Cell biology. Fusion without SNAREs?

Highly orchestrated molecular rearrangements are required for two membranes to fuse, as happens, for example, during neurotransmitter release into the synapse. In an elegant Perspective, Scales et al. discuss two studies (Schoch et al., Wang et al.) that shed new light on the protein interactions involved in membrane fusion.

Sequential SNARE assembly underlies priming and triggering of exocytosis.

Changes in SNARE conformations during MgATP-dependent priming of cracked PC12 cells were probed by their altered accessibility to various inhibitors. Dominant negative soluble syntaxin and, to a much lesser extent, VAMP coil domains inhibited exocytosis more efficiently after priming. Neurotoxins and an anti-SNAP25 antibody inhibited exocytosis less effectively after priming. We propose that SNAREs partially and reversibly assemble during priming, and that the syntaxin H3 domain is prevented from fully joining the complex until the arrival of the Ca2+ trigger. Furthermore, we find that mutation of hydrophobic residues of the SNAP25 C-terminal coil that contribute to SNARE core interactions affects the maximal rate of exocytosis, while mutation of charged residues on the surface of the complex affects the apparent affinity of the coil domain for the partially assembled complex.

Calcium regulation of exocytosis in PC12 cells.

The calcium (Ca(2+)) regulation of neurotransmitter release is poorly understood. Here we investigated several aspects of this process in PC12 cells. We first showed that osmotic shock by 1 m sucrose stimulated rapid release of neurotransmitters from intact PC12 cells, indicating that most of the vesicles were docked at the plasma membrane. Second, we further investigated the mechanism of rescue of botulinum neurotoxin E inhibition of release by recombinant SNAP-25 COOH-terminal coil, which is known to be required in the triggering stage. We confirmed here that Ca(2+) was required simultaneously with the SNAP-25 peptide, with no significant increase in release if either the peptide or Ca(2+) was present during the priming stage as well as the triggering, suggesting that SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive fusion protein attachment protein receptor) complex assembly was involved in the final Ca(2+)-triggered event. Using this rescue system, we also identified a series of acidic surface SNAP-25 residues that rescued better than wild-type when mutated, due to broadened Ca(2+) sensitivity, suggesting that this charged patch may interact electrostatically with a negative regulator of membrane fusion. Finally, we showed that the previously demonstrated stimulation of exocytosis in this system by calmodulin required calcium binding, since calmodulin mutants defective in Ca(2+)-binding were not able to enhance release.

A discontinuous SNAP-25 C-terminal coil supports exocytosis.

Membrane fusion requires the formation of four-helical bundles comprised of the SNARE proteins syntaxin, vesicle-associated membrane protein (VAMP), and the synaptosomal-associated protein of 25 kDa (SNAP-25). Botulinum neurotoxin E cleaves the C-terminal coil of SNAP-25, inhibiting exocytosis of norepinephrine from permeabilized PC12 cells. Addition of a 26-mer peptide comprising the C terminus of SNAP-25 that is cleaved by the toxin restores exocytosis, demonstrating that continuity of the SNAP-25 C-terminal helix is not critical for its function. By contrast, vesicle-associated membrane protein peptides could not rescue botulinum neurotoxin D-treated cells, suggesting that helix continuity is critical for VAMP function. Much higher concentrations of the SNAP-25 C-terminal peptide are required for rescuing exocytosis (K(assembly) = approximately 460 microm) than for binding to other SNAREs in vitro (Kd < 5 microm). Each residue of the peptide was mutated to alanine to assess its functional importance. Whereas most mutants rescue exocytosis with lower efficiency than the wild type peptide, D186A rescues with higher efficiency, and kinetic analysis suggests this is because of higher affinity for the cellular binding site. This is consistent with Asp-186 contributing to negative regulation of the fusion process.

The ionic layer is required for efficient dissociation of the SNARE complex by alpha-SNAP and NSF.

