Challenges in congenital syphilis surveillance: how are congenital syphilis investigations classified?

BACKGROUND: Congenital syphilis is a serious, preventable, and nationally notifiable disease. Despite the existence of a surveillance case definition, congenital syphilis is sometimes classified differently using an algorithm on the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's case reporting form. METHODS: We reviewed Louisiana's congenital syphilis electronic reporting system for investigations of infants born from January 2010 to October 2011, abstracted data required for classification, and applied the surveillance definition and the algorithm. We calculated the sensitivities and specificities of the algorithm and Louisiana's classification using the surveillance definition as the surveillance gold standard. RESULTS: Among 349 congenital syphilis investigations, the surveillance definition identified 62 cases. The algorithm had a sensitivity of 91.9% and a specificity of 64.1%. Louisiana's classification had a sensitivity of 50% and a specificity of 91.3% compared with the surveillance definition. CONCLUSIONS: The differences between the algorithm and the surveillance definition led to misclassification of congenital syphilis cases. The algorithm should match the surveillance definition. Other state and local health departments should assure that their reported cases meet the surveillance definition.

[Syphilis. Clinical aspects of Treponema pallidum infection]. / Syphilis. Klinik der Treponema-pallidum-Infektion.

Syphilis is a sexually transmitted infection by Treponema pallidum. Without antibiotic treatment syphilis lasts for several decades and may develop up to 4 different clinical stages. Usually, the disease begins with a distinct painless and indurated ulcer at the contact site: the primary chancre. An indolent regional lymph node swelling is usually associated with the syphilitic chancre. After spontaneous healing of the primary lesion and several weeks of latency, the clinical symptoms of secondary syphilis occur. Treponema pallidum bacteremia leads to common symptoms like fever and malaise, but also to a generalized lymphadenopathy, and a broad variety of lesions of the skin and mucosal membranes. Non-pruritic transient exanthems often involving palms and soles, condylomata lata, and a specific angina with mucous patches of the oral cavity are prominent signs. After several relapses, which are characterized by a decreasing intensity of clinical symptoms, secondary syphilis then resolves spontaneously. A second period of latency follows, lasting 3-12 years. Then the outcome of untreated syphilis becomes apparent: spontaneous healing by elimination/inactivation of the spirochetes (75%) or transition to tertiary syphilis (25%). Two kinds of granulomatous skin reactions are typical for tertiary syphilis: superficial nodular syphilids and gummas. The bones, as well as the cardiovascular and central nervous system, may also be involved. Finally, metasyphilis with severe and sometimes lethal neurological symptoms (tabes dorsalis, progressive paralysis) occurs 10 to 30 years after primary infection. Except for irreversible tissue destruction which occurs prior to therapy, all stages of syphilis can be cured completely.

Problems in physician's classification and reporting of congenital syphilis.

The diagnosis of congenital syphilis (CS) in newborns can only be made through a review of the mothers' testing and treatment history and through the infants' clinical and laboratory findings. We describe difficulties in the classification of CS by physicians and the health department during a recent syphilis epidemic. The records of infants identified as potential cases of CS by laboratory testing, discharge diagnosis, or health department records were reviewed by epidemiologists. The reasons for concordance and discordance in classification between the physician and the epidemiologist were determined. Congenital syphilis was identified in 126 infants. Seventeen cases were discordant and 12 cases concordant but the physician's classification was for incorrect reasons. Misclassification occurred because physicians lacked data known to the health department (n=7), health departments lacked data known to the physician (n=1), and physicians misinterpreted the case definition for CS (n=21). Suggestions for improving the diagnosis and reporting of CS are included.

Problems in the current case definitions of congenital syphilis.

During the course of a population-based epidemiologic study of congenital syphilis, we found discrepancies and problems of validity in the case definitions of congenital syphilis of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and other experts. We analyzed these problems and determined their impact on case classification in our study. The most important problem that we found was the case definitions' lack of a valid scientific basis for the classification of symptom-free infants born to mothers who have been treated for syphilis but have uncertain infection status (286 infants in our study). The classification of these infants is based on diagnostic tests whose sensitivity and specificity are unknown. In our study, we found that results of some tests were rarely positive and that values for others were similar to those in uninfected infants. We believe that symptom-free infants of treated mothers of uncertain infection status should be classified as cases, pending the development of better diagnostic tests for congenital syphilis. The economic impact of treating these infants can be lessened by obtaining fewer diagnostic tests and by use of one injection of penicillin rather than a 10- to 14-day course, an approach suggested by a literature review. Use of infants' diagnostic tests to classify any other group of symptom-free infants does not seem appropriate, even though this is often recommended.

The cost of a preventable disease: estimated U.S. national medical expenditures for congenital syphilis, 1990.

Reported cases of congenital syphilis have increased rapidly in recent years. The purpose of this study was to estimate first-year medical care expenditures among 1990 incident cases of infants diagnosed with congenital syphilis. The authors used a synthetic estimation model to calculate expenditures for congenital syphilis as the number of treated cases multiplied by cost per case. The number of cases was derived from surveillance data adjusted for underreporting and presumptive (false-positive) treatment. Cost per case was based on expected hospital and physician charges applied to case treatment protocols appropriate to case severity. Base-case estimated first-year medical expenditure for 1990 treated cases (N = 4,400) in 1990 was +12.5 million. In sensitivity analysis, estimates ranged from +6.2 million to +47 million. Substantial reduction in congenital syphilis treatment costs could be achieved through targeted public health interventions consisting of prenatal maternal screening and contact tracing of males testing positive for syphilis. Physicians should be aggressive in presumptive treatment of newborns, since this usually prevents future disability but represents a small portion of total national expenditure for congenital syphilis. More precise data on severe cases resulting in long-term disability are needed to make reliable cost estimates.

Manifestaciones sifiliticas en ninos de madres con serologia positiva, Siete casos, Instituto de Enfermedades Venereas y Centro de Salud De Cundinamarca / Syphilitic manifestations in children from mothers with positive serologic tests, Seven cases, Instituto de Enfermedades Venereas y Centro de Salud de Cundinamarca

Este estudio se llevo a cabo fundamentalmente en el Instituto de Enfermedades Venereas, el Centro de Salud de Cundinamarca y en el Hospital San Jose durante el periodo de Enero a Diciembre de 1985, ahi se recogio la informacion estadistica, tomando una muestra de 16 mujeres en periodo gestacional de 2 meses, de un universo infinito; con serologia positiva, a las cuales se les realizao un seguimiento sobre el curso del embarazo hasta el parto, para conocer las manifestaciones clinicas y serologicas del recien nacido. Durante este seguimiento se dio instruccion sobre topicos encaminados a disminuir o eliminar los facatores de riesgo de contraer nuevamente la sifilis. Teniendo en cuenta el analisis de los datos se establecio que una de las madres tuvo un aborto provocado y en dos de ellas se obtuvieron sendos recien nacidos aparentemente normales, pero con serologia positiva, y en las tres restantes los recien nacidos acusaron serologias positivas mas aumentadas que las de las madres respectivas y con manifestaciones claramente sifiliticas como: hepatoesplenomegalia, paladar hendido, erupciones papulo ampollosa en palmas y plantas e ictericia sin incompatibilidad de Rh. Tambien se encontro un recien nacido con fascie mongoloide sin antecedentes familiares. Entre los factores de riesgo se pudo comprobar que influyen los aspectos socioeconomicos y culturales de las encuestadas en la adquisicion de esta enfermedad..