A multi-technique analytical approach to support (eco)toxicological investigation of zinc oxide nanoparticles.

Understanding the mechanism of toxicity of nanoparticles and their behavior in biological environments is crucial for designing materials with reduced side effects and improved performance. Among the factors influencing nanoparticle behavior in biological environments, the release and bioavailability of potentially toxic metal ions can alter equilibria and cause adverse effects. In this study, we applied two on-line Field-Flow Fractionation (FFF) strategies and compared the results with off-line benchmarking centrifugal ultrafiltration to assess a key descriptor, namely the solubility of zinc oxide (ZnO) nanoparticles. We found that, at the highest nanoparticle concentrations, the nanoparticle-ion ratio quickly reaches equilibrium, and the stability is not significantly affected by the separation technique. However, at lower concentrations, dynamic, non-equilibrium behavior occurs, and the results depend on the method used to separate the solid from the ionic fraction, where FFF yielded a more representative dissolution pattern. To support the (eco)toxicological profiling of the investigated nanoparticles, we generated experimental data on colloidal stability over typical (eco)toxicological assay durations. The Zeta Potential vs pH curves revealed two distinct scenarios typical of surfaces that have undergone significant modification, most likely due to pH-dependent dissolution and re-precipitation of surface groups. Finally, to enhance hazard assessment screening, we investigated ion-dependent toxicity and the effects of exposure to fresh water. Using an in vitro human skin model, we evaluated the cytotoxicity of fresh and aged ZnO nanoparticles (exposed for 72 h in M7), revealing time-dependent, dose-dependent, and nanoparticle-dependent cytotoxicity, with lower toxicity observed in the case of aged samples.

Are nano-colloids controlling rare earth elements mobility or is it the opposite? Insight from A4F-UV-QQQ-ICP-MS.

Rare earth element (REE) mobility in the environment is expected to be controlled by colloids. Recent research has detailed the structure of iron-organic colloids (Fe-OM colloids), which include both large colloids and smaller nano-colloids. To assess how these nano-colloids affect REE mobility, their interactions with REE and calcium (Ca) were investigated at pH 4 and 6. Using Asymmetric Flow Field Flow Fractionation (A4F) combined with UV and Triple Quadrupole Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (QQQ-ICP-MS), Fe-OM nano-colloids were separated from bulk Fe-OM colloids and their REE and Ca content were analyzed. Without REE and Ca, nano-colloids had an average diameter of approximately 25 nm. Their structure is pH-dependent, with aggregation increasing as pH decreases. At high REE loadings (REE/Fe ≥ 0.05), REE induced a size increase of nano-colloids, regardless of pH. Heavy REE (HREE), with their high affinity for organic matter, formed strong complexes with Fe-OM colloids, resulting in large aggregates. In contrast, light REE (LREE), which bind less strongly to organic molecules, were associated with the smallest nano-colloids. Low REE loading did not cause noticeable fractionation. Calcium further enhanced the aggregation process at both pH levels by neutralizing the charges on nano-colloids. These findings indicate that REE can act as aggregating agent controlling their own mobility, and regulating colloid transfer.

Development of an advanced separation and characterization platform for mRNA and lipid nanoparticles using multi-detector asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation.

In recent years, the use of lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) for delivery of messenger RNA (mRNA)-based therapies has gained substantial attention in the field of drug development. In such an application, multiple LNP attributes have to be carefully characterized to ensure product safety and quality, whereas accurate and efficient characterization of these complex mRNA-LNP formulations remains a challenging endeavor. Here, we present the development and application of an online separation and characterization platform designed for the isolation and in-depth analysis of mRNAs and mRNA-loaded LNPs. Our asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation with a multi-detector (MD-AF4) method has demonstrated exceptional resolution between mRNA-LNPs and mRNAs, delivering excellent recoveries (over 70%) for both analytes and exceptional repeatability. Notably, this platform allows for comprehensive and multi-attribute LNP characterization, including online particle sizing, morphology characterization, and determination of encapsulation efficiency, all within a single injection. Furthermore, real-time online sizing by synchronizing multi-angle light scattering (MALS) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) presented higher resolution over traditional batch-mode DLS, particularly in differentiating heterogeneous samples with a low abundance of large-sized particles. Additionally, our method proves to be a valuable tool for monitoring LNP stability under varying stress conditions. Our work introduces a robust and versatile analytical platform using MD-AF4 that not only efficiently provides multi-attribute characterizations of mRNA-LNPs but also holds promise in advancing studies related to formulation screening, quality control, and stability assessment in the evolving field of nanoparticle delivery systems for mRNAs.