The four-helical bundle soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive fusion protein (NSF) attachment protein receptor (SNARE) complex that mediates intracellular membrane fusion events contains a highly conserved ionic layer at the center of an otherwise hydrophobic core. This layer has an undetermined function; it consists of glutamine (Q) residues in syntaxin and the two synaptosomal-associated protein of 25 kDa (SNAP-25) family helices, and an arginine (R) in vesicle-associated membrane protein (a 3Q:1R ratio). Here, we show that the ionic-layer glutamine of syntaxin is required for efficient alpha-SNAP and NSF-mediated dissociation of the complex. When this residue is mutated, the SNARE complex still binds to alpha-SNAP and NSF and is released through ATP hydrolysis by NSF, but the complex no longer dissociates into SNARE monomers. Thus, one function of the ionic layer--in particular, the glutamine of syntaxin--is to couple ATP hydrolysis by NSF to the dissociation of the fusion complex. We propose that alpha-SNAP and NSF drive conformational changes at the ionic layer through specific interactions with the syntaxin glutamine, resulting in the dissociation of the SNARE complex.

Membrane recruitment of coatomer and binding to dilysine signals are separate events.

It has previously been shown that transport of newly synthesized proteins and the structure of the Golgi complex are affected in the Chinese hamster ovary cell line ldlF, which bears a temperature-sensitive mutation in the Coat protein I (COPI) subunit epsilon-COP (Guo, Q., Vasile, E., and Krieger, M. (1994) J. Cell Biol. 125, 1213-1224; Hobbie, L., Fisher, A. S., Lee, S., Flint, A., and Krieger, M. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 20958-20970). Here, we pinpoint the site of the secretory block to an intermediate compartment between the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and the Golgi complex and show that the distributions of ER-Golgi recycling proteins, such as KDEL receptor and p23, as well as resident Golgi proteins, such as mannosidase II, are accordingly affected. At the nonpermissive temperature, neither the stability of the COPI complex nor its recruitment to donor Golgi membranes is affected. However, the binding of coatomer to the dilysine-based ER-retrieval motif is impaired in the absence of epsilon-COP, suggesting that dilysine signal binding is not the major means of COPI recruitment. Because expression of the exogenous chimera of epsilon-COP and green fluorescent protein in ldlF cells at nonpermissive temperature rapidly restores the wild type properties, epsilon-COP is likely to play an important role in the cargo selection events mediated by COPI.

SNAREs contribute to the specificity of membrane fusion.

Intracellular membrane fusion is mediated by the formation of a four-helix bundle comprised of SNARE proteins. Every cell expresses a large number of SNARE proteins that are localized to particular membrane compartments, suggesting that the fidelity of vesicle trafficking might in part be determined by specific SNARE pairing. However, the promiscuity of SNARE pairing in vitro suggests that the information for membrane compartment organization is not encoded in the inherent ability of SNAREs to form complexes. Here, we show that exocytosis of norepinephrine from PC12 cells is only inhibited or rescued by specific SNAREs. The data suggest that SNARE pairing does underlie vesicle trafficking fidelity, and that specific SNARE interactions with other proteins may facilitate the correct pairing.

Coat proteins regulating membrane traffic.

This review focuses on the roles of coat proteins in regulating the membrane traffic of eukaryotic cells. Coat proteins are recruited to the donor organelle membrane from a cytosolic pool by specific small GTP-binding proteins and are required for the budding of coated vesicles. This review first describes the four types of coat complexes that have been characterized so far: clathrin and its adaptors, the adaptor-related AP-3 complex, COPI, and COPII. It then discusses the ascribed functions of coat proteins in vesicular transport, including the physical deformation of the membrane into a bud, the selection of cargo, and the targeting of the budded vesicle. It also mentions how the coat proteins may function in an alternative model for transport, namely via tubular connections, and how traffic is regulated. Finally, this review outlines the evidence that related coat proteins may regulate other steps of membrane traffic.

Segregation of COPI-rich and anterograde-cargo-rich domains in endoplasmic-reticulum-to-Golgi transport complexes.

