Dimensional Accuracy Comparison of Physical Models Generated by Digital Impression/3D-Printing or Analog Impression/Plaster Methods

ABSTRACT: This study aimed to compare the trueness and precision of physical models manufactured chairside (intraoral scanner and 3D printed) or by plaster models obtained using impression with alginate or addition silicone. A full- arch stainless steel die was impressed to obtain ten physical models for each group. The models were measured in a stereomicroscope, considering four linear distances. To assess the precision accuracy, an analysis of the measurement variability was carried out, identified by the coefficients of variation and by the Levene's test to compare the groups. To analyze trueness, the data average was subtracted from the database and compared considering alpha as 5 %. Considering precision, the higher dispersion of data occurred in the models obtained with silicone impression. And for trueness, Kruskal Wallis and Dunn tests results did not indicate differences between the groups in the anteroposterior linear distances (p> 0.05). Only in anterior transverse distance obtained through TRIOS (0.31 mm), it presented lower accuracy compared to the models from silicone impression (0.13 mm); however, at transverse posterior distance, the models from silicone impression showed the lowest accuracy (p 0.05). The physical dental models obtained by digital and analog workflows showed acceptable dimensional accuracy expressed by high precision and trueness. There is no difference between the evaluated intraoral scanner systems and the impression materials for the full-arch impression.

RESUMEN: Este estudio tuvo como objetivo comparar la veracidad y precisión de modelos físicos fabricados en la clínica dental (escáner intraoral e impreso en 3D) o por modelos de yeso obtenidos mediante impresión con alginato o silicona de adición. Una matriz de acero inoxidable de arco completo fue impresa para obtener diez modelos físicos para cada grupo. Los modelos se midieron en un estereomicroscopio, considerando cuatro distancias lineales. Se realizó un análisis de la variabilidad de la medida para evaluar la precisión, identificada por los coeficientes de variación y por la prueba de Levene para comparar los grupos. Para analizar la veracidad, el promedio de los datos se restó de la base de datos y se comparó considerando alfa como 5 %. Considerando la precisión, la mayor dispersión de datos ocurrió en los modelos obtenidos con impresión de silicona. Y para la veracidad, los resultados de las pruebas de Kruskal Wallis y Dunn no indicaron diferencias entre los grupos en las distancias lineales anteroposteriores (p> 0,05). Solo en la distancia transversal anterior obtenida mediante TRIOS (0,31 mm) presentó menor precisión en comparación con los modelos de impresión de silicona (0,13 mm); sin embargo, la distancia transversal posterior, los modelos de impresión de silicona mostraron la menor precisión (p 0,05). Los modelos dentales físicos obtenidos mediante flujos de trabajo digitales y analógicos mostraron una precisión dimensional aceptable expresada por alta precisión y veracidad. No se observó diferencia entre los sistemas de escáner intraoral evaluados y los materiales de impresión para la impresión de arco completa.

Effect of Implant Platform Connection and Abutment Material on Removal Torque and Implant Hexagon Plastic Deformation.

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the plastic deformation of the hexagonal connection, and the removal torque of the implant-abutment joint of two dental implants combined with internal or external hexagonal connection implants after mechanical cycling. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-four dental implants were used in the study. Half of the implants had internal hexagonal connections (IH; Titamax II Plus) and the other half had external hexagonal connections (EH; Titamax Ti Ex). Four groups of two types of dental implant abutments (titanium: Ti, UCLA II Plus and zirconia: Zr, fabricated by CAD/CAM; n = 6) were investigated. The abutments received a metallic crown and the settings were submitted to mechanical cycling (MC; 106 cycles, axial load, 120N). The connection surface area was measured by scanning electron microscope (SEM) images. The removal torque was evaluated and the plastic deformation of the hexagonal surface of the implant was measured by comparing the images before and after MC. STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: Paired-t test was used to analyze the data statistically at a significance level of α = 0.05. RESULTS: The torque values decreased for all groups after MC, and the hexagonal surface area decreased due to plastic deformation for IH and EH associated with Zr abutments. CONCLUSIONS: Zirconia abutments showed the worst plastic deformation of the implant connection surface and torque loosening when associated with IH implant.

