ABSTRACT
Introduction: Emergency medicine (EM) was recognized as a specialty in Israel in 1999. Fifty-nine of the 234 (25%) attending physicians working in emergency departments (ED) nationwide in 2002 were board-certified emergency physicians (EP). A 2012 study revealed that 123/270 (45%) of ED attendings were EPs, and that there were 71 EM residents. The EPs primarily worked midweek morning shifts, leaving the EDs mostly staffed by other specialties. Our objective in this study was to re-evaluate the EP workforce in Israeli EDs and their employment status and satisfaction 10 years after the last study, which was conducted in 2012. Methods: We performed a three-part, prospective cross-sectional study: 1) a survey, sent to all EDs in Israel, to assess the numbers, level of training, and specialties of physicians working in EDs; 2) an anonymous questionnaire, sent to EPs in Israel, to assess their demographics, training, employment, and work satisfaction; and 3) interviews of a convenience sample of EPs analyzed by a thematic approach. Results: There were 266 board-certified EPs, 141 (53%) of whom were employed in EDs full-time or part-time. Sixty-two non-EPs also worked in EDs. The EPs were present in the EDs primarily during weekday morning shifts. There were 273 EM residents nationwide. A total of 101 questionnaires were completed and revealed that EPs working part-time in the ED worked fewer hours, received higher salaries, and had more years of experience compared to EPs working full time or not working in the ED. Satisfaction correlated only with working part time. Meaningful work, diversity, and rewarding relationships with patients and colleagues were major positive reasons for working in the ED. Feeling undervalued, carrying a heavy caseload, and having complicated relationships with other hospital departments were reasons against working in the ED. Conclusion: Our study findings showed an increase in the number of trained and in-training EPs, and a decrease in the percentage of board-certified EPs who persevere in the EDs. Emergency medicine in Israel is at a crossroads: more physicians are choosing EM than a decade ago, but retention of board-certified EPs is a major concern, as it is worldwide. We recommend taking measures to maintain trained and experienced EPs working in the ED by allowing part-time ED positions, introducing dedicated academic time, and diversifying EP roles, functioning, and work routine.
Subject(s)
Emergency Medicine , Emergency Service, Hospital , Job Satisfaction , Israel , Humans , Emergency Service, Hospital/statistics & numerical data , Cross-Sectional Studies , Prospective Studies , Surveys and Questionnaires , Female , Male , Physicians/supply & distribution , Workforce/statistics & numerical data , Personnel Staffing and Scheduling/statistics & numerical data , Adult , CertificationABSTRACT
From July 2019 through April 2021, the Latino Center for Health, a bicultural population health research center at the University of Washington, partnered with community stakeholders to generate evidence to inform elected officials about the need to increase the diversity of the state's physician workforce and ultimately improve Latina/o health in Washington state. Legislative efforts resulted in legislation creating goals for the state's medical schools to admit students representative of the state's population diversity and the creation of a new residency pathway for international medical graduates. (Am J Public Health. 2024;114(S6):S467-S471. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2024.307627) [Formula: see text].
Subject(s)
Hispanic or Latino , Humans , Washington , Cultural Diversity , Physicians/supply & distribution , Schools, Medical/organization & administration , Foreign Medical GraduatesABSTRACT
The healthcare industry has long complained about an acute shortage of skilled workers. Vacancies can often only be filled by skilled workers from abroad. While rural areas are increasingly experiencing a shortage of personnel, many urban centers continue to have an oversupply and a sufficient number of young doctors. Hospitals do not expect the situation to improve in the future. Hospitals are trying to counteract the negative development of the job situation in nursing staff. Government intervention can limit the economically motivated adjustment of resource utilization. The demand for staff will not fall as a result of de-economization.
Subject(s)
Health Workforce , Humans , Health Workforce/statistics & numerical data , Health Care Sector/economics , Workforce/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/supply & distribution , Physicians/economicsSubject(s)
Emigrants and Immigrants , Health Equity , Humans , Child , United States , Physicians/supply & distribution , Pediatrics , Health WorkforceABSTRACT
Historically, the physician professional identity and the organizational structure of Western medicine have been defined by masculine norms such as authority and assertiveness. The past five decades have seen a rapid shift in the demographics of attendees as medical schools, with equal numbers of women and men matriculants for nearly twenty years. Gender as a social, cultural, and structural variable continues to influence the physician workforce. The entry of women into medicine, has had far reaching effects on the expectations of patients, the interactions of physicians with other members of the healthcare team, and the delivery of care. Redefining the culture of medicine to accommodate the diversity of the modern workforce may benefit all physician and improve the delivery of healthcare.
