Relationships between radiographic alveolar bone height and probing attachment level: data from healthy post-menopausal women.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the cross-sectional and longitudinal relationships between radiographic alveolar bone height and probing attachment level in a population of healthy postmenopausal women. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The 81 patients in this report were part of a prospective estrogen replacement interventional study. All patients were in good oral health at entry and received annual oral prophylaxis as part of the study. Standard probing measurements were made with a pressure sensitive probe at 6 sites on each tooth. Vertical bitewing radiographs were digitized, and 6 linear measurements corresponding to probing-site measurements were made from the cementoenamel junction to the alveolar crest. These procedures were performed at baseline and at annual intervals for three years. Data were analyzed both by site and by patient. RESULTS: Moderately strong correlations were found between cross-sectional measurements of probing attachment height and radiographic bone height. Correlations were stronger for patient data (r=0.44-0.61) than for site data (r=0.19-0.36). No relationships were found between longitudinal changes in alveolar bone height and attachment level in either the site data (r=-0.10-0.04). or the patient data (r=-0.005-0.10). CONCLUSION: Healthy patients may experience sporadic, temporary changes in attachment level or alveolar bone height which are resolved without one affecting the other.

Alveolar bone height and postcranial bone mineral density: negative effects of cigarette smoking and parity.

BACKGROUND: Our objective was to test the association between cemento-enamel junction, alveolar-crest distance (CEJ-AC, as measured on digitized vertical bite-wing radiographs) and postcranial bone mineral density (BMD) relative to clinical, dietary, and demographic variables. METHODS: Data were collected in a cross-sectional study of 134 postmenopausal women. CEJ-AC distances were determined from digitized vertical bite-wing radiographs. Lumbar spine and proximal femur BMDs were determined from dual-energy x-ray absorptiometric scans. Correlation analysis and Student t tests were used to identify those variables most associated with CEJ-AC distance. The selected variables were modeled with a backward stepwise regression analysis, with CEJ-AC distance as the dependent variable. RESULTS: Parity (number of pregnancies to term), cigarette smoking, and the interaction of lateral spine BMD with cigarette smoking were independent predictors of CEJ-AC distance (P < or =0.05). Statistical models containing these variables accounted for 19% of the variation in CEJ-AC distances. CONCLUSIONS: CEJ-AC distance in postmenopausal women is the result of a complicated interaction of many effects, including but not limited to, parity, cigarette smoking, and skeletal BMD.

Comparison of morphological measurements extracted from digitized dental radiographs with lumbar and femoral bone mineral density measurements in postmenopausal women.

BACKGROUND: We set out to determine whether morphologic measurements extracted from digitized images of bite-wing radiographs correlated with lumbar and femoral bone mineral density (BMD) measurements in 45 postmenopausal women who had no or only mild periodontal disease (no probing depths >5 mm). METHODS: Lumbar spine and femoral BMDs were determined by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry. Vertical bite-wing radiographs were taken and digitized. Crestal and apical regions of interest (ROIs) were drawn on the digital images of the maxillary and mandibular alveolar bone on the patient's right and left sides. For each patient, a single morphologic measurement was made for each of 8 ROIs. Correlation analysis was performed to determine the strengths of the relationships between the morphologic measurements made at the 8 locations and between these morphologic measurements and BMD measurements. RESULTS: The correlations (r) between the morphologic operator (MO) measurements and lumbar spine and femoral BMDs were weak (mean r = 0.02, range = 0.32 to -0.26) and not statistically significant, with no clear trends discernible. Correlations between MO measurements made at the 8 alveolar sites were also weak (mean r = 0.05, range = 0.35 to -0.38) and not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: The MO measurements used in this study were weakly correlated with lumbar spine and femoral BMDs, with no clear trends discernible in this population of postmenopausal women with no or mild periodontal disease.

The effect of region of interest variations on morphologic operations data and gray-level values extracted from digitized dental radiographs.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the correlations among morphologic operations (MO) values and the correlations among gray-level values for regions of interest (ROIs) placed at various locations on digital images of alveolar bone for 45 patients. STUDY DESIGN: As part of a larger study, up to 7 vertical bite-wing radiographs were taken and digitized for each of 45 patients. Sets of 2 rectangular ROIs were placed on the digitized images of interdental alveolar bone at 4 locations for each patient. The ROIs (1 crestal and 1 apical) were placed between second premolars and first molars in all 4 dental quadrants. Gray-level values were measured, and MO analysis was performed on each ROI. Descriptive statistics were calculated and correlations determined. RESULTS: Paired correlations (such as apical vs crestal, left vs right, maxillary apical vs mandibular apical) of MO values were weak (r = 0.01-0.21), but corresponding correlations for gray-level values were relatively strong (r = 0. 60-0.92). CONCLUSION: MO values varied with ROI location considerably more than did gray-level values. Additionally, ROI size and shape apparently affected MO data. Accurate placement and documentation of ROIs appear to be critical considerations in analyses that use MOs.

