Defense Responses in Grapevine Leaves Against Botrytis cinerea Induced by Application of a Pythium oligandrum Strain or Its Elicitin, Oligandrin, to Roots.

ABSTRACT Pythium oligandrum is known to display antagonistic activities against several species of pathogenic fungi. It also produces an elicitor of plant defense named oligandrin, which belongs to the elicitin family (10-kDa proteins synthesized by Phytophthora and Pythium species). Here, the potential of P. oligandrum or its purified elicitin to limit the progression of B. cinerea on grapevine leaf and the resulting plant-microorganism interactions are described. P. oligandrum or oligandrin were applied to roots, and changes in the ultrastructure and at the molecular level were examined. When B. cinerea was applied to leaves of pretreated plants, leaf invasion was limited and the protection level reached about 75%. On leaf tissues surrounding B. cinerea inoculation, modifications of cuticle thickness, accumulation of phenolic compounds, and cell wall apposition were observed, indicating that grapevine can be considered reactive to elicitins. No macroscopic hypersensitive reaction associated with the elicitation treatment was observed. At the molecular level, the expression of three defense-related genes (LTP-1, beta-1,3-glucanase, and stilbene synthase) was studied. RNAs isolated from B. cinerea-infected leaves of grapevine challenged or not with P. oligandrum or oligandrin were analyzed by real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction. In grapevine leaves, LTP-1 gene expression was enhanced in response to oligandrin, and RNA transcript levels of beta-1,3-glucanase and stilbene synthase increased in response to all treatments with different magnitude. Taken together, these results open new discussion on the concept of plant reactivity to elicitins, which has until now, been mainly based on plant hypersensitive responses.

Mediation of elicitin activity on tobacco is assumed by elicitin-sterol complexes.

Elicitins secreted by phytopathogenic Phytophthora spp. are proteinaceous elicitors of plant defense mechanisms and were demonstrated to load, carry, and transfer sterols between membranes. The link between elicitor and sterol-loading properties was assessed with the use of site-directed mutagenesis of the 47 and 87 cryptogein tyrosine residues, postulated to be involved in sterol binding. Mutated cryptogeins were tested for their ability to load sterols, bind to plasma membrane putative receptors, and trigger biological responses. For each mutated elicitin, the chemical characterization of the corresponding complexes with stigmasterol (1:1 stoichiometry) demonstrated their full functionality. However, these proteins were strongly altered in their sterol-loading efficiency, specific binding to high-affinity sites, and activities on tobacco cells. Ligand replacement experiments strongly suggest that the formation of a sterol-elicitin complex is a requisite step before elicitins fasten to specific binding sites. This was confirmed with the use of two sterol-preloaded elicitins. Both more rapidly displaced labeled cryptogein from its specific binding sites than the unloaded proteins. Moreover, the binding kinetics of elicitins are related to their biological effects, which constitutes the first evidence that binding sites could be the biological receptors. The first event involved in elicitin-mediated cell responses is proposed to be the protein loading with a sterol molecule.

Cercospora beticola toxins. VII. Fluorometric study of their interactions with biological membranes.

The interactions of two beticolins, Cercospora beticola toxins, and of their magnesium complexes with liposomes or plasma membrane were studied. The fluorometric pH titration curves of beticolins in liposomes and in plasma membranes reveal the presence of the dissociated form of beticolins. The concentration of the magnesium complex in these membranes increases at high pH. The partition coefficient of beticolin-1 on liposomes is 3-fold higher than that of beticolin-2 and the fluorescence of both compounds on liposomes is similar. The addition of magnesium to liposomes causes a 40-fold and 20-fold increase in the partition coefficient of beticolin-1 and -2, respectively, as a result of the interactions between membrane, magnesium and beticolins. Beticolins react to a delta pH across the liposome membrane but the formation of the magnesium complex completely abolishes this effect.

Elicitins trap and transfer sterols from micelles, liposomes and plant plasma membranes.