Stress distribution in the peri-implant area of pure titanium and titanium-zirconium small implants

Aim: In dental implant treatment, there is a demand for mechanically stronger implants. Despite the existence of several studies showing the clinical success of narrow diameter implants, most of them are based on pure titanium (cpTi) alloys. There is a few clinical evidences of the success rate of titanium-zirconium (TiZr) narrow diameter implants. The aim of this study was to evaluate the stress distribution in the peri-implant area of narrow diameter cpTi and TiZr implants under axial and oblique loads. Methods: Photoelastic models were produced using epoxy resin (PL2, Vishay Precision Group) from a master model. The implants (cpTi and TiZr; Straumann AG) had 3.3 mm in diameter and 12 mm in height. Loads of 100 N and 200 N were applied to the abutment at angles of 0° (axial), 10°, 20°, and 30° (oblique). A circular polariscope (Eikonal) was used under dark field white-light configuration. The isochromatic fringes were analyzed in the peri-implant region in 5 areas, using ASTM table with isochromatic fringes; cervical-mesial, cervical-distal, mid-mesial, mid-distal and apical. Results: In general, under axial and oblique loads, the stress in the TiZr implant was lower than in the cpTi implant. The load of 200 N produced the highest stress values in cpTi and TiZr implants. In both implants and loads, the fringes were located more in apical area at all angles evaluated. Conclusion: It can be concluded that for small implants, the load inclination and intensity change the pattern of stress distribution and the cpTi implant exhibited the highest peri-implant stress

Influence of plasma-based dry etching on the bond strength of Y-TZP ceramic.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the bond strength between an yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal (Y-TZP) ceramic and a luting agent when submitted to plasma etching surface treatment before and after thermocycling (TC) with 3000 cycles of 5°C-55°C. The null hypothesis was that the surface treatments and thermocycling would not influence the bond strength. A total of 160 Y-TZP ceramic blocks in 2 sizes (10 size 1 and 10 size 2 blocks in each group) were distributed into 8 groups: group C (control), no surface treatment; group C-TC, TC without prior surface treatment; group SAO, sandblasting with aluminum oxide (Al2O3); group SAO-TC, sandblasting with Al2O3 followed by TC; group SAOS, sandblasting with silica-coated Al2O3; group SAOS-TC, sandblasting with silica-coated Al2O3 followed by TC; group PE, plasma etching; and group PE-TC, plasma etching followed by TC. In each group, size 1 blocks were cemented to size 2 blocks to fabricate specimens for microshear bond strength testing (n = 10 per group). Cementation followed surface treatments (except in control groups) and preceded any TC. All specimens were cemented using a luting agent that contained 10-meth-acryloyloxydecyl dihydrogen phosphate (MDP). The specimens were submitted to a microshear bond strength test and the means were analyzed with a 2-factor analysis of variance and Tukey test. Group PE showed the highest bond strength value before thermocycling (17.31 MPa). After thermocycling, the highest value was observed in the SAO-TC group (9.73 MPa), and statistically significant differences were observed between SAOS-TC and SAO-TC (P < 0.05) and PE-TC and SAO-TC (P < 0.05). Plasma etching improved the bond strength values between the Y-TZP ceramic and MDP-containing luting agent before thermocycling. After thermocycling, all groups showed lower bond strength values.

Comparative photoelastic study of dental and skeletal anchorages in the canine retraction

OBJECTIVE: To compare dental and skeletal anchorages in mandibular canine retraction by means of a stress distribution analysis. METHODS: A photoelastic model was produced from second molar to canine, without the first premolar, and mandibular canine retraction was simulated by a rubber band tied to two types of anchorage: dental anchorage, in the first molar attached to adjacent teeth, and skeletal anchorage with a hook simulating the mini-implant. The forces were applied 10 times and observed in a circular polariscope. The stresses located in the mandibular canine were recorded in 7 regions. The Mann-Whitney test was employed to compare the stress in each region and between both anchorage systems. The stresses in the mandibular canine periradicular regions were compared by the Kruskal-Wallis test. RESULTS: Stresses were similar in the cervical region and the middle third. In the apical third, the stresses associated with skeletal anchorage were higher than the stresses associated with dental anchorage. The results of the Kruskal-Wallis test showed that the highest stresses were identified in the cervical-distal, apical-distal, and apex regions with the use of dental anchorage, and in the apical-distal, apical-mesial, cervical-distal, and apex regions with the use of skeletal anchorage. CONCLUSIONS: The use of skeletal anchorage in canine retraction caused greater stress in the apical third than the use of dental anchorage, which indicates an intrusive component resulting from the direction of the force due to the position of the mini-implant and the bracket hook of the canine. .

