ABSTRACT
Delayed loss of residual acoustic hearing after cochlear implantation is a common but poorly understood phenomenon due to the scarcity of relevant temporal bone tissues. Prior histopathological analysis of one case of post-implantation hearing loss suggested there were no interaural differences in hair cell or neural degeneration to explain the profound loss of low-frequency hearing on the implanted side (Quesnel et al., 2016) and attributed the threshold elevation to neo-ossification and fibrosis around the implant. Here we re-evaluated the histopathology in this case, applying immunostaining and improved microscopic techniques for differentiating surviving hair cells from supporting cells. The new analysis revealed dramatic interaural differences, with a > 80 % loss of inner hair cells in the cochlear apex on the implanted side, which can account for the post-implantation loss of residual hearing. Apical degeneration of the stria further contributed to threshold elevation on the implanted side. In contrast, spiral ganglion cell survival was reduced in the region of the electrode on the implanted side, but apical counts in the two ears were similar to that seen in age-matched unimplanted control ears. Almost none of the surviving auditory neurons retained peripheral axons throughout the basal half of the cochlea. Relevance to cochlear implant performance is discussed.
Subject(s)
Auditory Threshold , Cochlear Implantation , Cochlear Implants , Spiral Ganglion , Cochlear Implantation/instrumentation , Cochlear Implantation/adverse effects , Humans , Spiral Ganglion/pathology , Spiral Ganglion/physiopathology , Hair Cells, Auditory, Inner/pathology , Time Factors , Cell Survival , Male , Hearing , Hearing Loss/physiopathology , Hearing Loss/pathology , Hearing Loss/surgery , Hearing Loss/etiology , Female , Hair Cells, Auditory/pathology , Aged , Nerve Degeneration , Middle Aged , Temporal Bone/pathology , Temporal Bone/surgeryABSTRACT
HYPOTHESIS: Preimplantation word scores cannot reliably predict postimplantation outcomes. BACKGROUND: To date, there is no model based on preoperative data that can reliably predict the postoperative outcomes of cochlear implantation in the postlingually deafened adult patient. METHODS: In a group of 228 patients who received a cochlear implant between 2002 and 2021, we tested the predictive power of nine variables (age, etiology, sex, laterality of implantation, preimplantation thresholds and word scores, as well as the design, insertion approach, and angular insertion depth of the electrode array) on postimplantation outcomes. Results of multivariable linear regression analyses were then interpreted in light of data obtained from histopathological analyses of human temporal bones. RESULTS: Age and etiology were the only significant predictors of postimplantation outcomes. In agreement with many investigations, preimplantation word scores failed to significantly predict postimplantation outcomes. Analysis of temporal bone histopathology suggests that neuronal survival must fall below 40% before word scores in quiet begin to drop. Scores fall steeply with further neurodegeneration, such that only 20% survival can support acoustically driven word scores of 50%. Because almost all cochlear implant implantees have at least 20% of their spiral ganglion neurons (SGNs) surviving, it is expected that most cochlear implant users on average should improve to at least 50% word recognition score, as we observed, even if their preimplantation score was near zero as a result of widespread hair cell damage and the fact that ~50% of their SGNs have likely lost their peripheral axons. These "disconnected" SGNs would not contribute to acoustic hearing but likely remain electrically excitable. CONCLUSION: The relationship between preimplantation word scores and data describing the survival of SGNs in humans can explain why preimplantation word scores obtained in unaided conditions fail to predict postimplantation outcomes.
