Metastatic Breast Cancer as a Chronic Disease: Evidence-Based Data on a Theoretical Concept.

BACKGROUND: We challenge the concept of metastatic breast cancer (MBC) as a chronic disease. METHODS: We analyzed an unselected cohort of 367 patients who were diagnosed with MBC over a 22-year period (1990-2011). RESULTS: In order to create a "chronic disease subgroup", we separated those patients from the entire cohort in whom systemic therapy was not applied after the diagnosis of MBC (n = 53; 14.4%). Three hundred fourteen patients (85.6%) comprised the "chronic disease subgroup". The vast majority of those patients (89.8%) died of progressive disease after a median metastatic disease survival (MDS) of 25 months. Twenty patients (6.4%) died of non-MBC-related causes (MDS 38.5 months). Approximately 1 in 4 patients (26.8%) died within the first year after the MBC diagnosis. The 3- and 5-year MDS rates were 35.4 and 16.2%, respectively. Only 12 patients (3.8%) were exceptional survivors (MDS >10 years). CONCLUSION: The term "chronic disease" might be appropriate in selected MBC cases, bringing MBC into alignment with "classical" chronic diseases such as diabetes and hypertension. However, most cases display fundamental differences with regard to temporal progression and above all the case fatality rate. More than 90% of patients in the "chronic disease subgroup" died of the disease with a MDS of 2-3 years (even those who underwent systemic palliative therapies). Doctors and patients might understand the term "chronic disease" differently. The term must be used sparingly and explained carefully in order to create a common level of communication based on a shared understanding which avoids awakening false hopes and fostering misleading expectations.

Radiological Staging for Distant Metastases in Breast Cancer Patients with Confirmed Local and/or Locoregional Recurrence: How Useful are Current Guideline Recommendations?

BACKGROUND: Breast cancer patients with local and/or locoregional recurrence (LR) are at higher risk of developing distant metastases (DM) at a later time. Once LR has been confirmed, some international interdisciplinary guidelines recommend performing radiological examinations for DM to determine the course of further therapy (curative or palliative approach). This study analyzed the metastatic patterns of patients with LR with particular regard to the frequency of concurrent diagnosis of LR and DM; in other words: are radiological staging procedures actually justified for DM at the time of diagnosis of LR? METHODS: This study included all patients (n = 1368) who were diagnosed and treated for nonmetastatic breast cancer (Stage I-III) at the University Women's Hospital Basel, Switzerland between 1990 and 2009. RESULTS: In 137 patients, LR was diagnosed without a history of DM: in-breast/thoracic wall only, n = 90 (65.7%); involvement of axillary/supra-/infraclavicular lymph nodes, n = 47 (34.3%). DM was found at the time of diagnosis of LR in 44 patients (32.1%). Concurrent diagnosis of LR and DM occurred significantly more often in patients with lymph node recurrence compared with those with in-breast/chest wall recurrence (48.9% vs. 23.3%; p = 0.004). CONCLUSIONS: Approximately one-third of patients with a LR had synchronous DM at the time of their local/locoregional event. For this reason, routine systemic staging imaging at the time of LR should be an absolute requirement for planning further therapy. Confirmation of DM may spare the patients radical surgical interventions with questionable impact on survival in the face of an incurable disease.

Long-Term Survival and Cure in Distant Metastatic Breast Cancer.

