Guest/Host Complexes of Octa Acid and Amphiphilic Benzylidene-3-methylimidazolidinones Exchange Hosts within the NMR Time Scale.

Cavitand octa acid (OA) is established to form a stable capsular assembly with one or two hydrophobic guest molecules (1:2 or 2:2 guest/host complex). Examples are known in which the guest molecule tumbles within the capsule without disrupting the structure of the capsuleplex. This process makes the two OA molecules that form the capsule magnetically equivalent. In this study, we have examined the dynamics of capsules that host amphiphilic benzylidene-3-methylimidazolidinone molecules as guests. In these capsuleplexes, although the guest does not tumble, the two OA molecules become magnetically equivalent because the two OA molecules that form the capsule exchange their positions in the NMR time scale. This is equivalent to the content of the capsule remaining stationary while the capsule swirls around it. Benzylidene-3-methylimidazolidinones form both 1:1 and 1:2 supramolecular complexes with cavitand OA. Two-dimensional NMR, ROESY, and NOESY data suggest that in a 300 ms time scale, the two halves of the capsule exchange between themselves and with free OA. The conclusion drawn here provides valuable information concerning the stability of the OA capsuleplex and cavitandplex that is used as the well-defined space to control the excited-state chemistry and dynamics of confined guest molecules.

A latent reaction in a model GFP chromophore revealed upon confinement: photohydroxylation of ortho-halo benzylidene-3-methylimidazolidiones via an electrocylization process.

Excited state behavior of halogen substituted model GFP chromophores was investigated in an acetonitrile solution and in a confined environment provided by an octa acid capsule in water. Of the ortho, meta, and para halogen substituted GFP chromophores only the ortho compounds gave a new product resulting from an unprecedented photosubstitution of halogens by the hydroxyl group. This unusual reaction highlights the importance of confined spaces in bringing about some unattainable photoreactions.

Collapse and recovery of green fluorescent protein chromophore emission through topological effects.

Housed within the 11-stranded ß-barrel of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) is the arylideneimidazolidinone (AMI) chromophore, the component responsible for fluorescence. This class of small-molecule chromophore has drawn significant attention for its remarkable photophysical and photochemical properties, both within the intact protein and after its denaturation. All of the proteins so far isolated that have visible light fluorescence have been found to contain an AMI chromophore. These proteins comprise an extensive rainbow, ranging from GFP, which contains the simplest chromophore, p-hydroxybenzylideneimidazolidinone (p-HOBDI), to proteins having molecules with longer conjugation lengths and a variety of intraprotein interactions. The fluorescence invariably almost vanishes upon removal of the protective ß-barrel. The role of the barrel in hindering internal conversion has been the subject of numerous studies, especially in our laboratories and those of our collaborators. A better understanding of these chromophores has been facilitated by the development of numerous synthetic protocols. These syntheses, which commonly use the Erlenmeyer azlactone method, have evolved in recent years with the development of a [2 + 3] cycloaddition exploited in our laboratory. The synthetic AMI chromophores have allowed delineation of the complex photophysics of GFP and its derivatives. Upon denaturation, AMI chromophores are marked by 4 orders of magnitude of diminution in emission quantum yield (EQY). This result is attributed to internal conversion resulting from conformational freedom in the released chromophore, which is not allowed within the restrictive ß-barrel. To date, the photophysical properties of the AMI chromophore remain elusive and have been attributed to a variety of mechanisms, including cis-trans isomerization, triplet formation, hula twisting, and proton transfer. Advanced studies involving gas-phase behavior, solvent effects, and protonation states have significantly increased our understanding of the chromophore photophysics, but a comprehensive picture is only slowly emerging. Most importantly, mechanisms in structurally defined chromophores may provide clues as to the origin of the "blinking" behavior of the fluorescent proteins themselves. One approach to examining the effect of conformational freedom on rapid internal conversion of the chromophores is to restrict the molecules, both through structural modifications and through adjustments of the supramolecular systems. We thus include here a discussion of studies involving the crystalline state, inclusion within natural protein-binding pockets, complexation with metal ions, and sequestration within synthetic cavities; all of this research affirms the role of restricting conformational freedom in partially restoring the EQY. Additionally, new photochemistry is observed within these restricted systems. Many of the studies carried out in our laboratories show promise for these molecules to be adapted as molecular probes, wherein inclusion turns on the fluorescence and provides a signaling mechanism. In this Account, we present an overview of the AMI chromophores, including synthesis, overall photophysics, and supramolecular behavior. A significant amount of work remains for researchers to fully understand the properties of these chromophores, but important progress achieved thus far in photophysics and photochemistry is underscored here.

