Variability in Maize Seed Bacterization and Survival Correlating with Root Colonization by Pseudomonas Isolates with Plant-Probiotic Traits.

Seed treatment with plant growth-promoting bacteria represents the primary strategy to incorporate them into agricultural ecosystems, particularly for crops under extensive management, such as maize. In this study, we evaluated the seed bacterization levels, root colonization patterns, and root competitiveness of a collection of autochthonous Pseudomonas isolates that have demonstrated several plant-probiotic abilities in vitro. Our findings indicate that the seed bacterization level, both with and without the addition of various protectants, is specific to each Pseudomonas strain, including their response to seed pre-hydration. Bacterization kinetics revealed that while certain isolates persisted on seed surfaces for up to 4 days post-inoculation (dpi), others experienced a rapid decline in viability after 1 or 2 dpi. The observed differences in seed bacterization levels were consistent with the root colonization densities observed through confocal microscopy analysis, and with root competitiveness quantified via selective plate counts. Notably, isolates P. protegens RBAN4 and P. chlororaphis subsp. aurantiaca SMMP3 demonstrated effective competition with the natural microflora for colonizing the maize rhizosphere and both promoted shoot and root biomass production in maize assessed at the V3 grown stage. Conversely, P. donghuensis SVBP6 was detected at very low levels in the maize rhizosphere, but still exhibited a positive effect on plant parameters, suggesting a growth-stimulatory effect during the early stages of plant development. In conclusion, there is a considerable strain-specific variability in the maize seed bacterization and survival capacities of Pseudomonas isolates with plant-probiotic traits, with a correlation in their root competitiveness under natural conditions. This variability must be understood to optimize their adoption as inputs for the agricultural system. Our experimental approach emphasizes the critical importance of tailoring seed bacterization treatments for each inoculant candidate, including the selection and incorporation of protective substances. It should not be assumed that all bacterial cells exhibit a similar performance.

An Integrated Affinity Chromatography-Based Approach to Unravel the sRNA Interactome in Nitrogen-Fixing Rhizobia.

The activity mechanism and function of bacterial base-pairing small non-coding RNA regulators (sRNAs) are largely shaped by their main interacting cellular partners, i.e., proteins and mRNAs. We describe here an MS2 affinity chromatography-based procedure adapted to unravel the sRNA interactome in nitrogen-fixing legume endosymbiotic bacteria. The method consists of tagging of the bait sRNA at its 5'-end with the MS2 aptamer followed by pulse overexpression and immobilization of the chimeric transcript from cell lysates by an MS2-MBP fusion protein conjugated to an amylose resin. The sRNA-binding proteins and target mRNAs are further profiled by mass spectrometry and RNAseq, respectively.

Comparative genomics and informational content analysis uncovered internal regions of the core genes rpoD, pepN and gltX for an MLSA with genome-level resolving power within the genus Pseudomonas.

In the field of prokaryotic taxonomy, there has been a recent transition towards phylogenomics as the gold standard approach. However, genome-based phylogenetics is still restrictive for its cost when managing large amounts of isolates. Fast, cheap, and taxonomically competent alternatives, like multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) are thus recommendable. Nevertheless, the criteria for selecting the conserved genes for MLSA have not been explicit for different bacterial taxa, including the broadly diverse Pseudomonas genus. Here, we have carried out an unbiased and rational workflow to select internal sequence regions of Pseudomonas core genes (CG) for a MLSA with the best phylogenetic power, and with a resolution comparable to the genome-based ANI approach. A computational workflow was established to inspect 126 complete genomes of representatives from over 60 Pseudomonas species and subspecies, in order to identify the most informative CG internal regions and determine which combinations in sets of three partial CG sequences have comparable phylogenetic resolution to that of the current ANI standard. We found that the rpoD346-1196-pepN1711-2571-gltX86-909 concatenated sequences were the best performing in terms of phylogenetic robustness and resulted highly sensitive and specific when contrasted with ANI. The rpoD-pepN-gltX MLSA was validated in silico and in vitro. Altogether, the results presented here supports the proposal of the rpoD-pepN-gltX MLSA as a fast, affordable, and robust phylogenetic tool for members of the Pseudomonas genus.

Azospirillum baldaniorum Sp245 exploits Pseudomonas fluorescens A506 biofilm to overgrow in dual-species macrocolonies.

