Testing stimulus protocols in retinal-prosthesis patients.

Retinal prostheses have demonstrated the capability to give blind patients the ability to detect motion and locate large objects. High-resolution retinal prostheses require precise activation of retinal cells to elicit a small visual phosphine that can serve as a building block to make patterns. Each electrode should activate only nearby cells, however patients receiving single electrode stimulation often report a streak-shaped phosphene rather than a focal spot. It is important to investigate stimulus paradigms that will provide better control over the spatial patterns of activation. During this study a 55 year old patient implanted with the Argus II system on August 2015 was tested with single electrode stimulation and pattern stimulation experiments. Tasks were performed using Argus II normal parameters.

Evaluation of Effects of Electrical Stimulation in the Retina with Optical Coherence Tomography.

Retinal prostheses provide the capability to blind patients to detect motion and locate large objects. To avoid activating axons of passage, which can create streak-like perceptions, long pulse stimulation can be used to bypass axons and achieve focal retinal activation. Safety is a concern because long pulses require more charge than short pulses to elicit a response from neural tissue. Future implants will require smaller electrodes to improve resolution, but increased charge density may result, which is another safety concern. We developed a method to study the effects of electrical stimulation in the retina in real time using OCT (Optical Coherence Tomography) imaging combined with micropositioning of a stimulating electrode over the retina in an animal model. When using a 250-micron diameter electrode and stimulating for 30 minutes (frequency: 333 Hz), charge density: 1.22 mC/cm2, we observed an increase in retinal thickness from 154.3 µm ± 7.04 µm to 179.67 µm ± 0.47µm, a 16.66 % ± 5.49% increase compared to baseline. The region of increased thickness extended laterally for 0.56 mm ± 0.009 mm. When stimulating with a charge density of 1.63 mC/cm2, we observed an increase in retinal thickness from 160.3 µm ± 2.05 µm to 190 µm ± 0.81µm, a 19.52 % ± 1.86% increase compared to baseline. The region of increased thickness expanded laterally for 1.27 mm ± 0.19 mm.

Improved electrode material for deep brain stimulation.

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) devices have been implanted for treatment of basic tremor, Parkinson's disease and dystonia. These devices use electrodes in contact with tissue to deliver electrical pulses to targeted cells, to elicit specific therapeutic responses. In general, the neuromodulation industry has been evolving towards smaller, less invasive electrodes. However, current electrode materials do not support small sizes without severely restricting the stimulus output. Hence, an improved electrode material will benefit present and future DBS systems. In this study, five DBS leads were modified using a cost-effective and materials-efficient process for applying an ultra-low impedance platinum-iridium alloy coating. One DBS lead was used for insertion test and four DBS leads were chronically pulsed for 12 weeks. The platinum-iridium alloy significantly improved the electrical properties of the DBS electrodes and was robust to insertion into brain and to 12 weeks of chronic pulsing.

Elastic and viscoelastic characterization of agar.

Agar is a biological polymer, frequently used in tissue engineering research; due to its consistency, controllable size, and concentration-based properties, it often serves as a representative material for actual biological tissues. In this study, nanoindentation was used to characterize both the time-independent and time-dependent response of agar samples having various concentrations (0.5%-5.0% by weight). Quasi-static indentation was performed at different loads and depths using both open- and closed-loop controls. Reduced modulus (Er) values change with agar concentration, ranging from ∼30 kPa for 0.5% samples to ∼700 kPa for 5.0% samples, which is the same modulus range as usually encountered in soft biological materials. Dynamic indentation was performed to assess the effects of load, dynamic frequency and amplitude. Storage modulus values ranged from approximately 30 to 2300 kPa depending on agar concentration. Loss modulus remained consistently less than 30 kPa at all conditions, indicating a diminished damping response in agar.

Continuous electrical stimulation decreases retinal excitability but does not alter retinal morphology.

