Structural basis for proenzyme maturation, substrate recognition, and ligation by a hyperactive peptide asparaginyl ligase.

Peptide ligases are versatile enzymes that can be utilized for precise protein conjugation for bioengineering applications. Hyperactive peptide asparaginyl ligases (PALs), such as butelase-1, belong to a small class of enzymes from cyclotide-producing plants that can perform site-specific, rapid ligation reactions after a target peptide asparagine/aspartic acid (Asx) residue binds to the active site of the ligase. How PALs specifically recognize their polypeptide substrates has remained elusive, especially at the prime binding side of the enzyme. Here we report crystal structures that capture VyPAL2, a catalytically efficient PAL from Viola yedoensis, in an activated state, with and without a bound substrate. The bound structure shows one ligase with the N-terminal polypeptide tail from another ligase molecule trapped at its active site, revealing how Asx inserts in the enzyme's S1 pocket and why a hydrophobic residue is required at the P2' position. Besides illustrating the anchoring role played by P1 and P2' residues, these results uncover a role for the Gatekeeper residue at the surface of the S2 pocket in shifting the nonprime portion of the substrate and, as a result, the activity toward ligation or hydrolysis. These results suggest a picture for proenzyme maturation in the vacuole and will inform the rational design of peptide ligases with tailored specificities.

Consensus design and engineering of an efficient and high-yield peptide asparaginyl ligase for protein cyclization and ligation.

Plant legumains are Asn/Asp-specific endopeptidases that have diverse functions in plants. Peptide asparaginyl ligases (PALs) are a special legumain subtype that primarily catalyze peptide bond formation rather than hydrolysis. PALs are versatile protein engineering tools but are rarely found in nature. To overcome this limitation, here we describe a two-step method to design and engineer a high-yield and efficient recombinant PAL based on commonly found asparaginyl endopeptidases. We first constructed a consensus sequence derived from 1500 plant legumains to design the evolutionarily stable legumain conLEG that could be produced in E. coli with 20-fold higher yield relative to that for natural legumains. We then applied the ligase-activity determinant hypothesis to exploit conserved residues in PAL substrate-binding pockets and convert conLEG into conPAL1-3. Functional studies showed that conLEG is primarily a hydrolase, whereas conPALs are ligases. Importantly, conPAL3 is a superefficient and broadly active PAL for protein cyclization and ligation.

Substrate-binding glycine residues are major determinants for hydrolase and ligase activity of plant legumains.

Peptide asparaginyl ligases (PALs) are useful tools for precision modifications of proteins and live-cell surfaces by ligating peptides after Asn/Asp (Asx). They share high sequence and structural similarity to plant legumains that are generally known as asparaginyl endopeptidases (AEPs), thus making it challenging to identify PALs from AEPs. In this study, we investigate 875 plant species from algae to seed plants with available sequence data in public databases to identify new PALs. We conducted evolutionary trace analysis on 1500 plant legumains, including eight known PALs, to identify key residues that could differentiate ligases and proteases, followed by recombinant expression and functional validation of 16 novel legumains. Previously, we showed that the substrate-binding sequences flanking the catalytic site can strongly influence the enzymatic direction of a legumain and which we named as ligase-activity determinants (LADs). Here, we show that two conserved substrate-binding Gly residues of LADs are critical, but negative determinants for ligase activity. Our results suggest that specific glycine residues are molecular determinants to identify PALs and AEPs as two different legumain subfamilies, accounting for c. 1% and 88%, respectively.

The legumain McPAL1 from Momordica cochinchinensis is a highly stable Asx-specific splicing enzyme.

Legumains, also known as asparaginyl endopeptidases (AEPs), cleave peptide bonds after Asn/Asp (Asx) residues. In plants, certain legumains also have ligase activity that catalyzes biosynthesis of Asx-containing cyclic peptides. An example is the biosynthesis of MCoTI-I/II, a squash family-derived cyclic trypsin inhibitor, which involves splicing to remove the N-terminal prodomain and then N-to-C-terminal cyclization of the mature domain. To identify plant legumains responsible for the maturation of these cyclic peptides, we have isolated and characterized a legumain involved in splicing, McPAL1, from Momordica cochinchinensis (Cucurbitaceae) seeds. Functional studies show that recombinantly expressed McPAL1 displays a pH-dependent, trimodal enzymatic profile. At pH 4 to 6, McPAL1 selectively catalyzed Asp-ligation and Asn-cleavage, but at pH 6.5 to 8, Asn-ligation predominated. With peptide substrates containing N-terminal Asn and C-terminal Asp, such as is found in precursors of MCoTI-I/II, McPAL1 mediates proteolysis at the Asn site and then ligation at the Asp site at pH 5 to 6. Also, McPAL1 is an unusually stable legumain that is tolerant of heat and high pH. Together, our results support that McPAL1 is a splicing legumain at acidic pH that can mediate biosynthesis of MCoTI-I/II. We purport that the high thermal and pH stability of McPAL1 could have applications for protein engineering.