Relationships between longitudinal changes in radiographic alveolar bone height and probing depth measurements: data from postmenopausal women.

BACKGROUND: The relationship between loss of radiographic alveolar bone height and probing attachment loss has been studied by a number of investigators, with mixed results. Recent studies have found weak correlations and have suggested that the relationship between bone loss and attachment loss is complex, perhaps because changes in bone height and attachment level are separated in time. METHODS: The 85 patients in this report were part of a prospective estrogen replacement interventional study. All patients were in good oral health at entry and received annual oral prophylaxis as part of the study. Standard probing measurements were made with a pressure-sensitive probe at 6 sites on each tooth. Vertical bite-wing radiographs were taken of each patient, radiographs were digitized, and 6 linear measurements (corresponding to probing site measurements) were made from the cemento-enamel junction to the alveolar crest. These procedures were performed at baseline and at annual intervals; this study reports results after 2 years. Data were analyzed both by individual site and by averaging identical sites from all measured teeth for each patient. RESULTS: Very weak direct relationships between change in alveolar bone height and change in attachment level were found in both the site data (r2=0.0022; P = 0.189) and the patient average data (r2=0.031; P= 0.104). CONCLUSIONS: The changes in these patients were probably due to systemic changes in bone health rather than to periodontal disease. However, the weak correlations between changes in attachment level and bone height are similar to recent studies of periodontal disease. Our results support suggestions in the literature that the link between changes in attachment and alveolar bone height is complex, perhaps because changes in the 2 tissue types are separated by a considerable time delay.

Reliability of linear alveolar bone loss measurements of mandibular posterior teeth from digitized bitewing radiographs.

Observer reliability in performing linear measurements between the cementoenamel junction and alveolar crest was determined for mandibular posterior teeth from digitized clinical bitewing radiographs acquired during recall examinations. 6 measurements (corresponding to traditional probing measurements) were made per tooth by 3 observers. Mesial and distal measurements made to the most coronal aspects of the alveolar crest were the most reliable and least biased. As was anticipated, intra-observer reliability was better than inter-observer reliability although the 3 observers of our study were able to detect a significant mean change (0.1 mm, p<0.0001) in alveolar bone height over a 1-year period for 10 patients. For our most reliable and unbiased measurements (mesial measurements to the alveolar crest), a change of 0.54 mm (90th percentile) would be required to indicate change at a site from one time to the next. Based on the reliability of our digital radiographic measurements, with the alpha error rate set at 0.05 and beta at 0.20, a difference in alveolar bone height of 0.3 mm could be detected with a patient sample size of between 13 (best case) and 54 (worst case).

Comparison of reliability of manual and computer-intensive methods for radiodensity measures of alveolar bone loss.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the reliability of radiodensity measurements made from dental radiographs with manual and a novel computer-intensive methods. METHODS: As part of a prospective study of postmenopausal women, a series of seven vertical bitewing radiographs were taken of 36 patients. One of each set of radiographs was repeated. The original and the corresponding duplicate radiographs were used in this study. Radiographs were digitized at 50 microns spatial resolution and 12-bit gray-scale resolution. For the Manual Method, original and duplicate radiographs were manually cropped to improve image homology, histogram matched and mean pixel gray-scale values determined for an alveolar bone ROI within each image. For the computer-intensive method, images were put into registration with ANALYZE software (Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MINN, USA), cropped automatically, histogram matched and color-coded on the basis of the per cent difference. Alveolar bone ROIs adjacent to clinical crowns and root surfaces whose color code indicated less than a 5% change were sampled. Method error (ME) and the coefficient of variation of method error (CVME) were calculated. RESULTS: With the Manual Method the SD between original and duplicate measures was 95.21 out of 4096 gray scale values; ME = 67.32; CVME = 3.78%. For the computer-intensive method, the corresponding values were 54.74, 38.71, and 2.29%. CONCLUSIONS: The new computer-intensive method resulted in a 40% improvement over the Manual Method in the precision of radiodensity measurements.

Three-dimensional dental imaging by spiral CT. A progress report.

