Best practices for detection, assessment and management of suspected immune-mediated liver injury caused by immune checkpoint inhibitors during drug development.

Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) have shown significant efficacy in patients with various malignancies, however, they are associated with a wide range of immune-related toxicities affecting many organs, including the liver. Immune-mediated liver injury caused by checkpoint inhibitors (ILICI) is a distinctive form of drug induced liver injury (DILI), that differs from most DILI types in presumed underlying mechanism, incidence, and response to therapeutic interventions. Despite increased awareness of ILICI and other immune-related adverse effects of ICIs reflected by recent guidelines for their management in post marketing clinical practice, there is lack of uniform best practices to address ILICI risk during drug development. As efforts to develop safer and more effective ICIs for additional indications grow, and as combination therapies including ICIs are increasingly investigated, there is a growing need for consistent practices for ILICI in drug development. This publication summarizes current best practices to optimize the monitoring, diagnosis, assessment, and management of suspected ILICI in clinical trials using ICI as a single agent and in combination with other ICIs or other oncological agents. It is one of several publications developed by the IQ DILI Initiative in collaboration with DILI experts from academia and regulatory agencies. Recommended best practices are outlined pertaining to hepatic inclusion and exclusion criteria, monitoring of liver tests, ILICI detection, approach to a suspected ILICI signal, causality assessment, hepatic discontinuation rules and additional medical treatment.

Real-time imaging of oxidative and nitrosative stress in the liver of live animals for drug-toxicity testing.

Current drug-safety assays for hepatotoxicity rely on biomarkers with low predictive power. The production of radical species, specifically reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS), has been proposed as an early unifying event linking the bioactivation of drugs to hepatotoxicity and as a more direct and mechanistic indicator of hepatotoxic potential. Here we present a nanosensor for rapid, real-time in vivo imaging of drug-induced ROS and RNS for direct evaluation of acute hepatotoxicity. By combining fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and chemiluminescence resonance energy transfer (CRET), our semiconducting polymer-based nanosensor simultaneously and differentially detects RNS and ROS using two optically independent channels. We imaged drug-induced hepatotoxicity and its remediation longitudinally in mice after systemic challenge with acetaminophen or isoniazid. We detected dose-dependent ROS and RNS activity in the liver within minutes of drug challenge, which preceded histological changes, protein nitration and DNA double-strand-break induction.

12-OH-nevirapine sulfate, formed in the skin, is responsible for nevirapine-induced skin rash.

Nevirapine (NVP) treatment is associated with a significant incidence of skin rash in humans, and it also causes a similar immune-mediated skin rash in Brown Norway (BN) rats. We have shown that the sulfate of a major oxidative metabolite, 12-OH-NVP, covalently binds in the skin. The fact that the sulfate metabolite is responsible for covalent binding in the skin does not prove that it is responsible for the rash. We used various inhibitors of sulfation to test whether this reactive sulfate is responsible for the skin rash. Salicylamide (SA), which depletes 3'-phosphoadenosine-5'-phosphosulfate (PAPS) in the liver, significantly decreased 12-OH-NVP sulfate in the blood, but it did not prevent covalent binding in the skin or the rash. Topical application of 1-phenyl-1-hexanol, a sulfotransferase inhibitor, prevented covalent binding in the skin as well as the rash, but only where it was applied. In vitro incubations of 12-OH-NVP with PAPS and cytosolic fractions from the skin of rats or from human skin also led to covalent binding that was inhibited by 1-phenyl-1-hexanol. Incubation of 12-OH-NVP with PAPS and sulfotransferase 1A1*1, a human isoform that is present in the skin, also led to covalent binding, and this binding was also inhibited by 1-phenyl-1-hexanol. We conclude that salicylamide did not deplete PAPS in the skin and was unable to prevent covalent binding or the rash, while topical 1-phenyl-1-hexanol inhibited sulfation of 12-OH-NVP in the skin and did prevent covalent binding and the rash. These results provide definitive evidence that 12-OH-NVP sulfate formed in skin is responsible for NVP-induced skin rashes. Sulfotransferase is one of the few metabolic enzymes with significant activity in the skin, and it may be responsible for the bioactivation of other drugs that cause skin rashes.

