A combined theoretical and experimental approach to determine the right choice of co-ligand to impart spin crossover in Fe(II) complexes based on 1,3,4-oxadiazole ligands.

We present the synthesis of two new novel tetradentate ligands based on 1,3,4-oxadiazole, 2-(2-pyridyl)-5-[N,N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)aminomethyl]-1,3,4-oxadiazole (LTetraPy-ODA) and 2-(2-phenyl)-5-[N,N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)aminomethyl]-1,3,4-oxadiazole (LTetraPh-ODA). The ligands were used to prepare six mononuclear complexes [FeII(LTetraPy-ODA)(NCE)] (C1-C3) and [FeII(LTetraPh-ODA)(NCE)] (C4-C6) where E = S, Se or BH3. In addition, the ligand LTetraPy-ODA was employed in the synthesis of a new di-nuclear complex [FeII2(LTetraPh)](ClO4)4·1 CH3NO2·1.5 H2O (C7). Characterization of all complexes was carried out using single-crystal X-ray crystallography, elemental analysis, and infrared spectroscopy. Magnetic susceptibility measurements, performed in the temperature range of 2-300 K using a SQUID magnetometer, revealed spin crossover behaviour exclusively in the mononuclear complexes C3 and C6, in which two monodentate NCBH3- co-ligands coordinate. The presence of the lattice solvent was found to be crucial to the spin transition property, with complex C3 exhibiting a switching temperature (T1/2) of approximately 165 K and C6 approximately 194 K. The other four mononuclear complexes C1, C2, C4, C5, as well as the dinuclear complex C7 are locked in the high spin state over the measured temperature range. Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were performed on complexes C1-C6 to rationalise the observed magnetic behaviour, demonstrating the significant effect of the NCS-, NCSe- and NCBH3- co-ligands ligands on the spin-crossover behaviour of the [FeII(L)(NCE)] complexes.

Slow Magnetization Relaxation in a Family of Triangular {CoIII 2 LnIII } Clusters: The Effect of Diamagnetic CoIII Ions on the LnIII Magnetic Dynamics.

The first use of the Schiff base chelate N-naphthalidene-o-aminophenol (naphH2 ) in Co/Ln chemistry has afforded a family of isostructural [CoIII 2 LnIII (OMe)2 (naph)2 (O2 CMe)3 (MeOH)2 ] (Ln=Tb, Dy and Er) complexes, revealing a rare {CoIII 2 Ln(µ3 -OMe)}8+ triangular core composed of two diamagnetic CoIII ions and a 4f-ion with slightly distorted square antiprismatic geometry. Alternating current (ac) magnetic susceptibility studies revealed that {Co2 Dy}, and its magnetic diluted analogue {Co2 Dy0.05 Y0.95 }, behave as mononuclear single-molecule magnets (SMMs) with similar energy barriers for the magnetization reversal, Ueff , of ~85-90 K. SMM properties were also detected for {Co2 Er}, with the compound exhibiting a Ueff of 18.7 K under an applied magnetic field of 800 Oe. To interpret the experimental magnetic results, ab initio CASSCF/RASSI-SO and DFT calculations were performed as a means of exploring the single-ion characteristics of LnIII ions and comprehend the role of the diamagnetic CoIII ions in the magnetization relaxation of the three heterometallic compounds.

Efficient synthetic route to heterobimetallic trinuclear complexes [Ln-Mn-Ln] and their single molecule magnetic properties.