Physicochemical profiling of nanomedicines using centrifugal field flow fractionation.

Nanomedicines comprise multiple components, and particle density is considered an important property that regulates the biodistribution of administered nanomedicines. The density of nanoparticles is characterized by centrifugal methods, such as analytical ultracentrifugation. Particle size and distribution are key physicochemical and quality attributes of nanomedicines. In this study, we developed a novel profiling method applicable to liposomes and lipid nanoparticles (LNPs), based on particle size and density, using centrifugal field-flow fractionation (CF3). We evaluated the elution profiles of PEGylated liposomes of different sizes with various doxorubicin (DOX)-loading amounts using CF3. This method was applied to evaluate the drug release of DOX-loaded liposomes, intra- and inter-batch variability, reconstitution reproducibility of AmBisome®, and elution characteristics of LNPs in COVID-19 vaccines (Comirnaty® and SpikevaxTM). The data obtained in the present study underscore the significance of the proposed methodology and highlight the importance of profiling and characterizing liposomes and LNPs using CF3 fractograms and a multi-angle light-scattering detector.

Optimized AF4 combined with density cushion ultracentrifugation enables profiling of high-purity human blood extracellular vesicles.

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) have emerged as a promising tool for clinical liquid biopsy. However, the identification of EVs derived from blood samples is hindered by the presence of abundant plasma proteins, which impairs the downstream biochemical analysis of EV-associated proteins and nucleic acids. Here, we employed optimized asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) combined with density cushion ultracentrifugation (UC) to obtain high-purity and intact EVs with very low lipoprotein contamination from human plasma and serum. Further proteomic analysis revealed more than 1000 EV-associated proteins, a large proportion of which has not been previously reported. Specifically, we found that cell-line-derived EV markers are incompatible with the identification of plasma-EVs and proposed that the proteins MYCT1, TSPAN14, MPIG6B and MYADM, as well as the traditional EV markers CD63 and CD147, are plasma-EV markers. Benefiting from the high-purity of EVs, we conducted comprehensive miRNA profiling of plasma EVs and nanosized particles (NPs), as well as compared plasma- and serum-derived EVs, which provides a valuable resource for the EV research community. Overall, our findings provide a comprehensive assessment of human blood EVs as a basis for clinical biopsy applications.

Size exclusion chromatography and asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation for structural characterization of polysaccharides: A comparative review.

Natural polysaccharides exhibit a wide range of biological activities, which are closely related to their structural characteristics, including their molecular weight distribution, size, monosaccharide composition, glycosidic bond types and spatial conformation, etc. Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4), as two potent separation techniques, both harbor potential for continuous development and enhancement. This manuscript reviewed the fundamental principles and separation applications of SEC and AF4. The structural information and spatial conformation of polysaccharides can be obtained using SEC or AF4 coupled with multiple detectors. In addition, this manuscript elaborates in detail on the shear degradation of samples such as polysaccharides separated by SEC. In addition, the abnormal elution that occurs during the application of the two methods is also discussed. Both SEC and AF4 possess considerable potential for ongoing development and refinement, thereby offering increased possibilities and opportunities for polysaccharide separation and characterization.

Delicate Analysis of Interacting Proteins and Their Assemblies by Flow Field-Flow Fractionation Techniques.

