Comparison of the size of plates for fracture fixation with the size of phalanges and metacarpals in cadavers of Asian origin.

ABSTRACT

The size and volume of plates and screws for fracture fixation of the hand (1.5-mm screws and titanium miniplates, 2.0-mm screws and stainless-steel AO miniplates, and 2.7-mm screws and stainless-steel AO miniplates) were compared against the phalanges and metacarpal bones and the surrounding soft tissue from male cadavers of Asian decent. In the cadaver study, it was first established that the difference between anatomic measurements and radiologic measurements for the interarticular bone length and midshaft width were not significant (p = .09). Second, the volume occupied by the bone showed a close association to interarticular bone length. This finding would suggest that the volume occupied by the bone may be estimated from the radiographs. When the length of the plates was compared to that of the bones, the analysis showed 4-hole and 6-hole 1.5-mm titanium miniplates, and the 4-hole and 6-hole 2.0-mm AO plates were not suitable for the middle phalanx, although only rarely are fractures in the middle phalanx fixed with plates. For the proximal phalanx, only the 4-hole 1.5-mm and 2.0-mm plates were suitable in length. The 6-hole 2.0-mm AO plate was found to be suitable for only the longer proximal phalanx of the middle digit. For the metacarpals, the 5-hole 2.7-mm AO plate was found not to be suitable for the thumb (in length) and the ring digit (in width). The commonly used plates and screws for fracture fixation of the hand may not be suitable in size for groups of people with smaller hand sizes, in particular some Asians and women.