Development of a nested PCR assay for detection of Streptococcus equi subspecies equi in clinical equine specimens and comparison with a qPCR assay.

ABSTRACT

Streptococcus equi subsp. equi is a Gram positive bacterial pathogen commonly associated with strangles in horses, a respiratory disease characterized by abscessation of submandibular and retropharyngeal lymph nodes which can lead to obstruction of the airway. Several real-time PCR (qPCR) assays have been developed for detection of S. equi from horses with many targeting conserved regions of the S. equi cell wall-associated M-protein (SeM), a major virulence factor and immunogen of S. equi. Our objective was to develop a nested PCR (nPCR) targeting SeM and an 18S rRNA internal control gene for detection of S. equi from horses with potential improvement in detection sensitivity compared to a qPCR. Primers and probes from the Kansas State Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory (KSVDL) S. equi clinical testing assay were utilized for all qPCR testing. Primers flanking the SeM qPCR target region were selected for an initial end-point PCR step of the nested assay; PCR product from the end-point reaction then served as template for the qPCR reaction step of the nested assay. Sample nucleic acid was also tested directly with qPCR to allow for assay comparison. Nucleic acid from clinical specimens (n = 188) submitted to KSVDL were tested in parallel with each assay. The nPCR and qPCR assays identified 22.9% (43/188) and 13.3% (25/188) of samples positive for S. equi, respectively. None of the samples positive by qPCR were negative by nPCR. The PCR products from all positive samples were submitted for DNA sequencing. Each of the 25 samples positive by both assays had a high nucleotide identity match (>96%) to the SeM gene. Among the samples positive by nPCR but negative by qPCR, 17 of 18 were sequence confirmed for SeM at greater than 96% nucleotide identity. Based on the nPCR Ct (37.8) of the one sequence un-confirmed case, it is likely that the S. equi bacterial load in this sample was below the necessary concentration for successful sequencing. Limit of detection (LOD) for the nPCR was established at a Ct of 37, and based both on the LOD of the qPCR assay (Ct of 37), as determined by standard curve data, and on the highest nPCR Cts (~37) of clinical samples able to result in SeM sequence-confirmation. As demonstrated by sequencing confirmation, the nPCR assay targeting the SeM gene is highly specific to S. equi. The increased sensitivity of the nPCR, compared to the qPCR, may reduce the number of false negative sample results in clinical testing and provide a superior detection method during low bacterial shedding periods.