Subject(s)
Cochlear Implantation , Hearing Loss , Language , Speech Perception , Aged , Female , Male , Middle Aged , Audiometry , Cochlear Implantation/instrumentation , Cochlear Implantation/methods , Deafness/surgery , Hearing Loss/surgery , Hearing Loss, Sensorineural/surgery , Linear Models , Prognosis , Retrospective Studies , Speech Perception/physiology , Temporal Bone/pathology , Treatment Outcome , HumansABSTRACT
Acute noise-induced loss of synapses between inner hair cells (IHCs) and auditory nerve fibers (ANFs) has been documented in several strains of mice, but the extent of post-exposure recovery reportedly varies dramatically. If such inter-strain heterogeneity is real, it could be exploited to probe molecular pathways mediating neural remodeling in the adult cochlea. Here, we compared synaptopathy repair in CBA/CaJ vs. C57BL/6J, which are at opposite ends of the reported recovery spectrum. We evaluated C57BL/6J mice 0 h, 24 h, 2 wks or 8 wks after exposure for 2 h to octave-band noise (8-16 kHz) at either 90, 94 or 98 dB SPL, to compare with analogous post-exposure results in CBA/CaJ at 98 or 101 dB. We counted pre- and post-synaptic puncta in immunostained cochleas, using machine learning to classify paired (GluA2 and CtBP2) vs. orphan (CtBP2 only) puncta, and batch-processing to quantify immunostaining intensity. At 98 dB, both strains show ongoing loss of ribbons and synapses between 0 and 24 h, followed by partial recovery, however the extent and degree of these changes were greater in C57BL/6J. Much of the synaptic recovery is due to transient reduction in GluA2 intensity in synaptopathic regions. In contrast, CtBP2 intensity showed only transient increases (at 2 wks). Neurofilament staining revealed transient extension of ANF terminals in C57BL/6J, but not in CBA/CaJ, peaking at 24 h and reverting by 2 wks. Thus, although interstrain differences in synapse recovery are dominated by reversible changes in GluA2 receptor levels, the neurite extension seen in C57BL/6J suggests a qualitative difference in regenerative capacity.
Subject(s)
Hearing Loss, Noise-Induced , Mice , Animals , Hearing Loss, Noise-Induced/etiology , Hearing Loss, Noise-Induced/metabolism , Mice, Inbred C57BL , Auditory Threshold/physiology , Evoked Potentials, Auditory, Brain Stem/physiology , Mice, Inbred CBA , Cochlea/metabolism , Synapses/metabolismABSTRACT
Quantifying the survival patterns of spiral ganglion cells (SGCs), the cell bodies of auditory-nerve fibers, is critical to studies of sensorineural hearing loss, especially in human temporal bones. The classic method of manual counting is tedious, and, although stereology approaches can be faster, they can only be used to estimate total cell numbers per cochlea. Here, a machine-learning algorithm that automatically identifies, counts, and maps the SGCs in digitized images of semi-serial human temporal-bone sections not only speeds the analysis, with no loss of accuracy, but also allows 3D visualization of the SGCs and fine-grained mapping to cochlear frequency. Applying the algorithm to 62 normal-aging human ears shows significantly faster degeneration of SGCs in the basal than the apical half of the cochlea. Comparison to fiber counts in the same ears shows that the fraction of surviving SGCs lacking a peripheral axon steadily increases with age, reaching more than 50% in the apical cochlea and almost 66% in basal regions.
Subject(s)
Cochlea , Hearing Loss, Sensorineural , Humans , Aging , Spiral Ganglion , Temporal BoneABSTRACT
Several lines of evidence have suggested that steeply sloping audiometric losses are caused by hair cell degeneration, while flat audiometric losses are caused by strial atrophy, but this concept has never been rigorously tested in human specimens. Here, we systematically compare audiograms and cochlear histopathology in 160 human cases from the archival collection of celloidin-embedded temporal bones at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear. The dataset included 106 cases from a prior study of normal-aging ears, and an additional 54 cases selected by combing the database for flat audiograms. Audiogram shapes were classified algorithmically into five groups according to the relation between flatness (i.e., SD of hearing levels across all frequencies) and low-frequency pure-tone average (i.e., mean at 0.25, 0.5, and 1.0 kHz). Outer and inner hair cell losses, neural degeneration, and strial atrophy were all quantified as a function of cochlear location in each case. Results showed that strial atrophy was worse in the apical than the basal half of the cochlea and was worse in females than in males. The degree of strial atrophy was uncorrelated with audiogram flatness. Apical atrophy was correlated with low-frequency thresholds and basal atrophy with high-frequency thresholds, and the former correlation was higher. However, a multivariable regression with all histopathological measures as predictors and audiometric thresholds as the outcome showed that strial atrophy was a significant predictor of threshold shift only in the low-frequency region, and, even there, the contribution of outer hair cell damage was larger.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Cochlear pathology can only be assessed postmortem; thus, human cochlear histopathology is critical to our understanding of the mechanisms of hearing loss. Dogma holds that relative damage to sensory cells, which transduce mechanical vibration into electrical signals, versus the stria vascularis, the cellular battery that powers transduction, can be inferred by the shape of the audiogram, that is, down-sloping (hair cell damage) versus flat (strial atrophy). Here we quantified hair cell and strial atrophy in 160 human specimens to show that it is the degree of low-frequency hearing loss, rather than the audiogram slope, that predicts strial atrophy. Results are critical to the design of clinical trials for hearing-loss therapeutics, as current drugs target only hair cell, not strial, regeneration.