A series of mononuclear lanthanoidate complexes isolated as [Bu4N][Ln(QCl4)] 1Ln (QCl = 5-chloro-8-quinolinolate; Ln = Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, and Er) have been prepared, characterised, and used as facile precursors to obtain a series of new heterobimetallic complexes as crystalline materials. Reaction of 1Ln with manganese nitrate forms [Ln2Mn(QCl)8] (2Ln, where Ln = Tb, Dy, Er and Yb) which have been structurally characterised in the cases of 2Tb and 2Yb. The heteroleptic trinuclear complex [Dy3(QCl)8Cl(OH2)], 3, has also been obtained. Compounds 1Dy, 1Tb, and 1Er display slow relaxation of magnetisation below 10K, particularly for the prolate Er3+ ion. These results also suggest that the positive effects of the change from mononuclear to trinuclear lanthanoid complexes enhance their single molecule magnetic (SMM) behaviour, as evidenced by the well resolved frequency dependent AC out-of-phase susceptibility maxima seen in the 2Ln systems, that have been analysed quantitatively. The synthesis used here provides a promising strategy in obtaining heterobimetallic complexes with quinolinolate ligands and also constructing efficient heterobimetallic SMMs.

Strategies to Design Single-Molecule Toroics Using Triangular {Ln3} n Motifs.

In this mini-review, we highlight the research advanced in the field of single-molecule toroics (SMTs) with a specific focus on the triangular Ln3-based SMTs. SMTs are molecules with a toroidal magnetic state and are insensitive to homogeneous magnetic fields but cooperate with charge and spin currents. The rapid growth in the area of SMTs witnessed in recent years is correlated not only to the interest to understand the fundamental physics of these molecules but also to the intriguing potential applications proposed, as the SMTs have several advantages compared to other classes of molecules such as single-molecule magnets (SMMs). The important chemico-structural strategy in SMT chemistry is to choose and design ligand and bridging species that will help to attain toroidal behavior. Considering this primarily, all the Dy3 SMTs reported so far are summarized, showing how utilizing different peripheral ligands influences the toroidal nature beyond the role of the symmetry of the molecule and stronger dipolar interactions. Likewise, linking Dy3 toroidal units through 3d ions with suitable peripheral/bridging ligands enhances the toroidal magnetic moment and leads to fascinating physics of ferrotoroidal/antiferrotoridal behavior. Further, we have also summarized the recently reported non-Dy triangular SMTs.

Enhancing the barrier height for magnetization reversal in 4d/4f RuIII2LnIII2 "butterfly" single molecule magnets (Ln = Gd, Dy) via targeted structural alterations.

A series of 4d-4f {RuIII2DyIII2} and {RuIII2GdIII2} 'butterfly' (rhombohedral) complexes have been synthesized and characterized and their magnetic properties investigated. Earlier, we have reported the first 4d/4f SMM - [RuIII2DyIII2(OMe)2(O2CPh)4(mdea)2(NO3)2] (1Dy) with a Ueff value of 10.7 cm-1. As the structural distortion around the DyIII centres and the RuIII⋯DyIII exchange interactions are key to enhancing the anisotropy, in this work we have synthesised three more {Ru2Dy2} butterfly complexes where structural alteration around the DyIII centres and alterations to the bridging groups are performed with an aim to improve the magnetic properties. The new complexes reported here are [Ru2Dy2(OMe)2(O2C(4-Me-Ph)4(mdea)2(MeOH)4], 2Dy, [Ru2Dy2(OMe)2(O2C(2-Cl,4,5-F-Ph)4(mdea)2(NO3)2], 3Dy, and an acac derivative [Ru2Dy2(OMe)2(acac)4(NO3)2(edea)2], 4Dy, where acac- = acetylacetonate, edea2- = N-ethyldiethanolamine dianion. Complex 2Dy describes alteration in the DyIII centers, while complexes 3Dy and 4Dy are aimed to alter the RuIII⋯DyIII exchange pathways. To ascertain the 4d-4f exchange, the Gd-analogues of 1Dy and 4Dy were synthesised [Ru2Gd2(OMe)2(O2CPh)4(mdea)2(NO3)2], 1Gd, [Ru2Gd2(OMe)2(acac)4(NO3)2(edea)2], 4Gd. Both ac and dc susceptibility studies were performed on all these complexes, and out-of-phase signals were observed for 3Dy in zero-field while 2Dy and 4Dy show out-of-phase signals in the presence of an applied field. Complex 3Dy reveals a barrier height Ueff of 45 K. To understand the difference in the magnetic dynamic behavior compared to our earlier reported {RuIII2DyIII2} analogue, detailed theoretical calculations based on ab initio CASSCF/RASSI-SO calculations have been performed. Calculations reveal that the JRu⋯Dy value varies from -1.8 cm-1 (4Dy) to -2.4 cm-1 (3Dy). These values are also affirmed by DFT calculations performed on the corresponding GdIII analogues. The origin of the largest barrier and observation of slow magnetic relaxation in 3Dy is routed back to the stronger single-ion anisotropy and stronger JRu⋯Dy exchange which quenches the QTM effects more efficiently. This study thus paves the way forward to tune local structure around the LnIII center and the exchange pathway to enhance the SMM characteristics in other {3d-4f}/{4d-4f} SMMs.