Fluorescence turn on by cholate aggregates.

Bile salts, including sodium cholate (NaCh), are amphiphilic molecules with a concave hydrophilic side and a convex hydrophobic side. By forming aggregates in aqueous solution, these natural surfactants fulfill vital biological roles in the solubilization of cholesterol, lipids, and fat-soluble vitamins and thus are involved in the transport and absorption of important biological molecules. Following our success with the encapsulation of fluorescent protein chromophore (FP) analogs by synthetic hydrophobic and hydrophilic hosts, based upon substitution patterns, we now report the binding and turn on of other analogs by bile salt aggregates, observations which may lead to new tools for studying trafficking in these important systems.

Recapture of GFP chromophore fluorescence in a protein host.

When encapsulated by human serum albumin (HSA), certain derivatives of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) chromophore recover their fluorescence due to inhibition of torsional motion. These derivatives show remarkable sensitivity and selectivity as well as favorable spectroscopic properties toward HSA, thus providing selective probes for this and similar proteins and demonstrating the use of GFP chromophores as topological fluorophores.

Chemically modulating the photophysics of the GFP chromophore.

There is growing interest in engineering the properties of fluorescent proteins through modifications to the chromophore structure utilizing mutagenesis with either natural or unnatural amino acids. This entails an understanding of the photophysical and photochemical properties of the modified chromophore. In this work, a range of GFP chromophores with different alkyl substituents are synthesized and their electronic spectra, pH dependence, and ultrafast fluorescence decay kinetics are investigated. The weakly electron donating character of the alkyl substituents leads to dramatic red shifts in the electronic spectra of the anions, which are accompanied by increased fluorescence decay times. This high sensitivity of electronic structure to substitution is also characteristic of some fluorescent proteins. The solvent viscosity dependence of the decay kinetics are investigated, and found to be consistent with a bimodal radiationless relaxation coordinate. Some substituents are shown to distort the planar structure of the chromophore, which results in a blue shift in the electronic spectra and a strong enhancement of the radiationless decay. The significance of these data for the rational design of novel fluorescent proteins is discussed.

Fluorescence response profiling for small molecule sensors utilizing the green fluorescent protein chromophore and its derivatives.

Using a fluorescence response profile, a systematic examination was performed for synthetic chromophores of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) to discover new small molecule sensors. A group of 41 benzylideneimidazolinone compounds (BDI) was prepared and screened toward 94 biologically relevant analytes to generate fluorescence response profiles. From the response pattern, compounds containing aminobenzyl and heteroaromatic cyclic substructures revealed a pH dependent emission decrease effect, and unlike other fluorescence scaffolds, most BDIs showed fluorescence quenching when mixed with proteins. On the basis of the primary response profile, we obtained three selective fluorescence turn-on sensors for pH, human serum albumin (HSA), and total ribonucleic acid (RNA). Following analysis, a fluorescence response profile testing four nucleic acids revealed the alkyloxy (Ph-OR) functional group in the para position of benzyl analogues contributes to RNA selectivity. Among the primary hit compounds, BDI 2 showed outstanding selectivity toward total RNA with 5-fold emission enhancement. Finally, BDI 24 showed selective fluorescence increase to HSA (K(d) = 3.57 µM) with a blue-shifted emission max wavelength (Δλ(em) = 15 nm). These examples of fluorescence sensor discovery by large-scale fluorescence response profiling demonstrate the general applicability of this approach and the usefulness of the response profiles.