Subject(s)
Deafness , Stria Vascularis , Male , Female , Humans , Stria Vascularis/pathology , Cochlea/pathology , Deafness/pathology , Atrophy/pathology , Hair Cells, Auditory, Outer/pathologyABSTRACT
Animal studies have shown that the supporting-cells surviving in the organ of Corti after cochlear insult can be transdifferentiated into hair cells as a treatment for sensorineural hearing loss. Clinical trials of small-molecule therapeutics have been undertaken, but little is known about how to predict the pattern and degree of supporting-cell survival based on audiogram, hearing loss etiology or any other metric obtainable pre-mortem. To address this, we systematically assessed supporting-cell and hair cell survival, as a function of cochlear location in 274 temporal bone cases from the archives at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear and compared the histopathology with the audiograms and hearing-loss etiologies. Results showed that supporting-cell survival was always significantly greater in the apical half than the basal half of the cochlea, that inner pillars were more robust than outer pillars or Deiters' cells, and that total replacement of all supporting cells with a flat epithelium was rare outside of the extreme basal 20% of the cochlea. Supporting cell survival in the basal half of the cochlea was better correlated with the slope of the audiogram than with the mean high-frequency threshold per se: i.e. survival was better with flatter audiograms than with steeply down-sloping audiograms. Cochlear regions with extensive hair cell loss and exceptional supporting cell survival were most common in cases with hearing loss due to ototoxic drugs. Such cases also tended to have less pathology in other functionally critical structures, i.e. spiral ganglion neurons and the stria vascularis.
Subject(s)
Deafness , Hearing Loss , Humans , Cell Survival , Cochlea/pathology , Hair Cells, Auditory/pathology , Stria Vascularis/pathology , Deafness/pathology , Hearing Loss/pathologyABSTRACT
Animal studies have shown that the supporting-cells surviving in the organ of Corti after cochlear insult can be transdifferentiated into hair cells as a treatment for sensorineural hearing loss. Clinical trials of small-molecule therapeutics have been undertaken, but little is known about how to predict the pattern and degree of supporting-cell survival based on audiogram, hearing loss etiology or any other metric obtainable pre-mortem. To address this, we systematically assessed supporting-cell and hair cell survival, as a function of cochlear location in 274 temporal bone cases from the archives at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear and compared the histopathology with the audiograms and hearing-loss etiologies. Results showed that supporting-cell survival was always significantly greater in the apical half than the basal half of the cochlea, that inner pillars were more robust than outer pillars or Deiters' cells, and that total replacement of all supporting cells with a flat epithelium was rare outside of the extreme basal 20% of the cochlea. Supporting cell survival in the basal half of the cochlea was better correlated with the slope of the audiogram than with the mean high-frequency threshold per se: i.e. survival was better with flatter audiograms than with steeply down-sloping audiograms. Cochlear regions with extensive hair cell loss and exceptional supporting cell survival were most common in cases with hearing loss due to ototoxic drugs. Such cases also tended to have less pathology in other functionally critical structures, i.e. spiral ganglion neurons and the stria vascularis. Highlights: Supporting cell survival was systematically assessed in 274 human cochleasSupporting cell survival was better with flat than with down-sloping audiogramsSupporting cell survival was most robust when hearing loss was from ototoxic drugsOtotoxic cases also showed less pathology in other critical cochlear structuresThe data can inform clinical trials for regeneration via supporting cell conversion.
