ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study is to compare the short-term effect of 7 versus 3 days of voice rest (VR) on objective vocal (acoustic) parameters following phonosurgery. METHODS: A prospective randomized study conducted at a tertiary referral medical center. Patients with vocal fold nodules, polyps, or cysts and scheduled for phonosurgery were recruited from the Voice Clinic. They were randomized into groups of 7- or 3-day postoperative VR periods and their voices were recorded preoperatively and at 4-week postoperatively. A mixed linear model statistical analysis (MLMSA) was used to compare pre- and postoperative jitter, shimmer, harmonic-to-noise ratio, and maximum phonation time between the two groups. RESULTS: Sixty-five patients were recruited, but only 34 fully complied with the study protocol, and their data were included in the final analysis (19 males, 20 females; mean age: 40.6 years; 17 patients in the 7-day VR group and 16 in the 3-day VR group). The groups were comparable in age, sex, and type of vocal lesion distribution. The preoperative MLMSA showed no significant group differences in the tested vocal parameters. Both groups exhibited significant (p < 0.05) and comparable improvement in all vocal parameters at postoperative week 4. CONCLUSIONS: A VR duration of 7 days showed no greater benefit on the examined vocal parameters than the 3-day protocol 4-week postoperatively. Our results suggest that a 3-day VR regimen can be followed by patients who undergo phonosurgery without compromising the vocal results. Larger-scale and longer-duration studies are needed to confirm our findings. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2 Laryngoscope, 2024.
ABSTRACT
Flexible endoscopic phonosurgery (FEPS) is one of the most recent and constantly evolving operative techniques in the field of minimally invasive laryngeal surgery. Thanks in part to the possibility of using new technologies, such as digital endoscopes, laser fibres, and different laryngeal injection materials, its fields of application have rapidly expanded. This narrative review describes the current possible indications of FEPS ranging from injection laryngoplasties in cases of vocal cord paralysis or mass defect, to the correction of dysphagia after open partial horizontal laryngectomies. Use of microscissors, microforceps, and laser fibres also allows this technique to be applied for removal of superficial vocal cord lesions, avoiding general anaesthesia in an increasing number of patients.
Subject(s)
Laryngeal Neoplasms , Postoperative Complications , Humans , Laryngeal Neoplasms/surgery , Postoperative Complications/etiology , Postoperative Complications/surgery , Laryngectomy/adverse effects , LaryngoscopyABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Management of benign vocal fold lesions (BVFLs) is variable with individuals receiving surgery, voice therapy, or a combination of these approaches. Some evidence suggests that the best outcomes may be achieved when patients are offered pre- and post-operative voice therapy in addition to phonosurgery, but what constitutes pre- and post-operative voice therapy is poorly described. The pre- and post-operative voice therapy (PAPOV) intervention has been developed and described according to the TIDieR checklist and Rehabilitation Treatment Specification System (RTSS) for voice. The PAPOV intervention is delivered by specialist speech and language therapists trained in the intervention and comprises 7 essential and 4 additional components, delivered in voice therapy sessions with patients who are having surgery on their vocal folds for removal of BVFLs. STUDY DESIGN: Non-randomised, multicentre feasibility trial with embedded process evaluation. METHOD: Forty patients from two sites who are due to undergo phonosurgery will be recruited to receive the PAPOV intervention. Measures of feasibility, including recruitment, retention, and adherence, will be assessed. The feasibility of gathering clinical and cost effectiveness data will be measured pre-treatment, then at 3 and 6 months post-operatively. An embedded process evaluation will be undertaken to explain feasibility findings. DISCUSSION: This study will assess the feasibility of delivering a described voice therapy intervention protocol to patients who are undergoing surgery for removal of BVFLs. Findings will be used to inform the development and implementation of a subsequent effectiveness trial, should this be feasible. TRIAL REGISTRATION: This trial has been prospectively registered on ISRCTN (date 4th January 2023), registration number 17438192, and can be viewed here: https://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN17438192 .