BACKGROUND: Previous data showed that distant metastatic breast cancer (MBC) might be curable in up to 3% of the cases in selected patients, mostly young, with good performance status and with low-volume metastatic disease, mainly by an aggressive multidisciplinary approach including aggressive combination chemotherapy regimens. These long-lasting responses question the belief that MBC is wholly incurable. This study evaluates the rate of long-term survivors and potentially cured patients in an unselected cohort of MBC patients. METHODS: We analyzed the data from 342 patients in whom distant MBC was diagnosed from 1990 to 2011. For this study, we defined a metastatic disease survival (MDS) of 9 years as inclusion criterion for long-term survivorship. RESULTS: Eighteen patients (5.3%) were long-term survivors (MDS: 126 months; range, 108-300 months). The rate of long-term survivors was equally distributed over time (1990-1999: 4.3% vs. 2000-2011: 5.9%, p = 0.63). Compared to patients who had a lower MDS, long-term survivors had significantly more often primary MBC (p = 0.005) and hormone receptor-positive carcinomas (p = 0.015). Age at MBC diagnosis, presence of visceral metastases, and limited number of metastatic sites at the time of MBC diagnosis appeared to have no significant impact on long-term survival. Long-term survival was not associated with the use of chemotherapy (50.0% vs. 65.7% in the control group, p = 0.21). Eight patients (2.3%) developed a complete remission and presented with no evidence of disease at the time of last follow-up (MDS: 234.5 months). CONCLUSION: Since long-term survivors in MBC comprise a relatively heterogeneous group, the factors that lead to the quite rare and felicitous case of long-term survival or even cure can hardly be evaluated systematically. Some patients may be considered cured of their disease. This fraction may be small, but the chance of survival, and even of cure, truly exists. Perhaps we must accept that the factors contributing to long-term survival remain an enigma. It appears, however, that aggressive chemotherapy is not the only key factor to long-term remission.

Noncompliance with palliative systemic therapy in patients with distant metastatic breast cancer: a blind spot for oncologists?

PURPOSE: The goal of our study was to provide a general overview of noncompliance with palliative systemic therapy in distant metastatic breast cancer (MBC). METHODS: We analyzed an unselected cohort of 339 patients who were diagnosed with MBC over a 22-year period (1990-2011, age restriction: ≥ 85 years old). RESULTS: Forty patients (11.8%) rejected the offered or recommended systemic therapy (age distribution of this noncompliance subgroup: ≤60 years at MBC diagnosis: 7.9%; 60-70 years: 13.2%; > 70 years: 15.6%). The rate of noncompliance was equally distributed over time (1990-1999: 12.2% vs. 2000-2011: 11.5%, p = 0.87). Compared to patients who had received palliative antineoplastic systemic therapy, those who remained untreated were significantly older (70 vs. 61 years, p = 0.015), had shorter metastatic disease survival (2 vs. 27 months, p < 0.001), had more often an aggressive tumor subtype (hormone-receptor negative carcinomas: 48.7% vs. 22.2%, p < 0.001), and had more often secondary MBC (95.0% vs. 73.6%, p = 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Although the high rate of noncompliance in the subgroup of elderly patients was not unexpected, it is noticeable that even in the subgroup of patients who were younger than 60 years, approximately 8% also rejected any systemic therapy before a MBC-related death occurred This group of younger women rarely had any relevant comorbidities, were potential candidates for chemotherapy and knowingly declined the therapy options. Such patients are never or seldom seen by oncologists in their daily practice and therefore play a minor role in their personal perception of disease. Nevertheless, these under-reported cases make up a significant proportion of MBC.

Use of Palliative Endocrine Therapy in Patients with Hormone Receptor-Positive Distant Metastatic Breast Cancer: How Often, How Effective, How Long?

BACKGROUND: This study provides real-world clinical evidence regarding palliative endocrine therapy (ET) in breast cancer (BC). The main questions to be answered were: how often and how long did patients receive ET? A particular aspect was the analysis of compliance and persistence with ET. METHODS: An analysis of a nonselected/consecutive cohort of women with distant metastatic hormone receptor-positive BC (n = 205) was conducted. RESULTS: In all, 165 patients (80.5%) received ET during the palliative disease course. The noncompliance rate was 1.5%. Sixty-seven patients (40.6%) had ET as the only antineoplastic therapy. The median number of therapy lines was 2, and the median duration was 18 months. The median metastatic disease survival (MDS) was 34 months. In patients who had an MDS of ≥9 months (n = 145; 87.9%), during 70.6% of the MDS time only ET had been administered. Patients who were naïve to ET more often had a good response to and a longer duration of palliative ET than those who were not. The nonpersistence rate was 4.3%. CONCLUSIONS: Excluding the few patients who had a rapidly progressive course, the disease was controlled for about 70% of the entire palliative disease course with ET alone. Only very few patients were nonpersistent with ET and consciously stopped a still effective, ongoing ET.

