Molecular determinants of TRAF6 binding specificity suggest that native interaction partners are not optimized for affinity.

TRAF6 is an adaptor protein involved in signaling pathways that are essential for development and the immune system. It participates in many protein-protein interactions, some of which are mediated by the C-terminal MATH domain, which binds to short peptide segments containing the motif PxExx[FYWHDE], where x is any amino acid. Blocking MATH domain interactions is associated with favorable effects in various disease models. To better define TRAF6 MATH domain binding preferences, we screened a combinatorial library using bacterial cell-surface peptide display. We identified 236 of the best TRAF6-interacting peptides and a set of 1,200 peptides that match the sequence PxE but do not bind TRAF6 MATH. The peptides that were most enriched in the screen bound TRAF6 tighter than previously measured native peptides. To better understand the structural basis for TRAF6 interaction preferences, we built all-atom structural models of the MATH domain in complex with high-affinity binders and nonbinders identified in the screen. We identified favorable interactions for motif features in binders as well as negative design elements distributed across the motif that can disfavor or preclude binding. Searching the human proteome revealed that the most biologically relevant TRAF6 motif matches occupy a different sequence space from the best hits discovered in combinatorial library screening, suggesting that native interactions are not optimized for affinity. Our experimentally determined binding preferences and structural models support the design of peptide-based interaction inhibitors with higher affinities than endogenous TRAF6 ligands.

The ER Chaperones BiP and Grp94 Regulate the Formation of Insulin-Like Growth Factor 2 (IGF2) Oligomers.

While cytosolic Hsp90 chaperones have been extensively studied, less is known about how the ER Hsp90 paralog Grp94 recognizes clients and influences client folding. Here, we examine how Grp94 and the ER Hsp70 paralog, BiP, influence the folding of insulin-like growth factor 2 (IGF2), an established client protein of Grp94. ProIGF2 is composed of a disulfide-bonded insulin-like hormone and a C-terminal E-peptide that has sequence characteristics of an intrinsically disordered region. BiP and Grp94 have a minimal influence on folding whereby both chaperones slow proIGF2 folding and do not substantially alter the disulfide-bonded folding intermediates, suggesting that BiP and Grp94 may have an additional influence unrelated to proIGF2 folding. Indeed, we made the unexpected discovery that the E-peptide region allows proIGF2 to form dynamic oligomers. ProIGF2 oligomers can transition from a dynamic state that is capable of exchanging monomers to an irreversibly aggregated state, providing a plausible role for BiP and Grp94 in regulating proIGF2 oligomerization. In contrast to the modest influence on folding, BiP and Grp94 have a stronger influence on proIGF2 oligomerization and these chaperones exert counteracting effects. BiP suppresses proIGF2 oligomerization while Grp94 can enhance proIGF2 oligomerization in a nucleotide-dependent manner. We propose that BiP and Grp94 regulate the assembly and dynamic behavior of proIGF2 oligomers, although the biological role of proIGF2 oligomerization is not yet known.

Multimapping confounds ribosome profiling analysis: A case-study of the Hsp90 molecular chaperone.

Ribosome profiling (Ribo-seq) can potentially provide detailed information about ribosome position on transcripts and estimates of protein translation levels in vivo. Hsp90 chaperones, which play a critical role in stress tolerance, have characteristic patterns of differential expression under nonstressed and heat shock conditions. By analyzing published Ribo-seq data for the Hsp90 chaperones in S. cerevisiae, we find wide-ranging artifacts originating from "multimapping" reads (reads that cannot be uniquely assigned to one position), which constitute ~25% of typical S. cerevisiae Ribo-seq datasets and ~80% of the reads from HEK293 cells. Estimates of Hsp90 protein production as determined by Ribo-seq are reproducible but not robust, with inferred expression levels that can change 10-fold depending on how multimapping reads are processed. The differential expression of Hsp90 chaperones under nonstressed and heat shock conditions creates artificial peaks and valleys in their ribosome profiles that give a false impression of regulated translational pausing. Indeed, we find that multimapping can even create an appearance of reproducibility to the shape of the Hsp90 ribosome profiles from biological replicates. Adding further complexity, this artificial reproducibility is dependent on the computational method used to construct the ribosome profile. Given the ubiquity of multimapping reads in Ribo-seq experiments and the complexity of artifacts associated with multimapping, we developed a publicly available computational tool to identify transcripts most at risk for multimapping artifacts. In doing so, we identify biological pathways that are enriched in multimapping transcripts, meaning that particular biological pathways will be highly susceptible to multimapping artifacts.

Hsp90 Sensitivity to ADP Reveals Hidden Regulation Mechanisms.

The ATPase cycle of the Hsp90 molecular chaperone is essential for maintaining the stability of numerous client proteins. Extensive analysis has focused on ATP-driven conformational changes of Hsp90; however, little is known about how Hsp90 operates under physiological nucleotide conditions in which both ATP and ADP are present. By quantifying Hsp90 activity under mixed nucleotide conditions, we find dramatic differences in ADP sensitivity among Hsp90 homologs. ADP acts as a strong ATPase inhibitor of cytosol-specific Hsp90 homologs, whereas organellular Hsp90 homologs (Grp94 and TRAP1) are relatively insensitive to the presence of ADP. These results imply that an ATP/ADP heterodimer of cytosolic Hsp90 is the predominant active state under physiological nucleotide conditions. ADP inhibition of human and yeast cytosolic Hsp90 can be relieved by the cochaperone aha1. ADP inhibition of bacterial Hsp90 can be relieved by bacterial Hsp70 and an activating client protein. These results suggest that altering ADP inhibition may be a mechanism of Hsp90 regulation. To determine the molecular origin of ADP inhibition, we identify residues that preferentially stabilize either ATP or ADP. Mutations at these sites can both increase and decrease ADP inhibition. An accounting of ADP is critically important for designing and interpreting experiments with Hsp90. For example, contaminating ADP is a confounding factor in fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments measuring arm closure rates of Hsp90. Our observations suggest that ADP at physiological levels is important to Hsp90 structure, activity, and regulation.

Crowding Activates Heat Shock Protein 90.

Hsp90 is a dimeric ATP-dependent chaperone involved in the folding, maturation, and activation of diverse target proteins. Extensive in vitro structural analysis has led to a working model of Hsp90's ATP-driven conformational cycle. An implicit assumption is that dilute experimental conditions do not significantly perturb Hsp90 structure and function. However, Hsp90 undergoes a dramatic open/closed conformational change, which raises the possibility that this assumption may not be valid for this chaperone. Indeed, here we show that the ATPase activity of Hsp90 is highly sensitive to molecular crowding, whereas the ATPase activities of Hsp60 and Hsp70 chaperones are insensitive to crowding conditions. Polymer crowders activate Hsp90 in a non-saturable manner, with increasing efficacy at increasing concentration. Crowders exhibit a non-linear relationship between their radius of gyration and the extent to which they activate Hsp90. This experimental relationship can be qualitatively recapitulated with simple structure-based volume calculations comparing open/closed configurations of Hsp90. Thermodynamic analysis indicates that crowding activation of Hsp90 is entropically driven, which is consistent with a model in which excluded volume provides a driving force that favors the closed active state of Hsp90. Multiple Hsp90 homologs are activated by crowders, with the endoplasmic reticulum-specific Hsp90, Grp94, exhibiting the highest sensitivity. Finally, we find that crowding activation works by a different mechanism than co-chaperone activation and that these mechanisms are independent. We hypothesize that Hsp90 has a higher intrinsic activity in the cell than in vitro.