Evaluation of Ovsynch versus modified Ovsynch program on pregnancy rate in water buffaloes: a meta-analysis.

ABSTRACT

Ovsynch is a widely accepted estrus synchronization protocol for improving the reproductive performance of water buffaloes who manifest low reproductive efficiency. Recently, some modified protocols based on Ovsynch such as 2 injections of prostaglandin 14 days apart following the Ovsynch are also introduced to enhance the reproductive potential of this species. In the present study, a meta-analytical assessment was performed with the objective to evaluate the reproductive performance of water buffaloes synchronized with Ovsynch or modified Ovsynch programs. Meta-analysis of the fixed or random effects model was determined by the heterogeneity among the studies. Reproductive outcome of interest was pregnancy per artificial insemination (P/AI) measured on day 25 (25-100). A total of 32 articles including 4003 buffaloes using either Ovsynch or modified Ovsynch protocol were reviewed. In the random effects model for buffaloes, the overall proportion of P/AI was 42.55% [95% confidence interval (CI) 37.48-47.70; n = 3,089] and 46.44% (95% CI 39.63-53.31; n = 914) on day 25 after AI for Ovsynch and modified Ovsynch, respectively. Results for P/AI were then categorized by ovarian activity, where P/AI was available for 3575 cyclic buffaloes and 320 non-cyclic buffaloes. For cyclic buffaloes, the overall proportion of P/AI was 47.54% (95% CI 42.72-52.38; n = 2911) and 57.97% (95% CI 54.12-61.77; n = 664) on day 25 after AI for Ovsynch and modified Ovsynch, respectively. In the fixed effects model for non-cyclic buffaloes, the overall proportion of P/AI was 19.68% (95% CI 13.48-26.58; n = 167) and 33.01% (95% CI 25.50-40.94; n = 153) on day 25 after AI for Ovsynch and modified Ovsynch, respectively. In conclusion, a benefit for P/AI is detected in buffaloes with the modified Ovsynch protocol. Besides, whichever estrus synchronization protocols (Ovsynch or modified Ovsynch), cyclic buffaloes have higher P/AI compared with non-cyclic buffaloes.