ABSTRACT
Age-related hearing loss in humans is characterized by progressive loss of threshold sensitivity, especially at high frequencies. A multivariable regression of histopathological metrics from normal-aging human cochleae (Wu et al., 2020) showed that hair cell loss better predicts the audiometric shifts than either neural loss or strial atrophy, however considerable variability in age-related threshold elevation remained unexplained. Here, we develop and apply an algorithm to quantify stereocilia pathology in high-power confocal images of inner and outer hair cells in normal aging human cochleae, aged 21 - 71 yrs. Microdissected epithelial wholemounts of the cochleae were immunostained for myosin VIIa and espin to show cuticular plates and stereocilia, respectively, and each cochlea was imaged at 10 log-spaced locations along the cochlear spiral. An approach based on Fourier transforms was used to quantify the regularity of each stereocilia bundle, and the outcome was compared to a parallel analysis by a human observer. Results show a significant age-related decline in stereocilia regularity and increase in stereocilia loss and fusion. Stereocilia pathology was especially severe on the outer hair cells and in the basal half of the cochlea, and may represent a key contributor to age-related threshold elevations. For the one case with an associated pre-mortem audiogram, the threshold shifts are better predicted from the pattern of stereocilia damage than from the pattern of hair cell loss alone.
Subject(s)
Presbycusis , Stereocilia , Humans , Cochlea/pathology , Hair Cells, Auditory, Outer , Actin Cytoskeleton , Presbycusis/pathology , Hair Cells, Auditory, InnerABSTRACT
Healthy aging may be associated with neural degeneration in the cochlea even before clinical hearing loss emerges. Reduction in frequency-following responses (FFRs) to tonal carriers in older clinically normal-hearing listeners has previously been reported, and has been argued to reflect an age-dependent decline in temporal processing in the central auditory system. Alternatively, age-dependent loss of auditory nerve fibers (ANFs) may have little effect on audiometric sensitivity and yet compromise the precision of neural phase-locking relying on joint activity across populations of fibers. This peripheral loss may, in turn, contribute to reduced neural synchrony in the brainstem as reflected in the FFR. Here, we combined human electrophysiology and auditory nerve (AN) modeling to investigate whether age-related changes in the FFR would be consistent with peripheral neural degeneration. FFRs elicited by pure tones and frequency sweeps at carrier frequencies between 200 and 1200 Hz were obtained in older (ages 48-76) and younger (ages 20-30) listeners, both groups having clinically normal audiometric thresholds up to 6 kHz. The same stimuli were presented to a computational model of the AN in which age-related loss of hair cells or ANFs was modelled using human histopathological data. In the older human listeners, the measured FFRs to both sweeps and pure tones were found to be reduced across the carrier frequencies examined. These FFR reductions were consistent with model simulations of age-related ANF loss. In model simulations, the phase-locked response produced by the population of remaining fibers decreased proportionally with increasing loss of the ANFs. Basal-turn loss of inner hair cells also reduced synchronous activity at lower frequencies, albeit to a lesser degree. Model simulations of age-related threshold elevation further indicated that outer hair cell dysfunction had no negative effect on phase-locked AN responses. These results are consistent with a peripheral source of the FFR reductions observed in older normal-hearing listeners, and indicate that FFRs at lower carrier frequencies may potentially be a sensitive marker of peripheral neural degeneration.
Subject(s)
Cochlear Nerve , Hearing Loss, Sensorineural , Adult , Aged , Audiometry , Auditory Threshold/physiology , Hair Cells, Auditory, Inner , Hair Cells, Auditory, Outer , Humans , Middle Aged , Young AdultABSTRACT
Animal studies suggest that cochlear nerve degeneration precedes sensory cell degeneration in both noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) and age-related hearing loss (ARHL), producing a hearing impairment that is not reflected in audiometric thresholds. Here, we investigated the histopathology of human ARHL and NIHL by comparing loss of auditory nerve fibers (ANFs), cochlear hair cells and the stria vascularis in a group of 52 cases with noise-exposure history against an age-matched control group. Although strial atrophy increased with age, there was no effect of noise history. Outer hair cell (OHC) loss also increased with age throughout the cochlea but was unaffected by noise history in the low-frequency region (<2 kHz), while greatly exacerbated at high frequencies (≥2 kHz). Inner hair cell (IHC) loss was primarily seen at high frequencies but was unaffected by noise at either low or high frequencies. ANF loss was substantial at all cochlear frequencies and was exacerbated by noise throughout. According to a multivariable regression model, this loss of neural channels contributes to poor word discrimination among those with similar audiometric threshold losses. The histopathological patterns observed also suggest that, whereas the low-frequency OHC loss may be an unavoidable consequence of aging, the high-frequency loss, which produces the classic down-sloping audiogram of ARHL, may be partially because of avoidable ear abuse, even among those without a documented history of acoustic overexposure.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT As regenerative therapeutics in sensorineural hearing loss enter clinical trials, it becomes critical to infer which cochlear pathologies are present in addition to hair cell loss. Here, by analyzing human autopsy material, we show that acoustic injury accelerates age-related primary neural degeneration, but not strial degeneration, neither of which can be inferred from audiometric thresholds. It exacerbates outer hair cell (OHC) loss only in the high-frequency half of the cochlea, suggesting that the apical loss is age-related, whereas the basal loss is partially noise induced, and therefore avoidable. Statistical analysis suggests that neural loss helps explain differences in word-recognition ability among individuals with similar audiometric thresholds. The surprising correlation between neural loss and OHC loss in the cochlea's speech region also implicates neural loss in the well-known decline in word scores as thresholds deteriorate with age.