OBJETIVO: comparar as ancoragens dentária e esquelética na retração do canino inferior, por meio do estudo da distribuição de tensões. MÉTODOS: foi confeccionado um modelo fotoelástico de segundo molar a canino, sem o primeiro pré-molar, e simulada a retração do canino inferior com elástico preso a dois tipos de ancoragem: dentária, no primeiro molar conjugado aos dentes adjacentes; e ancoragem esquelética, em gancho simulando o mini-implante. As forças foram aplicadas 10 vezes e observadas no polariscópio circular. As tensões no canino inferior foram registradas em 7 regiões. O teste de Mann-Whitney foi aplicado para comparar as tensões em cada região, considerando os dois sistemas de ancoragem. As tensões nas regiões perirradiculares do canino foram comparadas pelo teste de Kruskal-Wallis. RESULTADOS: as tensões foram similares tanto na região cervical quanto no terço médio. No terço apical, as tensões associadas à ancoragem esquelética foram maiores que as tensões associadas à ancoragem dentária. Os resultados do teste de Kruskal-Wallis mostraram que as maiores tensões foram identificadas nas regiões cervicodistal, apicodistal e na região do ápice com o uso da ancoragem dentária; e com o uso da ancoragem esquelética, as maiores tensões se localizaram nas regiões apicodistal, apicomesial, cervicodistal e no ápice. CONCLUSÃO: o uso de ancoragem esquelética na retração promoveu maior tensão no terço apical do que o uso da ancoragem dentária, indicando um componente intrusivo devido à direção da força decorrente da posição do mini-implante e do gancho do braquete do canino. .

Influence of the casting material on the dimensional accuracy of dental dies

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the dimensional accuracy of different materials used in the confection of dies. Two stainless steel standard models were confected. One of the models, which was 2 mm larger than the other model, was used to provide a uniform relief for the two-step putty-wash impression technique. Thirty impressions were obtained using a polyvinyl siloxane impression material and randomly divided into three groups (n = 10) according to the type of casting material: type IV dental stone, commercially available epoxy resin (Tri-Epoxy), and industrial epoxy resin (Sikadur). After the setting/polymerization of the casting material, the dimensional stability was measured in terms of the height, diameter of the base and diameter of the top from the obtained dies and from the standard metal model using a profile projector. Results were analyzed by ANOVA and Dunnet test (α = 0.05). In the height values, no significant difference was observed between the groups, except for Sikadur casts, which showed lower mean values. The Tri-Epoxi group showed statistically lower mean base diameter values, compared with the other groups, and both epoxy resin groups showed statistically lower mean top diameter values, compared with that for the type IV dental stone group. We concluded that type IV gypsum and the commercially available epoxy resin showed similar behavior in most areas. The industrial epoxy resin did not show the same characteristics, although the diameter of the base obtained with it was similar to that obtained with type IV dental stone.

Comparação da variação da temperatura produzida por dois tipos de instrumentos cortantes rotatórios diamantados no preparo cavitário / A comparison of the temperature variation produced by two kinds of diamond rotatory cutting instruments on the cavity preparation

