Similar Binding Modes of cGMP Analogues Limit Selectivity in Modulating Retinal CNG Channels via the Cyclic Nucleotide-Binding Domain.

ABSTRACT

In treating retinitis pigmentosa, a genetic disorder causing progressive vision loss, selective inhibition of rod cyclic nucleotide-gated (CNG) channels holds promise. Blocking the increased Ca2+-influx in rod photoreceptors through CNG channels can potentially delay disease progression and improve the quality of life for patients. To find inhibitors for rod CNG channels, we investigated the impact of 16 cGMP analogues on both rod and cone CNG channels using the patch-clamp technique. Although modifications at the C8 position of the guanine ring did not change the ligand efficacy, modifications at the N1 and N2 positions rendered cGMP largely ineffective in activating retinal CNG channels. Notably, PET-cGMP displayed selective potential, favoring rod over cone, whereas Rp-cGMPS showed greater efficiency in activating cone over rod CNG channels. Ligand docking and molecular dynamics simulations on cyclic nucleotide-binding domains showed comparable binding energies and binding modes for cGMP and its analogues in both rod and cone CNG channels (CNGA1 vs CNGA3 subunits). Computational experiments on CNGB1a vs CNGB3 subunits showed similar binding modes albeit with fewer amino acid interactions with cGMP due to an inactivated conformation of their C-helix. In addition, no clear correlation could be observed between the computational scores and the CNG channel efficacy values, suggesting additional factors beyond binding strength determining ligand selectivity and potency. This study highlights the importance of looking beyond the cyclic nucleotide-binding domain and toward the gating mechanism when searching for selective modulators. Future efforts in developing selective modulators for CNG channels should prioritize targeting alternative channel domains.