A meta-analysis of clinical manifestations in asian systemic lupus erythematous: The effects of ancestry, ethnicity and gender.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVES: Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in Asians is a unique patient group that has been thought to present with more severe organ involvement in comparison to their non-Asian counterparts. We set out to perform a meta-analysis to compare clinical manifestations between ancestries, with a focus on Southeast Asian ethnicities and gender. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A cross-sectional study was performed in conjunction with a meta-analysis to identify differences in prevalences of SLE clinical manifestations. Searches were conducted on Medline for articles comparing between (i) Asian and non-Asian ancestry; (ii) Southeast Asian ethnicities (Chinese, Malay and Indian); and (iii) male and female Asians. Using random effects model, effect sizes as odd ratios were pooled with DerSimonian and Laird's model. RESULTS: A total of 13 articles were identified and pooled together with our study for this meta-analysis. Comparing among patients of Asian with Non-Asian/European ancestries, no significance difference was found in severe organ manifestations such as renal and neurological involvement [odds ratio (OR) 1.398, p= 0.320 and OR 1.224, p= 0.526 respectively]. There was significantly greater proportion of Asian SLE patients with thrombocytopenia compared to non-Asian SLE. Chinese SLE patients were less likely to have oral ulcers compared to Indian SLE patients. Lastly, Asian male SLE patients had greater incidence of renal involvement and thrombocytopenia compared to Asian female SLE patients. CONCLUSIONS: Severe SLE manifestations such as renal and neurological involvement were not significantly more frequent in Asian SLE compared to non-Asian/European SLE in this analysis.