Biofilms are essential for plant-associated bacteria to colonize their host. In this work, we analysed the interaction of Azospirillum baldaniorum Sp245 and Pseudomonas fluorescens A506 in mixed macrocolony biofilms. We identified certain culture conditions where A. baldaniorum Sp245 exploits P. fluorescens A506 to boost its growth. Azospirillum growth increased proportionally to the initial number of pseudomonads building the biofilm, which in turn were negatively affected in their growth. Physical contact with P. fluorescens A506 was essential for A. baldaniorum Sp245 growth increase. Biofilm ultrastructure analysis revealed that Pseudomonas produces a thick structure that hosts Azospirillum cells in its interior. Additional experimentation demonstrated that Azospirillum growth boost is compromised when interacting with biofilm-deficient Pseudomonas mutants, and that a low oxygen concentration strongly induce A. baldaniorum Sp245 growth, overriding Pseudomonas stimulation. In this line, we used a microaerophilia reporter strain of A. baldaniorum Sp245 to confirm that dual-species macrocolonies contain a higher number of cells under microaerophilic conditions. Taking all the results into consideration, we propose that A. baldaniorum Sp245 can benefit from P. fluorescens A506 partnership in mixed biofilms by taking advantage of the low oxygen concentration and scaffold made up of Pseudomonas-derived matrix, to expand its growth.

Agronomic efficiency and genome mining analysis of the wheat-biostimulant rhizospheric bacterium Pseudomonas pergaminensis sp. nov. strain 1008T.

Pseudomonas sp. strain 1008 was isolated from the rhizosphere of field grown wheat plants at the tillering stage in an agricultural plot near Pergamino city, Argentina. Based on its in vitro phosphate solubilizing capacity and the production of IAA, strain 1008 was formulated as an inoculant for bacterization of wheat seeds and subjected to multiple field assays within the period 2010-2017. Pseudomonas sp. strain 1008 showed a robust positive impact on the grain yield (+8% on average) across a number of campaigns, soil properties, seed genotypes, and with no significant influence of the simultaneous seed treatment with a fungicide, strongly supporting the use of this biostimulant bacterium as an agricultural input for promoting the yield of wheat. Full genome sequencing revealed that strain 1008 has the capacity to access a number of sources of inorganic and organic phosphorus, to compete for iron scavenging, to produce auxin, 2,3-butanediol and acetoin, and to metabolize GABA. Additionally, the genome of strain 1008 harbors several loci related to rhizosphere competitiveness, but it is devoid of biosynthetic gene clusters for production of typical secondary metabolites of biocontrol representatives of the Pseudomonas genus. Finally, the phylogenomic, phenotypic, and chemotaxonomic comparative analysis of strain 1008 with related taxa strongly suggests that this wheat rhizospheric biostimulant isolate is a representative of a novel species within the genus Pseudomonas, for which the name Pseudomonas pergaminensis sp. nov. (type strain 1008T = DSM 113453T = ATCC TSD-287T) is proposed.

Structural studies on the O-specific polysaccharide of the lipopolysaccharide from Pseudomonas donghuensis strain SVBP6, with antifungal activity against the phytopathogenic fungus Macrophomina phaseolina.

An O-specific polysaccharide (OPS) was isolated from the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) of Pseudomonas donghuensis SVBP6, a bacterium with a broad-spectrum antifungal activity in vitro, particularly that against Macrophomina phaseolina. This latter is one of the most virulent and dangerous pathogens of plants, including soybean which is an economically important crop in Argentina today. The OPS was studied by sugar analysis and spectroscopy (1D and 2D 1H and 13C NMR) showing the following trisaccharide repeating unit: →6)-ɑ-D-ManpNAc-(1 â†’ 3)-ß-l-Rhap-(1 â†’ 4)-ß-D-Glcp-(1→. The crude LPS, the purified LPS and the O-chain were assayed for their antifungal activity against M. phaseolina at 25, 50, 100, and 200 µg plug-1. The results showed that the crude LPS best inhibition was at 200 µg plug-1, able to inhibit the fungus growth by about 45%, while purified LPS and the corresponding OPS, in the same condition, reduced fungus growth by 65%, and 75%, respectively. Furthermore, the purified LPS and OPS significantly reduced the growth of M. phaseolina already at 100 µg plug-1 compared to the crude LPS. The structure of the O-chain is unique among the bacterial LPS and this is the first time that both the antifungal activity of a bacterial LPS and its corresponding O-chain were described.