Using elicitins, proteins secreted by some phytopathogenic Oomycetes (Phytophthora) known to be able to transfer sterols between phospholipid vesicles, the transfer of sterols between micelles, liposomes and biological membranes was studied. Firstly, a simple fluorometric method to screen the sterol-carrier capacity of proteins, avoiding the preparation of sterol-containing phospholipidic vesicles, is proposed. The transfer of sterols between DHE micelles (donor) and stigmasterol or cholesterol micelles (acceptor) was directly measured, as the increase in DHE fluorescence signal. The results obtained with this rapid and easy method lead to the same conclusions as those previously reported, using fluorescence polarization of a mixture of donor and acceptor phospholipid vesicles, prepared in the presence of different sterols. Therefore, the micelles method can be useful to screen proteins for their sterol carrier activity. Secondly, elicitins are shown to trap sterols from purified plant plasma membranes and to transfer sterols from micelles to these biological membranes. This property should contribute to understand the molecular mechanism involved in sterol uptake by Phytophthora. It opens new perspectives concerning the role of such proteins in plant-microorganism interactions.

Cercospora beticola toxins. Part XVII. The role of the beticolin/Mg2+ complexes in their biological activity. Study of plasma membrane H(+)-ATPase, vacuolar H(+)-PPase, alkaline and acid phosphatases.

Beticolin-1 and beticolin-2, yellow toxins produced by the phytopathogenic fungus Cercospora beticola, inhibit the plasma membrane H(+)-ATPase. Firstly, since beticolins are able to form complexes with Mg2+, the role of the beticolin/Mg2+ complexes in the inhibition of the plasma membrane proton pump has been investigated. Calculations indicate that beticolins could exist under several forms, in the H(+)-ATPase assay mixture, both free or complexed with Mg2+. However, the percentage inhibition of the H(+)-ATPase activity is correlated to the concentration of one single form of beticolin, the dimeric neutral complex Mg2H2B2, which appears to be the active form involved in the H(+)-ATPase inhibition. Secondly, since previous data suggested that beticolins could also be active against other Mg2(+)-dependent enzymes, we tested beticolin-1 on the vacuolar H(+)-PPase, which requires Mg2+ as co-substrate, and on the alkaline and acid phosphatases, which do not use Mg2+ as co-substrate. Only vacuolar H(+)-PPase is sensitive to beticolin-1, which suggests that beticolins are specific to enzymes that use a complex of Mg2+ as the substrate. The same Mg2H2B2 complex which is responsible of the plasma membrane H(+)-ATPase inhibition appears to be also involved in the inhibition of the vacuolar H(+)-PPase.

Physiological and Molecular Characteristics of Elicitin-Induced Systemic Acquired Resistance in Tobacco.

Elicitins are low molecular weight proteins secreted by all Phytophthora species analyzed so far. Application of the purified proteins to tobacco Nicotiana tabacum leads to the induction of resistance to subsequent inoculations with the black shank-causing agent, Phytophthora parasitica var nicotianae. In this paper, we describe the systemic characteristics of elicitin-induced acquired resistance in tobacco. Elicitin application is followed by the rapid translocation of the protein in the plant. The basic elicitin, cryptogein, induces necrosis formation in the leaves, which results from accumulation of the protein in these organs. Necrosis does not seem to be essential for the establishment of systemic acquired resistance (SAR), since resistance induced by the acidic elicitin, capsicein, is not accompanied by the development of visible symptoms on the leaves. Both elicitins trigger the coordinate accumulation of transcripts from nine genes, previously described to be expressed during establishment of SAR. Additionally, elicitin treatment leads to the activation of the multiple response gene str 246. In leaves, transcript accumulation was found to be higher in all cases in response to cryptogein compared to capsicein treatment. These results, along with northern hybridization analysis following infiltration of leaves with cryptogein, indicate that SAR genes appear to be expressed locally, corresponding to necrosis formation as well as systemically during induction of resistance. To our knowledge, elicitins are the only well-characterized, pathogen-derived molecules that trigger SAR in a plant.

Involvement of Free Calcium in Action of Cryptogein, a Proteinaceous Elicitor of Hypersensitive Reaction in Tobacco Cells.

Treatment of suspension-cultured tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum var Xanthi) cells with cryptogein, a proteinaceous elicitor from Phytophthora cryptogea, induced a great stimulation of Ca2+ influx within the first minutes. Ca2+ influx is essential for the initiation of cryptogein-induced responses, since ethyleneglycol-bis([beta]-amino-ethyl ether)-N,N[prime]-tetraacetic acid or La3+, which block Ca2+ entrance, suppress cryptogein-induced responses such as extracellular alkalinization, active oxygen species, and phytoalexin production. Moreover, once initiated, these responses require sustained Ca2+ influx within the 1st h. A Ca2+ ionophore (A23187) was able to trigger an extracellular alkalinization but not the formation of active oxygen species and phytoalexins, even in the presence of cryptogein. Staurosporine, a protein kinase inhibitor that was recently reported to suppress cryptogein-induced responses (M.-P. Viard, F. Martin, A. Pugin, P. Ricci, J.-P. Blein [1994] Plant Physiol 104: 1245-1249), inhibited Ca2+ influx induced by cryptogein in a dose-dependent manner. These results suggest that protein phosphorylation followed by Ca2+ influx might be involved in the initial steps of cryptogein signal transduction.