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVES: Though hemorrhagic vocal fold polyps are a common entity, hemorrhagic vocal fold cysts have not been previously described. In our study, we have evaluated patients who were diagnosed on stroboscopy with "hemorrhagic" cysts. METHODS: This 18-month retrospective study has received institutional ethics clearance. Using the database of our voice clinic, 14 patients diagnosed with hemorrhagic cysts by stroboscopy were reviewed. Age, sex, chief complaints, symptom duration, videostroboscopy findings, surgical details, and histopathology were noted. RESULTS: Out of a total 14 patients, 12 were males with a mean age of presentation of 41 years. The duration of hoarseness ranged from 2-24 months. Videostroboscopy revealed a markedly decreased amplitude of the mucosal waves over a well-delineated ovoid or spheroid hemorrhagic lesion, which seemed tethered down by overlying vocal fold epithelium. All patients had operative findings of a well-encapsulated hemorrhagic lesion in the superficial lamina propria with anterior and posterior fibrotic bands. Histopathology of 13 patients was similar and revealed a hemorrhagic polypoidal lesion. A pseudo-capsule could be identified occasionally. These lesions seemed to be hemorrhagic pseudocysts, named "polyst" by us. In one male patient, the histopathology revealed a true vocal fold cyst (type C Koren) with hemorrhage. CONCLUSIONS: A hemorrhagic pseudocyst (polyst) of the vocal fold has stroboscopic and surgical findings resembling a true vocal fold cyst with hemorrhage; however, histologically it resembles a hemorrhagic polyp. A true hemorrhagic cyst however is typically a type C Koren cyst with hemorrhage. Both these entities have not been previously described.
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To develop phonosurgery skills, surgical training of the actual larynx is essential. In our institution, the Japanese deer (Cervus Nippon aplodontids) larynx is used in phonosurgery training. This study aimed to examine the similarities and differences between the Japanese deer and human larynx and to demonstrate their utility in vocal surgery practice. METHODS: A comparative study was conducted using 30 Japanese deer larynges and 51 human donor larynges, evaluating the overall framework, dimensions, and angle of the thyroid cartilage, vocal cord length, and location of the arytenoid cartilage muscular process. The changes and movements of the vocal folds during contraction and relaxation of each internal laryngeal muscle were also visually analyzed. RESULTS: The larynx size of Japanese deer is intermediate between that of human males and females. The adduction and abduction of the vocal folds induced by contraction of the posterior and lateral cricoarytenoid muscles, as well as the extension of the vocal folds induced by contraction of the cricothyroid muscle, behaved in the same manner as in the human larynx. CONCLUSION: The morphology of the Japanese deer larynx is similar to that of the human larynx, making it suitable for use in dissection and surgical practice. Owing to the recent animal damage problem and the popularity of gibier cuisine, large quantities of Japanese deer larynx are available at low prices. We believe that the Japanese deer larynx is the most appropriate animal for phonosurgery training so far.
Subject(s)
Deer , Laryngeal Muscles , Larynx , Vocal Cords , Animals , Larynx/surgery , Larynx/anatomy & histology , Male , Humans , Vocal Cords/surgery , Vocal Cords/anatomy & histology , Female , Laryngeal Muscles/surgery , Laryngeal Muscles/anatomy & histology , Arytenoid Cartilage/surgery , Arytenoid Cartilage/anatomy & histology , Thyroid Cartilage/surgery , Thyroid Cartilage/anatomy & histology , Japan , East Asian PeopleABSTRACT
Voices can convey content, emotion, and essential information about an individual's gender and social information. Closely related to gender identification and sexual attraction, voices also positively affect many psychological factors of individuals. Surgeries have evolved from treating congenital diseases to fulfilling an individual's aesthetic needs for voice. Voice shaping is emerging as the next cosmetic surgery hotspot after skincare and appearance and body shaping. This paper summarizes the development of voice pitch shaping and genderization procedures out of the cosmetic need. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV: This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these evidence-based medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors https://www.springer.com/00266 .