Quinoxaline radical-bridged transition metal complexes with very strong antiferromagnetic coupling.

A new family of radical-bridged compounds, (Cp*2Co)[M2Cl4(dpq)] (M = Fe (1), Co (2), Zn (3)), (dpq = 2,3-di(2-pyridyl)-quinoxaline) is reported. Magnetic studies, DFT and ab initio calculations reveal strong antiferromagnetic metal-radical interactions with coupling constants of J = -213.1 and -218.8 cm-1 for 1 and 2, respectively.

Six-coordinate mononuclear dysprosium(iii) single-molecule magnets with the triphenylphosphine oxide ligand.

Structural, magnetic and theoretical studies of three octahedral mononuclear DyIII complexes with triphenylphosphine oxide and halide ligands are reported. The Cl- and Br- analogues exhibit SMM behavior with energy barriers of 49.1 K and 70.9 K, respectively under a small dc field. Ab initio calculations were performed, the results of which predict higher energy barriers for iodide containing SMMs.

New examples of triangular terbium(iii) and holmium(iii) and hexagonal dysprosium(iii) single molecule toroics.

The structural, magnetic and theoretical aspects are described for three triangular lanthanide complexes, [Tb(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl2 (1), [Dy(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl2 (2) and [Ho(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl2 (3), and a hexanuclear wheel of formula [Dy(pdeaH)6(NO3)6] (4) [teaH3 = triethanolamine, paaH = N-(2-pyridyl)-acetoacetamide and pdeaH3 = 3-[bis(2-hydroxyethyl)amino]propan-1-ol]. Each complex displays single molecule toroidal behaviour as rationalised using high-level ab initio calculations. Complexes 2 and 3 are the first examples of mixed moment single molecule toroidal complexes featuring non-Kramers ions.

A Co8 metallacycle stabilized by double anion-π interactions.

Self-assembly reactions of CoII ions in the presence of the 2,2-bipyrimidine (bpym) ligand produced both a dinuclear and an octanuclear cation with the nuclearity being governed by hydrogen-bonding versus anion-π interactions between the anions and the ligands.

Switching on single-molecule magnet properties of homoleptic sandwich tris(pyrazolyl)borate dysprosium(iii) cations via intermolecular dipolar coupling.

Two new homoleptic DyIII compounds [Dy(TpMe2)2][DyCl3(TpMe2)]·CH2Cl2 (1) and [Dy(TpMe2)2]I (3) as well as a heteroleptic (NMe4)[DyCl3(TpMe2)] (2) (TpMe2 = tris(3,5-dimethylpyrazolyl)borate) species are reported. Magnetic studies revealed that 1 is a single-molecule magnet (SMM) with an energy barrier of Ueff = 80.7 K with τ0 = 6.2 × 10-7 s under a zero applied field. Compound 3 exhibits a Ueff of 13.5 K with τ0 = 1.6 × 10-6 s under a 0.08 T applied field. Ab initio CASSCF + RASSI-SO calculations were performed to further investigate the magnetic behavior of complexes 1-3. The results support experimental magnetic data for 1 and 3 and indicate that an intermolecular dipolar interaction of (zJ = -0.1 cm-1) is responsible for the SMM behavior of 1.