Self-detection and clinical breast examination: comparison of the two "classical" physical examination methods for the diagnosis of breast cancer.

UNLABELLED: This is the first comprehensive analysis comparing specific aspects of tumor detection between the two "traditional" breast cancer detection methods self-detection (SD) and clinical breast examination (CBE). a) Which method is better in detecting smaller tumors? Both methods showed similar mean tumor diameters (SD: 22.1 mm vs. CBE: 21.9 mm; p = 0.991). b) Different frequency distributions of tumor locations would indicate that certain locations in the breast are more difficult to palpate: comparison of both methods showed comparable results (p = 0.835). c) General differences in tumor sizes with regard to certain locations would be of importance because the patients and/or the physicians could be educated to pay particular attention to certain locations during physical examination, where larger tumors tend to be found: tumors located in the central region were with 25.0 mm significantly larger than those in the peripheral regions of the breast (superior: 21.6 mm, p = 0.001; inferior: 21.6 mm, p = 0.015; lateral: 21.9 mm, p = 0.002; medial (20.9 mm, p = 0.001). Tumor sizes within the four peripheral regions did not differ significantly. d) Patients whose tumors were found by CBE were older than those whose tumors were found by SD (67 years vs. 60 years, p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: annual CBE should be an integral part of general medical care in older women.

Personal or first-degree family breast cancer history: which has higher impact on tumor detection and tumor size in breast cancer.

PURPOSE: A woman's risk of developing breast cancer (BC) is increased if she has a personal history (PH) or family history (FH) of the disease. We compared the impact of the two risk factors PH and FH on tumor detection and tumor size at diagnosis in a cohort of BC patients. METHODS: The study cohort comprised 1,037 invasive BC patients (≤70 years at diagnosis). From these, 92 patients (8.5%) had a positive PH and 151 patients (13.7%) had a positive first-degree FH. RESULTS: Compared to the tumors of patients without PH or FH, the lesions of patients who had a positive PH or a positive FH were more often found by radiologic breast examinations (RBE) (PH: 49.4%, FH: 43.4%, no PH/FH: 26.2%; both comparisons p < 0.001). In patients with a positive FH, the tumors were slightly less often found by RBE as in patients with a positive PH (p = 0.468). Patients with a positive PH or FH had smaller tumors compared with those without such a history (PH: 19.7 mm, FH: 19.6 mm, no PH/FH: 26.7 mm; p = 0.015/p < 0.001). The tumor sizes of patients with a positive PH were almost identical to those of patients with a positive FH (p = 0.999). CONCLUSIONS: In women with a positive FH or PH of BC, the increased awareness of BC risk led to the detection of smaller tumors compared to women who have not had this experience. However, comparison of the two risk factors showed that they had a similar impact on the RBE detection rate of BC lesions and that the tumor sizes were nearly identical.

The impact of overweight and obesity on breast cancer: data from Switzerland, so far a country little affected by the current global obesity epidemic.

