Reliability in viscosity measurement of thickening agents for dysphagia management: Are results obtained by cone-and-plate rheometers reproducible between laboratories?

ABSTRACT

Viscosity measurement using a cone-and-plate rheometer is considered to provide an objective and reliable evaluation of thickening agents for dysphagia management. Here, we showed its measurement uncertainty in the context of an inter-laboratory study. Eight test samples (i.e., four viscosity standard liquids, one xanthan gum reagent powder, and three commercial thickening agent powders) were distributed to 10 laboratories in a blinded manner. According to the same standard operating procedure, each laboratory dissolved the xanthan gum or thickening agents at four concentrations (0.5-4.0 g/100 g) and then measured their viscosity (35-803 mPa∙s). As for the viscosity of the standard liquids, the grand means were 98-100% of the certified values, and the relative standard deviations for repeatability (RSDr ) and reproducibility (RSDR ) were ca. 1% and ca. 5%, respectively, suggesting good accuracy in the measurement process. On the other hand, as for the viscosity of the thickening agents, RSDr and RSDR were ca. 2-6% and ca. 5-8%, respectively; however, heterogeneity in the preparation process comprising a manual dissolving step may increase these to near 60%. Furthermore, RSDr and RSDR of estimated additive concentrations to achieve targeted viscosities (50-500 mPa∙s) based on concentration-viscosity curves were ca. 1-3% and ca. 3-5%, respectively, with a few exceptions. These findings suggest that a strictly standardized procedure provides reliable data on the viscosity measurements for thickening agents.