We study the efficiency of several asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) techniques to investigate self-associating wheat gluten proteins. We compare the use of a denaturing buffer including sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and a mild chaotropic solvent, water/ethanol, as the eluent, on a model gluten sample. Through a thorough analysis of the data obtained from coupled light scattering detectors and with the identification of molecular composition of the eluted protein, we evidence coelution events in several conditions. We show that the focus step used in conventional AF4 with the SDS buffer leads to the formation of aggregates that coelute with monomeric proteins. By contrast, a frit-inlet device enables the fractionation of individual wheat proteins in the SDS buffer. Interestingly conventional AF4, using water/ethanol as eluent, is an effective method for fractionating gluten proteins and their complex dynamic assemblies, which involve weak forces and are composed of both monomeric and polymeric proteins.

On-line coupling of hollow-fiber flow field-flow fractionation and depolarized multi-angle static light scattering (HF5/D-MALS). Proof of principle.

Introduced here is the on-line coupling of hollow-fiber flow field-flow fractionation (HF5) to depolarized multi-angle static light scattering (D-MALS). HF5 is a size-based separation alternative to size-exclusion and hydrodynamic chromatography and asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation. HF5 can separate larger sizes than its chromatographic counterparts and provides several advantages over its fractionation counterpart, including reduced sample consumption and greater ease of operation. D-MALS is a variant of MALS in which the depolarized scattering from the analyte solution is measured at a variety of angles simultaneously. Measurements of depolarized scattering have previously been employed in studying the optical properties of solutions or suspensions, to determine the length of rod-like analytes, and to gain increased accuracy in the determination of analyte molar mass. The coupling HF5/D-MALS allows for the depolarization ratio of a solution or suspension to be measured continuously across the fractogram. This is demonstrated here for a Teflon latex the size range of which extends beyond that accessible to commercial size-exclusion columns. The results presented provide the first reported on-line HF5/D-MALS coupling, showing the feasibility of the technique as well as its realized potential for providing continuous depolarization measurements, inter alia.

Sedimentation field-flow fractionation for rapid phenotypic antimicrobial susceptibility testing: a pilot study.

BACKGROUND: The increase in antibiotic resistance is a major public health issue. The development of rapid antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) methods is becoming a priority to ensure early and appropriate antibiotic therapy. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate sedimentation field-flow fractionation (SdFFF) as a method for performing AST in less than 3 h. METHODS: SdFFF is based on the detection of early biophysical changes in bacteria, using a chromatographic-type technology. One hundred clinical Escherichia coli strains were studied. A calibrated bacterial suspension was incubated for 2 h at 37°C in the absence (untreated) or presence (treated) of five antibiotics used at EUCAST breakpoint concentrations. Bacterial suspensions were then injected into the SdFFF machine. For each E. coli isolate, retention times and elution profiles of antibiotic-treated bacteria were compared with retention times and elution profiles of untreated bacteria. Algorithms comparing retention times and elution profiles were used to determine if the strain was susceptible or resistant. Performance evaluation was done according to CLSI and the ISO standard 20776-2:2021 with broth microdilution used as the reference method. RESULTS: AST results from SdFFF were obtained in less than 3 h. SdFFF showed high categorical agreement (99.8%), sensitivity (99.5%) and specificity (100.0%) with broth microdilution. Results for each antimicrobial were also in agreement with the ISO 20776-2 recommendations, with sensitivity and specificity of ≥95.0%. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed that SdFFF can be used as a rapid, accurate and reliable phenotypic AST method with a turnaround time of less than 3 h.

Comprehensive analysis of colloid formation, distribution, and properties of monovarietal red wines using asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation with online multidetection.