Retinal prostheses aim to provide visual perception through electrical stimulation of the retina. Hence they have to operate between threshold charge density and maximum safe charge density. To date most studies in the retina have concentrated on understanding the threshold, while stimulation safety has predominantly been studied in structures other than the retina. Toward this end, the present study focuses on determining the effect of continuous electrical stimulation of the retina both on retinal morphology and on the electrically evoked responses in the superior colliculus in a rodent model. The results demonstrate that the retina is able to tolerate 1 h long stimulation with only minor changes evident in retinal histology when examined three to 14 days later, even at charge densities (0.68 mC cm(-2)) above the safe limit of platinum delivered at high stimulus frequency (300 Hz). However, this continuous electrical stimulation causes an elevation in the threshold of the electrically evoked response in the superior colliculus, indicating some form of adaptation to continuous stimulation.

Interphase gap decreases electrical stimulation threshold of retinal ganglion cells.

The most common electrical stimulation pulse used in retinal implants is a symmetric biphasic current pulse. Prior electrophysiological studies in peripheral nerve have shown that adding an interphase gap (IPG) between the two phases makes stimulation more efficient. We investigated the effect of IPG duration on retinal ganglion cell (RGC) electrical threshold. We used calcium imaging to measure the activity of RGCs in isolated retina in response to electrical stimulation. By varying IPG duration, we were able to examine the effect of duration on threshold. We further studied this effect by simulating RGC behavior with a Hodgkin-Huxley-type model. Our results indicate that the threshold for electrical activation of RGCs can be reduced by increasing the length of the IPG.

Finite element modeling of retinal prosthesis mechanics.

Epiretinal prostheses used to treat degenerative retina diseases apply stimulus via an electrode array fixed to the ganglion cell side of the retina. Mechanical pressure applied by these arrays to the retina, both during initial insertion and throughout chronic use, could cause sufficient retinal damage to reduce the device's effectiveness. In order to understand and minimize potential mechanical damage, we have used finite element analysis to model mechanical interactions between an electrode array and the retina in both acute and chronic loading configurations. Modeling indicates that an acute tacking force distributes stress primarily underneath the tack site and heel edge of the array, while more moderate chronic stresses are distributed more evenly underneath the array. Retinal damage in a canine model chronically implanted with a similar array occurred in correlating locations, and model predictions correlate well with benchtop eyewall compression tests. This model provides retinal prosthesis researchers with a tool to optimize the mechanical electrode array design, but the techniques used here represent a unique effort to combine a modifiable device and soft biological tissues in the same model and those techniques could be extended to other devices that come into mechanical contact with soft neural tissues.

On the thermal elevation of a 60-electrode epiretinal prosthesis for the blind.

In this paper, the thermal elevation in the human body due to the operation of a dual-unit epiretinal prosthesis to restore partial vision to the blind affected by irreversible retinal degeneration is presented. An accurate computational model of a 60-electrode device dissipating 97 mW power, currently under clinical trials is developed and positioned in a 0.25 mm resolution, heterogeneous model of the human head to resemble actual conditions of operation of the prosthesis. A novel simple finite difference scheme combining the explicit and the alternating-direction implicit (ADI) method has been developed and validated with existing methods. Simulation speed improvement up to 11 times was obtained for the the head model considered in this work with very good accuracy. Using this method, solutions of the bioheat equation were obtained for different placements of the implant. Comparison with in-vivo experimental measurements showed good agreement.

In vivo study of response threshold in retinal degenerate model at different degenerate stages.

Retinal prostheses are being developed to apply electrical stimulation to the retina in order to restore vision of individuals who suffer from diseases such as retinitis pigmentosa (RP) and aged related macular degeneration (AMD). Various electrical stimulus parameters have been extensively studied in both experimental and clinical settings. Both electrophysiological and psychophysical results have shown that outer retina disease exhibit higher stimulus threshold in one degenerate group versus the control group. Fewer studies have been conducted to investigate the change in threshold currents as a function of different degenerate stages. We propose to study the electrophysiological change in degenerate rat retinas by using an in vivo recording method. We recorded retinal-driven superior colliculus cells response in two control groups and four degenerate groups. Current pulses of seven different stimulus pulse durations were applied to the retinas to obtain strength duration curve per group. Preliminary results showed that for the postnatal (P) day 90 and 180 degenerate groups, threshold currents were not significantly different from the normal control group (P90 and P230). For P300 degenerate group, the threshold currents progressively increased. For P760 degenerate group, threshold currents were significantly elevated across all the stimulus pulse durations tested. Charge densities calculated for P760 degenerate group exceeded the safe limit of the stimulating electrode. Cell morphology in all control and degenerate groups is still under investigation for a correlation study.

