Ambiguous melanocytic lesions: A retrospective cohort study of incidence and outcome of melanocytic tumor of uncertain malignant potential (MELTUMP) and superficial atypical melanocytic proliferation of uncertain significance (SAMPUS) in the Netherlands.

BACKGROUND: Melanocytic tumor of uncertain malignant potential (MELTUMP) and superficial atypical melanocytic proliferation of uncertain significance (SAMPUS) are descriptive and provisional terms for melanocytic tumors with ambiguous histopathological features that are not easily classified as either benign or malignant. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the incidence and clinical outcome of MELTUMP and SAMPUS in the Netherlands. METHODS: In this retrospective cohort study, we reviewed all diagnoses of MELTUMP and SAMPUS from the Dutch Nationwide Pathology Databank from 1991 to October 1, 2021. Clinical outcome was studied for cases diagnosed until October 1, 2018. RESULTS: A total of 1685 MELTUMP and 1957 SAMPUS were identified with an annual incidence of 150 to 300 cases. Metastatic behavior was seen in 0.7% of all initially diagnosed MELTUMP. All SAMPUS remained free of metastases. LIMITATIONS: Reassessment of pathology slides and confirmation of clonality between primary and metastatic lesions remained outside the scope of this study. CONCLUSION: Despite the 'uncertainty' in the nomenclature, our results demonstrate a low malignant potential for MELTUMP and no malignant potential for SAMPUS. We emphasize the importance of consultation for ambiguous melanocytic lesions and to limit the MELTUMP/SAMPUS terminology to legitimately uncertain or unclassifiable cases.

Characterization of multiple diagnostic terms in melanocytic skin lesion pathology reports.

BACKGROUND: Histopathologically ambiguous melanocytic lesions lead some pathologists to list multiple diagnostic considerations in the pathology report. The frequency and circumstance of multiple diagnostic considerations remain poorly characterized. METHODS: Two hundred and forty skin biopsy samples were interpreted by 187 pathologists (8976 independent diagnoses) and classified according to a diagnostic/treatment stratification (MPATH-Dx). RESULTS: Multiple diagnoses in different MPATH-Dx classes were used in n = 1320 (14.7%) interpretations, with 97% of pathologists and 91% of cases having at least one such interpretation. Multiple diagnoses were more common for intermediate risk lesions and are associated with greater subjective difficulty and lower confidence. We estimate that 6% of pathology reports for melanocytic lesions in the United States contain two diagnoses of different MPATH-Dx prognostic classes, and 2% of cases are given two diagnoses with significant treatment implications. CONCLUSIONS: Difficult melanocytic diagnoses in skin may necessitate multiple diagnostic considerations; however, as patients increasingly access their health records and retrieve pathology reports (as mandated by US law), uncertainty should be expressed unambiguously.

ESP, EORTC, and EURACAN Expert Opinion: practical recommendations for the pathological diagnosis and clinical management of intermediate melanocytic tumors and rare related melanoma variants.

The recent WHO classification of skin tumors has underscored the importance of acknowledging intermediate grade melanocytic proliferations. A multistep acquisition of oncogenic events drives the progressive transformation of nevi into melanomas. The various pathways described are modulated by the initial oncogenic drivers that define the common, blue, and Spitz nevi groups. Intermediate lesions are most often the result of a clonal evolution within such nevi. Based on this established classification, we have suggested for each pathway a practical diagnostic approach, benefiting from the recently developed molecular tools, both in the setting of general pathology labs and expert centers. Moreover, recommendations regarding the re-excision and clinical follow-up are given to support decision-making in multidisciplinary tumor boards.

Expanding spectrum of "spitzoid" lesions: a small series of 4 cases with MAP2K1 mutations.

The molecular background of a significant proportion of spitzoid neoplasms is still unknown. Recently, activating mutations in MAP2K1 have been described in a few spitzoid lesions, but not in benign Spitz nevi. We report four cases of melanocytic tumors with spitzoid features in which a MAP2K1 mutation was detected. The lesions did not show a single distinct phenotype and ranged from benign to malignant. Two cases resembled desmoplastic Spitz nevi. Based on the combination of morphological, immunohistochemical, and molecular findings, one case was classified as benign, one as probably benign, possibly intermediate low-grade (MELTUMP-melanocytic tumor of unknown malignant potential), one case was classified as intermediate (MELTUMP), and one case was considered a superficial spreading melanoma with spitzoid features. Based on this, we conclude that MAP2K1 mutations can indicate a spitzoid genetic signature and can be found in both benign and malignant spitzoid neoplasms.

5-Hydroxymethylcytosine is a nuclear biomarker to assess biological potential in histologically ambiguous heavily pigmented melanocytic neoplasms.

BACKGROUND: 5-Hydroxymethylcytosine (5-hmC) is an epigenetic marker detectable through immunohistochemistry (IHC) that has been shown to distinguish benign nevi from melanoma with high sensitivity and specificity. The purpose of the study was to explore its diagnostic utility in a subset of histologically challenging, heavily pigmented cutaneous melanocytic neoplasms. METHODS: 5-hmC IHC was performed on 54 heavily pigmented melanocytic tumors. Semi-quantitative analysis of immunoreactivity was correlated with clinical, pathologic and follow-up data. RESULTS: Benign melanocytic neoplasms (4 of 4 blue nevi with epithelioid change; 12 of 12 combined nevi; 5 of 5 deep penetrating nevi, DPN) exhibited strong 5-hmC nuclear reactivity. Eight heavily pigmented blue nevus-like melanomas and 7 of 8 pigmented epithelioid melanocytomas (PEM) showed significant 5-hmC loss. Five of 7 atypical DPN cases and 8 of 10 melanocytic tumors of uncertain malignant potential (MELTUMP) showed low to intermediate 5-hmC immunoreactivity. These differences were statistically significant (P-value <.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Loss of 5-hmC may be helpful in differentiating benign, diagnostically challenging, heavily pigmented melanocytic tumors from those with malignant potential. The intermediate to low 5-hmC immunoreactivity in atypical DPNs, PEMs and so-called MELTUMP categories further underscores the need to consider these neoplasms as having some potential for lethal biological behavior.

The plexiform spindle cell nevus nevi and atypical variants: report of 128 cases.

The plexiform spindle cell nevus (PLXSCN) is a distinct melanocytic lesion that often provokes concern for melanoma. We describe the features of 119 typical PLXSCNs and 9 atypical/high-grade lesions. Histologically, all cases had a fascicular plexiform architecture and were composed of predominately spindled cells. The 6 atypical plexiform spindle cell tumors (PLXSCTs) exhibited features such as greater mitotic activity, increased cellularity/nodular confluence, and more concerning cytological atypia. Three high-grade tumors (perhaps evolving plexiform spindle cell melanomas) had additional alarming clinical or histologic characteristics, such as patient age greater than 40 years, greater degree of cellularity, higher degree of cytological atypia, mitotic rate greater than 3/mm(2), regional lymph node metastases, and greater than 1 positive sentinel lymph node. Follow-up data were available for 18 typical PLXSCNs: all patients were without tumor recurrence or death in a mean follow-up period of 3.9 years (range, 1 month to 10 years). One atypical PLXSCT and 3 high-grade lesions had follow-up information: the atypical PLXSCT had sentinel lymph node involvement, and the patient was alive without recurrent disease at 1-year follow-up; 2 of the 3 high-grade lesions were positive for lymph node involvement, and all 3 patients were alive with 2-, 4-, and 0.8-year follow-up periods. All PLXSCTs should be completely excised with clear margins, and high-grade or potentially malignant lesions may require management as melanoma.