O objetivo desse estudo foi comparar as variações de temperatura no interior da câmara pulpar provocadas por dois tipos de instrumento cortante rotatório (ICR), a ponta diamantada padrão e Turbo, que promete redução na transmissão de calor. Foram realizados preparos para coroa total na face vestibular de vinte molares humanos extraídos. Os dentes foram divididos em 2 grupos (n-10): Grupo 1 - ponta diamantada padrão nº 4219; Grupo 2 - ponta diamantada Turbo nº 4219T. Para cada preparo foi utilizado um novo ICR e a profundidade do preparo foi de 1,4mm. A espessura de dentina foi padronizada em 2,81 mm. Para leitura das temperaturas foi introduzido um dispositivo termopar na câmara pulpar. Os dados foram transferidos para o software IR-graph e submetidos ao teste Mann-Whitney (p<0,05). Resultados: os valores de variação de temperatura (Celsius): Grupo 1 ±0,55 ºC; Grupo 2 – ± 0,76ºC. Os preparos cavitários realizados com os dois tipos de ICRs geraram alterações de temperatura semelhantes (p>0.05). Os ICRs padrão e Turbo apresentaram o mesmo comportamento quanto à capacidade de gerar calor.

Objective: The objective of this study was to compare the temperature variations of pulp chamber caused by two types of diamond burs: standard and Turbo, which promises a reduction in heat transfer. Twenty full crown preparations were made on the vestibular human molars. The teeth were divided into 2 groups (n-10): Group 1 – diamond bur standard No. 4219, Group 2 – diamond bur Turbo No. 4219T. For each preparation was used a new bur and the depth of the preparation was 1.4 mm. The thickness of dentine was standardized to 2.81 mm. To read the temperature, thermocouple device was introduced in the pulp chamber. Date were transferred to IR-graph software and submitted to the Mann-Whitney test (p<0.05). Results: The values of temperature (Celsius): Group 1 - ±0,55 ºC; Group 2 - ±0,76 °C. The dental cavities made with two kinds of burs generated similar changes in temperature (p> 0.05). The diamond burs standard and Turbo had the same behavior as the ability to generate heat.

Influence of anatomic reference on the buccal contour of prosthetic crowns.

During clinical practice, when performing prosthetic rehabilitation with single crowns, improper reproduction of the dental contour by the dental laboratory is a common occurrence. Therefore, the present study evaluated the fidelity of the reproduction of the buccal contour in an upper left canine performed by three Dental Prosthesis Technicians (DPT) using the indirect laminate veneer technique. First, the DPTs confected the veneers based on a model obtained from the upper arch of a dental dummy, containing a replica of an upper left canine with a prosthetic preparation for a laminate veneer. Then, the same DPTs received other identical models, now with the replica of the upper left canine with no preparation, to be used as an anatomical reference for confecting the laminate veneers. The laminate veneers were then bonded to the plaster models and had their buccal contour individually measured. Measurements were also made of the buccal contour of the reference canine. The data were analyzed by ANOVA and the t-test (p = 0.05). Results showed 100% of buccal overcontour when the laminate veneers were compared to the reference canine, regardless of which DPT confected the veneer and regardless of using or not the anatomical reference. The DPTs who participated in the present study were unable to acomplish a faithful anatomical reproduction of the buccal contour, creating an overcontour in all samples. This situation may be responsible for increasing the probability of periodontal and esthetic harm in clinical practice.

Influence of anatomic reference on the buccal contour of prosthetic crowns

During clinical practice, when performing prosthetic rehabilitation with single crowns, improper reproduction of the dental contour by the dental laboratory is a common occurrence. Therefore, the present study evaluated the fidelity of the reproduction of the buccal contour in an upper left canine performed by three Dental Prosthesis Technicians (DPT) using the indirect laminate veneer technique. First, the DPTs confected the veneers based on a model obtained from the upper arch of a dental dummy, containing a replica of an upper left canine with a prosthetic preparation for a laminate veneer. Then, the same DPTs received other identical models, now with the replica of the upper left canine with no preparation, to be used as an anatomical reference for confecting the laminate veneers. The laminate veneers were then bonded to the plaster models and had their buccal contour individually measured. Measurements were also made of the buccal contour of the reference canine. The data were analyzed by ANOVA and the t-test (p = 0.05). Results showed 100 percent of buccal overcontour when the laminate veneers were compared to the reference canine, regardless of which DPT confected the veneer and regardless of using or not the anatomical reference. The DPTs who participated in the present study were unable to acomplish a faithful anatomical reproduction of the buccal contour, creating an overcontour in all samples. This situation may be responsible for increasing the probability of periodontal and esthetic harm in clinical practice.