Comparative Genomics and Evolutionary Analysis of RNA-Binding Proteins of the CsrA Family in the Genus Pseudomonas.

Gene expression is adjusted according to cellular needs through a combination of mechanisms acting at different layers of the flow of genetic information. At the posttranscriptional level, RNA-binding proteins are key factors controlling the fate of nascent and mature mRNAs. Among them, the members of the CsrA family are small dimeric proteins with heterogeneous distribution across the bacterial tree of life, that act as global regulators of gene expression because they recognize characteristic sequence/structural motifs (short hairpins with GGA triplets in the loop) present in hundreds of mRNAs. The regulatory output of CsrA binding to mRNAs is counteracted in most cases by molecular mimic, non-protein coding RNAs that titrate the CsrA dimers away from the target mRNAs. In γ-proteobacteria, the regulatory modules composed by CsrA homologs and the corresponding antagonistic sRNAs, are mastered by two-component systems of the GacS-GacA type, which control the transcription and the abundance of the sRNAs, thus constituting the rather linear cascade Gac-Rsm that responds to environmental or cellular signals to adjust and coordinate the expression of a set of target genes posttranscriptionally. Within the γ-proteobacteria, the genus Pseudomonas has been shown to contain species with different number of active CsrA (RsmA) homologs and of molecular mimic sRNAs. Here, with the help of the increasing availability of genomic data we provide a comprehensive state-of-the-art picture of the remarkable multiplicity of CsrA lineages, including novel yet uncharacterized paralogues, and discuss evolutionary aspects of the CsrA subfamilies of the genus Pseudomonas, and implications of the striking presence of csrA alleles in natural mobile genetic elements (phages and plasmids).

7-hydroxytropolone is the main metabolite responsible for the fungal antagonism of Pseudomonas donghuensis strain SVBP6.

Pseudomonas donghuensis strain SVBP6, an isolate from an agricultural plot in Argentina, displays a broad-spectrum and diffusible antifungal activity, which requires a functional gacS gene but could not be ascribed yet to known secondary metabolites typical of Pseudomonas biocontrol species. Here, we report that Tn5 mutagenesis allowed the identification of a gene cluster involved in both the fungal antagonism and the production of a soluble tropolonoid compound. The ethyl acetate extract from culture supernatant showed a dose-dependent inhibitory effect against the phytopathogenic fungus Macrophomina phaseolina. The main compound present in the organic extract was identified by spectroscopic and X-ray analyses as 7-hydroxytropolone (7HT). Its structure and tautomerism was confirmed by preparing the two key derivatives 2,3-dimethoxy- and 2,7-dimethoxy-tropone. 7HT, but not 2,3- or 2,7-dimethoxy-tropone, mimicked the fungal inhibitory activity of the ethyl acetate extract from culture supernatant. The activity of 7HT, as well as its production, was barely affected by the presence of up to 50 µM added iron (Fe+2 ). To summarize, P. donghuensis SVBP6 produces 7HT under the positive control of the Gac-Rsm cascade and is the main active metabolite responsible for the broad-spectrum inhibition of different phytopathogenic fungi.

Biocontrol Traits Correlate With Resistance to Predation by Protists in Soil Pseudomonads.

Root-colonizing bacteria can support plant growth and help fend off pathogens. It is clear that such bacteria benefit from plant-derived carbon, but it remains ambiguous why they invest in plant-beneficial traits. We suggest that selection via protist predation contributes to recruitment of plant-beneficial traits in rhizosphere bacteria. To this end, we examined the extent to which bacterial traits associated with pathogen inhibition coincide with resistance to protist predation. We investigated the resistance to predation of a collection of Pseudomonas spp. against a range of representative soil protists covering three eukaryotic supergroups. We then examined whether patterns of resistance to predation could be explained by functional traits related to plant growth promotion, disease suppression and root colonization success. We observed a strong correlation between resistance to predation and phytopathogen inhibition. In addition, our analysis highlighted an important contribution of lytic enzymes and motility traits to resist predation by protists. We conclude that the widespread occurrence of plant-protective traits in the rhizosphere microbiome may be driven by the evolutionary pressure for resistance against predation by protists. Protists may therefore act as microbiome regulators promoting native bacteria involved in plant protection against diseases.