This review presents results from the project "The Impact of Overweight/Obesity on Breast Cancer: data from Switzerland". Swiss data is interesting because the general female population is distinctive in two areas when compared to that of most other industrialized countries: Switzerland has comparatively low rates of overweight (22-23%) and obesity (7-8%) and has rather stable rates of overweight and obesity. The entire project comprised three major issues: (I) etiology of breast cancer (BC). There is a consistently shown association between obesity and postmenopausal BC risk in countries with high obesity prevalence rates in the literature. In our Swiss study group, however, we did not find higher rates of overweight and obesity in postmenopausal BC cases than in the general population. A possible explanation for this observation may be a curvilinear dose-response relationship between BMI and postmenopausal BC risk, so that an increased risk may only be observed in populations with a high prevalence of obese/very obese women; (II) tumor characteristics. BMI was significantly associated with tumor size; this applied not only to the cases where the tumor was found by self-detection, but also to lesions detected by radiological breast examinations. In addition, a higher BMI was positively correlated with advanced TNM stage, unfavorable grading and a higher St. Gallen risk score. No associations were observed between BMI and histological subtype, estrogen receptor status, HER2 status and triple negative BC; (III) patient compliance and persistence towards adjuvant BC therapy. Many studies found that the prognosis of overweight/obese BC patients was significantly lower than that of normal weight patients. However, failure of compliance and persistence towards therapy on the part of the patient is not a contributing factor for this observed unfavorable prognosis. In most therapy modes, patients with increasing BMI demonstrated greater motivation and perseverance towards the recommended treatment.

Impact of breast cancer family history on tumor detection and tumor size in women newly-diagnosed with invasive breast cancer.

This study evaluated the impact of family history (FH) on tumor detection, the patient's age and tumor size at diagnosis in breast cancer (BC). Furthermore, we investigated whether the impact of FH on these features was dependent on degree of relationship, number of relatives with a BC history, or the age of the affected relative at the time that her BC was diagnosed. Out of the entire cohort (n = 1,037), 244 patients (23.5%) had a positive FH; 159 (15.3%) had first-degree relatives affected with BC and 85 patients (8.2%) had second-degree affected relatives. Compared to women who had no BC-affected relatives, the tumors of women who had positive FH were more often found by radiological breast examination (RBE: 31.7%/27.2%, p = 0.008), and they were smaller (general tumor size: 21.8 mm/26.4 mm, p = 0.003; size of tumors found by breast self-examination (BSE): 26.1 mm/30.6 mm, p = 0.041). However, this positive effect of increased use of BC screening and smaller tumor sizes was only observed in patients whose first-degree relatives were affected (comparison with second-degree affected relatives: RBE: 43.8%/24.7%; odds ratio 2.38, p = 0.007; general tumor size: 19.3 mm/26.3 mm; mean difference (MD) -6.9, p = 0.025; tumor size found by BSE: 22.5 mm/31.0 mm; MD -8.5, p = 0.044). When more second-degree relatives or older relatives were diagnosed with BC, the tumors of these patients were similarly often detected by RBE (relationship: 24.7%/27.2%, p = 0.641; age: 33.7 %/27.2 %, p = 0.177) and had similar tumor sizes (general size: 26.3 mm/26.4 mm, p = 0.960; BSE: 31.0 mm/30.6 mm, p = 0.902) as those of women without a FH. Women with a positive FH generally use mammography screening more often and perceive changes in the breast earlier than women without such history. The increased awareness of BC risk decreases if the relationship is more distant.

Compliance and persistence of endocrine adjuvant breast cancer therapy.

This study evaluates compliance and persistence in adjuvant endocrine breast cancer (BC) therapy by clearly analyzing reasons of therapy cessation by differentiating clinical meaningful situations. In order to illuminate the complex field of personal motivation to therapy, a single institution study with a more individual-based approach might better be suited to provide a detailed case documentation than the more epidemiologic approach of large database studies. An unselected cohort of 698 patients (≤ 80 years) diagnosed with hormonal receptor-positive BC from 1997 to 2008 at the University Hospital Basel, Switzerland, was analyzed. The term "non-persistence" was exclusively used for patients where the discontinuation of endocrine therapy (ET) could have been modified by more intensive care and improved counseling (e.g., in women who lost faith/motivation to therapy or those who suffered from therapy-related side effects). These cases must be differentiated from cases where therapy cessation was inevitable (e.g., due to recurrent disease or severe intercurrent illness). Out of the 685 patients to whom ET was recommended, 42 patients (6.1%) refused and never began treatment (non-compliance). Women younger than 50 were more likely to be non-compliant (P < 0.001). 12.9% of the patients who started therapy were non-persistent to therapy. Patients who were treated by general practitioners tended to be non-persistent more often compared to those treated by oncologists (17.7% vs. 11.3%; P = 0.07). The aim of a non-persistence rate between 10 and 15% is realistic when patients are treated by specialized oncologists. Interventions are needed to support patients, particularly the younger ones, to comply with therapy. Efforts should be made to make sure that all physicians, above all general practitioners, who are involved in BC treatment, are provided with current knowledge as to guarantee an optimal patient management.