Subject(s)
Cochlea/pathology , Hair Cells, Auditory, Outer/pathology , Hearing Loss, Noise-Induced/pathology , Nerve Degeneration/pathology , Noise/adverse effects , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Aging/pathology , Auditory Threshold/physiology , Cochlear Nerve/pathology , Female , Hair Cells, Auditory, Inner , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Nerve Degeneration/etiologyABSTRACT
Age-related hearing loss arises from irreversible damage in the inner ear, where sound is transduced into electrical signals. Prior human studies suggested that sensory-cell loss is rarely the cause; correspondingly, animal work has implicated the stria vascularis, the cellular "battery" driving the amplification of sound by hair cell "motors." Here, quantitative microscopic analysis of hair cells, auditory nerve fibers, and strial tissues in 120 human inner ears obtained at autopsy, most of whom had recent audiograms in their medical records, shows that the degree of hearing loss is well predicted from the amount of hair cell loss and that inclusion of strial damage does not improve the prediction. Although many aging ears showed significant strial degeneration throughout the cochlea, our statistical models suggest that, by the time strial tissues are lost, hair cell death is so extensive that the loss of battery is no longer important to pure-tone thresholds and that audiogram slope is not diagnostic for strial degeneration. These data comprise the first quantitative survey of hair cell death in normal-aging human cochleas, and reveal unexpectedly severe hair cell loss in low-frequency cochlear regions, and dramatically greater loss in high-frequency regions than seen in any aging animal model. Comparison of normal-aging ears to an age-matched group with acoustic-overexposure history suggests that a lifetime of acoustic overexposure is to blame.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT This report upends dogma about the causes of age-related hearing loss. Our analysis of over 120 autopsy specimens shows that inner-ear sensory cell loss can largely explain the audiometric patterns in aging, with minimal contribution from the stria vascularis, the "battery" that powers the inner ear, previously viewed as the major locus of age-related hearing dysfunction. Predicting inner ear damage from the audiogram is critical, now that clinical trials of therapeutics designed to regrow hair cells are underway. Our data also show that hair cell degeneration in aging humans is dramatically worse than that in aging animals, suggesting that the high-frequency hearing losses that define human presbycusis reflect avoidable contributions of chronic ear abuse to which aging animals are not exposed.
Subject(s)
Hair Cells, Auditory, Inner/pathology , Presbycusis/pathology , Stria Vascularis/pathology , Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Audiometry , Auditory Pathways/pathology , Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Infant , Male , Middle Aged , Presbycusis/etiology , Young AdultABSTRACT
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Histopathological analysis of hair cell survival in human temporal bone sections has historically been binarized such that each hair cell row is rated as either present or absent, thereby greatly underestimating the amount of hair cell loss. Here, we describe and validate a technique to reliably assess fractional hair cell survival in archival sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) using high-resolution light microscopy and optical sectioning. STUDY DESIGN: Technique validation. METHODS: Hair cell counts in archival temporal bone slide sets were performed by several observers using either differential interference contrast (DIC) or confocal microscopy of the endogenous eosin fluorescence in hair cells. As a further cross-check, additional decelloidinized sections were immunostained with hair cell markers myosin VI and VIIa. RESULTS: Cuticular plates and stereocilia bundles are routinely resolvable in DIC imaging of archival H&E-stained human material using standard research-grade microscopes, allowing highly accurate counts of fractional hair cell survival that are reproducible across observer and can be verified by confocal microscopy. CONCLUSIONS: Reanalysis of cases from the classic temporal bone literature on presbycusis suggests that, contrary to prior reports, differences in audiometric patterns may be well explained by the patterns of hair cell loss. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: NA Laryngoscope, 130:487-495, 2020.