian DNA surface on a polycationic poly(ethylenimine) (PEI) film. We show that both single- and double-stranded DNA films can be deposited on the PEI surface by modulating the DNA adsorption time. The two distinct DNA surfaces can be confirmed by their interactions with urea, a common DNA denaturant, and ethidium bromide, a common DNA intercalator, both of which lead to characteristic changes in the QCM-D frequency and dissipation. The hybridization process between surface-bound single-stranded DNA to complementary strands in solution can be resolved in real-time. Moreover, we have also investigated the effects of incorporating NaCl in the various PEI-DNA assemblies and have shown that higher ionic strengths lead to greater DNA adsorption to the PEI surface. An increase in the QCM-D resonant frequency and a decrease in dissipation occur when these assemblies are rinsed with salt-free water. We interpret these changes as a loss of counterions from the film and an increase in intrinsic ion-pair complexation, leading to a more rigid PEI-DNA assembly. Varying the salt content in the DNA film can be used to control the film thickness and morphology.

A real-time QCM-D approach to monitoring mammalian DNA damage using DNA adsorbed to a polyelectrolyte surface.

We have successfully demonstrated that the quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) can be used to monitor real-time damage to genomic mammalian DNA adsorbed to a polyelectrolyte surface. To reveal the capabilities of this technique, we exposed DNA surfaces to quercetin, an agent that has been implicated in causing DNA strand breaks in a Cu(II)-dependent fashion in vitro. We show that the QCM-D frequency and dissipation patterns that result from exposure of the DNA surfaces to quercetin-Cu(II) are consistent with the induction of DNA strand scission. We use QCM-D to furthermore demonstrate that this process is dependent on Cu(II) and that the DNA damage induced by quercetin can still be detected if Cu(II) is in situ with the DNA surface and not in solution phase.

Creation of mammalian single- and double-stranded DNA surfaces: a real-time QCM-D study.

The quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) is an excellent method for studying the creation of DNA-based surfaces and films. Previous studies have used QCM-D to focus on the construction of DNA surfaces composed of short synthetic DNA oligomers or plasmid DNA. Here, we have used QCM-D to monitor the creation of genomic single- and double-stranded calf thymus DNA surfaces on a polycation adsorbed to a SiO2 support. We have successfully monitored the hybridization between the ssDNA surfaces and their complementary strands in solution and have also shown that DNA multilayer formation can be observed using denatured calf thymus DNA. We have furthermore established that the ssDNA and dsDNA surfaces show different binding characteristics to ethidium bromide, a common dsDNA intercalator, demonstrating the potential use of such surfaces to identify possible DNA ligands.