Friends or foes in the rhizosphere: traits of fluorescent Pseudomonas that hinder Azospirillum brasilense growth and root colonization.

Bacteria of the Azospirillum and Pseudomonas genera are ubiquitous members of the rhizosphere, where they stimulate plant growth. Given the outstanding capacity of pseudomonads to antagonize other microorganisms, we analyzed the interaction between these two bacterial groups to identify determinants of their compatibility. We could establish that, when in direct contact, certain Pseudomonas strains produce lethality on Azospirillum brasilense cells using an antibacterial type 6 secretion system. When analyzing the effect of Pseudomonas spp. diffusible metabolites on A. brasilense growth on King's B medium, we detected strong inhibitory effects, mostly mediated by siderophores. On Congo Red medium, both inhibitory and stimulatory effects were induced by unidentified compounds. Under this condition, Pseudomonas protegens CHA0 produced a Gac/Rsm-regulated antibiotic which specifically inhibited A. brasilense Sp7 but not Sp245. This effect was not associated with the production of 2,4-diacetylphloroglucinol. The three identified antagonism determinants were also active in vivo, producing a reduction of viable cells of A. brasilense in the roots of wheat seedlings when co-inoculated with pseudomonads. These results are relevant to the understanding of social dynamics in the rhizosphere and might aid in the selection of strains for mixed inoculants.

Genomic insights into the broad antifungal activity, plant-probiotic properties, and their regulation, in Pseudomonas donghuensis strain SVBP6.

Plant-growth promotion has been linked to the Pseudomonas genus since the beginning of this research field. In this work, we mined the genome of an Argentinean isolate of the recently described species P. donghuensis. Strain SVBP6, isolated from bulk soil of an agricultural plot, showed a broad antifungal activity and several other plant-probiotic activities. As this species has been recently described, and it seems like some plant-growth promoting (PGP) traits do not belong to the classical pseudomonads toolbox, we decide to explore the SVBP6 genome via an bioinformatic approach. Genome inspection confirmed our previous in vitro results about genes involved in several probiotic activities. Other genetic traits possibly involved in survival of SVBP6 in highly competitive environments, such as rhizospheres, were found. Tn5 mutagenesis revealed that the antifungal activity against the soil pathogen Macrophomina phaseolina was dependent on a functional gacS gene, from the regulatory cascade Gac-Rsm, but it was not due to volatile compounds. Altogether, our genomic analyses and in vitro tests allowed the phylogenetic assignment and provided the first insights into probiotic properties of the first P. donghuensis isolate from the Americas.

Guidelines for Inferring and Characterizing a Family of Bacterial trans-Acting Small Noncoding RNAs.

So far, every sequenced bacterial transcriptome encompasses hundreds of small regulatory noncoding RNAs (sRNAs). From those sRNAs that have been already characterized, we learned that their regulatory functions could span over almost every bacterial process, mostly acting at the posttranscriptional control of gene expression (Wagner and Romby, Adv Genet 90:133-208, 2015). Canonical molecular mechanisms of sRNA action have been described to rely on both sequence and/or structural traits of the RNA molecule. As for protein-coding genes, the conservation of sRNAs among species suggests conserved and adjusted functions across evolution. Knowing the phylogenetic distribution of an sRNA gene and how its functional traits have evolved may help to get a broad picture of its biological role in each single species. Here, we present a simple computational workflow to identify close and distant sRNA homologs present in sequenced bacterial genomes, which allows defining novel sRNA families. This strategy is based on the use of Covariance Models (CM) and assumes the conservation of sequence and structure of functional sRNA genes throughout evolution. Moreover, by carefully inspecting the conservation of the close genomic context of every member of the RNA family and how the patterns of microsynteny follow the path of species evolution, it is possible to define subgroups of sRNA orthologs, which in turn enables the definition of RNA subfamilies.

Expression of the small regulatory RNA gene mmgR is regulated negatively by AniA and positively by NtrC in Sinorhizobium meliloti 2011.

