Adaptation of HIV-1/HIV-2 Chimeras with Defects in Genome Packaging and Viral Replication.

Frequent recombination is a hallmark of retrovirus replication. In rare cases, recombination occurs between distantly related retroviruses, generating novel viruses that may significantly impact viral evolution and public health. These recombinants may initially have substantial replication defects due to impaired interactions between proteins and/or nucleic acids from the two parental viruses. However, given the high mutation rates of retroviruses, these recombinants may be able to evolve improved compatibility of these viral elements. To test this hypothesis, we examined the adaptation of chimeras between two distantly related human pathogens: HIV-1 and HIV-2. We constructed HIV-1-based chimeras containing the HIV-2 nucleocapsid (NC) domain of Gag or the two zinc fingers of HIV-2 NC, which are critical for specific recognition of viral RNA. These chimeras exhibited significant defects in RNA genome packaging and replication kinetics in T cells. However, in some experiments, the chimeric viruses replicated with faster kinetics when repassaged, indicating that viral adaptation had occurred. Sequence analysis revealed the acquisition of a single amino acid substitution, S18L, in the first zinc finger of HIV-2 NC. This substitution, which represents a switch from a conserved HIV-2 residue to a conserved HIV-1 residue at this position, partially rescued RNA packaging and replication kinetics. Further analysis revealed that the combination of two substitutions in HIV-2 NC, W10F and S18L, almost completely restored RNA packaging and replication kinetics. Our study demonstrates that chimeras of distantly related retroviruses can adapt and significantly enhance their replication by acquiring a single substitution. IMPORTANCE Novel retroviruses can emerge from recombination between distantly related retroviruses. Most notably, HIV-1 originated from zoonotic transmission of a novel recombinant (SIVcpz) into humans. Newly generated recombinants may initially have significant replication defects due to impaired interactions between viral proteins and/or nucleic acids, such as between cis- and trans-acting elements from the two parental viruses. However, provided that the recombinants retain some ability to replicate, they may be able to adapt and repair the defective interactions. Here, we used HIV-1 and HIV-2 Gag chimeras as a model system for studying the adaptation of recombinant viruses. We found that only two substitutions in the HIV-2 NC domain, W10F and S18L, were required to almost fully restore RNA genome packaging and replication kinetics. These results illustrate the extremely flexible nature of retroviruses and highlight the possible emergence of novel recombinants in the future that could pose a significant threat to public health.

Unpaired Guanosines in the 5' Untranslated Region of HIV-1 RNA Act Synergistically To Mediate Genome Packaging.

The viral protein Gag selects full-length HIV-1 RNA from a large pool of mRNAs as virion genome during virus assembly. Currently, the precise mechanism that mediates the genome selection is not understood. Previous studies have identified several sites in the 5' untranslated region (5' UTR) of HIV-1 RNA that are bound by nucleocapsid (NC) protein, which is derived from Gag during virus maturation. However, whether these NC binding sites direct HIV-1 RNA genome packaging has not been fully investigated. In this report, we examined the roles of single-stranded exposed guanosines at NC binding sites in RNA genome packaging using stable cell lines expressing competing wild-type and mutant HIV-1 RNAs. Mutant RNA packaging efficiencies were determined by comparing their prevalences in cytoplasmic RNA and in virion RNA. We observed that multiple NC binding sites affected RNA packaging; of the sites tested, those located within stem-loop 1 of the 5' UTR had the most significant effects. These sites were previously reported as the primary NC binding sites by using a chemical probe reverse-footprinting assay and as the major Gag binding sites by using an in vitro assay. Of the mutants tested in this report, substituting 3 to 4 guanosines resulted in <2-fold defects in packaging. However, when mutations at different NC binding sites were combined, severe defects were observed. Furthermore, combining the mutations resulted in synergistic defects in RNA packaging, suggesting redundancy in Gag-RNA interactions and a requirement for multiple Gag binding on viral RNA during HIV-1 genome encapsidation.IMPORTANCE HIV-1 must package its RNA genome during virus assembly to generate infectious viruses. To better understand how HIV-1 packages its RNA genome, we examined the roles of RNA elements identified as binding sites for NC, a Gag-derived RNA-binding protein. Our results demonstrate that binding sites within stem-loop 1 of the 5' untranslated region play important roles in genome packaging. Although mutating one or two NC-binding sites caused only mild defects in packaging, mutating multiple sites resulted in severe defects in genome encapsidation, indicating that unpaired guanosines act synergistically to promote packaging. Our results suggest that Gag-RNA interactions occur at multiple RNA sites during genome packaging; furthermore, there are functionally redundant binding sites in viral RNA.