Evaluation of the performance of multiple immunoassay diagnostic platforms on the National Microbiology Laboratory SARS-CoV-2 National Serology Panel.

BACKGROUND: Serological assays designed to detect SARS-CoV-2 antibodies are being used in serological surveys and other specialized applications. As a result, and to ensure that the outcomes of serological testing meet high quality standards, evaluations are required to assess the performance of these assays and the proficiency of laboratories performing them. METHODS: A panel of 60 plasma/serum samples from blood donors who had reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infections and 21 SARS-CoV-2 negative samples were secured and distributed to interested laboratories within Canada (n = 30) and the United States (n = 1). Participating laboratories were asked to provide details on the diagnostic assays used, the platforms the assays were performed on, and the results obtained for each panel sample. Laboratories were blinded with respect to the expected outcomes. RESULTS: The performance of the different assays evaluated was excellent, with the high-throughput platforms of Roche, Ortho, and Siemens demonstrating 100% sensitivity. Most other high-throughput platforms had sensitivities of >93%, with the exception of the IgG assay using the Abbott ARCHITECT which had an average sensitivity of only 87%. The majority of the high-throughput platforms also demonstrated very good specificities (>97%). CONCLUSION: This proficiency study demonstrates that most of the SARS-CoV-2 serological assays utilized by provincial public health or hospital laboratories in Canada have acceptable sensitivity and excellent specificity.

HISTORIQUE: Les dosages sérologiques conçus pour dépister les anticorps anti-SRAS-CoV-2 sont utilisés dans les études sérologiques et d'autres applications spécialisées. Par conséquent, et pour s'assurer que leurs résultats respectent des normes de qualité, il faut procéder à des évaluations de leur performance et de la compétence des laboratoires à les effectuer. MÉTHODOLOGIE: Les chercheurs ont obtenu une batterie de 60 prélèvements de plasma et de sérum chez des donneurs dont l'amplification en chaîne par polymérase après transcription inverse (RT-PCR) avait confirmé des infections par le SRAS-CoV-2 et de 21 prélèvements dont les résultats étaient négatifs au SRAS-CoV-2 et les ont distribués aux laboratoires intéressés du Canada (n = 30) et des États-Unis (n = 1). Ils ont invité les laboratoires participants à fournir de l'information détaillée sur les dosages diagnostiques utilisés, les plateformes sur lesquelles les dosages étaient exécutés et les résultats obtenus pour chaque échantillon. Les chercheurs ont demandé aux laboratoires participants de fournir de l'information détaillée sur les dosages diagnostiques utilisés, les plateformes sur lesquelles les dosages ont été effectués, et les résultats obtenus à l'égard de chaque échantillon. Les laboratoires ont mené les études à l'insu des résultats escomptés. RÉSULTATS: Les divers dosages avaient une excellente exécution, les plateformes à haut débit de Roche, d'Ortho et de Siemens démontrant une sensibilité de 100 %. La plupart des autres plateformes à haut débit avaient des sensibilités de plus de 93 %, à l'exception des dosages des IgG faisant appel à l'analyseur ARCHITECT d'Abbott, dont la sensibilité moyenne était de seulement 87 %. La majorité des plateformes à haut débit avaient également une très bonne spécificité (plus de 97 %). CONCLUSION: La présente étude de compétence démontre que la plupart des dosages sérologiques du SRAS-CoV-2 évalués dans des laboratoires sanitaires provinciaux ou les laboratoires hospitaliers du Canada possèdent une sensibilité acceptable et une excellente spécificité.

Paramagnetic probes in an organic semiconductor: µSR and DFT calculations of the Mu adducts of Alq3 and 8-hydroxyquinoline.