Impact of overweight and obesity on postmenopausal breast cancer: analysis of 20-year data from Switzerland.

PURPOSE: Greater body fatness has been identified as a risk factor for postmenopausal breast cancer. For countries with low overweight/obesity rates, data on prevalence and time course of overweight/obesity in women with breast cancer in comparison to women in the general population is limited. The Swiss female population is distinctive for two reasons: (a) low rates of overweight/obesity compared with other western countries, and (b) no obesity epidemic, i.e. stable rates of overweight/obesity for more than 10 years. METHODS: Overweight and obesity were analyzed in 51 to 80-year-old breast cancer patients initially diagnosed between 1990 and 2009. Patient data was derived from the Basel Breast Cancer Database (BBCD). This data was compared with the data of women of the same age from the four Swiss Health Surveys (SHS) conducted between 1992 and 2007. Differences between measured (BBCD) and self-reported (SHS) data were corrected using equations approved for the Swiss population. RESULTS: Of 958 postmenopausal BBCD patients, 32% were overweight and 20% were obese. Of the 14,476 women of the SHS, 38% were overweight and 17% were obese. In the BBCD, there was no change in the prevalence of overweight/obesity over the last 20 years. The four SHS show a convex curvature for obesity, i.e. a transient increase. No significant differences were observed between BBCD and corrected SHS data for overweight and obesity during this period. CONCLUSIONS: In this Swiss study group with a comparably low prevalence of overweight and obesity, no association between body fatness and postmenopausal breast cancer was observed.

Impact of body mass index on compliance and persistence to adjuvant breast cancer therapy.

Several authors found that the prognosis of overweight and obese breast cancer (BC) patients was lower than that of normal weight patients. We present the first study which evaluates the impact of body mass index (BMI) on compliance (i.e. to start a recommended therapy) and persistence to adjuvant BC therapy. An unselected cohort of 766 patients (≤75 years) diagnosed from 1997 to 2009 was analyzed in relevance to the four adjuvant therapy modalities: (A) radiation, (B) chemotherapy, (C) therapy with trastuzumab, and (D) endocrine therapy. With respect to compliance, multivariate analyses calculated Odds ratios (ORs) >1 for increased BMI in all four therapy modalities, i.e. increased BMI had a positive influence on compliance. The results were significant for radiotherapy (OR,2.37;95%CI,1.45-3.88;p < 0.001) and endocrine therapy (OR,1.92;95%CI,1.21-3.04;p = 0.002) and showed a trend in chemotherapy (OR,1.42;95%CI,0.97-2.08;p = 0.063). Analyzing persistence, increasing BMI had ORs <1 for chemotherapy and therapy with trastuzumab, both not reaching statistical significance. For endocrine therapy, increasing BMI was a significant predictor for persistence (OR,1.35;95%CI,1.08-1.80;p = 0.042). Failure of compliance and persistence to adjuvant therapy does not pose a contributing factor for the observed unfavorable prognosis in overweight/obese BC patients. In most therapy modes, patients with increasing BMI demonstrated a higher motivation and perseverance to the recommended treatment.

Eligibility, compliance and persistence of sequential therapy with aromatase inhibitors following 2-3 years of tamoxifen in endocrine adjuvant breast cancer therapy.