Protein Phosphorylation Is Induced in Tobacco Cells by the Elicitor Cryptogein.

Changes in plasmalemma ion fluxes were observed when tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) cells were treated with cryptogein, a proteinaceous elicitor from Phytophthora cryptogea. A strong alkalization of the culture medium, accompanied by a leakage of potassium, was induced within a few minutes of treatment. These effects reached a maximum after 30 to 40 min and lasted for several hours. This treatment also resulted in a rapid, but transient, production of activated oxygen species. All these physiological responses were fully sensitive to staurosporine, a known protein kinase inhibitor. Furthermore, a study of protein phosphorylation showed that cryptogein induced a staurosporine-sensitive phosphorylation of several polypeptides. These data suggest that phosphorylated proteins may be essential for the transduction of elicitor signals.

Cercospora beticola Toxins (X. Inhibition of Plasma Membrane H+-ATPase by Beticolin-1).

Beticolin-1 is a toxin produced by the fungus Cercospora beticola. The chemical structure of this toxin was previously elucidated. The effects of beticolin-1 on purified corn root plasma membrane H+-ATPase were studied in a solubilized form or were reconstituted into liposome membranes. The ATP hydrolysis activity of the purified solubilized enzyme was inhibited by micromolar concentrations of beticolin-1, and this inhibition was noncompetitive with respect to ATP. When this purified enzyme was inserted into liposome membranes, a competitive inhibition of the H+-ATPase hydrolysis activity by beticolin-1 was observed. The effect of beticolin-1 on the formation of H+-ATPase-phosphorylated intermediate was also studied. With the purified enzyme in its solubilized form, the level of phosphorylated intermediate was not affected by the presence of beticolin-1, whereas micromolar concentrations of the toxin led to a marked inhibition of its formation when the enzyme was reconstituted into liposomes. These data suggest that (a) the plasma membrane H+-ATPase is a direct target for beticolin-1, and (b) the kinetics of inhibition and the effect on the phosphorylated intermediate are linked and both depend on the lipid environment of the enzyme.

Relationship between Active Oxygen Species, Lipid Peroxidation, Necrosis, and Phytoalexin Production Induced by Elicitins in Nicotiana.

Excised leaves of Nicotiana tabacum var Xanthi and Nicotiana rustica were treated with cryptogein and capsicein, basic and acidic elicitins, respectively. Both compounds induced leaf necrosis, the intensity of which depended on concentration and duration of treatment. N. tabacum var Xanthi was the most sensitive species and cryptogein was the most active elicitin. Lipid peroxidation in elicitin-treated Nicotiana leaves was closely correlated with the appearance of necrosis. Elicitin treatments induced a rapid and transient burst of active oxygen species (AOS) in cell cultures of both Nicotiana species, with the production by Xanthi cells being 6-fold greater than that by N. rustica. Similar maximum AOS production levels were observed with both elicitins, but capsicein required 10-fold higher concentrations than those of cryptogein. Phytoalexin production was lower in response to both elicitins in N. tabacum var Xanthi cells than in N. rustica cells, and capsicein was the most efficient elicitor of this response. In cryptogein-treated cell suspensions, phytoalexin synthesis was unaffected by diphenyleneiodonium, which inhibited AOS generation, nor was it affected by tiron or catalase, which suppressed AOS accumulation in the extracellular medium. These results suggest that AOS production, lipid peroxidation, and necrosis are directly related, whereas phytoalexin production depends on neither the presence nor the intensity of these responses.

Tobacco cells contain a protein, immunologically related to the neutrophil small G protein Rac2 and involved in elicitor-induced oxidative burst.