Subject(s)
Physicians, Women , Humans , Female , Physicians, Women/statistics & numerical data , Male , Physicians/supply & distribution , Physicians/psychology , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Women, Working/statistics & numerical dataABSTRACT
This Medical News article discusses the great resignation in health care and new efforts to create a sustainable medical workforce in the US.
Subject(s)
Burnout, Professional , COVID-19 , Delivery of Health Care , Physicians , Resilience, Psychological , Humans , Burnout, Professional/prevention & control , COVID-19/psychology , Delivery of Health Care/statistics & numerical data , Health Personnel/psychology , Physicians/psychology , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/supply & distributionABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Academic emergency medicine (EM) is foundational to the EM specialty through the development of new knowledge and clinical training of resident physicians. Despite recent increased attention to the future of the EM workforce, no evaluations have specifically characterized the U.S. academic EM workforce. We sought to estimate the national proportion of emergency physicians (EPs) identified as academic and the proportion of emergency department (ED) visits that take place at academic sites. METHODS: We performed a cross-sectional analysis of EPs and EDs using data from the American Hospital Association, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, and Doximity's Residency Navigator. EPs were identified as "academic" if they were affiliated with at least one facility determined to be academic, defined as EDs officially designated by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) as clinical training sites at accredited EM residency programs. Our primary outcomes were to estimate the national proportion of EPs identified as academic and the proportion of ED visits performed at academic sites. RESULTS: Our analytic sample included 26,937 EPs practicing clinically across 4920 EDs and providing care during 130,471,386 ED visits. Among EPs, 11,720 (43.5%) were identified as academic, and among EDs, 635 (12.9%) were identified as academic sites, including 585 adult/general sites, 45 pediatric-specific sites, and 10 sites affiliated with the Department of Veterans Affairs. In 2021, academic EDs provided care for 42,794,106 ED visits or 32.8% of all ED visits nationally. CONCLUSIONS: Approximately four in 10 EPs practice in at least one clinical training site affiliated with an ACGME-accredited EM residency program, and approximately one in three ED visits nationally occur in these academic EDs. We encourage further work using alternative definitions of an academic EPs and EDs, along with longitudinal research to identify trends in the workforce's composition.
Subject(s)
Emergency Medicine , Emergency Service, Hospital , Physicians , Humans , Cross-Sectional Studies , United States , Emergency Medicine/education , Emergency Service, Hospital/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/supply & distribution , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Academic Medical Centers/statistics & numerical data , Workforce/statistics & numerical data , Internship and Residency/statistics & numerical dataABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Unequal access to primary healthcare (PHC) has become a critical issue in global health inequalities, requiring governments to implement policies tailored to communities' needs and abilities. However, the place-based facility dimension of PHCs is oversimplified in current healthcare literature, and formulating the equity-oriented PHC spatial planning remains challenging without understanding the multiple impacts of community socio-spatial dynamics, particularly in remote areas. This study aims to push the boundary of PHC studies one step further by presenting a nuanced and dynamic understanding of the impact of community environments on the uneven primary healthcare supply. METHODS: Focusing on Shuicheng, a remote rural area in southwestern China, multiple data are included in this village-based study, i.e., the facility-level healthcare statistics data (2016-2019), the statistical yearbooks, WorldPop, and Chinese GDP's spatial distribution data. We evaluate villages' PHC service capacity using the number of doctors and essential equipment per capita, which are the major components of China's PHC delivery. The indicators describing community environments are selected based on extant literature and China's planning paradigms, including town- and village-level factors. Gini coefficients and local spatial autocorrelation analysis are used to present the divergences of PHC capacity, and multilevel regression model and (heterogeneous) difference in difference model are used to examine the driving role of community environments and the dynamics under the policy intervention. RESULTS: Despite the general improvement, PHC inequalities remain significant in remote rural areas. The village's location, aging, topography, ethnic autonomy, and economic conditions significantly influence village-level PHC capacity, while demographic characteristics and healthcare delivery at the town level are also important. Although it may improve the hardware setting in village clinics (coef. = 0.350), the recent equity-oriented policy attempts may accelerate the loss of rural doctors (coef. = - 0.517). Notably, the associations between PHC and community environments are affected inconsistently by this round of policy intervention. The town healthcare centers with higher inpatient service capacity (coef. = - 0.514) and more licensed doctors (coef. = - 0.587) and nurses (coef. = - 0.344) may indicate more detrimental policy effects that reduced the number of rural doctors, while the centers with more professional equipment (coef. = 0.504) and nurses (coef. = 0.184) are beneficial for the improvement of hardware setting in clinics. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that the PHC inequalities are increasingly a result of joint social, economic, and institutional forces in recent years, underlining the increased complexity of the PHC resource allocation mechanism. Therefore, we claim the necessity to incorporate a broader understanding of community orientation in PHC delivery, particularly the interdisciplinary knowledge of the spatial lens of community, to support its sustainable development. Our findings also provide timely policy insights for ongoing primary healthcare reform in China.