Rare "Janus"-faced single-molecule magnet exhibiting intramolecular ferromagnetic interactions.

A rare disk-like single-molecule magnet (SMM) exclusively bridged by end-on azides with a spin ground state of S = 14 was prepared by the reaction of a divalent FeII precursor with Me3SiN3 under basic conditions. AC magnetic susceptibility studies revealed unusual, "Janus"-faced SMM behavior for the dried and pristine forms of the compound attributed to solvation/de-solvation effects of the coordinated MeCN ligands which leads to alterations in the crystal field and symmetry of the metal ions. DFT calculations confirmed the ferromagnetic nature of the interactions between the FeII spin carriers with the zero-field splitting parameters D = -0.2323 cm-1 and E/D = 0.027. The results have important implications for the future study of single-molecule magnets incorporating volatile solvent molecules in the first coordination sphere of the metal ions and their effect on the relaxation dynamics.

Hard versus soft: zero-field dinuclear Dy(iii) oxygen bridged SMM and theoretical predictions of the sulfur and selenium analogues.

Two dinuclear lanthanide complexes (Gd and Dy) were prepared and characterized by X-ray, magnetic and computational methods. The Dy analogue shows SMM behavior with an energy barrier of 98.4 K in the absence of an applied dc field. Theoretical calculations were performed on model complexes which support the hypothesis that the energy barrier will increase if the soft-donor atoms S and Se are used in lieu of an O donor.

Oblate versus Prolate Electron Density of Lanthanide Ions: A Design Criterion for Engineering Toroidal Moments? A Case Study on {LnIII 6 } (Ln=Tb, Dy, Ho and Er) Wheels.

We report four new complexes based on a {LnIII 6 } wheel structure, three of which possess a net toroidal magnetic moment. The four examples consist of {TbIII 6 } and {HoIII 6 } wheels, which are rare examples of non DyIII based complexes possessing a toroidal magnetic ground state, and a {DyIII 6 } complex which improves its toroidal structure upon lowering the crystallographic symmetry from trigonal (R 3 ‾ ) to triclinic (P 1 ‾ ). Notably the toroidal moment is lost for the trigonal {ErIII 6 } analogue. This suggests the possibility of utilizing the popular concept of oblate and prolate electron density of the ground state MJ levels of lanthanide ions to engineer toroidal moments.

A cyanide-bridged wheel featuring a seven-coordinate Mo(iii) center.

A new cyclic molecule incorporating [MoIII(CN)7]4- has been characterized by single crystal X-ray methods, SQUID magnetometry and theoretical calculations. The wheel molecule [MoIII(CN)7]6[Ni(L)]12(H2O)6 exhibits ferromagnetic Mo-Ni coupling which did not exist for the previously reported octacyanometallate analogue [MoIV(CN)8]6[Ni(L)]12(H2O)6. These results indicate that known supramolecular architectures incorporating octacyanometallates can be used as platforms for making new molecules incorporating seven-coordinate cyanide precursors.

Slow magnetic dynamics in a family of mononuclear lanthanide complexes exhibiting the rare cubic coordination geometry.

A new family of mononuclear lanthanide complexes, where the eight coordinate lanthanide ions adopt a very rare cubic coordination geometry is reported. The Dy analogue exhibits SMM behavior with a Ueff value 95.7 K under a 0.02 T applied dc field. Ab initio calculations support the observed magnetic behavior.

Rationalizing the sign and magnitude of the magnetic coupling and anisotropy in dinuclear manganese(iii) complexes.