Structural determinants for peptide-bond formation by asparaginyl ligases.

Asparaginyl endopeptidases (AEPs) are cysteine proteases which break Asx (Asn/Asp)-Xaa bonds in acidic conditions. Despite sharing a conserved overall structure with AEPs, certain plant enzymes such as butelase 1 act as a peptide asparaginyl ligase (PAL) and catalyze Asx-Xaa bond formation in near-neutral conditions. PALs also serve as macrocyclases in the biosynthesis of cyclic peptides. Here, we address the question of how a PAL can function as a ligase rather than a protease. Based on sequence homology of butelase 1, we identified AEPs and PALs from the cyclic peptide-producing plants Viola yedoensis (Vy) and Viola canadensis (Vc) of the Violaceae family. Using a crystal structure of a PAL obtained at 2.4-Å resolution coupled to mutagenesis studies, we discovered ligase-activity determinants flanking the S1 site, namely LAD1 and LAD2 located around the S2 and S1' sites, respectively, which modulate ligase activity by controlling the accessibility of water or amine nucleophile to the S-ester intermediate. Recombinantly expressed VyPAL1-3, predicted to be PALs, were confirmed to be ligases by functional studies. In addition, mutagenesis studies on VyPAL1-3, VyAEP1, and VcAEP supported our prediction that LAD1 and LAD2 are important for ligase activity. In particular, mutagenesis targeting LAD2 selectively enhanced the ligase activity of VyPAL3 and converted the protease VcAEP into a ligase. The definition of structural determinants required for ligation activity of the asparaginyl ligases presented here will facilitate genomic identification of PALs and engineering of AEPs into PALs.

Immobilized Peptide Asparaginyl Ligases Enhance Stability and Facilitate Macrocyclization and Site-Specific Ligation.

The recently discovered peptide asparaginyl ligases (PALs) from cyclotide-producing plants are efficient and versatile tools for protein and peptide engineering. Here, we report immobilization of two glycosylated PALs, butelase-1 and VyPAL2, using three different attachment methods and their applications for peptide engineering. We compared immobilization indirectly via noncovalent affinity capture using NeutrAvidin or concanavalin A agarose beads or directly via covalent coupling of free amines on the enzyme surface with the N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS) ester attached on agarose beads. The catalytic efficiency of immobilized PALs correlated with the distance between the biocatalysts and the solid supports, and in turn, the mobility of enzymes and the accessibility of substrates. Compared to their soluble counterparts, the site separations of immobilized PALs retain higher activity after prolonged storage and confer reusability for over 100 runs with less than 10% activity loss. We also showed that the cyclization and ligation of peptides and proteins with varying shapes and sizes can be accelerated by providing higher concentration of reusable immobilized PALs. These advantages could be exploited for large-scale industrial applications and nanodevices.

Immobilization and Intracellular Delivery of Circular Proteins by Modifying a Genetically Incorporated Unnatural Amino Acid.

Backbone-cyclic proteins are of great scientific and therapeutic interest owing to their higher stability over their linear counterparts. Modification of such cyclic proteins at a selected site would further enhance their versatility. Here we report a chemoenzymatic strategy to engineer site-selectively modified cyclic proteins by combining butelase-mediated macrocyclization with the genetic code expansion methodology. Using this strategy, we prepared a cyclic protein which was modified with biotin or a cell-penetrating peptide at a genetically incorporated noncanonical amino acid, making the cyclization-stabilized protein further amenable for site-specific immobilization and intracellular delivery. Our results point to a new avenue to engineering novel cyclic proteins with improved physicochemical and pharmacological properties for potential applications in biotechnology and medicine.

Enzymatic Engineering of Live Bacterial Cell Surfaces Using Butelase†1.

Butelase-mediated ligation (BML) can be used to modify live bacterial cell surfaces with diverse cargo molecules. Surface-displayed butelase recognition motif NHV was first introduced at the C-terminal end of the anchoring protein OmpA on E. coli cells. This then served as a handle of BML for the functionalization of E. coli cell surfaces with fluorescein and biotin tags, a tumor-associated monoglycosylated peptide, and mCherry protein. The cell-surface ligation reaction was achieved at low concentrations of butelase and the labeling substrates. Furthermore, the fluorescein-labeled bacterial cells were used to show the interactions with cultured HeLa cells and with macrophages in live transgenic zebrafish, capturing the latter's powerful phagocytic effect in action. Together these results highlight the usefulness of butelase 1 in live bacterial cell surface engineering for novel applications.