Red wine colloids, crucial in determining wine quality and stability, are understudied due to inadequate techniques for studying them effectively in the natural wine environment. Recently, Asymmetrical Flow Field-flow Fractionation (AF4) with online multidetection has emerged as a novel analytical tool for quantifying, fractionating, and characterizing red wine colloids in their native state. This study aimed to characterize the colloidal composition of 24 monovarietal Italian wines produced without filtration, oak contact, fining treatments, malolactic fermentation, macerating enzymes or ageing on yeast lees. AF4 analysis allowed quantification and characterization of wine colloids based on light scattering signal (MALS; gyration radius - Rg), size (hydrodynamic radius - Rh) and absorbance (A280 & A520 nm). The results showed that each wine contained up to five distinct colloids' populations, varying in size and gyration radii. Despite possessing very similar Rh, most colloids exhibited great differences in compactness, as indicated by their varying Rg values. Comparing the A280 signal of whole wines to those of wines containing only species larger than 5 kDa (considered colloids) allowed to calculate the percentage of molecules involved in colloidal particles assembly, ranging from 1 to 44 % of the total A280 absorbing compounds, reflecting the diversity among wines. The A520 signal indicated the presence of polymeric pigments in the colloidal fraction. Notably, colored colloids all had Rg > 20 nm, indicating their association with other colloidal-forming compounds. This observation led to the conclusion that, apart from free anthocyanins and polymeric pigments, the color of red wines is also due to colloidal particles formed by the latter bound to proteins, with their quantity being highly variable across wines of different origin. These findings, which highlight the fundamental role of proteins in shaping the colloidal status of red wines, were utilized to propose an updated hypothetical model for colloidal aggregation in red wine.

Centrifugal Field-Flow Fractionation Enables Detection of Slight Aggregation of Nanoparticles That Impacts Their Biomedical Applications.

Nanoparticles (NPs) are anticipated to be used for various biomedical applications in which their aggregation has been an important issue. However, concerns regarding slightly aggregated but apparently monodispersed NPs have been difficult to address because of a lack of appropriate evaluation methods. Here, we report centrifugal field-flow fractionation (CF3) as a powerful method for analyzing the slight aggregation of NPs, using antibody-modified gold NPs (Ab-AuNPs) prepared by a conventional protocol with centrifugal purification as a model. While common evaluation methods such as dynamic light scattering cannot detect significant signs of aggregation, CF3 successfully detects distinct peaks of slightly aggregated NPs, including dimers and trimers. Their impact on biological interactions was also demonstrated by a cellular uptake study: slightly aggregated Ab-AuNPs exhibited 1.8 times higher cellular uptake than monodispersed Ab-AuNPs. These results suggest the importance of aggregate evaluation via CF3 as well as the need for careful attention to the bioconjugation procedures for NPs.

Comparison of a thickness-tapered channel in flow field-flow fractionation with a conventional channel with flow rate programming.

The thickness-tapered channel structure in flow field-flow fractionation (FlFFF), recently introduced by constructing a channel with a linear decrease in thickness along its length, demonstrated effectiveness in steric/hyperlayer separation of supramicron particles with improvements in separation speed, elution recovery, and an expanded dynamic size range of separation. In this study, we conducted a comparative analysis of the performance between the impact of field (or crossflow rate) programming or outflow rate programming for the separation of polystyrene latex standards (50 ∼ 800 nm) with a conventional channel having uniform thickness and a thickness-tapered channel without programming. Outlet flow rate and crossflow rate conditions were also varied. Although the particle size resolution of the tapered channel does not surpass that of field programming in uniform thickness channel, it achieves higher-speed separation without a significant loss of resolution and without the need for a complex flow controller system even at a low outflow rate condition. Furthermore, it yielded an improved resolution for particles close to the steric transition regime (400 ∼ 600 nm) in the normal mode of separation. Due to the continuous increase in mean flow velocity down the channel, the tapered channel exhibits flexibility in separating submicron-sized particles at high crossflow rate conditions or low outflow rate conditions, of which the latter can be advantageous when coupled with mass spectrometry in a miniaturized setup.

Assessment of Protein Binding Using Asymmetric-Flow Field-Flow Fractionation Combined with Multi-angle Light Scattering and Dynamic Light Scattering.

Asymmetric-flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) is a valuable tool to separate and assess different size populations in nanotherapeutics. When coupled with both static light scattering and dynamic light scattering, it can be used to qualitatively assess protein binding to nanoparticles by comparing the shape factors for both non-plasma-incubated samples and plasma-incubated samples. The shape factor is defined as the ratio of the derived root mean square radius (by static light scattering) to the measured hydrodynamic radius (by dynamic light scattering). The shape factor gives an idea of where the center of mass lies in a nanoparticle, and any shift in the shape factor to larger values is indicative of a mass addition to the periphery of the nanoparticle and suggests the presence of protein binding. This protocol will discuss how to set up an experiment to assess protein binding in nanoparticles using AF4, multi-angle light scattering (MALS), and dynamic light scattering (DLS).