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Many transsexual women seek to feminise their voice through pitch elevation surgeries so that it becomes congruent with their gender identity. This study aims to determine the safety and effectiveness of Wendler glottoplasty (WG) in vocal feminisation through the assessment of acoustic and aerodynamic parameters of the voice, as well as voice-related quality of life (QoL) in male-to-female transsexuals. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of transsexual women who underwent WG for voice feminisation at our institution between 2016 and 2023. All acoustic and aerodynamic analyses, a voice self-assessment, and a videolaryngostroboscopic evaluation were performed in the immediate preoperative period and at the follow-up visit 6 weeks after the procedure. RESULTS: A total of 11 patients with a mean age of 32.73 years were included. After WG, there was a significant fundamental frequency and speaking fundamental frequency increase of 109.64 Hz and 83.48 Hz, respectively (p < 0.001), representing an average rise by 9.71 semitones and 8.36 semitones (STs), respectively. No significant differences were found between the mean pre- and postoperative values of fundamental frequencies, frequency range, upper limit of the frequency range of spoken voice, and maximum phonation time. Contrarily, the mean lower limit of frequency range rose by 75.56 Hz (p < 0.001), representing an average increase of 10.56 STs. None of the assessed spirometric parameters changed significantly after WG (p > 0.05). The mean overall Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and Voice-Related Quality of Life (V-RQOL) scores significantly improved after the surgery, decreasing by 24.54 points (p = 0.008) and 11.5 points (p = 0.001), respectively. A significant improvement was observed in the functional and emotional domains of VHI. Additionally, significantly fewer patients considered the overall quality of their voice to be "poor" after WG. CONCLUSIONS: WG constitutes an effective method of surgical voice feminisation in male-to-female transsexuals with concurrent improvement in their voice-related QoL. Furthermore, it remains a safe procedure without persistent complications and negative influence on the acoustic-aerodynamic measures of the voice.
Subject(s)
Quality of Life , Transgender Persons , Transsexualism , Voice Quality , Humans , Adult , Male , Retrospective Studies , Female , Transgender Persons/psychology , Transsexualism/surgery , Transsexualism/psychology , Glottis/surgery , Treatment Outcome , Middle Aged , Sex Reassignment Procedures/methodsABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Since new evidence regarding the impact of Wendler glottoplasty (WG) on the voice in transgender women became available in the literature in recent years, we aimed to perform an updated systematic review and meta-analysis to determine the actual safety and efficacy of WG in the process of vocal feminization. METHODS: PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane were searched for English-language articles published until July 4, 2023. Studies were found eligible if they evaluated the impact of WG on the acoustic-aerodynamic measures and quality of voice in transgender women. RESULTS: Twenty-three studies were identified. After exclusion of three studies due to incomplete data, 20 studies including 656 patients were included in the meta-analysis. After WG, there was a significant increase of fundamental frequency, speaking fundamental frequency, and lower limit of the frequency range (p < 0.001). Concurrently, a significant reduction of frequency range and maximum phonation time was observed (p < 0.001). No significant differences were found between the pre- and postoperative values regarding the Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Asthenia, and Strain scale score (p = 0.339). The overall score in the Trans Woman Voice Questionnaire (TWVQ) significantly improved after WG (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: WG is an effective voice feminization method in transgender women, associated with a high procedural success and low risk of postoperative complications. Significantly improved TWVQ score after surgery suggests its positive impact on the voice-related quality of life. Postoperative decrease of maximum phonation time and frequency range does not seem to significantly impact the effectiveness of voice production.
Subject(s)
Glottis , Transgender Persons , Voice Quality , Female , Humans , Male , Glottis/surgery , Laryngoplasty/methods , Speech AcousticsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Current voice assessments focus on perceptive evaluation and acoustic analysis. The interaction of vocal tract pressure (PVT) and vocal fold (VF) vibrations are important for volume and pitch control. However, there are currently little non-invasive ways to measure PVT. Limited information has been provided by previous human trials, and interactions between PVT and VF vibrations and the potential clinical application remain unclear. Here, we propose a non-invasive method for monitoring the nonlinear characteristics of PVT and VF vibrations, analyze voices from pathological and healthy individuals, and evaluate treatment efficacy. METHOD: Healthy volunteers and patients with benign laryngeal lesions were recruited for this study. PVT was estimated using an airflow interruption method, VF vibrational frequency was calculated from accelerometer signals, and nonlinear relationships between PVT and VF vibrations were analyzed. Results from healthy volunteers and patients, as well as pre- and post-operation for the patients, were compared. RESULTS: For healthy volunteers, nonlinearity was exhibited as an initial increase and then prompt decrease in vibrational frequency at the end of phonation, coinciding with PVT equilibrating with the subglottal pressure upon airflow interruption. For patients, nonlinearity was present throughout the phonation period pre-operatively, but showed a similar trend to healthy volunteers post-operatively. CONCLUSION: This novel method simultaneously monitors PVT and VF vibration and helps clarify the role of PVT. The results demonstrate differences in nonlinear characteristics between healthy volunteers and patients, and pre-/post-operation in patients. The method may serve as an analysis tool for clinicians to assess pathological phonation and treatment efficacy.
