Performance evaluation of VRAIN: a brain-dedicated PET with a hemispherical detector arrangement.

Objective.For PET imaging systems, a smaller detector ring enables less intrinsic spatial resolution loss due to the photon non-collinearity effect as well as better balance between production cost and sensitivity, and a hemispherical detector arrangement is more appropriate for brain imaging than a conventional cylindrical arrangement. Therefore, we have developed a brain-dedicated PET system with a hemispherical detector arrangement, which has been commercialized in Japan under the product name of VRAINTM. In this study, we evaluated imaging performance of VRAIN.Approach.The VRAIN used 54 detectors to form the main hemispherical unit and an additional half-ring behind the neck. Each detector was composed of a 12 × 12 array of lutetium fine silicate crystals (4.1 × 4.1 × 10 mm3) and a 12 × 12 array of silicon photomultipliers (4 × 4 mm2active area) with the one-to-one coupling. We evaluated the physical performance of VRAIN according to the NEMA NU 2-2018 standards. Some measurements were modified so as to fit the hemispherical geometry. In addition, we performed18F-FDG imaging in a healthy volunteer.Main results.In the phantom study, the VRAIN showed high resolution for separating 2.2 mm rods, 229 ps TOF resolution and 19% scatter fraction. With the TOF gain for a 20 cm diameter object (an assumed head diameter), the peak noise-equivalent count rate was 144 kcps at 9.8 kBq ml-1and the sensitivity was 25 kcps MBq-1. Overall, the VRAIN provided excellent image quality in phantom and human studies. In the human FDG images, small brain nuclei and gray matter structures were clearly visualized with high contrast and low noise.Significance.We demonstrated the excellent imaging performance of VRAIN, which supported the advantages of the hemispherical detector arrangement.

245 ps-TOF brain-dedicated PET prototype with a hemispherical detector arrangement.

Brain PET, which has led research in molecular imaging and diagnosis of brain cancer, epilepsy and neurodegenerative disorders, is being spotlighted again to promote earlier diagnosis of dementia with the advent of amyloid and tau tracers. To meet this demand, in this paper, we developed a brain-dedicated PET imaging device with a hemispherical detector arrangement, which provides comparable sensitivity with fewer detectors than conventional cylindrical geometries. The introduction of the time-of-flight (TOF) measurement capability was a key point for the development to get a gain in the image signal-to-noise ratio. Currently, whole-body PET scanners with around 200-400 ps coincidence resolving time (CRT) are commercially available. In order to obtain the same TOF gain which can be obtained with 400 ps CRT for a 30 cm diameter object, 267 ps CRT will be required for a 20 cm diameter object such as the human head. In this work, therefore, we aimed at developing a TOF brain-dedicated PET prototype with the hemisphere detector arrangement and the CRT faster than 267 ps. The detector was composed of a 12 × 12 lutetium fine silicate (LFS) array coupled with a 12 × 12 multi-pixel photon counter (MPPC) array. Each LFS crystal with a size of 4.14 × 4.14 × 10 mm3 was individually coupled to a separate MPPC. Singles list-mode data from each detector were stored, and coincidences were identified using a coincidence-detection software algorithm. The CRT of 245 ps was finally achieved as the system average after a fine timing correction. For image reconstruction, we implemented the list-mode TOF-OSEM. For a small rod phantom, rods of 3 mm diameter were clearly separated. Also, images of the 3D Hoffman brain phantom, which demonstrated clear contrast between gray and white matter, supported the effect of TOF information.

Design study of a brain-dedicated time-of-flight PET system with a hemispherical detector arrangement.

Time-of-flight (TOF) is now a standard technology for positron emission tomography (PET), but its effective use for small diameter PET systems has not been studied well. In this paper, we simulated a brain-dedicated TOF-PET system with a hemispherical detector arrangement. We modeled a Hamamatsu TOF-PET module (C13500-4075LC-12) with 280 ps coincidence resolving time (CRT), in which a 12 × 12 array of multi pixel photon counters (MPPCs) is connected to a lutetium fine silicate (LFS) crystal array of 4.1 × 4.1 mm2 cross section each, based on one-to-one coupling. On the other hand, spatial resolution degradation due to the parallax error should be carefully addressed for the small diameter PET systems. The ideal PET detector would have both depth-of-interaction (DOI) and TOF capabilities, but typical DOI detectors that are based on light sharing tend to degrade TOF performance. Therefore, in this work, we investigated non-DOI detectors with an appropriate crystal length, which was a compromise between suppressed parallax error and decreased sensitivity. Using GEANT4, we compared two TOF detectors, a 20 mm long non-DOI and a 10 mm long non-DOI, with a non-TOF, 4-layer DOI detector with a total length of 20 mm (i.e. 5 × 4 mm). We simulated a contrast phantom and evaluated the relationship between the contrast recovery coefficient (CRC) and the noise level (the coefficient of variation, COV) for reconstructed images. The 10 mm long non-DOI, which reduces the parallax error at the cost of sensitivity loss, showed better imaging quality than the 20 mm long non-DOI. For example, the CRC value of a 10 mm hot sphere at COV = 20% was 72% for the 10 mm long non-DOI, which was 1.2 times higher than that of the 20 mm long non-DOI. The converged CRC values for the 10 mm long non-DOI were almost equivalent to those of the non-TOF 4-layer DOI, and the 10 mm long non-DOI converged faster than the non-TOF 4-layer DOI did. Based on the simulation results, we evaluated a one-pair prototype system of the TOF-PET detectors with 10 mm crystal length, which yielded the CRT of 250 ± 8 ps. In summary, we demonstrated support for feasibility of the brain-dedicated TOF-PET system with the hemispherical detector arrangement.

First prototyping of a dedicated PET system with the hemisphere detector arrangement.

A strong demand is expected for high-sensitivity, high-resolution and low-cost brain positron emission tomography (PET) imaging for early diagnosis of dementia, as well as for general neuroscience studies. Therefore, we have proposed novel geometries of a hemisphere detector arrangement for high-sensitivity brain imaging, in which an add-on detector at the chin position or neck position helps in sensitivity uniformity improvement. In this study, we developed the first prototype system for proof-of-concept using four-layer depth-of-interaction detectors, each of which consisted of 16 × 16 × 4 Zr-doped GSO crystals with dimensions of 2.8 × 2.8 × 7.5 mm3 and a high-sensitivity 64-channel flat-panel photomultiplier tube. We used 47 detectors to form a hemisphere detector with a hemisphere shape of 25 cm inner diameter and 50 cm outer diameter, and we used seven detectors for each of the add-on detectors. The total detector number of 54 was about one-fourth that of a typical whole-body PET scanner. The hemisphere detector for the prototype system was realized by multiple rings having different numbers of detectors and a cross-shaped top detector unit covering the top. Performance evaluation showed uniform spatial resolutions of 3-4 mm by the filtered back-projection method. Imaging tests of a hot-rod phantom done with an iterative method were able to resolve 2.2 mm rods. Peak sensitivity was measured as more than 10% at a region near the top of the head, which was achieved with the help of the top detector unit. In addition, using the prototype system, we performed the first FDG clinical test with a healthy volunteer. The results showed that the proposed geometries had high potential for realizing high-sensitivity, high-resolution, and low-cost brain PET imaging. As for the add-on detector position, it was shown that the neck position resulted in higher sensitivity and wider field of view (FOV) than the chin position because the add-on detector at the neck position can be placed continuously to the hemisphere detector and close to the FOV.