It has been claimed that longitudinal field muon spin relaxation (LF-µSR) experiments on the organic semiconductor (OSC) tris-(8-hydroxyquinoline)aluminum(III) (Alq3) have measured electron hopping rates of ∼1012s-1, while density functional theory (DFT) calculations suggest that electron hopping between a muoniated radical and a neighboring molecule is energetically unfavorable and that the LF-µSR experiments were probing muoniated radicals with localized spin density. We have performed avoided level crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-µSR) and transverse field muon spin rotation (TF-µSR) measurements on Alq3 and 8-hydroxyquinoline (8hq), which is meant to model the muoniated radicals present in Alq3 when they are not in an OSC. These are supplemented by benchmarked DFT calculations. The ALC-µSR and TF-µSR spectra of 8hq and Alq3 are best explained by Mu adding to all six secondary carbons of the quinolate rings with roughly equal yields and localized spin density. There is no evidence in the TF-µSR spectrum of Alq3 for the formation of radicals with muon hyperfine coupling constants of 23 or 91 MHz as reported earlier by others. Our measurements support the view that there is localized spin density on the molecule to which Mu is covalently bound and the muon is not a passive probe in organic systems as it can be incorporated into radicals that have different electronic structures to the parent compounds. The muoniated radicals in Alq3 are more short-lived than in 8hq, which could be due to interactions with mobile electrons in the OSC, but with electron spin flip rates on the order of ∼107s-1.

Dynamics and local environment of an aromatic counterion bound to di-chain cationic surfactant bilayers studied by avoided level crossing muon spin resonance: evidence for counterion condensation.

Avoided level crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-µSR) has been used to study the reorientational dynamics of muon-spin-labelled 2,4,6-trimethylbenzoate (246TMB-) counterions and their interaction with DODMAC (dioctadecyldimethylammonium chloride) bilayers in the Lα and Lß liquid crystalline states. The muoniated radical anion formed by the addition of muonium to the secondary carbons of the aromatic ring of 246TMB- is used as a local spin probe. The muon and methylene proton hyperfine parameters and the electron spin relaxation rate (λe) of the muoniated spin probe were determined as a function of temperature by modelling the ALC-µSR spectra with Monte Carlo numerical simulations. The observation of a Δ1 resonance indicates that 246TMB- is undergoing anisotropic motion and doesn't reside in the aqueous layer in either the Lα and Lß phases. The lack of an abrupt change in the hyperfine parameters or λe when the system goes from the Lß to the Lα lamellar liquid crystalline phases suggests that 246TMB- is located at the oil-water interface rather than within the bilayer. The hyperfine parameters indicate that 246TMB- is undergoing large amplitude reorientational motion about a preferred orientation resulting from the bilayer's electric field. The interaction between 246TMB- and the bilayer decreases and the amplitude of the wobbling-in-a-cone motion increases with increasing temperature. The temperature dependence of the electron spin relaxation rate indicates the barrier to reorientation is 41.7 kJ mol-1.

Partitioning of 2-phenylethanol and limonene cosurfactants in C12E4.

Avoided level-crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-µSR) has been used to study the dynamics and local environment of spin probes formed by muonium (Mu) addition to 2-phenylethanol (PEA) and limonene (1-methyl-4-(1-methylethenyl)-cyclohexene) in an aqueous dispersion of the nonionic surfactant C12E4 (tetra(ethylene glycol) n-dodecyl ether). The spin probes derived from both cosurfactants reside within the micelles in the L1 phase and the bilayers in the Lα phase rather than in the aqueous region. The local polarity measured by the different isomers of the Mu adducts of PEA suggests there is a water gradient within the micelles and bilayers. Slow rotation of the micelles broadened the Δ1 resonances with increasing temperature in the L1 phase while narrower Δ1 resonances were observed in the Lα phase due to the rapid rotation of the spin probes around a preferred axis, which was wobbling within a cone.

Rate of Molecular Transfer of Allyl Alcohol across an AOT Surfactant Layer Using Muon Spin Spectroscopy.

