Pulmonary giant cell carcinoma: pathological entity or morphological phenotype?

ABSTRACT

AIMS: To evaluate the morphological spectrum and clinical significance of giant cell carcinoma and to assess the frequency of tumour giant cell production in a consecutive series of primary (non-giant cell) lung tumours. METHODS AND RESULTS: Forty-six cases of giant cell carcinoma of the lung were collated from two centres over a 12-year period. Giant cell carcinoma was found to be associated with areas of clear cell carcinoma, spindle cell carcinoma and showed trophoblastic differentiation (syncytiotrophoblastic giant cells and beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin immunopositivity) in 57%, 34% and 26% cases, respectively. 'Pure' giant cell carcinoma was identified in five (11%) cases. Eleven of the tumours contained diastase-resistant periodic acid-Schiff positive material and were separately designated as giant cell adenocarcinomas. Areas of squamous cell and neuroendocrine differentiation (as determined by chromogranin A and Leu-7 immunopositivity) were not found. The median survival for giant cell carcinoma (excluding the giant cell adenocarcinomas) was 18 months. Median survival was not adversely affected by the extent of tumour giant cell formation or by the presence of trophoblastic differentiation. Of 200 consecutive non-small cell lung carcinomas, tumour giant cells constituting < 10% of the tumour were identified in 32% of adenocarcinomas and 26% of squamous cell carcinomas. CONCLUSIONS: The presence of tumour giant cells in lung carcinoma does not, in itself, indicate a more aggressive tumour type, Giant cell carcinoma of the lung does not appear to be a distinct entity but a morphological phenotype expressed by a heterogenous group of tumours. We support and advocate the use of an encompassing term such as 'pleomorphic' or 'anaplastic' carcinoma for those tumours showing no specific differentiation pattern but which express diverse morphological features such as giant cell formation, clear or spindle cell change.