Alternatives to the acid-oriented approach to ulcer disease: does 'cytoprotection' exist in man? A new classification of antiulcer agents.

ABSTRACT

This review summarizes the historical contradictions and inconsistencies that form the labile arguments advocating neutralization or inhibition of secretion of gastric acid for the prevention or treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers. Re-evaluation of old concepts is needed in the wake of recognition that even the most potent antisecretory agents do not change the natural history of ulcer disease; that is, the recurrence is high after termination of treatment. New biochemical, functional, and structural targets are listed for pharmacologic intervention in ulcer disease. As a supplement or alternative to the antisecretory agents, we should now consider prosecretory agents (for example, for bicarbonate and mucus secretion) and antioxidants (for example, free radical scavengers). Gastroduodenal motility, smooth muscle, the vascular endothelial cell, and the basement membrane seem to represent additional pharmacologic targets toward which new gastroprotective drugs can be directed even though the biochemical mechanism of action of these new agents may not be fully understood. New results suggest that these elements have a role in the pathogenesis of ulcer disease, and their modulations seem to exert a beneficial effect without inhibiting gastric secretion in rodents. In man, the acid antisecretory and cytoprotective doses seem to overlap, but arguments are presented to shift defining gastric 'cytoprotection' by the dose of drugs to the characterization of the phenomenon (for example, events such as the ethanol-induced hemorrhagic erosions which cannot be decreased by antisecretory agents). Furthermore, non-prostaglandin and non-H2-receptor antagonist drugs are available that exert acid-independent gastroprotection both in animals and humans. The future is thus bright for the development of new antiulcer agents.