Retinal prosthesis phosphene shape analysis.

A retinal prosthesis system to restore sight for the blind is under development. The system is analogous to cochlear implants, in which photoreceptor input is bypassed and replaced by direct electrical stimulation of the retinal ganglion cells. Currently, six test subjects have been implanted with a 4x4 electrode array and stimulator. We report here psychophysical clinical data examining how stimulation amplitude affects phosphene shape and repeatability on a single electrode. Phosphene shape data was quantified by a set of numerical descriptors calculated from image moments. Comparison of phosphene descriptors for a single electrode across repeated trials and amplitude levels measured the repeatability within an amplitude group. Our experimental findings show that stimulation of the retina creates repeatable percept shapes and that an increase in stimulation amplitude causes a significant change in size and shape of phosphenes.

Pathology of damaging electrical stimulation in the retina.

The goal of this study was to examine the characteristics of electrically induced retinal damage. A retinal prosthesis must be both effective and safe, but most research related to electrical stimulation of the retina has involved measures of efficacy (for example, stimulus threshold), while relatively little research has investigated the safety of electrical stimulation. In this study, a single platinum microelectrode was inserted into the vitreous cavity of normally-sighted adult Long Evans pigmented rats. In one group of animals, no contact was made between the electrode and the retina and current pulses of 0.05 (n=3) and 0.2 (n=6) microC/phase were applied. In a second group, visible contact (slight dimpling of the retina) was made between the electrode and the retina and current pulses of 0.09 (n=4) microC/phase were applied. In both cases, stimulus pulses (biphasic, cathodic first, 1 ms/phase) were applied for 1 h at 100 Hz. Also, control experiments were run with no electrical stimulation with retina contact (n=4) and with no retinal contact (n=3). After stimulation, the animal was survived for 2 weeks with ocular photography and electroretinography (ERG) to document changes. During the follow-up period, retinal changes were observed only when the electrode contacted the retina, with or without electrical stimulation. No difference was noted in ERG amplitude or latency comparing the test eye to the stimulated eye. Histological analysis was performed after sacrifice at 2 weeks. A semi-quantitative method for grading 18 features of retina/RPE/choroidal appearance was established and integer grades applied to both test and control eyes. Using this method and comparing the most severely affected area (highest grade), significant differences (p<0.05) were noted between experiments with retinal contact and without retinal contact in all features except inner nuclear layer thickness. No difference was noted within a group based on the intensity of electrical stimulus applied. The size of the affected area was significantly larger with both retinal contact and electrical stimulation compared to with retinal contact alone. We conclude that mechanical pressure alone and mechanical pressure with excessive electrical stimulation causes damage to the retina but that electrical stimulation coupled with mechanical pressure increases the area of the damage.

Effects of prolonged stimulation at the electrode-retina interface.

Prolonged electrical stimulation can lead to temporary or permanent changes in neural response. Stimulation of neurons at levels sufficient to cause overlapping zones of excitation can induce multiple effects, leading to permanent damage to neurons or temporary depression not detectable through histopathological analysis. The present study focuses on determining the effects of prolonged, continuous electrical stimulation in the retina. One hour stimulation was performed in the rat retina and electrically evoked responses in the superior colliculus were recorded before and after the continuous stimulation. Comparison of the pre and post stimulation responses indicates a depression in the excitability of the neurons.

Visual task performance in blind humans with retinal prosthetic implants.

A prototype electronic retinal prosthesis has been tested in three subjects. The system features an implanted retinal stimulator and an external system for image acquisition, processing, and telemetry. The subjects in general performed better than chance on psychophysical tests involving object detection, object counting, object discrimination, and direction of movement.

Visual and electrical evoked response recorded from subdural electrodes implanted above the visual cortex in normal dogs under two methods of anesthesia.