The transfer rate of a probe molecule across the interfacial layer of a water-in-oil (w/o) microemulsion was investigated using a combination of transverse field muon spin rotation (TF-µSR), avoided level crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-µSR), and Monte Carlo simulations. Reverse microemulsions consist of nanometer-sized water droplets dispersed in an apolar solvent separated by a surfactant monolayer. Although the thermodynamic, static model of these systems has been well described, our understanding of their dynamics is currently incomplete. For example, what is the rate of solute transfer between the aqueous and apolar solvents, and how this is influenced by the structure of the interface? With an appropriate choice of system and probe molecule, µSR offers a unique opportunity to directly probe these interfacial transfer dynamics. Here, we have employed a well characterized w/o microemulsion stabilized by bis(2-ethylhexyl) sodium sulfosuccinate (Aerosol OT), with allyl alcohol (CH2═CH-CH2-OH, AA) as the probe. Resonances due to both muoniated radicals, CMuH2-C*H-CH2-OH and C*H2-CHMu-CH2-OH, were observed with the former being the dominant species. All resonances displayed solvent dependence, with those in the microemulsion observed as a single resonance located at intermediate magnetic fields to those present in either of the pure solvents. Observation of a single resonance is strong evidence for interfacial transfer being in the fast exchange limit. Monte Carlo calculations of the ΔM = 0 ALC resonances are consistent with the experimental data, indicating exchange rates greater than 10(9) s(-1), placing the rate of interfacial transfer at the diffusion limit.

Hyperfine coupling constants of the cyclohexadienyl radical in benzene and dilute aqueous solution.

The muon hyperfine coupling constant (Aµ) of the muoniated cyclohexadienyl radical (C6H6Mu) has been directly measured in a 5 mM solution of benzene in water by the radio-frequency muon spin resonance (RF-µSR) technique. The relative shift of Aµ in aqueous solution compared with the value in neat benzene (ΔAµ/Aµ = +0.98(5)% at 293 K) can now be compared directly with theoretical predictions. Application of the RF-µSR method to other dilute systems will provide extremely important information on understanding solvent effects.

Muoniated spin probes in the discotic liquid crystal HHTT: rapid electron spin relaxation in the hexagonal columnar and isotropic phases.

Avoided level crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-µSR) spectroscopy was used to study radicals produced by the addition of the light hydrogen isotope muonium (Mu) to the discotic liquid crystal (DLC) 2,3,6,7,10,11-hexahexylthiotriphenylene (HHTT). Mu adds to the secondary carbon atoms of HHTT to produce a substituted cyclohexadienyl radical, whose identity was confirmed by comparing the measured hyperfine coupling constants with values obtained from DFT calculations. ALC-µSR spectra were obtained in the isotropic (I), hexagonal columnar (Col(h)), helical (H), and crystalline (Cr) phases. In the I and Col(h) phases the radicals, which are incorporated within the stacks of HHTT molecules as isolated paramagnetic defects, undergo extremely rapid electron spin relaxation, on the order of a hundredfold faster than in the H or Cr phases. The electron spin relaxation rate increases significantly with increasing temperature and appears to be caused by the liquidlike motion within the columns, which modulates the overlap between the π system of the radical and the π systems of the neighboring HHTT molecules, and hence, the hyperfine coupling constants. Rapid electron spin relaxation should occur for any π radical incorporated within the columns of a DLC, which may limit the utility of DLCs for future spin-based technologies.

How do strain and steric interactions affect the reactions of aromatic compounds with free radicals? Characterization of the radicals formed by muonium addition to p-xylene and [2.2]paracyclophane by DFT calculations and muon spin spectroscopy.

Muoniated radicals were produced by the addition of muonium (Mu) to the aromatic compound p-xylene (1) in the solid and liquid states and to the strained aromatic compound [2.2]paracyclophane (2) in the solid state. The radicals were characterized by avoided level crossing muon spin resonance spectroscopy and identified by comparing the experimentally determined muon hyperfine coupling constants with values obtained from DFT calculations. Mu was observed to add to both the secondary and tertiary carbons of 1, with the relative yield of the Mu adduct of the tertiary carbons estimated to be ∼10% in the liquid phase. The relative yield of the tertiary adduct is much higher in the solid state although this cannot be calculated exactly due to the overlap of resonances and the apparent nonuniform distribution of the radical orientations. There are three possible addition sites in 2 due to the lower symmetry of the six-membered ring compared with 1. Mu can add to the secondary carbons either from the outside of 2, generating the "exo" adduct, or from the inside, generating the "endo" adduct. The relative yields of the exo, endo, and tertiary carbon adducts are 67.1(1), 21.8(1), and 11.1(1)%, respectively. The barriers to Mu addition at the different sites of isolated molecules were determined from DFT calculations. The barriers for Mu addition to 2 are lower than the barriers for Mu addition to 1, except for addition to the "endo" position, where the unfavorable steric interactions with the second ring of 2 raise the addition barrier considerably. The measured relative yields do not reflect the distribution of products calculated using the activation energies obtained from the DFT calculations due to strong steric interactions with neighboring molecules.