We have synthesised twelve manganese(iii) dinuclear complexes, 1-12, in order to understand the origin of magnetic exchange (J) between the metal centres and the magnetic anisotropy (D) of each metal ion using a combined experimental and theoretical approach. All twelve complexes contain the same bridging ligand environment of one µ-oxo and two µ-carboxylato, that helped us to probe how the structural parameters, such as bond distance, bond angle and especially Jahn-Teller dihedral angle affect the magnetic behaviour. Among the twelve complexes, we found ferromagnetic coupling for five and antiferromagnetic coupling for seven. DFT computed the J and ab initio methods computed the D parameter, and are in general agreement with the experimentally determined values. The dihedral angle between the two Jahn-Teller axes of the constituent MnIII ions are found to play a key role in determining the sign of the magnetic coupling. Magneto-structural correlations are developed by varying the Mn-O distance and the Mn-O-Mn angle to understand how the magnetic coupling changes upon these structural changes. Among the developed correlations, the Mn-O distance is found to be the most sensitive parameter that switches the sign of the magnetic coupling from negative to positive. The single-ion zero-field splitting of the MnIII centres is found to be negative for complexes 1-11 and positive for complex 12. However, the zero-field splitting of the S = 4 state for the ferromagnetic coupled dimers is found to be positive, revealing a significant contribution from the exchange anisotropy - a parameter which has long been ignored as being too small to be effective.

Understanding the Mechanism of Magnetic Relaxation in Pentanuclear {MnIVMnIII2LnIII2} Single-Molecule Magnets.

A new family of heterometallic pentanuclear complexes of formulas [MnIVMnIII2LnIII2O2(benz)4(mdea)3(NO3)2(MeOH)] (Ln = Dy (1-Dy), Tb (2-Tb), Gd (3-Gd), Eu (4-Eu), Sm (5-Sm), Nd (6-Nd), Pr (7-Pr); benz(H) = benzoic acid; mdeaH2= N-methyldiethanolamine) and [MnIVMnIII2LnIII2O2(o-tol)4(mdea)3(NO3)2(MeOH)] (Ln = Gd (8-Gd), Eu (9-Eu); o-tol(H) = o-toluic acid) have been isolated and structurally, magnetically, and theoretically characterized. dc magnetic susceptibility measurements reveal dominant antiferromagnetic magnetic interactions for each complex, except for 2-Tb and 3-Gd, which reveal an upturn in the χMT product at low temperatures. The magnetic interactions between the spin centers in the Gd derivatives, 3-Gd and 8-Gd, which display markedly different χMT vs T profiles, were found to be due to the interactions of the GdIII-GdIII ions which change from ferromagnetic (3-Gd) to antiferromagnetic (8-Gd) due to structural differences. ac magnetic susceptibility measurements reveal a nonzero out-of-phase component for 1-Dy and 7-Pr, but no maxima were observed above 2 K (Hdc = 0 Oe), which suggests single-molecule magnet (SMM) behavior. Out-of-phase signals were observed for complexes 2-Tb, 4-Eu, 8-Gd, and 9-Eu, in the presence of a static dc field (Hdc = 2000, 3000 Oe). The anisotropic nature of the lanthanide ions in the benzoate series (1-Dy, 2-Tb, 5-Sm, 6-Nd, and 7-Pr) were thoroughly investigated using ab initio methods. CASSCF calculations predict that the origin of SMM behavior in 1-Dy and 7-Pr and the applied field SMM behavior in 2-Tb does not solely originate from the single-ion anisotropy of the lanthanide ions. To fully understand the relaxation mechanism, we have employed the Lines model to fit the susceptibility data using the POLY_ANISO program, which suggests that the zero-field SMM behavior observed in complexes 1-Dy and 7-Pr is due to weak MnIII/IV-LnIII and LnIII-LnIII couplings and an unfavorable LnIII/MnIII/MnIV anisotropy. In complexes 4-Eu, 8-Gd, and 9-Eu ab initio calculations indicate that the anisotropy of the MnIII ions solely gives rise to the possibility of SMM behavior. Complex 7-Pr is a Pr(III)-containing complex that displays zero-field SMM behavior, which is rare, and our study suggests the possibility of coupling weak SOC lanthanide metal ions to anisotropic transition-metal ions to derive SMM characteristics; however, enhancing the exchange coupling in {3d-4f} complexes is still a stubborn hurdle in harnessing new generation {3d-4f} SMMs.