Suspension-cultured cells of Nicotiana tabacum generated active oxygen species (AOS) when they were treated with the proteinaceous elicitor, cryptogein. This response was blocked by diphenylene iodonium, an inhibitor of the neutrophil NADPH oxidase. When microsomal extracts of tobacco cells were probed with an antibody directed against the human small G protein Rac2, two immunoreactive proteins were detected at 18.5 and 20.5 kDa. The same experiment performed with cytosolic extracts of tobacco cells led to the observation of a strong immunoreactive protein at 21.5 kDa only in the cryptogein-treated cells. The appearance of this cytosolic protein was related to the production of AOS by the elicited cells. These results provide evidence for the possible involvement of small G proteins, homologous to the neutrophil Rac2 protein, in the regulation of the elicitor-induced oxidative burst in plant.

The fungal elicitor cryptogein is a sterol carrier protein.

Cryptogein is a protein secreted by the phytopathogenic pseudo-fungus, Phytophthora cryptogea. It is a basic 10 kDa hydrophilic protein having a hydrophobic pocket and three disulfide bridges. These common features with sterol carrier proteins led us to investigate its possible sterol transfer activity using the fluorescent sterol, dehydroergosterol. The results show that cryptogein has one binding site with strong affinity for dehydroergosterol. Moreover, this protein catalyzes the transfer of sterols between phospholipidic artificial membranes. This is the first evidence for the existence of an extracellular sterol carrier protein and for a molecular activity of cryptogein. This property should contribute to an understanding of the role of cryptogein in plant-microorganism interactions.

Evidence for specific, high-affinity binding sites for a proteinaceous elicitor in tobacco plasma membrane.

Binding of cryptogein, a proteinaceous elicitor, was studied on tobacco plasma membrane. The binding of the [125I]cryptogein was saturable, reversible and specific with an apparent Kd of 2 nM. A single class of cryptogein binding sites was found with a sharp optimum pH for binding at about pH 7.0. The high-affinity correlates with crytogein concentrations required for biological activity in vivo.

Activation of the plant plasma membrane H+-ATPase. Is there a direct interaction between lysophosphatidylcholine and the C-terminal part of the enzyme?

The antagonistic effects of the fungal toxin beticolin-1 and of L-alpha-lysophosphatidylcholine (lysoPC) were investigated on the plasma membrane H+-ATPase of the plant Arabidopsis thaliana (isoform 2) expressed in yeast, using both wild-type enzyme (AHA2) and C-terminal truncated enzyme (aha2delta92). Phosphohydrolytic activities of both enzymes were inhibited by beticolin-1, with very similar 50% inhibitory concentrations, indicating that the toxin action does not involve the C-terminal located autoinhibitory domain of the proton pump. Egg lysoPC, a compound that activates the H+-ATPase by a mechanism involving the C-terminal part of the protein, was found to be able to reverse the inhibition of AHA2 by beticolin-1. The lack of effect of other detergents and the comparison of different carbon chain length lysoPCs show that the capacity to reverse the enzyme inhibition is clearly related to their ability to activate the pump. Long chain length lysoPC was also shown to reverse the inhibition of aha2delta92 by beticolin-1, which strongly suggests that lysoPC binds to the H+-ATPase on site(s) not located on its autoinhibitory domain.

Induction of tcI 7, a gene encoding a beta-subunit of proteasome, in tobacco plants treated with elicitins, salicylic acid or hydrogen peroxide.

We previously isolated, by differential display and 5' RACE (rapid amplification of cDNA ends), cDNAs corresponding to genes activated following cryptogein treatment of tobacco cell suspensions, among them tcI 7 (tcI for tobacco cryptogein Induced), a gene encoding a beta-subunit of proteasome. Here, we report that tcl 7 was up-regulated in tobacco plants treated with elicitins (cryptogein and parasiticein) that have been shown to induce a systemic acquired resistance (SAR). Moreover, subsequent inoculation of tobacco with the pathogen Phytophthora parasitica var. nicotianae (Ppn) was shown to induce an additional activation of tcI 7 in tobacco plants pretreated with cryptogein. We also showed an up-regulation of tcI 7 by salicylic acid (SA). Moreover, accumulation of tcI 7 transcripts after treatment with cryptogein or with SA only occurred in NahG 9-tobacco plants that do not express the salicylate hydroxylase and thus are able to accumulate SA and develop a SAR. Suppressed accumulation of tcI 7 transcripts in NahG 8+ tobacco plants after cryptogein or SA treatment correlated with the loss of SAR. H2O2 was also shown to up-regulate tcI 7 in tobacco plants. Using gene walking by PCR we cloned and sequenced the 5' flanking region of tcI 7 containing hypothetical regulatory sequences, especially myb and NF-kappaB boxes, that could be responsible for the regulation of tcI 7 by salicylic acid and H2O2 respectively.