Involvement of T helper 17 cells in D-penicillamine-induced autoimmune disease in Brown Norway rats.

Idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs) are poorly understood, but their clinical characteristics suggest that they are immune mediated. Penicillamine-induced autoimmunity in Brown Norway rats has been utilized as an animal model for mechanistic studies of one type of IDR because it closely mimics the autoimmune syndromes that it causes in humans. Our previous work suggested that it is T-cell mediated. It has been shown that T helper 17 (Th17) cells play a central role in many types of autoimmune diseases. This study was designed to test whether Th17 cells are involved in the pathogenesis of penicillamine-induced autoimmunity and to establish an overall serum cytokine/chemokine profile for this IDR. In total, 24 serum cytokines/chemokines were determined and revealed a dynamic process. In sick animals, interleukin (IL) 6 and transforming growth factor-ß1, known to be driving forces of Th17 differentiation, were consistently increased at both early and late stages of penicillamine treatment; however, no significant changes in these cytokines were observed in animals that did not develop autoimmunity. IL-17, a characteristic cytokine produced by Th17 cells, was increased in sick animals at both the messenger RNA and serum protein level. In addition, serum concentrations of IL-22, another characteristic cytokine produced by Th17 cells, were found to be elevated. Furthermore, the percentage of IL-17-producing CD4 T cells was significantly increased but only in sick animals. These data strongly suggest that Th17 cells are involved in penicillamine-induced autoimmunity. Such data provide important mechanistic clues that may help to predict which drug candidates will cause a relatively high incidence of such autoimmune IDRs.

Effect of clozapine on neutrophil kinetics in rabbits.

Clozapine is an atypical antipsychotic drug effective in the treatment of refractory schizophrenia; however, its use is limited due to its propensity to cause agranulocytosis in some patients. Little is known about the mechanism of idiosyncratic drug-induced agranulocytosis, in part because of the lack of a valid animal model. Clozapine is oxidized by activated human neutrophils and bone marrow cells to a reactive nitrenium ion by the myeloperoxidase-hydrogen peroxide system of neutrophils. This reactive metabolite has been shown in vitro to induce the apoptosis of neutrophils and bone marrow cells. While in vitro studies demonstrated the toxic potential of clozapine upon oxidation, it is not clear if similar conditions occur in vivo. In response to the difficulties encountered with detecting apoptotic neutrophils in vivo, we conducted a series of studies in rabbits using two fluorescent cell-labeling techniques to study the effect of clozapine treatment on neutrophil kinetics, that is, their rates of production and removal from circulation. The fluorescein dye, 5-(and-6)-carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester (CFSE), was used as a general cell label to measure the half-life of neutrophils in blood. In addition, the thymidine analogue, 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdU), was used to label dividing cells, thus enabling the measurement of the efflux of neutrophils from the bone marrow. Clozapine, indeed, increased the rate of both the release of neutrophils from the bone marrow and their subsequent disappearance from circulation. Failure of the bone marrow to compensate for a shorter neutrophil half-life could lead to agranulocytosis. Alternatively, the damage to neutrophils caused by clozapine could, in some patients, lead to an immune-mediated response against neutrophils resulting in agranulocytosis.

The danger hypothesis applied to idiosyncratic drug reactions.