Sensitive methods are required to record electrical evoked potentials over the visual cortex to evaluate the efficacy and safety of a retinal prosthesis before it can be implanted on the retinal surface of patients afflicted by outer retinal diseases. This study was designed to examine subdural electrodes as a mean to evaluate cortical evoked potentials in response to light and electrical stimulation of the retina in three dogs under two methods of anesthesia-halothane and propofol. Results showed that subdural electrodes could be stabilized over the visual cortex for several (3-5) months, and that they were 6.95 times more sensitive than subdermal electrodes in recording cortical visual evoked potentials (VEPs) and 4.31 times more sensitive in recording cortical electrical evoked potentials under both methods of anesthesia. The waveforms' shape changed for each electrode in the subdural array during 6/6 (100%) and 20/38 (52%) multi-channel recording sessions under halothane and propofol, respectively. This change could point to a cortical retinotopic organization versus hierarchical organization of different cortical areas for a given retinal stimulus. In summary, subdural electrodes show promising results for recording visual and electrical evoked responses (EERs) and thus for evaluation of the retinal prosthesis.

Bioadhesives for intraocular use.

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: A safe, effective adhesive could be useful in the management of retinal holes or tears and selected complicated retinal detachments, as well as for attaching a small electronic device (retinal prosthesis) to the retina. In this study, we examined nine commercially available compounds for their suitability as intraocular adhesives. METHODS: The following materials were studied: commercial fibrin sealant, autologous fibrin, Cell-Tak, three photocurable glues, and three different polyethylene glycol hydrogels. An electronic strain gauge measured the adherence forces between different glues and the retina. The stability of hydrogels at body temperature and the impermeability of the hydrogel adhesive to dextran blue were examined. Long-term biocompatibility testing of the most promising glues in terms of adhesive force, consistency, and short-term safety (hydrogels) were done in rabbits. Funduscopy, electroretinogram, and histology of the retina were performed. RESULTS: Hydrogels had 2 to 39 times more adhesive force (measured in mN) than the other glues tested. They liquefied at body temperature after 3 days to a few months. Hydrogels were impermeable to dextran blue. One type of hydrogel proved to be nontoxic to the retina. CONCLUSIONS: Hydrogels proved to be superior for intraocular use in terms of consistency, adhesiveness, stability, impermeability, and safety.

Chronic neural stimulation with thin-film, iridium oxide electrodes.

Experiments were conducted to assess the effect of chronic stimulation on the electrical properties of the electrode-tissue system, as measured using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and cyclic voltammetry (CV). Silicon, micromachined probes with multiple iridium oxide stimulating electrodes (400-1600 micron 2) were implanted in guinea pig cortex. A 10-17 day post-operative recovery period was followed by five days of monopolar stimulation, two hours/electrode each day using biphasic, constant current stimulation (5-100 microA, 100 microseconds/phase). EIS and CV data were taken before and after stimulation. The post-stimulation impedance [at mid-range frequencies (100 Hz-100 kHz)] consistently and significantly decreased relative to prestimulation levels. Impedance magnitude increased permanently at low frequencies (< 100 Hz), correlating to a change in the charge storage capacity (the area under a cyclic voltammagram). Impedance magnitude significantly increased during the recovery period, though this increase could be mostly reversed by applying small currents. A mathematical model of the electrode-tissue system impedance was used to analyze in vivo behavior. The data and modeling results shows that applying charge to the electrode can consistently reduce the impedance of the electrode-tissue system. Analysis of explanted probes suggests that the interaction between the tissue and electrode is dependent on whether chronic pulses were applied. It is hypothesized that the interface between the tissue and metal is altered by current pulsing, resulting in a temporary impedance shift.

Long-term histological and electrophysiological results of an inactive epiretinal electrode array implantation in dogs.

