A review of the use of biological mesh products in modern UK surgical practice: a religious and cultural perspective.

INTRODUCTION: The UK is an increasingly multicultural society. This change coincides with an increasing use of animal products in medicine and surgery and a change in the UK law of consent. The refusal of Jehovah's Witnesses to accept blood products is well known, but the use of animal products in surgery is a neglected topic. As society becomes more diverse and medicine becomes ever more advanced, there is increasing potential for a mismatch between what is medically possible and what is acceptable from a religious perspective. METHODS: Surgical products were identified by searching the literature and contacting manufacturing companies. Literature was identified by using PubMed and OVID (MEDLINE). Religious views were established by contacting national bodies for each group. FINDINGS: The views of common UK religious groups and the constituent parts of biological meshes are summarised in tables intended to be used as a reference during clinical practice. On an elective basis, the Islamic, Hindu. Sikh and Jain leaders contacted had strong views on avoiding animal derived products. The Christian and Jewish leaders contacted did not. All religious leaders contacted accepted the use of mesh derived from human tissue. All products, including those of porcine and bovine origin, were acceptable to all leaders contacted if the procedure was performed to save life. The highlighting of this issue should prompt earlier consideration and discussion in the surgical planning and the consenting process with all final decisions taken by both the surgeon and the individual patient.

The impact of conflict of interest in abdominal wall reconstruction with acellular dermal matrix.

INTRODUCTION: Conflict of interest (COI) and disclosure of financial relationships have received increased attention recently owing in part to the passage of the Physician Payments Sunshine Act, which requires manufacturers of drugs, medical devices, and biological to record payments to physicians and health care systems. The impact of financial relationships with industry sponsorship and COI reporting on surgical outcomes of abdominal wall reconstruction with acellular dermal matrices (ADMs) has not been previously explored. METHODS: A systematic review of the literature for studies that evaluated surgical outcomes in abdominal wall reconstruction using ADM was conducted. The level of evidence of these studies was evaluated; and data concerning the type of industry, government, or national society sponsorship, primary outcome, complications, and statistical results were collected. The overall favorability of the study with respect to ADM use was systematically assessed. Comparisons between type of sponsorship and significant results were analyzed using the Pearson χ2 test. RESULTS: A total of 204 studies were identified, of which 124 fulfilled our inclusion criteria. Sixty-four (52%) studies had a disclosure statement present. Conflict of interest was reported in 39 (61%) of these studies. Taken collectively, studies that report no COI are more likely to be unfunded (P<0.001). Studies with a reported COI are more likely to report a favorable outcome with respect to infection (P<0.01), wound complications (P<0.01), and overall morbidity (P<0.07) and mortality (P<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Industry sponsorship and COI are common in abdominal wall reconstruction studies with ADM. Studies authored by groups disclosing an industry conflict that report clinical outcomes are significantly associated with reporting lower postoperative complications, and consequently describing positive research findings.

Time sparing and effective procedure for dural closure in the posterior fossa using a vicryl mesh (Ethisorb®) / Cierre de duramadre en cirugía de fosa posterior con una malla de vicryl (Ethisorb®): un procedimiento simple y efectivo

Introduction. Dural defects and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks are a common problem following posterior fossa surgery. The management includes either nonoperative management (e.g. external lumbar drainage) or surgical re-exploration. Objectives. We present our surgical, clinical and histopathological experience of dural closure in the posterior fossa. In order to avoid CSF leaks we developed a simple but effective and time-sparing method using a well-cut sheet of a vicryl-poly-pdioxanone mesh (Ethisorb®) covering the whole defect of the craniectomy. Additional fibrin glue or sealant is not necessary. Special attention was focused upon the frequency of postoperative complications, in particular infection rate and CSF leaks. Patients. 85 patients were treated with vicryl mesh as dural substitute after posterior fossa surgery due to distinct pathologies. An illustrative case is presented. Results. In none of the patients a postoperative infection was observed. Four patients presented postoperative CSF leakage and were treated by percutaneous lumbar drainage. Three of the patients improved completely, requiring no additional treatment. Only in one case defect covered by a vicryl mesh, a surgical reexploration became necessary. Conclusion. We consider the vicryl mesh (Ethisorb®) as an ideal dural substitute especially for the dural closure of the posterior fossa (AU)

Introducción. Los defectos en el cierre de duramadre y por consiguiente fístulas de líquido cefalorraquídeo son comunes en cirugía de fosa posterior. El tratamiento incluye manejo conservador o no quirúrgico como drenaje lumbar externo de líquido cefalorraquídeo, cuando éstas medidas fallan se requiere de una nueva cirugía. Objetivos. Con el propósito de evitar fístulas de líquido cefalorraquídeo en cirugía de fosa posterior desarrollamos un método simple, pero efectivo, que permite ahorrar tiempo quirúrgico utilizando una malla de viyril-poly-p-dioxanone (Ethisorb®) para cubrir por completo el defecto de la craniectomía. No se requiere del uso adicional de adhesivo de fibrina. Nuestra experiencia clínica, quirúrgica y hallazgos histopatológicos con ésta técnica de cierre dural se discuten en el presente artículo así como las complicaciones, en particular infección y presencia de fístulas de líquido cefalorraquídeo. Pacientes. En 85 pacientes sometidos a cirugía de fosa posterior debida a diferentes patologías, se utilizó una malla de vicryl (Ethisorb®) como sustituto de duramadre. Se presenta un caso que ilustra nuestra técnica. Resultados. En ninguno de los casos se presentó infección postoperatoria. Cuatro casos presentaron fístula de líquido cefalorraquídeo y fueron tratados con drenaje lumbar externo; tres pacientes mejoraron por completo sin requerir otras medidas. Sólo en un caso se requirió de exploración quirúrgica. Conclusiones. De acuerdo con los resultados y complicaciones, consideramos que la malla de vicryl (Ethisorb®) es un sustituto de duramadre ideal, en particular para cirugías de fosa posterior (AU)