Steric and electronic effects in capsule-confined green fluorescent protein chromophores.

The turn-on of emission in fluorescent protein chromophores sequestered in an "octaacid" capsule is controlled by stereoelectronic effects described by a linear free energy relationship. The stereochemical effects are governed by both the positions and volumes of the aryl substituents, while the electronic effects, including ortho effects, can be treated with Hammett σ parameters. The use of substituent volumes rather than A values reflects packing of the molecule within the confines of the capsule.

Inhibition of twisting of a green fluorescent protein-like chromophore by metal complexation.

Substitution of a pyridyl for the hydroxyphenyl moiety in the Green Fluorescent Protein analog p-hydroxybenzylidene-dimethylimidiazolinone produces a chromophore which "turns on" fluorescence in the presence of Zn(2+) or Cd(2+) ions. Such a phenomenon provides "proof of principle" for using GFP chromophores in a variety of sensing applications.

Topochemistry and photomechanical effects in crystals of green fluorescent protein-like chromophores: effects of hydrogen bonding and crystal packing.

To obtain insight into the effects of the environment on the photophysics and photochemistry of the green fluorescence protein (GFP), eight crystal structures of six synthetic aryl-substituted analogues (2-fluoro, 2-methyl, 3-hydroxy, 3-methoxy, 2,4-dimethyl and 2,5-dimethyl) of the GFP chromophore (4-hydroxy-benzylidenedimethylimidazolinone) were determined and correlated with their two-dimensional steady-state and time-resolved solid-state excitation-emission spectra. The stacking between the molecules greatly affected the emission energy and the lifetime of the emission of the chromophore, implying that pi-pi interactions could be critical for the photophysics of GFP. The reaction pathways were dependent on the excitation energy, resulting either in [2 + 2] photodimerization at the bridging double bond (UV excitation) or flipping of the imidazolone ring (visible excitation). The meta-hydroxy chromophore (3-HOBDI) was the only GFP-chromophore analogue that was obtained as more than one stable polymorph in the pure state thus far. Due to the asymmetric substitution with hydrogen bond donors and acceptors, 3-HOBDI is tetramorphic, the forms showing distinctly different structure and behavior: (1) while one of the polymorphs (3-HOBDI-A), having multilayer structure with alternating stereochemistry of linear hydrogen-bonded motifs, undergoes photodimerization under UV light, (2) another (3-HOBDI-C), which has dimeric head-to-tail structure, shows Z-to-E isomerization via tau-one-bond flip of the imidazolone ring by excitation in the visible region. X-ray diffraction analysis of a partially reacted single crystal of 3-HOBDI-C provided the first direct evidence of tau-one-bond flip occurring in a GFP-like compound. Moreover, the cooperative action of the photodimerization of 3-HOBDI-A appears as a photomechanical effect of unprecedented magnitude for a single crystalline specimen, where photoexcited single crystals bend to more than 90 degrees without breaking.

Activation of fluorescent protein chromophores by encapsulation.

Chromophores related to fluorescent proteins, when sequestered into the "octaacid" capsule, recover their fluorescence. The fluorescence recovery is related to the inhibition of torsional motions within the cavity, implicating the single-bond torsion as an important contributor to internal conversion within this important class of chromophores.

Isomerization in fluorescent protein chromophores involves addition/elimination.

The green fluorescent protein (GFP) chromophore undergoes both photochemical and thermal isomerizations. Typically, the Z form is more stable and undergoes photochemical conversion to the E form followed by thermal reversion over a period of seconds or minutes. Although the mechanism of the thermal reversion has been the subject of some investigations, the surprisingly low activation energy for this process has not sparked any controversy. We now show that the chromophore is surprisingly stable in both E and Z forms and that the facile thermal reversion is the result of a novel nucleophilic addition/elimination mechanism. This observation may have implications for the intervention of such processes, as well as blinking and kindling, in fluorescent proteins.