Multimodal nocturnal seizure detection in a residential care setting: A long-term prospective trial.

OBJECTIVE: To develop and prospectively evaluate a method of epileptic seizure detection combining heart rate and movement. METHODS: In this multicenter, in-home, prospective, video-controlled cohort study, nocturnal seizures were detected by heart rate (photoplethysmography) or movement (3-D accelerometry) in persons with epilepsy and intellectual disability. Participants with >1 monthly major seizure wore a bracelet (Nightwatch) on the upper arm at night for 2 to 3 months. Major seizures were tonic-clonic, generalized tonic >30 seconds, hyperkinetic, or others, including clusters (>30 minutes) of short myoclonic/tonic seizures. The video of all events (alarms, nurse diaries) and 10% completely screened nights were reviewed to classify major (needing an alarm), minor (needing no alarm), or no seizure. Reliability was tested by interobserver agreement. We determined device performance, compared it to a bed sensor (Emfit), and evaluated the caregivers' user experience. RESULTS: Twenty-eight of 34 admitted participants (1,826 nights, 809 major seizures) completed the study. Interobserver agreement (major/no major seizures) was 0.77 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.65-0.89). Median sensitivity per participant amounted to 86% (95% CI 77%-93%); the false-negative alarm rate was 0.03 per night (95% CI 0.01-0.05); and the positive predictive value was 49% (95% CI 33%-64%). The multimodal sensor showed a better sensitivity than the bed sensor (n = 14, median difference 58%, 95% CI 39%-80%, p < 0.001). The caregivers' questionnaire (n = 33) indicated good sensor acceptance and usability according to 28 and 27 participants, respectively. CONCLUSION: Combining heart rate and movement resulted in reliable detection of a broad range of nocturnal seizures.

Automated video-based detection of nocturnal convulsive seizures in a residential care setting.

People with epilepsy need assistance and are at risk of sudden death when having convulsive seizures (CS). Automated real-time seizure detection systems can help alert caregivers, but wearable sensors are not always tolerated. We determined algorithm settings and investigated detection performance of a video algorithm to detect CS in a residential care setting. The algorithm calculates power in the 2-6 Hz range relative to 0.5-12.5 Hz range in group velocity signals derived from video-sequence optical flow. A detection threshold was found using a training set consisting of video-electroencephalogaphy (EEG) recordings of 72 CS. A test set consisting of 24 full nights of 12 new subjects in residential care and additional recordings of 50 CS selected randomly was used to estimate performance. All data were analyzed retrospectively. The start and end of CS (generalized clonic and tonic-clonic seizures) and other seizures considered desirable to detect (long generalized tonic, hyperkinetic, and other major seizures) were annotated. The detection threshold was set to the value that obtained 97% sensitivity in the training set. Sensitivity, latency, and false detection rate (FDR) per night were calculated in the test set. A seizure was detected when the algorithm output exceeded the threshold continuously for 2 seconds. With the detection threshold determined in the training set, all CS were detected in the test set (100% sensitivity). Latency was ≤10 seconds in 78% of detections. Three/five hyperkinetic and 6/9 other major seizures were detected. Median FDR was 0.78 per night and no false detections occurred in 9/24 nights. Our algorithm could improve safety unobtrusively by automated real-time detection of CS in video registrations, with an acceptable latency and FDR. The algorithm can also detect some other motor seizures requiring assistance.

Multimodal, automated detection of nocturnal motor seizures at home: Is a reliable seizure detector feasible?

Objective: Automated seizure detection and alarming could improve quality of life and potentially prevent sudden, unexpected death in patients with severe epilepsy. As currently available systems focus on tonic-clonic seizures, we want to detect a broader range of seizure types, including tonic, hypermotor, and clusters of seizures. Methods: In this multicenter, prospective cohort study, the nonelectroencephalographic (non-EEG) signals heart rate and accelerometry were measured during the night in patients undergoing a diagnostic video-EEG examination. Based on clinical video-EEG data, seizures were classified and categorized as clinically urgent or not. Seizures included for analysis were tonic, tonic-clonic, hypermotor, and clusters of short myoclonic/tonic seizures. Features reflecting physiological changes in heart rate and movement were extracted. Detection algorithms were developed based on stepwise fulfillment of conditions during increases in either feature. A training set was used for development of algorithms, and an independent test set was used for assessing performance. Results: Ninety-five patients were included, but due to sensor failures, data from only 43 (of whom 23 patients had 86 seizures, representing 402 h of data) could be used for analysis. The algorithms yield acceptable sensitivities, especially for clinically urgent seizures (sensitivity = 71-87%), but produce high false alarm rates (2.3-5.7 per night, positive predictive value = 25-43%). There was a large variation in the number of false alarms per patient. Significance: It seems feasible to develop a detector with high sensitivity, but false alarm rates are too high for use in clinical practice. For further optimization, personalization of algorithms may be necessary.

Automatic segmentation of episodes containing epileptic clonic seizures in video sequences.

Epilepsy is a neurological disorder characterized by sudden, often unexpected transitions from normal to pathological behavioral states called epileptic seizures. Some of these seizures are accompanied by uncontrolled, often rhythmic movements of body parts when seizure activity propagates to brain areas responsible for the initiation and control of movement. The dynamics of these transitions is, in general, unknown. As a consequence, individuals have to be monitored for long periods in order to obtain sufficient data for adequate diagnosis and to plan therapeutic strategy. Some people may require long-term care in special units to allow for timely intervention in case seizures get out of control. Our goal is to present a method by which a subset of motor seizures can be detected using only remote sensing devices (i.e., not in contact with the subject) such as video cameras. These major motor seizures (MMS) consist of clonic movements and are often precursors of generalized tonic-clonic (convulsive) seizures, sometimes leading to a condition known as status epilepticus, which is an acute life-threatening event. We propose an algorithm based on optical flow, extraction of global group transformation velocities, and band-pass temporal filtering to identify occurrence of clonic movements in video sequences. We show that for a validation set of 72 prerecorded epileptic seizures in 50 people, our method is highly sensitive and specific in detecting video segments containing MMS with clonic movements.

Electroencephalographic events prior to epileptic major motor seizures.

RATIONALE: The goal of this study is to evaluate the electroencephalographic (EEG) events, prior to clonic phases of epileptic motor seizures. Analyzing video sequences we were able to detect these special phases of motor seizures, by image features. This can be used for an early detection and alerting for these events. In the study we analyzed 42 seizures. Based on collected data we compare the quantitative results from video detection of seizures with the features computed from EEG scalp recordings from about 3 minutes prior to the seizure. We analyze the non-stationary frequency spectrum of the EEG recordings and match it against our automated video detection output in order to investigate possible precursory EEG events. METHODS: Video recordings are analyzed by applying optical flow theory, reconstruction of geometrical flow invariants, low and high pass filtering, and suitable normalizations. EEG recordings are processed with use of a Gabor wavelet technique. Comparison is achieved by means of analysis of the cross-correlation function between the derivatives of the Gabor amplitudes and the measure of "seizureness" produced by our video detection algorithm. RESULTS: In the present study certain ranges of EEG frequencies were found, where electro-graphical events precede clonic phases of clinical motor seizures from 2-8 up to 30-40 seconds. These results could be used for construction of new generation of methods for automated motor seizure detection.