OBJECTIVE: This study evaluated the eligibility, compliance and persistence of sequential therapy, i.e. a switch to an aromatase inhibitor (AI) following 2-3 years of tamoxifen, in adjuvant endocrine breast cancer (BC) treatment. METHODS: Data concerning 388 BC patients (age ≤70 years) who started endocrine adjuvant therapy between 1998 and 2008 were analyzed. RESULTS: From the 263 patients who started therapy with tamoxifen, 167 (63.5%) were eligible for a sequential therapy. Fifty-nine patients (35.3%) were offered a switch by their physicians; women who had their follow-up at oncological units received the offer more often when compared to those treated by general practitioners (p < 0.001). Out of these 59 patients, 50 followed the proposal (compliance 84.7%). Of those who agreed to a sequential therapy, 2 (4%) were non-persistent to endocrine therapy; in 9 cases (18.0%), a re-switch to tamoxifen was done due to AI-related adverse side effects. CONCLUSIONS: Only a minority of the patients who started an endocrine adjuvant BC therapy was eligible for sequential therapy. Patients who underwent a switch had a high rate of persistence. Efforts should be made to make sure that all physicians, above all general practitioners, who are involved in the treatment of BC patients, are provided with current therapy guidelines.

Menopausal state in breast cancer: how reliable is the data?

UNLABELLED: Despite the high importance of the menopausal state for the management of breast cancer, above all, when planning antihormonal adjuvant therapy, the menopausal state cannot be defined at the time of diagnosis ina significant proportion of women. The scope of uncertainties regarding the recording of the menopausal state in a cohort of patients with breast cancer is evaluated. INTRODUCTION: Menopause is a cornerstone both in breast cancer (BC) pathophysiology and in clinical management. The scope of uncertainties regarding the recording of the menopausal state in a cohort of patients with BC is evaluated in this study. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The data of a Swiss prospective relational BC database that covered a 20-year period (1990-2009; n=1457) was analyzed. For the definition of menopause, the guidelines of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network were used. RESULTS: The menopausal state was unclear in 150 patients (10.2%). Of these, 122 (81.3%) had undergone a hysterectomy before menopause; in 28 women (18.7%), an endocrine therapy obscured the patient's actual endocrine status. When taking only the subgroup of women in which menopause usually occurs (45-55 years) into consideration, the menopausal state was unclear in 91 cases of 337 women (27.0%). From the entire cohort, the date of last menstruation remained obscure in 450 patients (30.9%). CONCLUSION: Despite the high importance of the menopausal state for the management of BC, above all, when planning antihormonal adjuvant therapy, the menopausal state was unable to be defined at the time of BC diagnosis in a significant proportion of women. The dilemma that menopause cannot be assessed in some BC cases is increasingly being recognized. Close cooperation between oncologists and endocrinologists is desirable to establish an optimal, individually tailored therapy for women with an unclear menopausal state due to hormonal therapies, hysterectomy, or chemotherapy.

Suicide in breast cancer patients: an individual-centered approach provides insight beyond epidemiology.

BACKGROUND: Epidemiologic studies have identified increased suicide rates among breast cancer (BC) patients. The population-based approach, however, has considerable methodic shortcomings. None of the studies have been carried out in a prospective manner and none reported suicide rates from a country in which physician-assisted suicide (PAS) is legal. PATIENTS AND METHODS: All cases recorded by a prospective Swiss BC database during a 17-year period (1990-2006; n = 1165) were analyzed. Using an individual-centered approach, the cases of women who committed suicide are reported according to the psychological autopsy method. RESULTS: In six patients (0.5%; 5.1/1.000 patients), suicidal death was identified. In four patients, suicide was committed during late stages of metastatic BC. In two cases, comorbid conditions were associated with suicide. Three women chose PAS. CONCLUSION: The individual-centered approach is a well-suited innovative concept to increase the knowledge regarding the relationship between cancer and suicide. We found a two to seven times higher suicide rate than those reported in epidemiologic studies. The population-based approach can barely elucidate the immense variety of one of the most personal decisions: the act of intentionally ending one's own life. These studies suffer from systematic failure of analysis since they did not a) consider the potential confounding role of comorbid medical and/or psychiatric conditions, and b) report in which disease stage suicide was committed, since the decisive disease-related event whether and when metastatic disease occurred was not recorded. Furthermore, epidemiologic data stems from countries in which PAS is prohibited and therefore not included in official statistics. This grey area of medicine accounts for a greater scope of underreporting than had previously been assumed.

