The Italian Consensus for the Classification and Reporting of Thyroid Cytology: Cytohistologic and molecular correlations on 37,371 nodules from a single institution.

BACKGROUND: The Italian Consensus for the Classification and Reporting of Thyroid Cytology (ICCRTC) includes six diagnostic categories (TIR 1/1C, TIR 2, TIR 3A, TIR 3B, TIR 4, and TIR 5), each indicating a different risk of malignancy. The objective of this monocentric retrospective study was to evaluate the distribution of the ICCRTC classes at the authors' institution and assess their cytohistologic correlations. METHODS: The authors retrospectively collected 37,371 consecutive cytologic reports of thyroid nodules and described the clinical-pathologic features of the different cytologic categories. The cytologic diagnoses also were compared with histologic outcomes in a subset of patients. RESULTS: The cytologic classes were distributed as follows: nondiagnostic, 15.6%; benign, 66.5%; low-risk indeterminate, 10% (TIR 3A); high-risk indeterminate, 3.5% (TIR 3B); suspicious, 1.7%; and malignant, 2.6%. According to histology, the risk of malignancy was very high in the nondiagnostic category (29.8%), with young male patients more exposed to malignancy, and it was relatively high among benign (7.8%) and indeterminate nodules (32.5% in TIR 3A; 52.1% in TIR 3B), mainly because of the high prevalence of follicular architecture in malignant tumors. On histology, the malignancy rates were 92.4% and 99.3% for the suspicious and malignant categories, respectively; aggressive variants of papillary thyroid carcinoma were mostly diagnosed in these categories. CONCLUSIONS: In this series, nondiagnostic nodules showed high prevalence and, surprisingly, high malignancy rates. Malignant tumors with follicular architecture represented a diagnostic pitfall in benign and indeterminate nodules. The suspicious and malignant categories had high specificity for malignancy. Importantly, the ICCRTC had high reliability for identifying preoperatively aggressive histotypes of thyroid carcinoma.

Patients with Indeterminate Thyroid Nodules at Cytology and Cancer at Histology Have a More Favorable Outcome Compared with Patients with Suspicious or Malignant Cytology.

BACKGROUND: The outcomes of patients with thyroid cancer proven by histology in patients in whom cytology was Thy 3 (indeterminate; Thy 3 patients in this study) based on the Italian consensus classification compared with those in whom cytology was Thy 4 (suspicious for malignancy) or Thy 5 (indicative for malignancy) (Thy 4-5 patients here) remains unclear. OBJECTIVE: To analyze the outcome of 371 Thy 3 patients versus 269 Thy 4-5 patients homogeneously treated with total thyroidectomy and 131I activity. RESULTS: T1 stage was observed in 46.0% of Thy 3 and in 38.8% of Thy 4-5 patients (p = 0.02), N0 in 95.9% of Thy 3 and in 75.5% of Thy 4-5 patients (p < 0.0001). 35/261 (9.6%) Thy 3 and 85/269 (31.5%) Thy 4-5 patients required >30 mCi of 131I (p < 0.0001). 359/371 (96.8%) Thy 3 and 232/269 (86.2%) Thy 4-5 patients were free of disease at the end of follow-up (p < 0.001). The time required to obtain 50% of patients in remission was 2 years in Thy 3 and 4 years in Thy 4-5 patients (p < 0.001). The most common histological type was the follicular variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma (FV-PTC) in Thy 3 patients (239/371, 64.4%) and the classic variant in Thy 4-5 patients (185/269; 68.8%). The FV-PTC had better prognostic features compared with the other PTC variants: T1 stage was observed in 133/277 (48.0%) FV-PTC patients and in 146/363 (40.0%) patients with the other variants (p < 0.001), N0 was present in 265/277 (96.0%) FV-PTC and in 290/363 (79.8%) patients with the other variants (p < 0.001). Overall, 267/277 FV-PTC patients (96.4%) and 324/363 patients (89.0%) with the other variants were free of disease (p < 0.0008) at the end of follow-up, and the time required to obtain 50% of patients in remission was 2 years in FV-PTC and 4.0 years in the other variants (p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Patients with Thy 3 cytology have better outcomes of thyroid cancer compared with patients with Thy 4 or Thy 5 cytology, and indeterminate cytology is commonly associated with the less aggressive FV-PTC.