Second Coordination Sphere Effect Shifts CO2 to CO Reduction by Iron Porphyrin from Fe0 to FeI.

Iron porphyrins are among the most studied molecular catalysts for carbon dioxide (CO2 ) reduction and their reactivity is constantly being enhanced through the implementation of chemical functionalities in the second coordination sphere inspired by the active sites of enzymes. In this study, we were intrigued to observe that a multipoint hydrogen bonding scheme provided by embarked urea groups could also shift the redox activation step of CO2 from the well-admitted Fe(0) to the Fe(I) state. Using EPR, resonance Raman, IR and UV-Visible spectroscopies, we underpinned a two-electron activation step of CO2 starting from the Fe(I) oxidation state to form, after protonation, an Fe(III)-COOH species. The addition of another electron and a proton to the latter species converged to the cleavage of a C-O bond with the loss of water molecule resulting in an Fe(II)-CO species. DFT analyses of these postulated intermediates are in good agreement with our collected spectroscopic data, allowing us to propose an alternative pathway in the catalytic CO2 reduction with iron porphyrin catalyst. Such a remarkable shift opens new lines of research in the design of molecular catalysts to reach low overpotentials in performing multi-electronic CO2 reduction catalysis.

Selectivity in Electrochemical CO2 Reduction.

The electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) to generate fixed forms of carbons that have commercial value is a lucrative avenue to ameliorate the growing concerns about the detrimental effect of CO2 emissions as well as to generate carbon-based feed chemicals, which are generally obtained from the petrochemical industry. The area of electrochemical CO2RR has seen substantial activity in the past decade, and several good catalysts have been reported. While the focus was initially on the rate and overpotential of electrocatalysis, it is gradually shifting toward the more chemically challenging issue of selectivity. CO2 can be partially reduced to produce several C1 products like CO, HCOOH, CH3OH, etc. before its complete 8e-/8H+ reduction to CH4. In addition to that, the low-valent electron-rich metal centers deployed to activate CO2, a Lewis acid, are prone to reduce protons, which are a substrate for CO2RR, leading to competing hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Similarly, the low-valent metal is prone to oxidation by atmospheric O2 (i.e., it can catalyze the oxygen reduction reaction, ORR), necessitating strictly anaerobic conditions for CO2RR. Not only is the requirement of O2-free reaction conditions impractical, but it also leads to the release of partially reduced O2 species such as O2-, H2O2, etc., which are reactive and result in oxidative degradation of the catalyst.In this Account, mechanistic investigations of CO2RR by detecting and, often, chemically trapping and characterizing reaction intermediates are used to understand the factors that determine the selectivity in CO2RR. The spectroscopic data obtained from different intermediates have been identified in different CO2RR catalysts to develop an electronic structure selectivity relationship that is deemed to be important for deciding the selectivity of 2e-/2H+ CO2RR. The roles played by the spin state, hydrogen bonding, and heterogenization in determining the rate and selectivity of CO2RR (producing only CO, only HCOOH, or only CH4) are discussed using examples of both iron porphyrin and non-heme bioinspired artificial mimics. In addition, strategies are demonstrated where the competition between CO2RR and HER as well as CO2RR and ORR could be skewed overwhelmingly in favor of CO2RR in both cases.

O2 reduction by iron porphyrins with electron withdrawing groups: to scale or not to scale.

Iron porphyrins are synthesized by systematically introducing electron withdrawing groups (EWGs) on pyrroles to evaluate the relationship between rate (k) and overpotential (η). The results indicate that while EWGs lead to a rise in the thermodynamic FeIII/II reduction potential (E0), the potential of the O2 reduction reaction (ORR) does not scale with E0. More importantly, the iron porphyrins with higher E0 show an order of magnitude higher rate of ORR than unsubstituted iron tetraphenyl porphyrin. This contests the scaling relationship often offered to predict rates of ORR by iron porphyrins based on their E0. Mechanistic investigations reveal that the rate-determining step (rds) of ORR change between these iron porphyrins with EWG's, as the pKa and E0 of several key intermediate species likely change on altering the macrocycle. These results suggest that linear dependence of log(rate) on E0 or η may only be valid for complexes where the rds of ORR remains the same.

Biochemical and artificial pathways for the reduction of carbon dioxide, nitrite and the competing proton reduction: effect of 2nd sphere interactions in catalysis.