Fatty acids bind to the fungal elicitor cryptogein and compete with sterols.

Cryptogein is a proteinaceous elicitor of plant defense reactions which also exhibits sterol carrier properties. In this study, we report that this protein binds fatty acids. The stoichiometry of the fatty acid-cryptogein complex is 1:1. Linoleic acid and dehydroergosterol compete for the same site, but elicitin affinity is 27 times lower for fatty acid than for sterol. We show that C7 to C12 saturated and C16 to C22 unsaturated fatty acids are the best ligands. The presence of double bonds markedly increases the affinity of cryptogein for fatty acids. A comparison between elicitins and known lipid transfer proteins is discussed.

A lipid transfer protein binds to a receptor involved in the control of plant defence responses.

Lipid transfer proteins (LTPs) and elicitins are both able to load and transfer lipidic molecules and share some structural and functional properties. While elicitins are known as elicitors of plant defence mechanisms, the biological function of LTP is still an enigma. We show that a wheat LTP1 binds with high affinity sites. Binding and in vivo competition experiments point out that these binding sites are common to LTP1 and elicitins and confirm that they are the biological receptors of elicitins. A mathematical analysis suggests that these receptors could be represented by an allosteric model corresponding to an oligomeric structure with four identical subunits.

Cloning of Rac and Rho-GDI from tobacco using an heterologous two-hybrid screen.

To examine whether molecular similarities exist between the animal and plant Rho GTPase signaling pathways, we have developed a heterologous two-hybrid screening method. By this technique, we have cloned a cDNA encoding a tobacco Rac-like protein able to interact with a mammalian Rho-GDI. In a second screen this tobacco Rac was used as a bait and a tobacco homologue of Rho-GDI was identified. These results show that some components of the animal and plant Rac signaling pathways are similar enough to allow their interaction in an heterologous approach. Moreover these data suggest a similar regulation of Rho GTPases in animals and plants.

Cercospora beticola toxins. Part VI: preliminary studies of protonation and complexation equilibria.

The biological activity of Cercospora beticola toxins might be enhanced by the complex formation with magnesium. Therefore, protonation and complexation equilibria of beticolins were studied. Beticolins carry three dissociable functions (H3B) two of which dissociate at a physiological pH. In the presence of magnesium, the neutralisation and protonation curves provide evidence for the formation of complexes. At physiological pH, the uncharged complex, Mg2H2B2, is the predominant form. The nonionised forms of free beticolin-1 and -2 fluoresce in a 50% dioxan-water solution and their emission maxima shift to higher wavelengths in water. The dianion HB(2-) is non-fluorescent both in water and in less polar media. The formation of the Mg2H2B2 complex which strongly fluoresces in nonpolar media is confirmed by a marked increase in fluorescence at 520 nm and by a shift of the excitation maximum.

Cytological Characterization of Elicitin-Induced Protection in Tobacco Plants Infected by Phytophthora parasitica or Phytoplasma.

ABSTRACT Elicitins, small proteins secreted by Phytophthora and Pythium spp., display the ability to induce plant resistance toward pathogens. Ultrastructural investigations of cryptogein-treated tobacco plants evidenced host defense responses such as (i) formation of a calcium pectate gel in intercellular spaces of parenchymas, (ii) impregnation of pectin by phenolic compounds in intercellular spaces of phloem bundles, and (iii) accumulation of phloem proteins (P proteins) in the lumen of leaf sieve elements. These cytological modifications lead to the enhancement of physical barriers that prevent pathogen ingress and restrict host tissue colonization when cryptogein-treated tobacco plants were challenged with the pathogen Phytophthora parasitica. Wall appositions also were observed at most sites of penetration of hyphae. Moreover, growing hyphae exhibited severe morphological damages, suggesting a modified toxic environment. The same induction of P proteins in mature sieve tubes of tobacco leaves was obtained with oligandrin treatment, another elicitin. Cryptogein or oligandrin treatment prevented symptom expression in phytoplasma-infected tobacco plants in contrast with nontreated tobacco plants. Moreover, P protein plugs and occlusion of pore sites by callose were evidenced in sieve elements of treated plants. Both these phloem modifications might prevent the in planta movement of phloem-restricted microorganisms.