Comparison of different rating scales for the use in Delphi studies: different scales lead to different consensus and show different test-retest reliability.

BACKGROUND: Consensus-orientated Delphi studies are increasingly used in various areas of medical research using a variety of different rating scales and criteria for reaching consensus. We explored the influence of using three different rating scales and different consensus criteria on the results for reaching consensus and assessed the test-retest reliability of these scales within a study aimed at identification of global treatment goals for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). METHODS: We conducted a two-stage study consisting of two surveys and consecutively included patients scheduled for TKA from five German hospitals. Patients were asked to rate 19 potential treatment goals on different rating scales (three-point, five-point, nine-point). Surveys were conducted within a 2 week period prior to TKA, order of questions (scales and treatment goals) was randomized. RESULTS: Eighty patients (mean age 68 ± 10 years; 70% females) completed both surveys. Different rating scales (three-point, five-point and nine-point rating scale) lead to different consensus despite moderate to high correlation between rating scales (r = 0.65 to 0.74). Final consensus was highly influenced by the choice of rating scale with 14 (three-point), 6 (five-point), 15 (nine-point) out of 19 treatment goals reaching the pre-defined 75% consensus threshold. The number of goals reaching consensus also highly varied between rating scales for other consensus thresholds. Overall, concordance differed between the three-point (percent agreement [p] = 88.5%, weighted kappa [k] = 0.63), five-point (p = 75.3%, k = 0.47) and nine-point scale (p = 67.8%, k = 0.78). CONCLUSION: This study provides evidence that consensus depends on the rating scale and consensus threshold within one population. The test-retest reliability of the three rating scales investigated differs substantially between individual treatment goals. This variation in reliability can become a potential source of bias in consensus studies. In our setting aimed at capturing patients' treatment goals for TKA, the three-point scale proves to be the most reasonable choice, as its translation into the clinical context is the most straightforward among the scales. Researchers conducting Delphi studies should be aware that final consensus is substantially influenced by the choice of rating scale and consensus criteria.

Pharmacological treatment of knee osteoarthritis: Special considerations of the new German guideline.

The pharmacological treatment of knee osteoarthritis (OA) is a purely symptomatic therapy, which often ensures that the mobility of the patient is successfully retained. This article refers to the recommendations and opinions regarding the pharmacotherapy of knee OA contained in the new guideline of the Association of the Scientific Medical Societies in Germany (AWMF), highlighting several important aspects and describing the considerations underlying the decision-making process. With this article it is hoped that therapeutic effectiveness can be realistically estimated, that any risks of medication errors and avoidable side effects can be reduced, and that further helpful measures can be taken into consideration.

Metabolic activity and gene expression of osteoarthritic chondrocytes in correlation with radiological and histological characteristics.

The aim of this study was to analyze metabolic activity of osteoarthritic chondrocytes in correlation with radiographic, histologic and gene expression data. Six patients with osteoarthritis (OA) of the knee were analyzed clinically and radiographically (Kellgren and Lawrence, K&L). During total knee replacement surgery cartilage samples from the medial and lateral condyles and tibial plateaus were separately harvested. Specimen were analyzed histologically (Mankin Score) and total RNA was extracted. Steady state levels of stromelysin (MMP-3), aggrecan (AGG) and the house-keeping gene beta-actin were measured using quantitative PCR. In order to estimate metabolic activity chondrocytes were cultured in alginate beads and proteoglycan content was measured after 1 week. PG content in cultures was dependent from degradation status of cartilage (medial compartments 20.4 +/- 0.83 ng/ng, lateral compartments 29.9 +/- 3.0 ng/ng P < 0.01). We found a positive correlation of PG content in cultures with Mankin's grading (r = 0.79; P < 0.01) and with K&L scoring (r = 0.57; P = 0.05). There was a considerable variation of expression levels of MMP-3 and AGG. PG metabolism of cultured chondrocytes correlated only with the macroscopic and microscopic degradation status of cartilage. Gene expression showed a high variability and no correlation to PG metabolism indicating a more complex regulation.

Validation of a diffusion chamber as in vitro system for the analysis of compound diffusibility through cartilage tissue.

The validation of a diffusion chamber comprising a donor and a receptor side separated by a cartilage membrane was undertaken according to the basic principles described by Peng et al. (1998). The study had three targets: first to evaluate the chamber as in vitro system by the examination of the diffusibility of compound through bovine cartilage samples; second the analysis of the affinity of compound (RS-130830) to cartilage; third to test the influence of two pre-incubation periods (one or three nights) of the cartilage samples. The validation of the chamber as in vitro system for the analysis of compound diffusibility and affinity to cartilage was performed using membrane slices of fresh bovine cartilage and a hydroxamic acid derivative (RS-130830) known as matrix metalloproteinase inhibitor (MMPI). The influence of the pre-incubation of cartilage was also examined. Compound concentrations in donor, receptor and membrane were determined by high performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS). Diffusion could be demonstrated after 6 h and finally 24 h incubation: the compound concentration in the receptor increased from 0 to 35 microM (mean) while it decreased in the donor from 200 to 144 microM (mean). We also found compound in the cartilage membrane (approximately 1.2 nmol (mean)). Pre-incubation of cartilage samples in culture buffer is suitable as a storage procedure, since the results on the donor side only were influenced significantly but not for the receptor and the cartilage affinity. Thus, the system could clearly reflect relevant properties of the tested compound with regard to its diffusibility and affinity to cartilage tissue.