Lanthanide Triangles Supported by Radical Bridging Ligands.

The first examples of metallacycles containing rare earth ions bridged by radicals are reported. The molecular triangles [Ln3(hfac)6(bptz•-)3] (Ln = DyIII, YIII; hfac = 1,1,1,5,5,5-hexafluoro-2,4-pentanedionate; bptz = 3,6-bis(2-pyridyl)-1,2,4,5-tetrazine) consist of lanthanide ions bridged by bptz radical anion (bptz•-) ligands. Magnetic susceptibility measurements and CASSCF calculations performed on [Dy3(hfac)6(bptz•-)3] reveal the presence of antiferromagnetic coupling between the DyIII centers and the bptz•- ligands, with J = -6.62 cm-1.

Slow Magnetic Relaxation and Single-Molecule Toroidal Behaviour in a Family of Heptanuclear {CrIII LnIII6 } (Ln=Tb, Ho, Er) Complexes.

The synthesis, magnetic properties, and theoretical studies of three heterometallic {CrIII LnIII6 } (Ln=Tb, Ho, Er) complexes, each containing a metal topology consisting of two Ln3 triangles connected via a CrIII linker, are reported. The {CrTb6 } and {CrEr6 } analogues display slow relaxation of magnetization in a 3000 Oe static magnetic field. Single-crystal measurements reveal opening up of the hysteresis loop for {CrTb6 } and {CrHo6 } molecules at low temperatures. Ab initio calculations predict toroidal magnetic moments in the two Ln3 triangles, which are found to couple, stabilizing a con-rotating ferrotoroidal ground state in Tb and Ho examples and extend the possibility of observing toroidal behaviour in non DyIII complexes for the first time.

Effects of coordination sphere on unusually large zero field splitting and slow magnetic relaxation in trigonally symmetric molecules.

Geometric control in mononuclear complexes has come to the forefront in the field of molecular magnets due to its profound effects on relaxation pathways and blocking temperature in single molecule magnets (SMMs). Herein we report the synthesis and magnetic characterization of six trigonally symmetric, divalent Fe, Co, and Ni molecules, with the rigid geometry enforced via the use of the tris-anionic, tetradentate ligand MST (N,N',N''-[2,2',2''-nitrilotris-(ethane-2,1-diyl)]tris(2,4,6-trimethylbenzenesulfonamide)). A systematic study on the effect of converting between trigonal monopyramidal complexes, (Me4N)[M(MST)], and trigonal bipyramidal complexes, (Me4N)[M(MST)(OH2)] was conducted experimentally and computationally. It was found that (Me4N)[Ni(MST)] exhibits a very large, near record zero-field splitting parameter (D) value of -434 cm-1, owing to an extremely low lying first excited state. The trigonal monopyramidal cobalt and iron complexes exhibit slow magnetic relaxation under applied fields, resulting in barriers of 45 K and 63.9 K respectively. Coordination of a single water molecule in the open axial site of the trigonal monopyramidal complexes exerts drastic dampening effects on the D value as well as slow relaxation. Computations reveal that coordination of water rotates the D zz axis away from the C 3 axis of symmetry resulting in a smaller D value. The aquo species (Me4N)[Co(MST)(OH2)] also exhibits magnetic relaxation under an applied field, but the barrier is reduced to 9.9 K. Water coordination totally quenches the magnetic behavior in the iron complex, and reduces the D value for nickel to -185 cm-1. These results showcase the drastic effect that a small change in the coordination environment can have on magnetic behavior, as well as that trigonal monopyramidal geometry can lead to near record D values.