In the N2-fixing symbiont of alfalfa root nodules, Sinorhizobium meliloti 2011, the mmgR gene encodes a 77 nt small untranslated RNA (sRNA) that negatively regulates the accumulation of polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) when the bacterium is grown under conditions of surplus carbon (C) in relation to nitrogen (N). We previously showed that the expression of mmgR is primarily controlled at the transcriptional level and that it depends on the cellular N status, although the regulatory mechanism and the factors involved were unknown. In this study, we provide experimental data supporting that: (a) mmgR is induced upon N limitation with the maximum expression found at the highest tested C/N molar ratio in the growth medium; (b) a conserved heptamer TTGTGCA located between the -35 and -10 mmgR promoter elements is necessary and sufficient for induction by N limitation; (c) induction of mmgR requires the N-status regulator NtrC; (d) under C limitation, mmgR transcription is repressed by AniA, a global regulator of C flow; (e) the mmgR promoter contains a conserved dyadic motif (TGC[N3]GCA) partially overlapping the heptamer TTGTGCA, which was also found in the promoters of the PHB-related genes phaP1, phaP2, phaZ and phaR (aniA) of S. meliloti and other alpha-proteobacteria. Taken together, these results suggest that the mmgR promoter would integrate signals from the metabolism of C and N through - at least - the global regulators NtrC and AniA, to provide an optimal level of the MmgR sRNA to fine-tune gene expression post-transcriptionally according to varying C and N availability.

A matter of hierarchy: activation of orfamide production by the post-transcriptional Gac-Rsm cascade of Pseudomonas protegens CHA0 through expression upregulation of the two dedicated transcriptional regulators.

In this work, we surveyed the genome of P. protegens CHA0 in order to identify novel mRNAs possibly under the control of the Gac-Rsm cascade that might, for their part, serve to elucidate as-yet-unknown functions involved in the biocontrol of plant pathogens and/or in cellular processes required for fitness in natural environments. In view of the experimental evidence from former studies on the Gac-Rsm cascade, we developed a computational screen supported by a combination of sequence, structural and evolutionary constraints that led to a dataset of 43 potential novel mRNA targets. We then confirmed several mRNA targets experimentally and next focused on two of the respective genes that are physically linked to the orfamide biosynthetic gene cluster and whose predicted open-reading frames resembled cognate LuxR-type transcriptional regulators of cyclic lipopeptide clusters in related pseudomonads. In this report, we demonstrate that in strain CHA0, orfamide production is stringently dependent on a functional Gac-Rsm cascade and that both mRNAs encoding transcriptional regulatory proteins are under direct translational control of the RsmA/E proteins. Our results have thus revealed a hierarchical control over the expression of orfamide biosynthetic genes with the final transcriptional control subordinated to the global Gac-Rsm post-transcriptional regulatory system.

The Irr and RirA Proteins Participate in a Complex Regulatory Circuit and Act in Concert To Modulate Bacterioferritin Expression in Ensifer meliloti 1021.

In this work we found that the bfr gene of the rhizobial species Ensifer meliloti, encoding a bacterioferritin iron storage protein, is involved in iron homeostasis and the oxidative stress response. This gene is located downstream of and overlapping the smc03787 open reading frame (ORF). No well-predicted RirA or Irr boxes were found in the region immediately upstream of the bfr gene although two presumptive RirA boxes and one presumptive Irr box were present in the putative promoter of smc03787 We demonstrate that bfr gene expression is enhanced under iron-sufficient conditions and that Irr and RirA modulate this expression. The pattern of bfr gene expression as well as the response to Irr and RirA is inversely correlated to that of smc03787 Moreover, our results suggest that the small RNA SmelC759 participates in RirA- and Irr-mediated regulation of bfr expression and that additional unknown factors are involved in iron-dependent regulation.IMPORTANCEE. meliloti belongs to the Alphaproteobacteria, a group of bacteria that includes several species able to associate with eukaryotic hosts, from mammals to plants, in a symbiotic or pathogenic manner. Regulation of iron homeostasis in this group of bacteria differs from that found in the well-studied Gammaproteobacteria In this work we analyzed the effect of rirA and irr mutations on bfr gene expression. We demonstrate the effect of an irr mutation on iron homeostasis in this bacterial genus. Moreover, results obtained indicate a complex regulatory circuit where multiple regulators, including RirA, Irr, the small RNA SmelC759, and still unknown factors, act in concert to balance bfr gene expression.