PTHrP, PTHr, and FGFR3 are involved in the process of endochondral ossification in human osteophytes.

To elucidate the process of endochondral ossification in human osteophytes we have studied the expression of parathyroid hormone-related protein (PTHrP), its receptor (PTHr), and fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3). Osteophytes from patients undergoing total knee replacement ( n=13), and fetal growth plate cartilages ( n=4) were processed for safranin O staining and immunohistochemistry. Chondrocytes and their matrix were preferentially stained for PTHrP in the middle and deep zones of the osteophytes examined. Ossified areas did not show a positive staining. In fetal joints the cartilaginous surface and the perichondrium as well as the osteoblasts in the trabecular bone were positive. PTHr was expressed at large in chondrocytes and osteoblasts of all osteophytes and fetal joints. Cells of the perichondrium were also positive. The FGFR3 antibody stained only single chondrocytes in some osteophytes, and groups of cells in others. In fetal samples, chondrocytes of the proliferating and the hypertrophic zone showed staining for FGFR3. This is the first report on the expression of PTHrP, PTHr, and FGFR3 in human osteophytes. As in fetal joints these mediators might regulate proliferation and differentiation of chondrocytes playing an important role in osteo(chondro)phyte growth.

Effects of dexamethasone on proteoglycan content and gene expression of IL-1beta-stimulated osteoarthrotic chondrocytes in vitro.

We studied the effects of dexamethasone on proteoglycan (PG) concentration and gene expression in human osteoarthrotic chondrocytes stimulated with IL-1beta. Cartilage samples were taken from 7 patients with osteoarthrosis of the knee and chondrocytes cultivated in alginate beads. Dexamethasone was added in three concentrations (10(-5), 10(-6), 10(-7) M) to IL-1beta (100 pg/nL)-stimulated chondrocytes. PG concentration was estimated by a dimethylmethylene blue assay. To assess cell proliferation, DNA content was measured fluorometrically. Quantitative Lightcycler-PCR was used to estimate the mRNA levels of stromelysin-1 (MMP-3) and aggrecan (AGG). The proliferation rate was unchanged in all treatment groups. IL-1beta increased MMP-3 expression by 44% and inhibited AGG expression by 16%, but PG-concentration was reduced by 7%. The addition of dexamethasone to IL-1beta-stimulated chondrocytes further reduced the PG concentration by 19% at 10(-5) M and by 17% at 10(-7) M. The MMP-3 expression was inhibited between 27-53% and the AGG expression between 30-46% by dexamethasone. In osteoarthrotic chondrocytes, dexamethasone in an appropriate dose range reduced the expression of MMP-3 and AGG at the same time. The resulting decrease in PG concentration should be considered when using intraarticular corticosteroids to treat an osteoarthrotic joint.

Effects of hyaluronan on proteoglycan content of osteoarthritic chondrocytes in vitro.

PURPOSE: To investigate the effect of hyaluronic acid (HA) on proteoglycan (PG) concentration in alginate cultures of human osteoarthritic chondrocytes and to analyze whether HA exhibit anti-degradative effects in the presence of the cytokine IL-1beta. METHODS: Cartilage samples from ten patients with osteoarthritis of the knee were harvested and chondrocytes were cultivated in alginate beads. Four groups were cultured: control group with and without IL-1beta (500 pg/ml) and HA group (100 microg/ml) with and without IL-1beta (500 pg/ml). PG concentration was estimated by a dimethylmethylene blue assay. To assess cell proliferation, we measured DNA content fluorometrically. RESULTS: The proliferation rate (DNA) was unchanged in all culture groups. In the control-group PG/DNA (ng/ng) concentration was 27.1 +/- 7.2. Supplementation of the medium with HA decreased PG concentration to 25.3 +/- 6.9 (p < 0.05). After administration of IL-1beta PG/DNA concentration dropped to 23.1 +/- 6.0 (p < 0.01). By contrast HA treatment of IL-1beta stimulated chondrocytes did not further decrease PG concentration (23.9 +/- 6.1). In fact the negative effect of isolated HA application was inverted if HA was given with IL-1beta (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: In osteoarthritic chondrocytes cultured phenotypically stable, HA could exhibit protective effects only in the presence of the degradative cytokine IL-1beta. Thus, the reported anti-inflammatory effects of HA to cartilage matrix seem to be more indirect by blocking degradative effects of cytokines to the matrix.