Total Synthesis of Circular Bacteriocins by Butelase 1.

Circular bacteriocins, ranging from 35 to 70 amino acids, are the largest cyclic peptides produced by lactic acid bacteria to suppress growth of other bacteria. Their end-to-end cyclized backbone that enhances molecular stability is an advantage to survive in pasteurization and cooking processes in food preservation, but becomes a disadvantage and challenge in chemical synthesis. They also contain unusually long and highly hydrophobic segments which pose an additional synthetic challenge. Here we report the total synthesis of the three largest circular bacteriocins, AS-48, uberolysin, and garvicin ML, by an efficient chemoenzymatic strategy. A key feature of our synthetic scheme is the use of an Asn-specific butelase-mediated cyclization of their linear precursors, prepared by microwave stepwise synthesis. Antimicrobial assays showed that the AS-48 linear precursor is inactive at concentrations up to 100 µM, whereas the macrocyclic AS-48 is potently active against pathogenic and drug-resistant bacteria, with minimal inhibitory concentrations in a sub-micromolar range.

Butelase 1 is an Asx-specific ligase enabling peptide macrocyclization and synthesis.

Proteases are ubiquitous in nature, whereas naturally occurring peptide ligases, enzymes catalyzing the reverse reactions of proteases, are rare occurrences. Here we describe the discovery of butelase 1, to our knowledge the first asparagine/aspartate (Asx) peptide ligase to be reported. This highly efficient enzyme was isolated from Clitoria ternatea, a cyclic peptide-producing medicinal plant. Butelase 1 shares 71% sequence identity and the same catalytic triad with legumain proteases but does not hydrolyze the protease substrate of legumain. Instead, butelase 1 cyclizes various peptides of plant and animal origin with yields greater than 95%. With Kcat values of up to 17 s(-1) and catalytic efficiencies as high as 542,000 M(-1) s(-1), butelase 1 is the fastest peptide ligase known. Notably, butelase 1 also displays broad specificity for the N-terminal amino acids of the peptide substrate, thus providing a new tool for C terminus-specific intermolecular peptide ligations.

Butelase-Mediated Macrocyclization of d-Amino-Acid-Containing Peptides.

Macrocyclic compounds have received increasing attention in recent years. With their large surface area, they hold promise for inhibiting protein-protein interactions, a chemical space that was thought to be undruggable. Although many chemical methods have been developed for peptide macrocyclization, enzymatic methods have emerged as a promising new economical approach. Thus far, most enzymes have been shown to act on l-peptides; their ability to cyclize d-amino-acid-containing peptides has rarely been documented. Herein we show that macrocycles consisting of d-amino acids, except for the Asn residue at the ligating site, were efficiently synthesized by butelase 1, an Asn/Asp-specific ligase. Furthermore, by using a peptide-library approach, we show that butelase 1 tolerates most of the d-amino acid residues at the P1'' and P2'' positions.

OSMAC Strategy: A promising way to explore microbial cyclic peptides.

Microbial secondary metabolites are pivotal for the development of novel drugs. However, conventional culture techniques, have left a vast array of unexpressed biosynthetic gene clusters (BGCs) in microorganisms, hindering the discovery of metabolites with distinct structural features and diverse biological functions. To address this limitation, several innovative strategies have been emerged. The "One Strain Many Compounds" (OSMAC) strategy, which involves altering microbial culture conditions, has proven to be particularly effective in mining numerous novel secondary metabolites for the past few years. Among these, microbial cyclic peptides stand out. These peptides often comprise rare amino acids, unique chemical structures, and remarkable biological function. With the advancement of the OSMAC strategy, a plethora of new cyclic peptides have been identified from diverse microbial genera. This work reviews the progress in mining novel compounds using the OSMAC strategy and the applications of this strategy in discovering 284 microbial cyclic peptides from 63 endophytic strains, aiming to offer insights for the further explorations into novel active cyclic peptides.

Biomimetic synthesis of cyclic peptides using novel thioester surrogates.