Nanoparticle Size Distribution and Stability Assessment Using Asymmetric-Flow Field-Flow Fractionation.

Nanomaterials are inherently polydisperse. Traditional techniques, such as the widely used batch-mode dynamic light-scattering (DLS) analysis, are not ideal nor thoroughly descriptive enough to define the full complexity of these materials. Asymmetric-flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) with various in-line detectors, such as ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis), multi-angle light scattering (MALS), refractive index (RI), and DLS, is an alternative technique that can provide flow-mode analysis of not only size distribution but also shape, drug release/stability, and protein binding.

Characterization of molar mass and conformation of relevant (non-)starch polysaccharides in cereal-based beverages.

Arabinoxylans, ß-glucans, and dextrins influence the brewing industry's filtration process and product quality. Despite their relevance, only a maximum concentration of ß-glucans is recommended. Nevertheless, filtration problems are still present, indicating that although the chemical concentration is essential, other parameters should be investigated. Molar mass and conformation are important polymer physical characteristics often neglected in this industry. Therefore, this research proposes an approach to physically characterize enzymatically isolated beer polysaccharides by asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation coupled to multi-angle light scattering and differential refractive index detector. Based on the obtained molar masses, root-mean-square radius (rrms from MALS), and hydrodynamic radius (rhyd), conformational properties such as apparent density (ρapp) and rrms/rhyd can be calculated based on their molar mass and size. Consequently, the ρapp and rrms/rhyd behavior hints at the different structures within each polysaccharide. The rrms/rhyd 1.2 and high ρapp values on low molar mass dextrins (1-2·105 g/mol) indicate branches, while aggregated structures at high molar masses on arabinoxylans and ß-glucans (2·105 -6·106 g/mol) are due to an increase of ρapp and a rrms/rhyd (0.6-1). This methodology provides a new perspective to analyze starch and non-starch polysaccharides in cereal-based beverages since different physical characteristics could influence beer's filtration and sensory characteristics.

Quantitative determination of the intracellular uptake of silica nanoparticles using asymmetric flow field flow fractionation coupled with ICP mass spectrometry and their cytotoxicity in HepG2 cells.

We established a size separation method for silica nanoparticles (SiNPs) measuring 10, 30, 50, 70, and 100 nm in diameter using asymmetric flow field flow fractionation hyphenated with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (AF4-ICP-MS), and evaluated the cytotoxicity of SiNPs in human hepatoma HepG2 cells. Analysis of the mixture sample revealed that nanoparticles of different sizes were eluted at approximately 2-min intervals, with no effect on each elution time or percentage recovery. Compared with larger SiNPs, smaller SiNPs exhibited high cytotoxicity when the volume of SiNPs exposed to the cells was the same. We measured SiNPs in culture medium and inside cells by AF4-ICP-MS and found that approximately 17% of SiNPs in the mixture of five differently sized particles were absorbed by the cells. Transmission electron microscopy revealed that 10 nm SiNPs formed aggregates and accumulated in the cells. Based on AF4-ICP-MS analysis, there is no clear difference in the particle volume absorbed by the cells among different sizes. Therefore, the high toxicity of small SiNPs can be explained by the fact that their large surface area relative to particle volume efficiently induces toxicological influences. Indeed, the large surface area of 10 nm SiNPs significantly contributed to the production of reactive oxygen species.

Rapid and green discrimination of bovine milk according to fat content, thermal treatment, brand and manufacturer via colloidal fingerprinting.