PURPOSE: Short-term pattern electrical stimulation of the retina via multielectrode arrays in humans blind from photoreceptor loss has shown that ambulatory vision and limited character recognition is possible. To develop an implantable retinal prosthesis that would provide useful vision, these results need to be sustained over a prolonged period of retinal electrical stimulation. As a first step toward this goal, the biocompatibility and the feasibility of surgically implanting an electrically inactive electrode array onto the retinal surface was tested. METHODS: A 5 x 5 electrode array (25 platinum disc-shaped electrodes in a silicone matrix) was implanted onto the retinal surface using retinal tacks in each of the 4 mixed-breed sighted dogs. Color fundus photography, fluorescein angiography, electroretinography, and visual evoked potentials were obtained preoperatively, at 1-week intervals for 2 weeks postoperatively, then at 2-week intervals up to 2 months postoperatively, and thereafter at 1-month intervals. One dog was killed at 2 months after implantation and a second dog after 3 months of implantation. Histologic evaluation of the retinas was performed. The remaining two dogs continue to be followed beyond 6 months after the implantation surgery. RESULTS: No retinal detachment, infection, or uncontrolled intraocular bleeding occurred in any of the animals. Retinal tacks and the retinal array remained firmly affixed to the retina throughout the follow-up period. Hyperpigmentation of the retinal pigment epithelium was observed only around the site of retinal tack insertion. No fibrous encapsulation of the implant or intraocular inflammation was visible. A- and b-wave amplitudes of the electroretinogram were depressed at the first postoperative week testing but recovered over the ensuing 1 week and were not statistically different from the normal unoperated fellow eye throughout the postoperative period. N1 and P1 wave amplitudes of the visual evoked potentials were not significantly different from the normal fellow eyes at any of the postoperative test intervals. Fluorescein angiography showed that the entire retina including the area under the electrode array remained well perfused. Similarly, histologic evaluation revealed near total preservation of the retina underlying the electrode array. CONCLUSIONS: Implantation of an electrode array on the epiretinal side (i.e., side closest to the ganglion cell layer) is surgically feasible, with insignificant damage to the underlying retina. The platinum and silicone arrays as well as the metal tacks are biocompatible. With the success of implanting an electrically inactive device onto the retinal surface for prolonged periods, the effects of long-term retinal electrical stimulation are now ready to be tested as the next step toward developing a prototype retinal prosthesis for human use.

Pattern electrical stimulation of the human retina.

Experiments were conducted to study if electrical stimulation of the retinal surface can elicit visual sensation in individuals blind from end-stage retinitis pigmentosa (RP) or age-related macular degeneration (AMD). Under local anesthesia, different stimulating electrodes were inserted through the eyewall and positioned over the surface of the retina. Subjects' psychophysical responses to electrical stimulation were recorded. Subjects perceived simple forms in response to pattern electrical stimulation of the retina. A non-flickering perception was created with stimulating frequencies between 40 and 50 Hz. The stimulation threshold was dependent on the targeted retinal area (macular versus extramacular).

Understanding the origin of visual percepts elicited by electrical stimulation of the human retina.

BACKGROUND: The success of a retinal prosthesis for patients with outer retinal degeneration (ORD) depends on the ability to electrically stimulate retinal cells other than photoreceptors. Experiments were undertaken in human volunteers to ascertain whether electrical stimulation of cells other than photoreceptors will result in the perception of light. METHODS: In two subjects, two areas of laser damage (argon green and krypton red) were created in an eye scheduled for exenteration due to recurrent cancer near the eye. In the operating room prior to exenteration, under local anesthesia, a hand-held stimulating device was inserted via the pars plana and positioned over the damaged areas and normal retina. Subjects' psychophysical responses to electrical stimulation were recorded. RESULTS: In both subjects, electrical stimulation produced the following perceptions. Normal retina: dark oval (subject 1), dark half-moon (subject 2); krypton red laser-treated retina: small, white light (both subjects); argon green laser treated retina: thin thread (subject 1), thin hook (subject 2). Histologic evaluation of the krypton red-treated retina showed damage confined to the outer retinal layers, while the argon green-treated area evinced damage to both the outer and the inner nuclear layers. CONCLUSION: The perception produced by electrical stimulation was dependent on the retinal cells present. Electrical stimulation of the krypton red-ablated area best simulated the electrically elicited visual perceptions of our blind, ORD patients, suggesting that the site of stimulation in blind patients is the inner retinal neurons.