Origin and elaboration of a major evolutionary transition in individuality.

Obligate endosymbiosis, in which distantly related species integrate to form a single replicating individual, represents a major evolutionary transition in individuality1-3. Although such transitions are thought to increase biological complexity1,2,4-6, the evolutionary and developmental steps that lead to integration remain poorly understood. Here we show that obligate endosymbiosis between the bacteria Blochmannia and the hyperdiverse ant tribe Camponotini7-11 originated and also elaborated through radical alterations in embryonic development, as compared to other insects. The Hox genes Abdominal A (abdA) and Ultrabithorax (Ubx)-which, in arthropods, normally function to differentiate abdominal and thoracic segments after they form-were rewired to also regulate germline genes early in development. Consequently, the mRNAs and proteins of these Hox genes are expressed maternally and colocalize at a subcellular level with those of germline genes in the germplasm and three novel locations in the freshly laid egg. Blochmannia bacteria then selectively regulate these mRNAs and proteins to make each of these four locations functionally distinct, creating a system of coordinates in the embryo in which each location performs a different function to integrate Blochmannia into the Camponotini. Finally, we show that the capacity to localize mRNAs and proteins to new locations in the embryo evolved before obligate endosymbiosis and was subsequently co-opted by Blochmannia and Camponotini. This pre-existing molecular capacity converged with a pre-existing ecological mutualism12,13 to facilitate both the horizontal transfer10 and developmental integration of Blochmannia into Camponotini. Therefore, the convergence of pre-existing molecular capacities and ecological interactions-as well as the rewiring of highly conserved gene networks-may be a general feature that facilitates the origin and elaboration of major transitions in individuality.

In situ hybridization on ant ovaries and embryos.

The detection of transcript distribution throughout a fixed tissue is a major step in studying the transcriptional activity of target genes and their function. In situ hybridization specifically detects the spatial distribution of RNA transcripts using an antisense RNA probe. This protocol describes the preparation of digoxigenin-labeled antisense RNA probes and their hybridization to complementary mRNA sequences; expression can then be localized using an antibody against digoxigenin conjugated to a chromogenic enzyme. In ants, this method can be applied to visualize cell populations of interest among other populations in a tissue, such as insect ovaries, or in the whole organism, such as insect embryos. Specific markers (e.g., genes known to be expressed in particular clusters of cells) can be cloned and used as probes to study the distribution and development of germline cells (e.g., nanos, vasa), neurons (repo), or limb structures (e.g., distal-less). Various markers might also allow the study of oogenesis (nanos, par-1, oskar), segmentation in the embryo (e.g., engrailed, wingless), or other developmental processes.

Sex mosaics in a male dimorphic ant Cardiocondyla kagutsuchi.

Gynandromorphy, or the development of organisms with a combination of male and female morphological features, is common in Hymenoptera. The underlying mechanism is likely associated with the sex-determination system, and studying this phenomenon should lead to a deeper understanding of both embryonic development and sex determination. The reproductive capabilities of gynandromorphs (hereafter, sex mosaics) remain unclear. We studied gynandromorphy in the Malaysian ant Cardiocondyla kagutsuchi, which has sex mosaics of queens (gynandromorphs; mosaic of queens and winged male) and workers (ergatandromorphs; mosaic of worker and wingless ergatoid male). These sex mosaics were classified into seven morphological categories. Most individuals had more male than female body areas. Behavioral observations revealed that sex mosaics behave more in accordance with the "sex" of their brain than that of the reproductive organs (gaster). Relative DNA quantities showed that both female and male regions contained haploid and diploid nuclei, irrespective of their phenotypic appearance, indicating that external appearance did not reflect internal tissues. Nearly one third of the adults were sex mosaics and they were not infected with Wolbachia. Our results suggest that the production of sex mosaics in this species does not pose a substantial cost to colonies and that the underlying causes are therefore not strongly selected against.

Reproductive constraint is a developmental mechanism that maintains social harmony in advanced ant societies.

A hallmark of eusociality in ants is the reproductive division of labor between queens and workers. Yet, nothing is known about the molecular mechanisms underlying reproduction in this group. We therefore compared the developmental genetic capacity of queens and workers to reproduce in several eusocially advanced species from the two largest subfamilies of ants, the Myrmicinae and Formicinae. In flies, the asymmetric localization of maternally encoded determinants (mRNAs and proteins) during oogenesis establishes oocyte polarity and subsequently ensures proper embryonic development. Vasa and nanos, two key maternal determinants, are properly localized in the posterior of queen oocytes, but their localization is impaired in those of the workers. This mislocalization leads to severe embryonic defects in worker progeny, and therefore, represents a constraint on worker reproduction that we call 'reproductive constraint.' We show that reproductive constraint is phylogenetically widespread, and is at high levels in most species tested. Reproductive constraint can simultaneously reduce or eliminate the workers' ability to produce viable eggs for reproduction, while preserving their ability to produce trophic eggs for nutrition, and thus, may have been the basis for the evolutionary retention of worker ovaries in the majority of ants. We propose that high levels of reproductive constraint has most likely evolved as a consequence of selection at the colony level to reduce or eliminate any potential conflict over worker reproduction, therefore maintaining harmony and colony efficiency in advanced ant societies.

Expression of abdominal-A homeotic gene in ants with different abdominal morphologies.

In most insect groups, the Hox gene abdominal-A specifies the development of consecutive monotonous anterior abdominal segments. In contrast, the ant family shows pronounced differentiation of the anterior abdominal segments: the first is fused to the thoracic segments, the second, the petiole, is a specialised segment in all ants and the third, the post-petiole, can either take the appearance of a gastric segment (as in the Dolichoderinae) or of a petiole-like segment, (as in the Myrmicinae). Changes in the regulation of the abdominal-A gene are suspected to be instrumental in this morphological differentiation. Previous work has shown that the genomic coding sequences of the abdominal-A gene is nearly identical between all ant subfamilies. Therefore any evolutionary change within the ant family in the developmental activity of abdominal-A is most likely due to a change in gene expression than to a change in the activity of the Abdominal-A protein. Here I present the embryonic expression of the abdominal-A gene in two ant species with different abdominal morphologies. I find that by the late-germ band stage, abdominal-A transcripts are detected in a similar pattern in both species whereas the early patterning of abdominal-A is distinctly different between the two species.

Evolution of the gene network underlying wing polyphenism in ants.

Wing polyphenism in ants evolved once, 125 million years ago, and has been a key to their amazing evolutionary success. We characterized the expression of several genes within the network underlying the wing primordia of reproductive (winged) and sterile (wingless) ant castes. We show that the expression of several genes within the network is conserved in the winged castes of four ant species, whereas points of interruption within the network in the wingless castes are evolutionarily labile. The simultaneous evolutionary lability and conservation of the network underlying wing development in ants may have played an important role in the morphological diversification of this group and may be a general feature of polyphenic development and evolution in plants and animals.