Membrane traffic between the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and the Golgi complex is regulated by two vesicular coat complexes, COPII and COPI. COPII has been implicated in the selective packaging of anterograde cargo into coated transport vesicles budding from the ER [1]. In mammalian cells, these vesicles coalesce to form tubulo-vesicular transport complexes (TCs), which shuttle anterograde cargo from the ER to the Golgi complex [2] [3] [4]. In contrast, COPI-coated vesicles are proposed to mediate recycling of proteins from the Golgi complex to the ER [1] [5] [6] [7]. The binding of COPI to COPII-coated TCs [3] [8] [9], however, has led to the proposal that COPI binds to TCs and specifically packages recycling proteins into retrograde vesicles for return to the ER [3] [9]. To test this hypothesis, we tracked fluorescently tagged COPI and anterograde-transport markers simultaneously in living cells. COPI predominated on TCs shuttling anterograde cargo to the Golgi complex and was rarely observed on structures moving in directions consistent with retrograde transport. Furthermore, a progressive segregation of COPI-rich domains and anterograde-cargo-rich domains was observed in the TCs. This segregation and the directed motility of COPI-containing TCs were inhibited by antibodies that blocked COPI function. These observations, which are consistent with previous biochemical data [2] [9], suggest a role for COPI within TCs en route to the Golgi complex. By sequestering retrograde cargo in the anterograde-directed TCs, COPI couples the sorting of ER recycling proteins [10] to the transport of anterograde cargo.

SNARE complex formation is triggered by Ca2+ and drives membrane fusion.

Neurotransmitter exocytosis, a process mediated by a core complex of syntaxin, SNAP-25, and VAMP (SNAREs), is inhibited by SNARE-cleaving neurotoxins. Botulinum neurotoxin E inhibition of norepinephrine release in permeabilized PC12 cells can be rescued by adding a 65 aa C-terminal fragment of SNAP-25 (S25-C). Mutations along the hydrophobic face of the S25-C helix result in SNARE complexes with different thermostabilities, and these mutants rescue exocytosis to different extents. Rescue depends on the continued presence of both S25-C and Ca2+ and correlates with complex formation. The data suggest that Ca2+ triggers S25-C binding to a low-affinity site, initiating trans-complex formation. Pairing of SNARE proteins on apposing membranes leads to bilayer fusion and results in a high-affinity cis-SNARE complex.

A formiminotransferase cyclodeaminase isoform is localized to the Golgi complex and can mediate interaction of trans-Golgi network-derived vesicles with microtubules.

A protein of 60 kDa (p60) has been identified using a quantitative in vitro vesicle-microtubule binding assay. Purified p60 induces co-sedimentation with microtubules of trans-Golgi network-derived vesicles isolated from polarized, perforated Madin-Darby canine kidney cells. Sequencing of the cDNA coding for this protein revealed that it is the chicken homologue of formiminotransferase cyclodeaminase (FTCD), a liver-specific enzyme involved in the histidine degradation pathway. Purified p60 from chicken liver has formiminotransferase activity, confirming that it is FTCD or an isoform of this enzyme. Isoforms of FTCD were identified in chicken hepatoma and HeLa cells, and immunolocalize to the region of the Golgi complex and vesicular structures in its vicinity. Furthermore, 58K, a previously identified microtubule-binding Golgi protein from rat liver (Bloom, G. S., and Brashear, T. A. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 16083-16092), is identical to FTCD. Both proteins co-purify with microtubules and co-localize with membranes of the Golgi complex. The capacity of FTCD to bind both to microtubules and Golgi-derived membranes may suggest that this protein, or one of its isoforms, might have in addition to its enzymatic activity, a second physiological function in mediating interaction of Golgi-derived membranes with microtubules.

Visualization of ER-to-Golgi transport in living cells reveals a sequential mode of action for COPII and COPI.

Exocytic transport from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the Golgi complex has been visualized in living cells using a chimera of the temperature-sensitive glycoprotein of vesicular stomatitis virus and green fluorescent protein (ts-G-GFP[ct]). Upon shifting to permissive temperature, ts-G-GFP(ct) concentrates into COPII-positive structures close to the ER, which then build up to form an intermediate compartment or transport complex, containing ERGIC-53 and the KDEL receptor, where COPII is replaced by COPI. These structures appear heterogenous and move in a microtubule-dependent manner toward the Golgi complex. Our results suggest a sequential mode of COPII and COPI action and indicate that the transport complexes are ER-to-Golgi transport intermediates from which COPI may be involved in recycling material to the ER.