Subject(s)
Laryngeal Diseases , Vocal Cords , Humans , Vocal Cords/pathology , Biomechanical Phenomena , Phonation , Laryngeal Diseases/pathology , Acoustics , VibrationABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Sulcus Vocalis (SV) is a voice disorder characterized by the parallel invagination of the vocal fold epithelium that adheres to the vocal ligament. This condition disrupts the vibratory function, leading to glottal incompetence, hoarseness, and vocal impairment. Despite various proposed surgical techniques, a standardized treatment approach remains elusive. METHODS: We conducted a comprehensive search across PubMed/Medline, Embase, Web of Science, Scholar, and the Cochrane Library for studies on SV treatment. The inclusion criteria comprised original studies comparing pre- and post-treatment vocal outcomes in SV patients, published in English. We excluded case reports, reviews, studies without continuous data, and patients with vocal scar/atrophy. RESULTS: Fifteen observational studies were included (361 patients, 53.73 % male, average age 41.64 years). 80 % of these studies employed self-reported outcomes, while 81.25 % analyzed acoustic/aerodynamic data. The follow-up period varied from 4 to 44 months. All techniques significantly improved Voice Handicap Index (VHI) scores (p < 0.001). Dissective and combined techniques exhibited greater reductions in VHI-30/10 (p < 0.001). Maximum Phonation Time (MPT) improved significantly across all techniques (p < 0.001), with dissective techniques demonstrating superior MPT outcomes (p < 0.001). Jitter improved significantly for dissective and injective techniques (p < 0.001), as did Shimmer for all techniques (p < 0.001). Notably, combined techniques displayed the most significant reductions (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Surgical treatments significantly improve subjective, aerodynamic, and acoustic outcomes in SV patients. Dissective and combined dissective/injective techniques appear to yield better perceptual and phonatory outcomes compared to injective techniques alone. Further research is necessary to establish the optimal treatment approach for SV.
Subject(s)
Voice Disorders , Voice Quality , Humans , Acoustics , Treatment Outcome , Vocal Cords/surgery , Voice Disorders/surgery , Voice Disorders/etiologyABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE(S): Voice rest is commonly recommended following phonomicrosurgery to minimize vocal fold scarring, but associated quality of life (QoL) is low resulting in poor compliance. This study aimed to explore patients' experiences with voice rest following phonomicrosurgery to identify facilitators and barriers. METHODS: This qualitative study used prospective, typical case technique for purposive sampling of consecutive patients who underwent voice rest following phonomicrosurgery for benign vocal fold lesions. Participants were enrolled at a single tertiary Laryngology center located at Unity Health Toronto - St. Michael's Hospital from 2020 to 2022. Semi-structured virtual interviews were conducted 4 weeks following patients' surgery. All interview transcripts were transcribed verbatim and underwent thematic analysis. Participant recruitment was stopped once thematic saturation was achieved. RESULTS: Twenty participants were recruited and 4 withdrew due to scheduling conflicts. Sixteen participants completed interviews, all of whom reported minimal impact of postoperative voice rest on QoL. The participants attributed their success to facilitators such as notifying close contacts of their situation beforehand and adopting nonverbal forms of communication. No participant endorsed a negative attitude toward voice rest. Understanding the rationale for voice rest and the consequences of noncompliance were reported to be effective in encouraging compliance. CONCLUSION: Overall, the participants tolerated voice rest well owing to facilitators such as early preparation, lifestyle modifications, and understanding the rationale for voice rest. Social disconnect and work demands were barriers of voice rest. Moving forward, facilitators and barriers should be addressed in efforts to optimize the voice rest experience for future patient populations. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4 Laryngoscope, 134:361-366, 2024.