The danger hypothesis has had a profound effect on the way immunologists view the immune response. This hypothesis proposes that the major determinant of whether an immune response is mounted against some agent is determined by whether that agent causes some type of cell damage. Assuming that most idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs) are immune-mediated, this hypothesis also has the potential to explain many aspects of the mechanism of these adverse drug reactions. For example, most IDRs appear to be caused by chemical metabolites rather than the parent drug, but not all drugs that form reactive metabolites are associated with a significant incidence of IDRs. Therefore, using the danger hypothesis, one feature of a drug candidate that may predict whether it causes an IDR is whether the drug, or more likely its reactive metabolites, cause cell damage. Although the range of molecules that can act as danger signals is unknown, the most attractive candidates are high mobility group box 1 protein (HMGB1), heat shock proteins, and S100 proteins. These molecules act through the same receptors (toll-like receptors) as pathogen-associated molecules that stimulate the immune system. Therefore, other environmental factors such as infections or trauma might determine which patients would be at increased risk for IDRs. Although there are examples where this appears to be the case, in most cases there are no obvious environmental factors that determine IDR risk. In addition, in animal models of immune-mediated reactions, stimulation of toll-like receptors often does not increase the immune response, and depending on the timing, it can actually be protective. Therefore, there may be additional unknown control mechanisms that are involved. A better understanding of these fundamental immune mechanisms has the potential to have a significant impact on many areas of medicine.

A study of the specificity of lymphocytes in nevirapine-induced skin rash.

Nevirapine treatment can cause a skin rash. We developed an animal model of this rash and determined that the 12-hydroxylation metabolic pathway is responsible for the rash, and treatment of animals with 12-OH-nevirapine also leads to a rash. In the present study, we investigated the specificity of lymphocytes in nevirapine-induced skin rash. Brown Norway rats were treated with nevirapine or 12-OH-nevirapine to induce a rash. Lymph nodes were removed, and the response of lymphocytes to nevirapine and its metabolites/analogs was determined by cytokine production (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot assay, and Luminex) and proliferation (alamar blue assay). Subsets of lymphocytes were depleted to determine which cells were responsible for cytokine production. Lymphocytes from animals rechallenged with nevirapine proliferated to nevirapine, but not to 12-OH-nevirapine or 4-chloro-nevirapine. They also produced interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) when exposed to nevirapine, significantly less when exposed to 4-chloro-nevirapine, and very little when exposed to 12-OH-nevirapine, even though oxidation to 12-OH-nevirapine is required to induce the rash. Moreover, the specificity of lymphocytes from 12-OH-nevirapine-treated rats was the same, i.e., responding to nevirapine more than to 12-OH-nevirapine, even though these animals had never been exposed to nevirapine. A Luminex immunoassay showed that a variety of other cytokines/chemokines were also produced by nevirapine-stimulated lymphocytes. CD4(+) cells were the major source of IFN-gamma. The specificity of lymphocytes in activation assays cannot be used to determine what initiated an immune response. This has significant implications for understanding the evolution of an immune response and the basis of the pharmacological interaction hypothesis.

D-penicillamine-induced autoimmunity: relationship to macrophage activation.

Idiosyncratic drug reactions represent a serious health problem, and they remain unpredictable largely due to our limited understanding of the mechanisms involved. Penicillamine-induced autoimmunity in Brown Norway (BN) rats represents one model of an idiosyncratic reaction, and this drug can also cause autoimmune reactions in humans. We previously demonstrated that penicillamine binds to aldehydes on the surface of macrophages. There is evidence that an imine bond formed by aldehyde groups on macrophages and amine groups on T cells is one type of interaction between these two cells that is involved in the induction of an immune response. We proposed that the binding of penicillamine with aldehyde groups on macrophages could lead to their activation and in some patients could lead to autoimmunity. In this study, the transcriptome profile of spleen macrophages 6 h after penicillamine treatment was used to detect effects of penicillamine on macrophages with a focus on 20 genes known to be macrophage activation biomarkers. One biological consequence of macrophage activation was investigated by determining mRNA levels for IL-15 and IL-1 beta which are crucial for NK cell activation, as well as levels of mRNA for selected cytokines in spleen NK cells. Up-regulation of the macrophage activating cytokines, IFN-gamma and GM-CSF, and down-regulation of IL-13 indicated activation of NK cells, which suggests a positive feedback loop between macrophages and NK cells. Furthermore, treatment of a murine macrophage cell line, RAW264.7, with penicillamine increased the production of TNF-alpha, IL-6, and IL-23, providing additional evidence that penicillamine activates macrophages. Hydralazine and isoniazid cause a lupus-like syndrome in humans and also bind to aldehyde groups. These drugs were also found to activate RAW264.7 macrophages. Together, these data support the hypothesis that drugs that bind irreversibly with aldehydes lead to macrophage activation, which in some patients can lead to an autoimmune syndrome.

