Branched chain amino acids harbor distinct and often opposing effects on health and disease.

The three branched chain amino acids (BCAAs) leucine, isoleucine, and valine are important building blocks of muscle proteins that are obtained from the diet. Many studies in human populations have examined whether BCAAs affect health and disease. These human studies report results that are inconsistent with results from highly controlled animal studies. Because interest in the therapeutic targeting of BCAAs is growing, we wanted to better understand these discrepancies. Briefly, we used data from a large database that captured many diseases (e.g., cardiovascular disease, cancers, and respiratory disease) and new statistical methods. Our results showed that discrepancies between human studies and animal studies may reflect errors in the ways human studies were designed and conducted. As a result, these human studies may provide a flawed picture of BCAA effects that could mislead efforts developing novel therapeutics.