Subject(s)
Health Services Accessibility , Primary Health Care , Rural Health Services , Rural Population , China , Humans , Primary Health Care/statistics & numerical data , Health Services Accessibility/statistics & numerical data , Rural Population/statistics & numerical data , Rural Health Services/statistics & numerical data , Health Policy , Physicians/supply & distribution , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Healthcare Disparities , Equipment and Supplies/supply & distributionABSTRACT
Importance: Black physicians are substantially underrepresented in the US health care workforce, with detrimental effects on the health and health care experiences of Black individuals. These contemporary gaps can be traced to the early days of the medical profession using the first edition of the American Medical Directory (AMD). Objective: To identify state- and county-level patterns related to the training and availability of Black physicians relative to their White counterparts in the 1906 AMD. Design, Setting, and Participants: For this cross-sectional study, data for 41â¯828 physician entries in 18 US states in or adjacent to the South as well as the District of Columbia were extracted from the 1906 AMD and aggregated to 1570 counties. Data analysis was performed between September 2023 and January 2024. Exposures: County-level exposure variables included population density, racial composition, and illiteracy rate among US-born White residents as well as an index of terrain ruggedness and the number of lynchings in the previous decade. Median values of physicians' distance from place of practice to place of medical training (by race of physician) were also used as an exposure variable. Main Outcomes and Measures: There were 4 county-level outcomes: (1) presence of any Black physician, (2) proportion of Black physicians per Black population, (3) proportion of White physicians per White population, and (4) community representativeness (reported as the community representativeness ratio). The cross-sectional analysis used generalized additive mixed models with state-level random effects. Results: Across 1570 counties, Black physicians comprised 746 (1.8%) of the 41â¯828 physicians in the dataset. Black physicians tended to train further from their place of practice than their White counterparts. The proportion of Black physicians per 1000 Black residents was 0.08 compared with 1.62 for White physicians; these proportions varied substantially by state. At the county level, the presence of any Black physician was associated with percentage Black population (odds ratio [OR], 28.94 [95% CI, 9.77 to 85.76]; P ≤ .001), population density (OR, 2.63 [95% CI, 2.03 to 3.40]; P ≤ .001), and distance to the nearest Black medical school (OR, 0.62 [95% CI, 0.42 to 0.92]; P = .02). Conclusions and Relevance: A variety of structural disadvantages are illustrated in this cross-sectional study of county-level sociodemographic and geographic characteristics associated with the prevalence of Black physicians in the earliest days of the profession. To demonstrate its broader utility for health disparities research, the dataset has been made publicly available with a visualization platform.