Correction: Quantitative Proteomic Analysis of the Hfq-Regulon in Sinorhizobium meliloti 2011.

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0048494.].

Regulation of Polyhydroxybutyrate Accumulation in Sinorhizobium meliloti by the Trans-Encoded Small RNA MmgR.

Riboregulation has a major role in the fine-tuning of multiple bacterial processes. Among the RNA players, trans-encoded untranslated small RNAs (sRNAs) regulate complex metabolic networks by tuning expression from multiple target genes in response to numerous signals. In Sinorhizobium meliloti, over 400 sRNAs are expressed under different stimuli. The sRNA MmgR (standing for Makes more granules Regulator) has been of particular interest to us since its sequence and structure are highly conserved among the alphaproteobacteria and its expression is regulated by the amount and quality of the bacterium's available nitrogen source. In this work, we explored the biological role of MmgR in S. meliloti 2011 by characterizing the effect of a deletion of the internal conserved core of mmgR (mmgRΔ33-51). This mutation resulted in larger amounts of polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) distributed into more intracellular granules than are found in the wild-type strain. This phenotype was expressed upon cessation of balanced growth owing to nitrogen depletion in the presence of surplus carbon (i.e., at a carbon/nitrogen molar ratio greater than 10). The normal PHB accumulation was complemented with a wild-type mmgR copy but not with unrelated sRNA genes. Furthermore, the expression of mmgR limited PHB accumulation in the wild type, regardless of the magnitude of the C surplus. Quantitative proteomic profiling and quantitative reverse transcription-PCR (qRT-PCR) revealed that the absence of MmgR results in a posttranscriptional overexpression of both PHB phasin proteins (PhaP1 and PhaP2). Together, our results indicate that the widely conserved alphaproteobacterial MmgR sRNA fine-tunes the regulation of PHB storage in S. melilotiIMPORTANCE High-throughput RNA sequencing has recently uncovered an overwhelming number of trans-encoded small RNAs (sRNAs) in diverse prokaryotes. In the nitrogen-fixing alphaproteobacterial symbiont of alfalfa root nodules Sinorhizobium meliloti, only four out of hundreds of identified sRNA genes have been functionally characterized. Thus, uncovering the biological role of sRNAs currently represents a major issue and one that is particularly challenging because of the usually subtle quantitative regulation contributed by most characterized sRNAs. Here, we have characterized the function of the broadly conserved alphaproteobacterial sRNA gene mmgR in S. meliloti Our results strongly suggest that mmgR encodes a negative regulator of the accumulation of polyhydroxybutyrate, the major carbon and reducing power storage polymer in S. meliloti cells growing under conditions of C/N overbalance.

Quantification of Bacterial Polyhydroxybutyrate Content by Flow Cytometry.

We describe here a detailed protocol for the quantification of the intracellular content of polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) in a population of bacterial cells by flow cytometry, which is based on a consensus of several previously reported works.

Interspecific cooperation: enhanced growth, attachment and strain-specific distribution in biofilms through Azospirillum brasilense-Pseudomonas protegens co-cultivation.

Plant-growth-promoting bacteria belonging to Azospirillum and Pseudomonas genera are major inhabitants of the rhizosphere. Both are increasingly commercialized as crops inoculants. Interspecific interaction in the rhizosphere is critical for inoculants aptness. The objective of this work was to evaluate Azospirillum and Pseudomonas interaction in mixed biofilms by co-cultivation of the model strains Azospirillum brasilense Sp245 and Pseudomonas protegens CHA0. The results revealed enhanced growth of both strains when co-cultured in static conditions. Moreover, Sp245 biofilm formed in plastic surfaces was increased 2-fold in the presence of CHA0. Confocal microscopy revealed highly structured mixed biofilms showing Sp245 mainly on the bottom and CHA0 towards the biofilm surface. In addition, A. brasilense biofilm was thicker and denser when co-cultured with P. protegens. In a colony-colony interaction assay, Sp245 changed nearby CHA0 producing small colony phenotype, which accounts for a diffusible metabolite mediator; though CHA0 spent medium did not affect Sp245 colony phenotype. Altogether, these results point to a cooperative interaction between A. brasilense Sp245 and P. protegens CHA0 in which both strains increase their static growth and produce structured mixed biofilms with a strain-specific distribution.