Subject(s)
Laryngeal Diseases , Humans , Laryngeal Diseases/surgery , Quality of Life , Voice Quality , Prospective Studies , Treatment Outcome , Microsurgery/methods , Vocal Cords/surgery , Patient Outcome AssessmentABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To perform a comparative analysis of phonosurgical interventions, which were made using a 445 nm semiconductor laser or cold microinstrumentation in patients with «vocal fold polyp¼ diagnosis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The number of surgical interventions equal 30 regarding vocal fold polyp was done in otorhinolaryngology clinic of Pavlov First State Medical University of St. Petersburg in the period from September 2021 yr. to September 2022 yr. The phonosurgical intervention was performed under the conditions of direct suspension microlaryngoscopy by Kleinsasser under general anesthesia using high frequency ventilation through an endotracheal catheter. Surgical interventions were carried out using a 445-nm semiconductor laser in pulsed mode for patients of the 1st group (n=15) and using microsurgical instruments for patients of the 2nd group (n=15). The comparative analysis was conducted based on the results of an objective vocal function assessment by acoustic analysis, as well as on the data of a subjective assessment of the voice using the questionnaire VHI-10rus. The severity of reactive inflammatory phenomena in the postoperative period has been compared and the oscillating movements of vocal folds have been evaluated according to the videolaryngoscopy data. The severity of pain syndrome in the postoperative period was assessed by visual analogue scale. RESULTS: There were no statistically significant differences in the results between two groups. Similarly, there were no statistically significant differences in parameter recovery degree, evaluated by videolaryngoscopy data. Moreover, a full recovery of mucosal wave was found in 93% of patients operated with laser on 7th day, while 47% of patients had the same result after use of cold microinstrumentation. CONCLUSION: The use of 445-nm semiconductor laser for phonosurgical interventions in vocal folds' polyps can be recommended for predicted successful recovery of vocal function, minimization of reactive inflammatory phenomena in postoperative period and early patients' rehabilitation.
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: This study compared the effects of radiofrequency (RF) coblation and cold steel (CS) surgery for the treatment of Reinke's edema (RE). METHODS: A retrospective analysis was conducted on 61 patients with RE, with 33 (54.1%) in the CS surgery group and 28 (45.9%) in the RF coblation group. The primary endpoints were the bilateral operation time and dyspnea severity, assessed preoperatively and at 1 and 3 months postoperatively. Secondary endpoints included subjective and objective vocal assessments, laryngovideostroboscopy (LVS) images, and Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) scores obtained before and at 1 and 3 months postoperatively. RESULTS: The average bilateral operation time was significantly shorter in the RF coblation group (24.2 ± 3.9 min) compared to the CS group (38.4 ± 5.2 min) (P = .041). All patients experienced a decrease in their Dyspnea Severity Index (DSI) scores postoperatively, with no significant differences observed between the two groups at any time point. However, improvements in the grade of hoarseness, roughness, and asthenia were significantly greater in the RF coblation group than in the CS group (P < .001). There were no statistically significant differences in breathiness and strain between the two groups. The average VHI-10 score significantly decreased from preoperative values in both groups (P < .001), with no significant differences observed between the two groups at any time point. CONCLUSIONS: The RF coblation procedure is a reliable and safe method for RE surgery, offering an effective treatment choice for RE.
ABSTRACT
Objective: The primary aim of this study was to define characteristics of transgender women seeking gender-affirming voice modification at our voice center. The secondary aim was to evaluate outcome measures, comparing (a) behavioral voice training alone, (b) surgery alone, and (c) combination of behavioral voice training+surgery. Methods: Patients seen in a 30-month period, who sought care for gender-affirming voice modification, were included if they were assigned male at birth and identified as female. Patient demographic information, patient quality of life index scores, Trans Woman Voice Questionnaire (TWVQ), and acoustic data were collected before and after intervention. Results: Sixteen patients met inclusion criteria. The majority of patients were (a) undergoing hormone replacement therapy at initiation of treatment, (b) were presenting in public for over 2 years as female, and (c) had a history of psychological disorders (i.e., gender dysphoria, anxiety, depression, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder [ADHD]). Increased f0 and decreased TWVQ scores were evident and statistically significant within behavioral voice training cohort and behavioral voice training+surgery cohort. Treatment groups appear similar with respect to average changes; pre- and post-data were not available for surgery only patients. Greater change in f0 was directly correlated with increased number of voice training sessions. Conclusion: There is variability in treatment course for patients seeking gender-affirming voice modification; however, treatment type may not impact outcomes. Increased patient quality of life and increased speaking fundamental frequency were found in this patient cohort.