Covalent binding of penicillamine to macrophages: implications for penicillamine-induced autoimmunity.

Idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs) represent a major clinical problem, and at present, the mechanisms involved are still poorly understood. One animal model that we have used for mechanistic studies of IDRs is penicillamine-induced autoimmunity in Brown Norway (BN) rats. Previous work in our lab found that macrophage activation preceded the clinical autoimmune syndrome. It is thought that one of the interactions between T cells and macrophages involves reversible Schiff base formation between an amine on T cells and an aldehyde on macrophages, but the identity of the molecules involved is unknown. It is also known that penicillamine reacts with aldehyde groups to form a thiazolidine ring, which unlike a Schiff base, is essentially irreversible. Such binding could lead to macrophage activation. Generalized macrophage activation could lead to the observed autoimmune reaction. Hydralazine and isoniazid also react with aldehydes to form stable hydrazones, and they also cause an autoimmune lupus-like syndrome. In this study, isolated spleen cells from male BN rats were incubated with biotin-aldehyde-reactive probe (ARP, a hydroxylamine), biotin-hydrazide, or D-penicillamine. At all concentrations, ARP, hydrazide, and penicillamine preferentially "stained" macrophages relative to other spleen cells. In addition, preincubation of cells with penicillamine or hydralazine decreased ARP staining of macrophages, which further indicates that most of the ARP binding to macrophages involves binding to aldehyde groups. This provides support for the hypothesis that the interaction between aldehyde-containing signaling molecules on macrophages and penicillamine could be the initial event of penicillamine-induced autoimmunity. Several of the proteins to which ARP binds were identified, and some such as myosin are attractive candidates to mediate macrophage activation.

Hepatic effects of duloxetine-II: spontaneous reports and epidemiology of hepatic events.

OBJECTIVE: Review spontaneous reports and epidemiology of hepatic events associated with duloxetine. METHODS: Spontaneous reports of adverse events potentially associated with hepatic injury were identified. Classification schemes were Clinical Significance and Etiologic Category relative to likelihood of being related to duloxetine. RESULTS: Duloxetine has been taken by an estimated 5,083,000 patients, representing approximately 1,551,000 person-years (PY) of worldwide exposure. In the Etiologic categorization of the 406 cases containing event terms potentially related to the liver that have been reported to the manufacturer, 26 were deemed Probable and 127 Possible. Because of scantly-reported information, 182 cases were considered Indeterminate. For Severe Hepatic Injury, the observed spontaneous reporting rate was 0.7/100,000 persons exposed. Of the 406 cases, 225 experienced enzyme elevations to values <500 U/L, most with concentrations well below this level. The calculated cumulative spontaneous reporting rate of all duloxetine hepatic-related events combined was 0.00799%, in the context of other drug-induced hepatic injury rates reported in the literature of 0.7 to 40.6 per 100,000 PY of observation. CONCLUSIONS: There were few cases of true hepatic injury possibly or probably related to duloxetine. The calculated cumulative reporting rate is consistent with very rarely reported per the Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences.

Hepatic effects of duloxetine-I: non-clinical and clinical trial data.