Reduction of oxides and oxoanions of carbon and nitrogen are of great contemporary importance as they are crucial for a sustainable environment. Substantial research has been dedicated to these areas in the last few decades. These reductions require both electrons and protons and their thermodynamic potentials often make them compete with hydrogen evolution reaction i.e., the reaction of protons and electrons to generate H2. These reactions are abundant in the environment in microorganisms and are facilitated by naturally occurring enzymes. This review brings together the state-of-the-art knowledge in the area of enzymatic reduction of CO2, NO2- and H+ with those of artificial molecular electrocatalysis. A simple ligand field theory-based design principle for electrocatalysts is first described. The electronic structure considerations developed automatically yield the basic geometry required and the 2nd sphere interactions which can potentially aid the activation and the further reduction of these small molecules. A systematic review of the enzymatic reaction followed by those reported in artificial molecular electrocatalysts is presented for the reduction of CO2, NO2- and H+. The review is focused on mechanism of action of these metalloenzymes and artificial electrocatalysts and discusses general principles that guide the rates and product selectivity of these reactions. The importance of the 2nd sphere interactions in both enzymatic and artificial molecular catalysis is discussed in detail.

Activating the Fe(I) State of Iron Porphyrinoid with Second-Sphere Proton Transfer Residues for Selective Reduction of CO2 to HCOOH via Fe(III/II)-COOH Intermediate(s).

The ability to tune the selectivity of CO2 reduction by first-row transition metal-based complexes via the inclusion of second-sphere effects heralds exciting and sought-after possibilities. On the basis of the mechanistic understanding of CO2 reduction by iron porphyrins developed by trapping and characterizing the intermediates involved ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2015, 137, 11214), a porphyrinoid ligand is envisaged to switch the selectivity of the iron porphyrins by reducing CO2 from CO to HCOOH as well as lower the overpotential to the process. The results show that the iron porphyrinoid designed can catalyze the reduction of CO2 to HCOOH using water as the proton source with 97% yield with no detectable H2 or CO. The iron porphyrinoid can activate CO2 in its Fe(I) state resulting in very low overpotential for CO2 reduction in contrast to all reported iron porphyrins, which can reduce CO2 in their Fe(0) state. Intermediates involved in CO2 reduction, Fe(III)-COOH and a Fe(II)-COOH, are identified with in situ FTIR-SEC and subsequently chemically generated and characterized using FTIR, resonance Raman, and Mössbauer spectroscopy. The mechanism of the reaction helps elucidate a key role played by a closely placed proton transfer residue in aiding CO2 binding to Fe(I), stabilizing the intermediates, and determining the fate of a rate-determining Fe(II)-COOH intermediate.

Electrocatalytic Reduction of Nitrogen to Hydrazine Using a Trinuclear Nickel Complex.

Activation and reduction of N2 have been a major challenge to chemists and the focus since now has mostly been on the synthesis of NH3. Alternatively, reduction of N2 to hydrazine is desirable because hydrazine is an excellent energy vector that can release the stored energy very conveniently without the need for catalysts. To date, only one molecular catalyst has been reported to be able to reduce N2 to hydrazine chemically. A trinuclear T-shaped nickel thiolate molecular complex has been designed to activate dinitrogen. The electrochemically generated all Ni(I) state of this molecule can reduce N2 in the presence of PhOH as a proton donor. Hydrazine is detected as the only nitrogen-containing product of the reaction, along with gaseous H2. The complex reported here is selective for the 4e-/4H+ reduction of nitrogen to hydrazine with a minor overpotential of ∼300 mV.

Formally Ferric Heme Carbon Monoxide Adduct.

Formally ferric carbonyl adducts are reported in a series of thiolate-bound iron porphyrins. Resonance Raman data indicate the presence of both Fe-S and Fe-CO bonds, and EPR data of this S = 1/2 species indicate a ligand-based electron hole, giving this complex an Fe(II)-thiyl radical electronic ground state. The FTIR data show that the C-O vibrations are substantially higher than in the corresponding ferrous-thiolate CO adducts. DFT calculations reproduce the spectroscopic features and indicate that backbonding to the low lying π* orbitals of the bound CO stabilizes the Fe 3d orbitals resulting in a stabilization of the ferrous-thiyl radical ground state compared to the five-coordinate ferric-thiolate precursor complexes. Access to stable thiyl radicals will help understand these elusive species that are mostly encountered as short-lived reactive reaction intermediates.

A bi-functional cobalt-porphyrinoid electrocatalyst: balance between overpotential and selectivity.

Cobalt porphyrins have been shown to electrocatalyze O2 reduction as well as H2 evolution. A cobalt porphyrin is synthesized when two electron-withdrawing groups are used in an attempt to reduce the overpotential involved in O2 reduction and H2 evolution. The results show that in the case of O2 reduction, instead of reduction of overpotential, the selectivity for O2 reduction changes to 2e-/2H+ to produce H2O2. In the case of H2 evolution, the CoI state is incapable of catalyzing H+ reduction. Rather, a CoIII-H species needs to be reduced to CoII-H before H2 can be produced. There results add to the ongoing investigations into the factors that control the rates, overpotential and selectivity of these important cathodic processes.