Subject(s)
Black or African American , Physicians , Humans , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/supply & distribution , United States , Cross-Sectional Studies , Black or African American/statistics & numerical data , Male , Prevalence , History, 20th Century , FemaleABSTRACT
The Polish healthcare system faces many problems, among which the shortage of healthcare professionals is one of the most urgent. In less than ten years, more than twenty Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) have been allowed to add medical programmes to their offer, aiming to increase the number of doctors in Poland. Recently, the healthcare system was faced with a proposal to abolish the mandatory postgraduate internship which has been a mandatory component of medical training for years. Two main reforms were considered. The first one focused on the programme of the internship and aimed to update it. The second one recommended an abolition of the internship. The authors of this article analysed the opinions and positions of key players within the system regarding the postgraduate internship. Opinions in this regard are diverse, leading to the conclusion that additional actions would be required prior to the internship abolition. Undergraduate training has changed and currently students are taught in modern facilities, using new teaching methods. On the other hand, internship allows trainees to improve or even acquire skills they may not have obtained during their studies. The postgraduate internship is an essential part of doctors' training. However, in Poland, there is still a lack of a well-thought, long-term policy or strategy for physicians' workforce development. Our study presents a Polish perspective on common challenges in medical training and workforce policy, highlighting the clash over the growing demand for physicians and the limitations of the existing system.
Subject(s)
Internship and Residency , Physicians , Poland , Humans , Physicians/supply & distribution , Education, Medical, GraduateABSTRACT
Rural communities in Alberta, Canada have faced physician shortages for decades. Attracting internationally educated physicians, including many South African physicians, is one way to address this problem. While much of the research on international medical graduates (IMGs) focuses on the push and pull of attraction and retention, I situate the decision to stay as a matter of geographic and professional mobility, all within a life course perspective. More specifically, I explore physicians' decisions to migrate from South Africa to rural Alberta and the impact of professional mobility on their migrations. To understand the processes, I collected data via semi-structured virtual interviews with 29 South African educated generalist/family physicians with experience in rural Alberta. Research was guided by abductive grounded theory and data was analysed using open thematic coding. I found that South African educated physicians made the decision to leave South Africa and to come to Canada to pursue prestige and opportunity they perceived to be inaccessible in South Africa. However, physicians were limited to perceived low prestige work as rural generalists, while they understood that more prestigious work was reserved for Canadian educated physicians. Physicians who remained in rural communities brought their aspirations to life, or achieved upward professional mobility in rural communities, through focused clinical and administrative opportunities. The decision to leave rural communities was often a matter of lifestyle and burnout over prestige.
Subject(s)
Emigration and Immigration , Foreign Medical Graduates , Humans , South Africa , Female , Male , Foreign Medical Graduates/psychology , Foreign Medical Graduates/statistics & numerical data , Alberta , Emigration and Immigration/statistics & numerical data , Adult , Rural Health Services , Qualitative Research , Career Mobility , Rural Population/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/psychology , Physicians/supply & distribution , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Middle AgedABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Many countries faced health workforce challenges even before the pandemic, such as impending retirements, negative population growth, or sub-optimal allocation of resources across health sectors. Current quantitative models are often of limited use, either because they require extensive individual-level data to be properly calibrated, or (in the absence of such data) because they are too simplistic to capture important demographic changes or disruptive epidemiological shocks such as the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. METHODS: We propose a population-dynamic and stock-flow-consistent approach to physician supply forecasting that is complex enough to account for dynamically changing behaviour, while requiring only publicly available time-series data for full calibration. We demonstrate the utility of this model by applying it to 21 European countries to forecast the supply of generalist and specialist physicians to 2040, and the impact of increased healthcare utilisation due to COVID-19 on this supply. RESULTS: Compared with the workforce needed to maintain physician density at 2019 levels, we find that in many countries there is indeed a significant trend towards decreasing generalist density at the expense of increasing specialist density. The trends for specialists are exacerbated by expectations of negative population growth in many Southern and Eastern European countries. Compared to the expected demographic changes in the population and the health workforce, we expect a limited impact of COVID-19 on these trends, even under conservative modelling assumptions. Finally, we generalise the approach to a multi-professional, multi-regional and multi-sectoral model for Austria, where we find an additional suboptimal distribution in the supply of contracted versus non-contracted (private) physicians. CONCLUSION: It is therefore vital to develop tools for decision-makers to influence the allocation and supply of doctors across specialties and sectors to address these imbalances.