Molecular dynamics in rod-like liquid crystals probed by muon spin resonance spectroscopy.

Muoniated spin probes were produced by the addition of muonium (Mu) to two rod-like liquid crystals: N-(4-methoxybenzylidene)-4'-n-butylaniline (MBBA) and cholesteryl nonanoate (CN). Avoided level crossing muon spin resonance spectroscopy was used to characterize the muoniated spin probes and to probe dynamics at the molecular level. In MBBA Mu adds predominantly to the carbon of the bridging imine group and the muon and methylene proton hyperfine coupling constants (hfccs) of the resulting radical shift in the nematic phase due to the dipolar hyperfine coupling, the ordering of the molecules along the applied magnetic field and fluctuations about the local director. The amplitude of these fluctuations in in the nematic phase of MBBA is determined from the temperature dependence of the methylene proton hfcc. Mu adds to the double bond of the steroidal ring system of CN and the temperature dependence of the Δ(1) line width provides information about the amplitude of the fluctuations about the local director in the chiral nematic phase and the slow isotropic reorientation in the isotropic phase.

Muon spin spectroscopy of the discotic liquid crystal HAT6.

Avoided level crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-muSR) has been used to study the cyclohexadienyl-type radicals produced by the addition of muonium (Mu) to the discotic liquid crystal HAT6 (2,3,6,7,10,11-hexahexyloxytriphenylene) in the crystalline (Cr) phase, the hexagonal columnar mesophase (Col(h)) and isotropic (I) phase. In the Cr phase unpaired electron spin density can be transferred from the radical to neighboring HAT6 molecules depending on the overlap of their pi-systems and hence on the relative orientation of the triphenylene rings. The two Delta(1) resonances in the ALC-muSR spectra of the Cr phase indicate that the neighboring HAT6 molecules have two preferred orientations with respect to the radical: one which results in negligible spin density transfer and a second where 17% of the unpaired spin density is transferred. The ALC-muSR spectra in Col(h) and I phases are substantially different from those of the Cr phase in that there are two narrow resonances superimposed on an extremely broad and intense resonance. The narrow resonances are due to highly mobile radicals located in the aliphatic region between the columns and the broad resonance is due to radicals incorporated within the columns of HAT6 molecules. The large width and amplitude of this resonance indicates that the radicals within the columns are undergoing rapid electron spin relaxation but the mechanism that causes this relaxation is unknown.

Muon spin spectroscopy of the nematic liquid crystal 4-n-pentyl-4'-cyanobiphenyl (5CB).

Avoided level crossing muon spin resonance (ALC-microSR) spectroscopy has been used to study the four cyclohexadienyl-type radicals produced by the addition of muonium (Mu) to the rodlike liquid crystal 4-n-pentyl-4'-cyanobiphenyl (5CB). ALC-microSR spectra have been obtained over a wide temperature range in the isotropic, nematic, and crystalline phases. Four Delta0 resonances were observed in the ALC-microSR spectra, from which the methylene proton hyperfine coupling constants (hfcs) of the Mu adducts of 5CB were determined as a function of temperature. The methylene proton hfcs of two of the radicals have unusual temperature dependence in the nematic phase and have smaller values than would be predicted from extrapolating the data in the isotropic phase. We have used the Maier-Saupe theory for rodlike liquid crystals to explain the temperature dependence of the methylene proton hfcs, which results from the ordering of the 5CB molecules, the alignment of the molecules with the external magnetic field, and fluctuations that average the anisotropic hyperfine coupling constants. There are no Delta1 resonances in the ALC-microSR spectra of the nematic phase due to the radicals rotating rapidly around the long molecular axis and fluctuations about the local director. The Delta0 resonances broaden substantially as the temperature is lowered due to the slowing down of the fluctuations, which have an average activation energy of approximately 15.9 kJ mol(-1). Cooling the sample below 275 K stopped the rotation around the long molecular axis and led to the appearance of Delta1 resonances.

