Comparative evaluation of radionuclide therapy using 90Y and 177Lu.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: Both 90Y and 177Lu are attractive ß-emitters for radionuclide therapy and have been used in clinical practice. Nevertheless, comparative evaluation between 90Y- and 177Lu-labeled molecules has not been fully conducted. Thus, in this study, the features of 90Y and 177Lu for radionuclide therapy were assessed in tumor-bearing mice. METHODS: Two tumor cell lines with different growth rates were used. Biodistribution studies of 177Lu-labeled antibodies (177Lu-Abs) were conducted in each tumor-bearing mouse model. Subsequently, the therapeutic effect of 90Y- and 177Lu-Ab were assessed in tumor-bearing mice. The absorbed radiation dose for the tumor was estimated using the Monte Carlo simulation. RESULTS: 177Lu-Abs demonstrated high tumor accumulation in both tumor-xerograph. In the fast-growing tumor model, 90Y-Ab showed a better therapeutic effect than 177Lu-Ab, reflecting a higher absorbed radiation dose of 90Y-Ab than that of 177Lu-Ab. In the slow-growing tumor model, both 90Y- and 177Lu-Ab showed an excellent therapeutic effect; however, 177Lu-Ab had a longer efficacy period than 90Y-Ab, which could be attributed to the longer half-life and better dose uniformity of 177Lu than those of 90Y. CONCLUSIONS: To accomplish a maximum therapeutic effect, selecting 90Y or 177Lu, to depend on the growth rate of individual cancer, would be helpful.