Synthetic Iron Porphyrins for Probing the Differences in the Electronic Structures of Heme a3, Heme d, and Heme d1.

A variety of heme derivatives are pervasive in nature, having different architectures that are complementary to their function. Herein, we report the synthesis of a series of iron porphyrinoids, which bear electron-withdrawing groups and/or are saturated at the ß-pyrrolic position, mimicking the structural variation of naturally occurring hemes. The effects of the aforementioned factors were systematically studied using a combination of electrochemistry, spectroscopy, and theoretical calculations with the carbon monoxide (CO) and nitric oxide (NO) adducts of these iron porphyinoids. The reduction potentials of iron porphyrinoids vary over several hundreds of millivolts, and the X-O (X = C, N) vibrations of the adducts vary over 10-15 cm-1. Density functional theory calculations indicate that the presence of electron-withdrawing groups and saturation of the pyrrole ring lowers the π*-acceptor orbital energies of the macrocycle, which, in turn, attenuates the bonding of iron to CO and NO. A hypothesis has been presented as to why cytochrome c containing nitrite reductases and cytochrome cd1 containing nitrite reductases follow different mechanistic pathways of nitrite reduction. This study also helps to rationalize the choice of heme a3 and not the most abundant heme b cofactor in cytochrome c oxidase.

Recent developments in the synthesis of bio-inspired iron porphyrins for small molecule activation.

Nature utilizes a diverse set of tetrapyrrole-based macrocycles (referred to as porphyrinoids) for catalyzing various biological processes. Investigation of the differences in electronic structure and reactivity in these reactions have revealed striking differences that lead to diverse reactivity from, apparently, similar looking active sites. Therefore, the role of the different heme cofactors as well as the distal superstructure in the proteins is important to understand. This article summarizes the role of a few synthetic metallo-porphyrinoids towards catalyzing several small molecule activation reactions, such as the ORR, NiRR, CO2RR, etc. The major focus of the article is to enlighten the synthetic routes to the well-decorated active-site mimic in a tailor-made fashion pursuing a retrosynthetic approach, learning from the biosynthesis of the cofactors. Techniques and the role of the second-sphere residues on the reaction rate, selectivity, etc. are incorporated emulating the basic amino acid residues fencing the active sites. These bioinspired mimics play an important role towards understanding the role of the prosthetic groups as well as the basic residues towards any reaction occurring in Nature.

The role of porphyrin peripheral substituents in determining the reactivities of ferrous nitrosyl species.

Ferrous nitrosyl {FeNO}7 species is an intermediate common to the catalytic cycles of Cd1NiR and CcNiR, two heme-based nitrite reductases (NiR), and its reactivity varies dramatically in these enzymes. The former reduces NO2 - to NO in the denitrification pathway while the latter reduces NO2 - to NH4 + in a dissimilatory nitrite reduction. With very similar electron transfer partners and heme based active sites, the origin of this difference in reactivity has remained unexplained. Differences in the structure of the heme d 1 (Cd1NiR), which bears electron-withdrawing groups and has saturated pyrroles, relative to heme c (CcNiR) are often invoked to explain these reactivities. A series of iron porphyrinoids, designed to model the electron-withdrawing peripheral substitution as well as the saturation present in heme d 1 in Cd1NiR, and their NO adducts were synthesized and their properties were investigated. The data clearly show that the presence of electron-withdrawing groups (EWGs) and saturated pyrroles together in a synthetic porphyrinoid (FeDEsC) weakens the Fe-NO bond in {FeNO}7 adducts along with decreasing the bond dissociation free energies (BDFENH) of the {FeHNO}8 species. The EWG raises the E° of the {FeNO}7/8 process, making the electron transfer (ET) facile, but decreases the pK a of {FeNO}8 species, making protonation (PT) difficult, while saturation has the opposite effect. The weakening of the Fe-NO bonding biases the {FeNO}7 species of FeDEsC for NO dissociation, as in Cd1NiR, which is otherwise set-up for a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) to form an {FeHNO}8 species eventually leading to its further reduction to NH4 +.

Tuning the thermodynamic onset potential of electrocatalytic O2 reduction reaction by synthetic iron-porphyrin complexes.

A porphyrin ligand with two ß-pyrrolic electron withdrawing ester groups is synthesized and its Co complex is crystallographically characterized. The iron complex of this porphyrin ligand shows an ∼200 mV positive shift in its Fe(III/II) potential in organic as well as aqueous solvents and in the onset potential of ORR relative to that of an unsubstituted porphyrin.