OBJECTIVE: Review nonclinical and clinical trial data for hepatic effects of duloxetine. METHODS: Review studies of toxicology, metabolism, mitochondrial effects, and clinical trials. RESULTS: Nonclinical studies revealed no treatment-related transaminase elevations and no effects of duloxetine on mitochondrial beta-oxidation in rat hepatocytes. In patients with a normal baseline alanine transaminase (ALT), duloxetine was associated with elevated transaminases >3X ULN in about 1% of patients. ALT and aspartate transaminase values peaked at 8 weeks, alkaline phosphatase steadily increased to maximum value at Week 52 and mean total bilirubin values were not increased. Hepatic-related treatment-emergent adverse events were uncommon. Seven of 23,000 duloxetine- and 2/6000 placebo-treated patients met criteria for modified Hy's rule (significant elevation of both ALT and total bilirubin) but were complicated by contributing factors such as excessive alcohol consumption (n=3), gall stones, common bile duct calculus, hepatitis C, and liver adenocarcinoma (n=1 each). CONCLUSIONS: Duloxetine has an effect on the liver, manifested by transient, self-limiting transaminase elevations. Rare events characterized as hepatocellular injury, cholestatic injury, or mixed type of hepatic injury have been reported. The pattern of liver effects was different from that in laboratory animals.

Changes in gene expression induced by carbamazepine and phenytoin: testing the danger hypothesis.

The aromatic anticonvulsants carbamazepine (CBZ) and phenytoin (PHN) are associated with a relatively high incidence of idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs). If biomarkers could be found that would predict the risk that a drug candidate would cause IDRs it would significantly decrease the risks associated with drug development. The IDRs associated with CBZ and PHN appear to be immune-mediated. The Danger Hypothesis posits that for something to induce an immune response, it must cause some type of cell damage that ultimately causes up-regulation of co-stimulatory molecules on antigen-presenting cells; without this, the response will be immune tolerance. If the Danger Hypothesis is correct, the ability of a drug or its reactive metabolite to induce cell damage or stress may be related to its risk of causing IDRs. In a parallel study reported elsewhere, we found that major metabolites of these two drugs: 3-OH-CBZ and 4-OH-PHN can be oxidized by peroxidases to phenoxyl free radicals, which could cause oxidative stress by redox cycling. In this study using mRNA microarrays, we found that CBZ and PHN treatment induced changes in mRNA expression in mice. Many of the changes were in genes related to Keap1-Nrf2-ARE signaling pathways and enzymes involved in responding to oxidant stressors and reactive metabolites such as glutathione transferase and heat shock proteins. The similar patterns of genes induced by these two drugs are consistent with the clinical observation that those two drugs exhibit cross-sensitivity. These findings are consistent with the induction of cell stress by CBZ and PHN, most likely due to reactive metabolites. Such changes may represent a danger signal and represent a biomarker of the potential that a drug will cause IDRs; however, different drugs likely cause cell stress by different mechanisms and, therefore, the biomarkers for other drugs would likely be different.

Pathways of carbamazepine bioactivation in vitro. III. The role of human cytochrome P450 enzymes in the formation of 2,3-dihydroxycarbamazepine.

