Evaluación emocional y actitudinal de advertencias sanitarias de tabaco en adultos y jóvenes de Argentina / Emotional and attitudinal evaluation of tobacco health warnings among youngsters and adults in Argentina

Resumen Objetivo Evaluar el impacto emocional y las respuestas cognitivas y actitudinales de las advertencias sanitarias, para evitar el consumo del tabaco. Material y métodos Se evaluaron 27 advertencias sanitarias de control del tabaco, procedentes de Argentina y de otros países, en 151 adolescentes y 168 adultos. Se aplicó un instrumento estandarizado para medir valencia y activación emocional y un cuestionario estructurado para la medición cognitivo-actitudinal. Se analizaron las correlaciones según edad y sexo, nivel de instrucción, condición de fumador, etapa de cambio en fumadores y susceptibilidad en adolescentes no fumadores. Resultados Se observó alta correlación entre las valoraciones cognitivo-actitudinales y las emocionales. Las advertencias basadas en imágenes cruentas y de sufrimiento generaron más respuestas actitudinales asociadas con el abandono y la prevención del consumo del tabaco. Conclusiones Se recomienda el uso de advertencias con altos niveles de activación emocional tanto para adultos como para adolescentes.

Abstract Objective To evaluate variables of tobacco health warnings associated with their emotional impact, the perception of smoking risks and the perceived effectiveness to avoid tobacco use. Materials and methods Teenagers (151) and adults (168) evaluated 27 tobacco health warnings selected from the sets used on tobacco packages in Argentina and in other countries. A standardized affective rating-scale system and a structured questionnaire measured respectively the emotional impact (hedonic valence and emotional arousal), and the cognitive-behavioral attributions. The correlation between emotional and cognitive-behavioral evaluations was analyzed by age, sex, education level, smoker status, stage of quitting and susceptibility of non-smokers teenagers. Results Strong significant correlations between cognitive-behavioral and emotional assessments were observed. The warnings depicting graphic images of tobacco-related injuries and suffering were considered more valuable for tobacco control, helping quitting and preventing initiation. Conclusions Using graphic images with high emotional arousal is recommended for both adults and teenagers.

Patients with multiple sclerosis do not necessarily consume more alcohol or tobacco than the general population / Pacientes com esclerose múltipla não necessariamente consomem mais álcool ou tabaco do que a população geral

Purpose Recent papers suggest that patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) are prone to alcohol misuse. This may be due to the combination of a lifelong and disabling disease with a psychiatric profile typical of MS. The objective of the present study was to assess these findings in a culturally different population of patients with MS.Method The present case-control transversal study assessed 168 patients with MS and 168 control subjects from Brazil.Results There were no evidence that patients with MS drank more alcohol or, smoked more than did controls. In fact, control subjects had a significantly higher alcohol consumption. The only trait associated to higher alcohol consumption was anxiety, both for patients and controls.Conclusion Unlike previous reports in the literature, patients with MS in our study did not drink or smoked more than a control population.

Propósito Artigos recentes sugerem que pacientes com esclerose múltipla (EM) tem tendência ao abuso de álcool. Isto poderia se dever à combinação de uma doença crônica e incapacitante e um perfil psiquiátrico típico da EM. O objetivo do presente estudo foi avaliar estes achados em uma população de pacientes com EM culturalmente diferente.Método O presente estudo caso-controle transversal avaliou 168 pacientes com EM e 168 controles, todos brasileiros.Resultados Não houve evidência que pacientes com EM usassem mais álcool ou tabaco do que os controles. Na verdade, os controles apresentavam um consumo significativamente maior de álcool. O único aspecto associado ao maior consumo de álcool foi a ansiedade, tanto para pacientes quanto para controles.Conclusão Ao contrário de outros dados da literatura, pacientes com EM neste nosso estudo não bebem ou fumam mais do que a população controle.