Subject(s)
COVID-19 , European Union , Forecasting , Physicians , COVID-19/epidemiology , Humans , Physicians/supply & distribution , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Health Workforce/statistics & numerical data , Health Workforce/trends , SARS-CoV-2 , Pandemics , Europe/epidemiology , Population Dynamics/trendsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Research on health resource allocation trends in ethnic minority and impoverished areas in China is limited since the 2009 Medical Reform. This study aimed to investigate the variations and inequalities in health resource distribution among ethnic minority, poverty-stricken, and non-minority regions in Sichuan Province, a multi-ethnic province in Southwest China, from 2009 to 2019. METHODS: The numbers of beds, doctors and nurses were retrospectively sourced from the Sichuan Health Statistics Yearbook between 2009 and 2019. All the 181 counties in Sichuan Province were categorized into five groups: Yi, Zang, other ethnic minority, poverty-stricken, and non-minority county. The Theil index, adjusted for population size, was used to evaluate health resource allocation inequalities. RESULTS: From 2009 to 2019, the number of beds (Bedp1000), doctors (Docp1000), and nurses (Nurp1000) per 1000 individuals in ethnic minority and poverty-stricken counties consistently remained lower than non-minority counties. The growth rates of Bedp1000 in Yi (140%) and other ethnic minority counties (127%) were higher than in non-minority counties (121%), while the growth rates of Docp1000 in Yi (20%) and Zang (11%) counties were lower than non-minority counties (61%). Docp1000 in 33% and 50% of Yi and Zang ethnic counties decreased, respectively. Nurp1000 in Yi (240%) and other ethnic minority (316%) counties increased faster than non-minority counties (198%). The Theil index for beds and nurses declined, while the index for doctors increased. Key factors driving increases in bed allocation include preferential policies and economic development levels, while health practitioner income, economic development levels and geographical environment significantly influence doctor and nurse allocation. CONCLUSIONS: Preferential policies have been successful in increasing the number of beds in health facilities, but not healthcare workers, in ethnic minority regions. The ethnic disparities in doctor allocation increased in Sichuan Province. To increase the number of doctors and nurses in ethnic minority and poverty-stricken regions, particularly in Yi counties, more preferential policies and resources should be introduced.
Subject(s)
Healthcare Disparities , Humans , China/ethnology , Ethnicity/statistics & numerical data , Healthcare Disparities/ethnology , Healthcare Disparities/statistics & numerical data , Healthcare Disparities/trends , Minority Groups/statistics & numerical data , Nurses/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/statistics & numerical data , Physicians/supply & distribution , Poverty/statistics & numerical data , Resource Allocation , Retrospective Studies , Asian PeopleABSTRACT
La distribución inequitativa del talento humano en salud afecta la capacidad de los sistemas de ofrecer servicios esenciales. En la provincia de Córdoba, el primer nivel de atención es responsabilidad de los municipios, pero el nivel provincial procura sostener la rectoría y ser garante del derecho a la salud. En ese marco, se desarrolló un programa para reducir las brechas en la distribución de médicos: el Plan Cordobés de Médicos del Interior. Acompañando ese plan se ejecutó un convenio específico con la Universidad Nacional de Córdoba para garantizar la formación en la especialidad de Medicina Familiar y General. Ingresaron al programa 170 personas, y hoy contamos con 98 médicos en formación o seguimiento. En este artículo damos cuenta de la experiencia docente, los desafíos y dificultades que supuso afrontar una formación en lugares de práctica variados, y con el aporte de las tecnologías de la información y comunicación. Esperamos que la experiencia sirva para transmitir los aprendizajes de nuestra práctica (AU)
The inequitable distribution of human talent in health affects the capacity of systems to offer essential services. In the province of Córdoba, the primary level of care is the responsibility of municipalities, but the provincial level aims to maintain leadership and guarantee the right to health. Within this framework, a program was developed to reduce gaps in the distribution of physicians: the Cordobés Plan for Interior Physicians. Accompanying this plan, a specific agreement was executed with the National University of Córdoba to ensure training in the specialty of Family and General Medicine. 170 individuals entered the program, and today we have 98 physicians in training or under supervision. In this article, we give an account of the teaching experience, the challenges, and difficulties involved in facing training in various practice settings, along with the contribution of information and communication technologies. We hope that this experience serves to transmit the lessons learned from our practice (AU)