Reliability of DNA cytometric S-phase analysis in surgical biopsies: assessment of systematic and sampling errors and comparison between results obtained by image and flow cytometry.

ABSTRACT

Three major parameters in DNA histograms that contribute to the reliability of S-phase analysis were evaluated. These parameters are (1) the extent of background in relation to the amount of S-phase cells (and the validity of its subtraction), (2) the size of the "free" S-phase range (S(free)), and (3) the sampling error of cell counting. Tests in histograms obtained from surgical biopsies by flow cytometry (FCM) showed that the background subtraction is reliable if the found S-phase fraction is higher than the fraction of background events in the histogram range of the cell population. The size of S(free) was determined in computer-generated test histograms as a function of variables such as the coefficient of variation (CV) and the DNA index (DI). To calculate the sampling error of cell counting above background and in S(free), a model was developed that was validated by experimental data. This error can serve as an indicator of the uncertainty in S-phase analysis. The poor correlation found between %S values measured by image cytometry (ICM) and FCM in surgical biopsies was assigned to high uncertainty by low cell numbers in ICM histograms. A method is proposed to estimate quantitatively the reliability of S-phase analysis that can facilitate the interpretation of results.