Solvation of a hydrogen isotope in aqueous methanol, NaCl, and KCl solutions.

The muon hyperfine coupling constant (hfc) of the light hydrogen isotope muonium (Mu) was measured in aqueous methanol, NaCl, and KCl solutions with varying concentrations, in deuterated water, and in deuterated methanol. The muon hfc is shown to be sensitive to the size and composition of the primary solvation shell, and the three-dimensional harmonic oscillator model of Roduner et al. (J. Chem. Phys. 1995, 102, 5989) has been modified to account for dependence of the muon hfc on the methanol or salt concentration. The muon hfc of Mu in the aqueous methanol solutions decreases with increasing methanol concentration up to a mole fraction (chiMeOH) of approximately 0.4, above which the muon hfc is approximately constant. The concentration dependence of the muon hfc is due to hydrophobic nature of Mu. It is preferentially solvated by the methyl group of methanol, and the proportion of methanol molecules in the primary solvation shell is greater than that in the bulk solution. Above chiMeOH approximately 0.4, Mu is completely surrounded by methanol. The muon hfc decreases with increasing methanol concentration because more unpaired electron spin density is transferred from Mu to methanol than to water. The unpaired electron spin density is transferred from Mu to the solvent by collisions that stretch one of the solvents bonds. The amount of spin density transferred is likely inversely related to the activation barrier for abstraction from the solvent, which accounts for the larger muon hfc in the deuterated solvents. The muon hfc of Mu in electrolyte solution decreases with increasing concentration of NaCl or KCl. We suggest that the decrease of the muon hfc is due to the amount of spin density transferred from Mu to its surroundings being dependent on the average orientation of the water molecules in the primary solvation shell, which is influenced by both Mu and the ions in solution, and spin density transfer to the ions themselves.

Local ordering in liquids: solvent effects on the hyperfine couplings of the cyclohexadienyl radical.

Ordering of solvent molecules in the vicinity of a dipolar free radical affects its hyperfine coupling constants (hfcs). Specifically, it is demonstrated how the variation of the experimental methylene proton and muon hfcs of the muoniated cyclohexadienyl radical in several solvents and solvent mixtures of varying polarity can be accounted for by a dipole-dipole reaction field model that is based on the model of Reddoch and Konishi (J. Chem. Phys. 1979, 70, 2121) which was developed to explain the solvent dependence of the 14N hfc in the di-tert-butyl-nitroxide radical. Ab initio calculations were carried out with the cyclohexadienyl radical in an electric field to model the electric field arising from the electric dipole moments of the surrounding solvent molecules. An extension of the model that includes the dipole-quadrupole interaction can account for the larger hfc in benzene compared with that in octadecane, and it is predicted that the hfc will be proportional to the concentration of quadrupole moments to the 4/3 power. The influence of hydrogen bonding between the radicals' pi electrons and the OH groups of the solvent on the hfcs is also discussed. Comparison with gas-phase data permits a separation of vibrational effects and reveals that approximately 28% of the temperature dependence in water is due to increasing solvent disorder.

Partitioning of small amphiphiles at surfactant bilayer/water interfaces: an avoided level crossing muon spin resonance study.

The temperature-dependent variation of local environment and reorientation dynamics of the small amphiphile 2-phenylethanol in lamellar phase dispersions of the dichain cationic surfactants, 2,3-diheptadecyl ester ethoxypropyl-1,1,1-trimethylammonium chloride (DHTAC) and dioctadecyldimethylammonium chloride (DODMAC), and the nonionic surfactant, tetra(ethylene glycol) n-dodecyl ether (C12E4), have been determined using avoided level crossing muon spin resonance spectroscopy (ALC-muSR). For cosurfactant radicals the hydrophobic or hydrophilic character of the surrounding media can be determined from their magnetic resonance signatures. Comparison of the three different bilayer-forming surfactant systems shows that the ALC-muSR technique is able to distinguish both major and subtle differences in the partitioning of the cosurfactant radicals between the different systems.