Conversion of the carbamazepine metabolite 3-hydroxycarbamazepine (3-OHCBZ) to the catechol 2,3-dihydroxycarbamazepine (2,3-diOHCBZ) followed by subsequent oxidation to a reactive o-quinone species has been proposed as a possible bioactivation pathway in the pathogenesis of carbamazepine-induced hypersensitivity. Initial in vitro phenotyping studies implicated CYP3A4 as a primary catalyst of 2,3-diOHCBZ formation: 2-hydroxylation of 3-OHCBZ correlated significantly (r(2) > or = 0.929, P < 0.001) with CYP3A4/5 activities in a panel of human liver microsomes (n = 14) and was markedly impaired by CYP3A inhibitors (>80%) but not by inhibitors of other cytochrome P450 enzymes (< or = 20%). However, in the presence of troleandomycin, the rate of 2,3-diOHCBZ formation correlated significantly with CYP2C19 activity (r(2) = 0.893, P < 0.001) in the panel of human liver microsomes. Studies with a panel of cDNA-expressed enzymes revealed that CYP2C19 and CYP3A4 were high (S50 = 30 microM) and low (S50 = 203 microM) affinity enzymes, respectively, for 2,3-diOHCBZ formation and suggested that CYP3A4, but not CYP2C19, might be inactivated by a metabolite formed from 3-OHCBZ. Subsequent experiments demonstrated that preincubation of 3-OHCBZ with human liver microsomes or recombinant CYP3A4 led to decreased CYP3A4 activity, which was both preincubation time- and concentration-dependent, but not inhibited by inclusion of glutathione or N-acetylcysteine. CYP3A4, CYP3A5, CYP3A7, CYP2C19, and CYP1A2 converted [14C]3-OHCBZ into protein-reactive metabolites, but CYP3A4 was the most catalytically active enzyme. The results of this study suggest that CYP3A4-dependent secondary oxidation of 3-OHCBZ represents a potential carbamazepine bioactivation pathway via formation of reactive metabolites capable of inactivating CYP3A4, potentially generating a neoantigen that may play a role in the etiology of carbamazepine-induced idiosyncratic toxicity.

Peroxidase-mediated bioactivation of hydroxylated metabolites of carbamazepine and phenytoin.

Carbamazepine (CBZ) and phenytoin (PHN) are associated with a relatively high incidence of idiosyncratic drug reactions. Most such reactions are believed to be due to reactive metabolites. The reactions associated with these two drugs are similar, and if a patient has a reaction to one, he or she is at increased risk of having a reaction to the other, suggesting that a similar reactive metabolite may be involved. CBZ causes neutropenia in approximately 10% of patients; this suggests that reactive metabolites are formed by myeloperoxidase (MPO), the major oxidative enzyme in neutrophils. Major metabolites of CBZ are the 2- and 3-OH metabolites, and that of PHN is the 4-OH metabolite. We found that both 2-OH-CBZ and 3-OH-CBZ were further oxidized by MPO/H2O2, and the oxidation of 3-OH-CBZ was much faster than the oxidation of 2-OH-CBZ or CBZ itself. Oxidation by MPO formed dimers of 3-OH-CBZ and 4-OH-PHN and, in the presence of N-acetyltyrosine, cross dimers were formed. This strongly suggests free radical intermediates. Bioactivation of 3-OH-CBZ and 4-OH-PHN by MPO/H2O2 led to covalent binding to the tyrosine of a model protein. Free radicals usually generate reactive oxygen species (ROS). We also tested the ability of these metabolites to generate ROS and found that 3-OH-CBZ generated more ROS than 2-OH-CBZ, which was, in turn, greater than that generated by CBZ. These results suggest that bioactivation of 3-OH-CBZ and 4-OH-PHN to free radicals by peroxidases may play a role in the ability of these drugs to cause idiosyncratic drug reactions.

Testing the hypothesis that selenium deficiency is a risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis in rats.

Clozapine is an effective atypical antipsychotic associated with a relatively high incidence of drug-induced agranulocytosis. It forms a reactive nitrenium ion metabolite upon oxidation by peripheral neutrophils and their precursors in the bone marrow. Although the mechanism of this idiosyncratic drug reaction is still unknown, the observation that it does not occur rapidly on rechallenge of patients with a history of clozapine-induced agranulocytosis suggests that it is not immune-mediated. Previous studies by other research groups had found that patients on clozapine had lower plasma and red blood cell levels of selenium. The reactive metabolite of clozapine reacts with glutathione, and therefore, it is likely that it also binds to selenocysteine-containing proteins, such as glutathione peroxidase, thioredoxin reductase, and protein disulfide isomerase. We set out to test the hypothesis that clozapine-induced agranulocytosis is associated with selenium deficiency with rats on a selenium-deficient diet. We studied the effects of clozapine on selenium levels and the effect of selenium deficiency on leukocyte and neutrophil counts and clozapine covalent binding. We did not observe any significant difference between clozapine-treated rats given a selenium-adequate or deficient diet. Therefore, it is unlikely that selenium deficiency is a major risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis.