OBJECTIVE: To demonstrate the feasibility of using spiral computed tomographic data for three-dimensional image acquisition, display, and segmentation of dental structures and lesions and to demonstrate the feasibility of metal artifact suppression. STUDY DESIGN: Isolated extracted teeth, a dry mandible, cadaver mandible, and cadaver head were scanned and reconstructed using spiral computed tomography data. Algorithms for metal artifact reduction including extended attenuation range and interpolation of missing projections were applied. Volumetric rendering was performed to synthesize images comparable to conventional intraoral dental radiographs. Serial examinations were obtained by spiral computed tomographic tomography, registered by surface matching, and interval change determined by three-dimensional subtraction. RESULTS: Metal artifact reduction was successful in markedly reducing the streaks and star patterns that usually accompany metallic restorations and intraoral appliances. Voxel sum images were comparable to dental radiographs. Image segmentation could successfully isolate dental structures, and simulated lesions could be detected through three-dimensional subtraction. CONCLUSION: The results demonstrate the feasibility of spiral volumetric computed tomography for quantitative study of oral hard tissues in the presence of metal restorations.

Attachment loss with postmenopausal age and smoking.

To determine whether postmenopausal bone loss and factors associated with osteoporosis affect tooth retention, we examined vertebral and proximal femoral (postcranial) bone mineral density in relation to tooth loss and attachment loss in a cross-sectional study of 135 postmenopausal women (age range 41-70 yr). Women had at least 10 teeth and no evidence of moderate or severe periodontal disease. Full-mouth attachment loss measurements were made using a pressure-sensitive probe, and bone density was determined by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. Attachment loss was correlated with tooth loss (number of remaining teeth, radiologically determined), but not with vertebral or proximal femur bone density. Multivariate analysis showed current smoking (p = 0.01), years since menopause (p = 0.02) and the interaction of age and current smoking (p < 0.01), to be statistically significant predictors of attachment loss in our study population.

A comparison of the response of storage phosphor and film radiography to small variations in X-ray exposure.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the response to small repeated variations in X-ray exposure of storage phosphor (SP) plates compared with Ektaspeed Plus dental film. METHODS: Exposure of SP plates and Ektaspeed Plus dental film was varied within a small range [8.62 microC kg-1 to 9.03 microC kg-1, (5%)]. Radiographs were digitized and SP plates read with a laser-based scanner. Nested analysis of variance, analysis of covariance, and regression analysis were used to test the relationship between exposure and the resulting signal. RESULTS: The relationship between exposure and signal for digital images of film radiographs was not significant whereas the corresponding relationship for SP images was highly significant (P < 0.001, R2 = 0.44). CONCLUSIONS: Over the narrow range of X-ray exposures studied there was a significant direct linear relationship between exposure and digital gray-scale values for SP images but not for digital images of Ektaspeed Plus films.

Comparison of linear measurements made from storage phosphor and dental radiographs.

OBJECTIVES: To compare linear measurements made from storage phosphor and dental radiographs. METHODS: Five dry hemimandibles were imaged with an 8 x 10-inch (20.3/25.4 cm) high-resolution storage phosphor plate and Ektaspeed Plus occlusal-size dental film. Optimal exposure was empirically determined for the dental films. Reductions in exposure of 50 and 75% were used for the storage phosphor. Three observers made linear measurements between end-points of lines and center-points of fiducials on clinical specimens, dental radiographs, digitized dental radiographs and storage phosphor images. Data were analysed with repeated-measures and nested analysis of variance. RESULTS: Measurements obtained from optimally exposed dental films and reduced-exposure storage phosphor images were equivalent to clinical measurements recorded from dry hemimandibles. Less than 2% of variation among measurements was attributable to the five modalities. CONCLUSION: No substantive difference was detected between linear measurements obtained from the storage phosphor or dental radiographis. Because storage phosphor images require no chemical processing, can be used at reduced exposure and are inherently digital, they are a viable alternative to dental film for making linear measurements.

Histogram-matching and histogram-flattening contrast correction methods: a comparison.

OBJECTIVES: To compare the results or two methods of histogram matching and two methods of histogram flattening for their ability to correct for contrast variations in digital dental images. METHODS: A custom-built, aluminium stepwedge with 0.1, 0.5 and 1.0 mm steps was placed over Ektaspeed films and exposed for 0.06, 0.12 and 0.25 s, respectively. Radiographs were digitized at 50 microns spatial resolution and 12-bit contrast resolution. Contrast corrections were performed using Rüttimann et al.'s algorithm (1986) for one method of matching (RM) and flattening (RF) and Castleman's algorithm (1979) for the other method of matching (CM) and flattening (CF). Mean pixel grey-scale values were determined for each step. The 0.12 s exposure was considered to be the target image exposure. Absolute differences in pixel grey-scale values between the target images and the modified images were determined. RESULTS: The median values of the absolute differences in pixel grey-scale values between the target images and the contrast corrected images were: CM = 4.3; RM = 4.1; CF = 70.2 and RF = 70.2. CONCLUSION: Castleman's and Rüttimann's matching algorithms perform equally well in correcting digital image contrast. Histogram flattening was less effective.