Drug switch because of treatment-related adverse side effects in endocrine adjuvant breast cancer therapy: how often and how often does it work?

Therapy-related adverse side effects are a main reason for non-persistence to adjuvant endocrine breast cancer therapy. This study reports frequency of drug-related adverse side effects that were so severe that a modification of the therapy was necessary. We evaluated how many patients discontinued adjuvant endocrine therapy because of these side effects (non-persistence). Last, we analyzed how often a drug switch was undertaken for this reason and how often this measure led to the patient successfully continuing their endocrine therapy. Data concerning all postmenopausal breast cancer patients (≤ 80 years), who initiated endocrine adjuvant therapy between 1998 and 2008 in a Swiss breast center (n = 400), were analyzed. Out of these 400 women, 37 (9.3%) were defined as being non-persistent to the therapy; out of these, 24 (64.9%) because of therapy-related side effects. About 78 patients (19.5%) suffered from severe therapy-related side effects that made a modification of therapy necessary. Out of these 78 cases, 14 patients (17.9%) stopped the therapy without attempting a drug switch (non-persistence). In 64 patients (82.1%; 16% of all women who started endocrine therapy), a drug switch was undertaken. Out of these 64 cases, in 52 cases (81.3%) endocrine therapy was completed after therapy modification. Patients who reported one major adverse effect were more likely to continue the endocrine therapy after a drug switch (P = 0.048) compared with those who suffered from at least two different side effects. In 10 of the 64 cases (15.6%), modification of the therapy was not successful and the patients stopped the treatment prematurely (non-persistence) because of ongoing side effects. In cases when therapy-related side effects occur, a drug switch is a promising step to further improve persistence and, by doing so, the outcome of breast cancer patients.

Success and failure of primary medical, nonoperative management in breast cancer.

BACKGROUND: Nonoperative but systemic therapy as first-line management is offered to some patients with breast cancer (BC) who have assumed limited life expectancy, such as older women or those who have distant metastases at initial presentation. We evaluated rates of and predicting factors for success and failure of this therapy approach. METHODS: Seventy-five patients who were initially treated only systemically, and cases in which local control while avoiding surgery was the intended long-term therapy goal were analyzed. Additionally, two stage-dependent subgroups were distinguished (A: stage I-III, n = 31; B: stage IV, n = 44). Failure of therapy was defined as when secondary surgery had to be performed due to locoregional progression or in case of no surgery when severe locoregional clinical signs/symptoms were observed during the further course. RESULTS: Patients in group A were older than those in group B (81 vs. 67.5 years; P < 0.001) and showed an increased survival (5-year rates: 40.2% vs. 24.3%). In 24 patients of the entire cohort (32%), secondary surgery had to be performed; surgery was performed more often in group A (58.1% vs. 13.6%). In the cases in which no surgery was performed (n = 51), 11 women (21.6%) suffered from severe locoregional symptoms in the palliative situation (A: n = 1; B: n = 10). Although the presence of stage IV was a significant factor for therapy success (odds ratio (OR), 2.59; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.95-7.05; P = 0.039), skin involvement was associated with failure of therapy (OR, 3.57; 95% CI, 1.16-11.11; P = 0.031). CONCLUSIONS: Nonoperative treatment may be offered to selected patients with BC who have assumed limited life expectancy. These women must be openly informed that this approach is not successful in nearly half of the cases.