Testing the hypothesis that vitamin C deficiency is a risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis using guinea pigs and ODS rats.

The use of clozapine is limited by a relatively high incidence of drug-induced agranulocytosis. Clozapine is oxidized by bone marrow cells to a reactive nitrenium ion. Although many idiosyncratic drug reactions are immune-mediated, the fact that patients with a history of clozapine-induced agranulocytosis do not immediately develop agranulocytosis on rechallenge suggests that some other factor may be responsible for the idiosyncratic nature of this reaction. The reactive nitrenium ion is very rapidly reduced back to clozapine by vitamin C, and many schizophrenic patients are vitamin C deficient. We set out to test the hypothesis that vitamin C deficiency is a major risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis using a vitamin C deficient guinea pig model. Although the vitamin C deficient guinea pigs did not develop agranulocytosis, the amount of clozapine covalent binding in these animals was less than we had previously observed in samples from rats and humans. Therefore, we studied ODS rats that also cannot synthesize vitamin C. Vitamin C deficient ODS rats also did not develop agranulocytosis, and furthermore, although covalent binding in the bone marrow was greater than that in the guinea pig, it was not increased in the vitamin C deficient ODS rats relative to ODS rats that had adequate vitamin C in their diet. Therefore, it is very unlikely that vitamin C deficiency is a major risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis.

Possible bioactivation pathways of lamotrigine.

The anticonvulsant lamotrigine is associated with idiosyncratic drug reactions, especially skin rashes. Most idiosyncratic reactions are believed to be caused by reactive metabolites. Previous studies have found evidence that an arene oxide is formed in rats; however, when we incubated radiolabeled lamotrigine with rat liver microsomes virtually no covalent binding was detected, and the expected downstream phenolic metabolites are not observed in humans. Rare cases of agranulocytosis have been associated with lamotrigine therapy, and we found that lamotrigine is oxidized to two different N-chloro products by HOCl. The more reactive N-chloro metabolite forms an adduct with N-acetylhistidine, and covalent binding was observed when radiolabeled lamotrigine was incubated with myeloperoxidase/H(2)O(2)/Cl(-). Another lamotrigine metabolite is an N-oxide. If this N-oxide were sulfated, it might be sufficiently reactive to bind to protein. The synthetic N-sulfate reacted with N-acetylserine; however, no covalent binding was detected when the radiolabeled N-oxide was incubated with sulfotransferase. We also investigated the possibility that lamotrigine might be oxidized to a free radical by other peroxidases or oxidized by other enzymes such as prostaglandin H synthase or tyrosinase, but no evidence of oxidation was found, and lamotrigine did not cause any detectable increase in lipid peroxidation in vivo. In view of the virtual lack of covalent binding to hepatic microsomes and the lack of any other likely pathway leading to metabolic activation in the skin, it is possible that the parent drug rather than a reactive metabolite causes lamotrigine-induced skin rashes.

Changes in gene expression induced by tienilic Acid and sulfamethoxazole: testing the danger hypothesis.