Addressing food safety and detecting food fraud while fulfilling greenness requisites for analysis is a challenging but necessary task. The use of sustainable techniques, with limited pretreatment, non-toxic chemicals, high throughput results, is recommended. A combination of Field Flow Fractionation (FFF), working in saline carrier and with minimal preprocessing, and chemometrics was for the first time applied to bovine milk grouping. A set of 47 bovine milk samples was analyzed: a single analysis yielded a characteristic multidimensional colloidal dataset, that once processed with multivariate tools allowed simultaneously for different discriminations: fat content, thermal treatment, brand and manufacturing plant. The analytical methodology is fast, green, simple, and inexpensive and could offer great help in the field of quality control and frauds identification. This work represents also the first attempt to identify milk sub-typologies based on colloidal profiles, and the most complete study concerning multivariate analysis of FFF fingerprint.

Field-flow fractionation - an excellent tool for fractionation, isolation and/or purification of biomacromolecules.

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) with its several variants, has developed into a mature methodology. The scope of the FFF investigations has expanded, covering both a wide range of basic studies and especially a wide range of analytical applications. Special attention of this review is given to the achievements of FFF with reference to recent applications in the fractionation, isolation, and purification of biomacromolecules, and from which especially those of (in alphabetical order) bacteria, cells, extracellular vesicles, liposomes, lipoproteins, nucleic acids, and viruses and virus-like particles. In evaluating the major approaches and trends demonstrated since 2012, the most significant biomacromolecule applications are compiled in tables. It is also evident that asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation is by far the most dominant technique in the studies. The industry has also shown current interest in FFF and adopted it in some sophisticated fields. FFF, in combination with appropriate detectors, handles biomacromolecules in open channel in a gentle way due to the lack of shear forces and unwanted interactions caused by the stationary phase present in chromatography. In addition, in isolation and purification of biomacromolecules quite high yields can be achieved under optimal conditions.

Sedimentation Field-Flow Fractionation: A Diagnostic Tool for Rapid Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing.

Conventional antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) methods require 24-48 h to provide results, creating the need for a probabilistic antibiotic therapy that increases the risk of antibiotic resistance emergence. Consequently, the development of rapid AST methods has become a priority. Over the past decades, sedimentation field-flow fractionation (SdFFF) has demonstrated high sensitivity in early monitoring of induced biological events in eukaryotic cell populations. This proof-of-concept study aimed at investigating SdFFF for the rapid assessment of bacterial susceptibility to antibiotics. Three bacterial species were included (Escherichia coli, Klebsiella pneumoniae, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa) with two panels of antibiotics tailored to each bacterial species. The results demonstrate that SdFFF, when used in "Hyperlayer" elution mode, enables monitoring of antibiotic-induced morphological changes. The percentage variation of the retention factor (PΔR) was used to quantify the biological effect of antibiotics on bacteria with the establishment of a threshold value of 16.8% to differentiate susceptible and resistant strains. The results obtained with SdFFF were compared to that of the AST reference method, and a categorical agreement of 100% was observed. Overall, this study demonstrates the potential of SdFFF as a rapid method for the determination of antibiotic susceptibility or resistance since it is able to provide results within a shorter time frame than that needed for conventional methods (3-4 h vs 16-24 h, respectively), enabling earlier targeted antibiotic therapy. Further research and validation are necessary to establish the effectiveness and reliability of SdFFF in clinical settings.

Increasing the Resolution of Field-Flow Fractionation with Increasing Crossflow Gradients.

The resolution of flow field-flow fractionation (flow FFF) depends primarily on the crossflow rate and its change over time. In this work, we demonstrate a method for modulation of the crossflow rate during separation that increases the peak-to-peak resolution of the resulting fractograms. In classical FFF methods, the crossflow rate is either maintained constant or decreased during the separation of the different species. In this work, higher resolution between peaks was achieved by a novel gradient method in which the crossflow is increased briefly during separation to allow stronger retention of the later eluting peaks. We first outline the theoretical basis by which improved separation is achieved. We confirm our hypothesis by quantifying the impact of increasing crossflow on the resolution between a monoclonal antibody monomer and its high-molecular-weight aggregate. We then demonstrate that this method is applicable to two different FFF methods (AF4 and HF5) and various pharmaceutically relevant samples (monoclonal antibodies and adeno-associated viruses). Finally, we hypothesize that increasing the force perpendicular to the laminar flow as described here is broadly applicable to all FFF methods and improves the quality of FFF-based separations.