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Tightly-focused ultrafast laser pulses (pulse widths of 100 fs-10 ps) provide high peak intensities to produce a spatially confined tissue ablation effect. The creation of sub-epithelial voids within scarred vocal folds (VFs) via ultrafast laser ablation may help to localize injectable biomaterials to treat VF scarring. Here, we demonstrate the feasibility of this technique in an animal model using a custom-designed endolaryngeal laser surgery probe. METHODS: Unilateral VF mucosal injuries were created in two canines. Four months later, ultrashort laser pulses (5 ps pulses at 500 kHz) were delivered via the custom laser probe to create sub-epithelial voids of ~3 × 3-mm2 in both healthy and scarred VFs. PEG-rhodamine was injected into these voids. Ex vivo optical imaging and histology were used to assess void morphology and biomaterial localization. RESULTS: Large sub-epithelial voids were observed in both healthy and scarred VFs immediately following in vivo laser treatment. Two-photon imaging and histology confirmed ~3-mm wide subsurface voids in healthy and scarred VFs of canine #2. Biomaterial localization within a void created in the scarred VF of canine #2 was confirmed with fluorescence imaging but was not visualized during follow-up two-photon imaging. As an alternative, the biomaterial was injected into the excised VF and could be observed to localize within the void. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrated sub-epithelial void formation and the ability to inject biomaterials into voids in a chronic VF scarring model. This proof-of-concept study provides preliminary evidence towards the clinical feasibility of such an approach to treating VF scarring using injectable biomaterials. LEVEL OF EVIDENCES: N/A Laryngoscope, 133:3042-3048, 2023.
Subject(s)
Laser Therapy , Vocal Cords , Animals , Dogs , Vocal Cords/surgery , Vocal Cords/pathology , Cicatrix/surgery , Cicatrix/pathology , Laser Therapy/methods , Lasers , Biocompatible MaterialsABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: This case comparison explored the relation between personality, perceived present control, and postoperative voice rest (as estimated by self-report and objective voice use) following surgery for benign vocal fold lesions. METHOD: Two participants were included. Both participants were diagnosed with benign vocal fold pathology, underwent phonosurgery, and were assigned to either complete voice rest (CVR) or relative voice rest (RVR) postoperatively. During voice rest (VR), a visual analog scale (VAS) and a dosimeter (the Vocalog2) were used daily to estimate self-perceived and objective voice use, respectively. The participants also completed questionnaires on voice-related demographics, the Voice Handicap Index (VHI), Ten-Item Personality Inventory (TIPI), and Perceived Present Control (PPC). After 7 days of CVR or RVR, participants completed a postoperative questionnaire and a final VAS for overall voice use. RESULTS: A wide discrepancy was observed in one of two participant's subjective perception of voice use (using the VAS) versus objective dosimetry data wherein she reported significantly more voice use than was observed objectively. Differences in personality and PPC between the participants did not appear to affect their voice use following the VR protocols. CONCLUSION: The amount of voice use in both VR protocols for these two participants suggests that personality and PPC did not affect their adherence to recommendations of VR. Patients may perceive their voice use differently across time, which might play a role in their adherence to voice rest recommendations: voice use measured as instances versus a unit of time (seconds).
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Voice therapy management of benign vocal fold lesions (BVFLs) is variable and there are currently no clinical guidelines. Poor descriptions of voice therapy interventions lead to unwarranted variation in treatment. Triangulation of the current evidence identifies a number of potential best practice elements, but also a number of outstanding questions to be explored. The aim of this study was to refine and gain global consensus on "best practice" for a pre- and postoperative voice therapy intervention for adults with BVFLs. METHODS: An international sample of expert voice therapists (n = 42) were recruited to take part in this three-round electronic modified Delphi study. Participants were presented with statements concerning a pre- and postoperative voice therapy intervention. Statements were developed from previous research and based on the TIDieR checklist (eg, why, when, what, how?) Participants rated the extent to which they agreed or disagreed with a statement and gave comments to support their response. Consensus was defined as >75% of participants agreeing or strongly agreeing with a given statement. If consensus was not reached, participant comments were used to generate new statements and were rated in the next round. Stability of consensus between rounds was assessed. RESULTS: The 42 international experts achieved consensus on 33 statements relating to components of a best practice pre- and postoperative voice therapy intervention for patients with BVFLs. Consensus on statements ranged from 81% to 100%. These statements were explicitly mapped to the TIDieR checklist to ensure that all aspects of the intervention were considered and the questions of "why, what, how, when and individual tailoring" were addressed. CONCLUSIONS: This study has significantly enhanced our understanding of what should be in a best practice pre- and postoperative voice therapy intervention. It is important to now test these findings for acceptability and feasibility, prior to considering effectiveness research.
ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Medialization laryngoplasty can be performed to treat glottic incompetence after endoscopic laser cordectomy. The aim of this study is to evaluate vocal outcome after this phonosurgical procedure and to analyze the critical aspects of the Montgomery and Gore-Tex laryngoplasty technique. METHODS: A retrospective observational study of patients with glottic incompetence after endoscopic laser cordectomy, underwent medialization laryngoplasty with Montgomery or Gore-Tex implant between January 2013 to December 2018 at the Bufalini Hospital of Cesena, Italy. The pre- and postphonosurgery evaluation included videolaryngostroboscopy, perceptual, evaluation of dysphonia with the GRBAS (grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, strain) scale, Voice Handicap Index-10, Maximum Phonation Time. The outcome was evaluated 6 months after the phonosurgical treatment. RESULTS: We treated 22 patients, 19 males and 3 females. Eight cases were treated with Montgomery implant and fourteen with Gore-Tex implant. The postphonosurgical videolaryngostroboscopy showed an improvement of the glottic closure in all patients; the scores of the Voice Handicap Index-10 and of the Maximum Phonation Time showed a statistically significant improvement after phonosurgery. The GRBAS scale scores showed a statistically significant improvement of Global Grade, Breathiness, and Asthenia; the parameter Strain remained unaltered both in pre- and postoperative evaluations, because the voice was never pressed due to glottic insufficiency, especially in preoperative observation. The parameter Roughness (R) did not show a significant difference between pre- and postoperative evaluation. CONCLUSION: Medialization laryngoplasty is an effective phonosurgical procedure to improve voice outcome, after extended endoscopic laser cordectomies, in patients with unacceptable results after voice therapy and injection laryngoplasty. In our experience the Gore-Tex implant allows the surgeon to perform a safer and more "tailored" phonosurgery in cases of cordectomies type IV and V, associated or not with radiotherapy and in revision surgery.
Subject(s)
Laryngoplasty , Male , Female , Humans , Laryngoplasty/adverse effects , Laryngoplasty/methods , Asthenia/etiology , Asthenia/surgery , Glottis/surgery , Endoscopy/methods , Retrospective Studies , Polytetrafluoroethylene , Treatment OutcomeABSTRACT
Benign vocal fold lesions cause dysphonia by preventing vocal fold closure, causing irregular vibration and increasing compensatory muscle tension. Voice therapy delivered in addition to phonosurgery may improve voice and quality of life outcomes but the evidence base is lacking and what constitutes voice therapy for this population is not defined. The purpose of this systematic review is to critically evaluate the evidence for pre and post-operative voice therapy to inform the development of an evidence based intervention. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic Review. METHODS: Electronic databases were searched using key terms including dysphonia, phonosurgery, voice therapy and outcomes. Eligible articles were extracted and reviewed by the authors for risk of bias and for information regarding the content, timing and intensity of any pre and post-operative voice therapy intervention. RESULTS: Of the 432 articles identified, 35 met the inclusion criteria and were included in the review. 5 were RCTs, 2 were individual cohort studies, 1 was a case control study and 26 were case series. There was considerable heterogeneity in participant characteristics. Information was frequently lacking regarding the content timing and intensity of the reported voice therapy intervention, and where present, interventions were highly variable. CONCLUSION: Reporting in relevant literature is limited in all aspects of content, timing and intensity of intervention. Further intervention development work is required to develop a robust voice therapy treatment intervention for this population, before effectiveness work can commence.
Subject(s)
Dysphonia , Humans , Dysphonia/diagnosis , Dysphonia/etiology , Dysphonia/surgery , Vocal Cords/surgery , Case-Control Studies , Quality of Life , Voice Training , Voice QualityABSTRACT
Gender affirmation laryngeal and voice surgeries are components of "voice-lift" or cosmetic voice surgeries. Feminization surgery can modify vocal folds (fundamental frequency [Fo]) and vocal tract (resonance frequency). For increased pitch, vocal folds should be shorter, thinner, and tighter. Cricothyroid approximation (CTA) surgery increases tension of the vocal folds. Endoscopic procedures for pitch raising are done by shortening the length and reducing mass of vocal folds. This shortening is achieved by surgically creating anterior glottic web. Comparing the results of various open and endoscopic surgical techniques, fundamental frequency (Fo) is raised maximally and remains stable after GL as compared with CTA.