Tienilic acid (TA) was withdrawn due to idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity. Two hypotheses for the mechanisms of idiosyncratic reactions are the hapten and danger hypotheses, which are not mutually exclusive. Both human CYP 2C9 and rat CYP 2C11 metabolize TA to a reactive metabolite that was reported to bind exclusively to these enzymes. TA-Induced liver toxicity is associated with antibodies against CYP 2C9, thus TA appears to act as a hapten. However, if the binding were limited to CYP 2C, it is unlikely that this would lead to significant cell stress. If TA does not cause cell stress it would suggest that acting as a hapten is sufficient to induce an idiosyncratic reaction. To test whether TA can cause cell stress rats were dosed with TA and hepatic gene expression was profiled at 6 and 24 hr after drug administration. TA induced changes in genes involved in oxidative stress (aldo-keto reductase, glutathione-S-transferase, thioredoxin reductase, epoxide hydrolase), inflammation (IL-1beta, interferon regulatory factor 1, macrophage stimulating protein 1), cytotoxicity (caspase-12), and liver regeneration (p27(Kip1), DUSP6, serine dehyratase, spectrin beta II, inhibin beta(A)). These data support the hypothesis that danger signals in the form of cell-stress may be involved in initiating the immune response observed in TA-induced toxicity. In separate experiments, we examined the changes in gene expression induced in mice by sulfamethoxazole, which also causes idiosyncratic reactions. Sulfamethoxazole is an aromatic amine, and aromatic amines in general are associated with idiosyncratic drug reactions. They form reactive metabolites that both act as electrophiles and can redox cycle; therefore, it was assumed that sulfamethoxazole would cause some type of cell stress, the only question was what changes in mRNA expression would occur. In contrast to expectations, no changes induced by sulfamethoxazole could easily be interpreted as a danger signal. These data are presented together because they are the opposite of the expected results and convey a complex story.

Study of the sequence of events involved in nevirapine-induced skin rash in Brown Norway rats.

Nevirapine, used for the treatment of HIV infection, is associated with development of skin rash and liver toxicity. The mechanism of these idiosyncratic reactions is unknown. We have previously reported the discovery of a new animal model of nevirapine-induced skin rash in rats. When treated with nevirapine, Brown Norway rats developed red ears on about day 7 and skin rash on about day 21. On rechallenge, ears turn red within 24 h, and skin lesions develop by day 9. In the current study, we analyzed the time course of the sequence of events involved in the development of skin rash. Rats were treated with nevirapine for 7, 14, or 21 days or rechallenged with it for 0, 1, or 9 days. This treatment led to an increase in the total number of auricular lymph node T, B, and macrophage cells. There was also an increase in the activation/infiltration marker ICAM-1 and activation/antigen presentation marker MHC II in these cells compared with those from control rats. Immunohistochemistry analysis showed macrophage infiltration and ICAM-1 expression in the ears of treated rats as early as day 7 of treatment. Macrophage infiltration preceded T cell infiltration, which was not apparent until the onset of rash. Both MHC I and MHC II expression increased in the skin of nevirapine-treated rats that developed rash. A major inducer of MHC is IFNgamma. Although rechallenge with nevirapine led to a large increase in serum levels of IFNgamma, this was not observed during the treatment of naïve rats with nevirapine. These observations provide further clues to the mechanism of nevirapine-induced skin rash.

In vitro and animal models of drug-induced blood dyscrasias.

Drug-induced blood dyscrasias can be either acute and predictable or delayed and unpredictable (idiosyncratic). The predictable toxicity is relatively easy to reproduce with in vitro models, although they may not work for drugs that require bioactivation. It is very unlikely that idiosyncratic blood dyscrasias can be modeled in vitro, although some drugs (or their reactive metabolites) that cause idiosyncratic reaction are toxic to bone marrow cells in vitro. Although the mechanisms of idiosyncratic reactions are poorly understood, there is evidence that most are due to reactive metabolites and some are immune-mediated. Therefore screening drugs for their bioactivation by myeloperoxidase, the major oxidative enzyme in bone marrow, may provide some measure of the risk that a drug will cause blood dyscrasias. Several examples of drug-induced idiosyncratic agranulocytosis, aplastic anemia and thrombocytopenia are presented, but better in vivo models are clearly needed to gain a clearer understanding of these adverse reactions.