Acyl shifts involving N-S and S-S rearrangements are reactions central to the breaking of a peptide bond and forming of thioester intermediates in an intein-catalyzed protein splicing that ultimately leads to the formation of a new peptide bond by an uncatalyzed S-N acyl shift reaction. To mimic these three acyl shift reactions in forming thioesters and the subsequent peptide ligation, here we describe the development of two 9-fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl (Fmoc)-compatible thioester surrogates that can undergo uncatalyzed N-S, S-S, and S-N acyl shifts for preparing thioesters and cyclic peptides. These surrogates were incorporated as a C-terminal amido moiety of a target peptide using Fmoc chemistry by solid-phase synthesis, and then transformed into a thioester or thiolactones via two acyl shift reactions with or without the presence of an external thiol under acidic conditions. The proposed intein-mimetic thioester surrogates were prepared using readily available starting materials including N-methyl cysteine or 2-thioethylbutylamide. A key functional moiety shared in their design is the thioethylamido (TEA) moiety, which is essential to effect a proximity-driven N-S acyl shift under a favorable five-member ring transition in the breaking of a peptide bond. Thus, the tandem series of acyl shifts effected by a TEA moiety in a thioester surrogate together with a thioethylamino moiety of an N-terminal Cys residue in a linear peptide precursor are chemical mimics of an intein, as they mediate both excision and ligation reactions in forming cyclic peptides including cyclic conotoxin and sunflower trypsin inhibitor described herein.

Engineering protein theranostics using bio-orthogonal asparaginyl peptide ligases.

Background: Protein theranostics integrate both diagnostic and treatment functions on a single disease-targeting protein. However, the preparation of these multimodal agents remains a major challenge. Ideally, conventional recombinant proteins should be used as starting materials for modification with the desired detection and therapeutic functionalities, but simple chemical strategies that allow the introduction of two different modifications into a protein in a site-specific manner are not currently available. We recently discovered two highly efficient peptide ligases, namely butelase-1 and VyPAL2. Although both ligate at asparaginyl peptide bonds, these two enzymes are bio-orthogonal with distinguishable substrate specificities, which can be exploited to introduce distinct modifications onto a protein. Methods: We quantified substrate specificity differences between butelase-1 and VyPAL2, which provide orthogonality for a tandem ligation method for protein dual modifications. Recombinant proteins or synthetic peptides engineered with the preferred recognition motifs of butelase-1 and VyPAL2 at their respective C- and N-terminal ends could be modified consecutively by the action of the two ligases. Results: Using this method, we modified an EGFR-targeting affibody with a fluorescein tag and a mitochondrion-lytic peptide at its respective N- and C-terminal ends. The dual-labeled protein was found to be a selective bioimaging and cytotoxic agent for EGFR-positive A431 cancer cells. In addition, the method was used to prepare a cyclic form of the affibody conjugated with doxorubicin. Both modified affibodies showed increased cytotoxicity to A431 cells by 10- and 100-fold compared to unconjugated doxorubicin and the free peptide, respectively. Conclusion: Bio-orthogonal tandem ligation using two asparaginyl peptide ligases with differential substrate specificities is a straightforward approach for the preparation of multifunctional protein biologics as potential theranostics.

Characterization and application of natural and recombinant butelase-1 to improve industrial enzymes by end-to-end circularization.

Butelase-1, an asparaginyl endopeptidase or legumain, is the prototypical and fastest known Asn/Asp-specific peptide ligase. It is highly useful for engineering and macrocyclization of peptides and proteins. However, certain biochemical properties and applications of naturally occurring and recombinant butelase-1 remain unexplored. Here we report methods to increase the yield of natural and bacterial expressed recombinant butelase-1 and how they can be used to improve the stability and activity of two important industrial enzymes, lipase and phytase, by end-to-end circularization. First, the yield of natural butelase-1 was increased 3-fold to 15 mg kg-1 by determining its highest distribution which is found in young tissues, such as shoots. The yield of recombinantly-produced soluble butelase-1 was improved by promoting cytoplasmic disulfide folding, codon changes, and truncation of the N-terminal pro-domain. Natural and recombinant butelase-1 displayed similar ligase activity, physical stability, and salt tolerance. Furthermore, the processing and glycosylation sites of natural and recombinant butelase-1 were determined by proteomic analysis. Storage conditions for both forms of butelase-1, frozen or lyophilized, were also optimized. Cyclization of lipase and phytase mediated by either soluble or immobilized butelase-1 was highly efficient and simple, and resulted in increased thermal stability and enhanced enzymatic activity. Overall, improved production of butelase-1 can be exploited to improve the biocatalytic efficacy of lipase and phytase by end-to-end cyclization. In turn, ligase-improved enzymes could be a general and environmentally friendly strategy for producing more stable and efficient industrial enzymes.

Ligase-Controlled Cyclo-oligomerization of Peptides.

A biomimetic one-step ligase-catalyzed cyclo-oligomerization mediated by butelase 1, an Asn/Asp-specific ligase, is introduced that is time-, concentration-, length-, and sequence-dependent. This reaction yields cyclic mono-, di-, tri-, and tetramers from peptide precursors containing 3-15 amino acids ended with Asn and a His-Val tail. The cyclomonomers were favored when the peptide lengths were >9 amino acids. A turn-forming Pro residue at the P2 position favored the formation of higher-order cyclo-oligomers.

Butelase 1-Mediated Ligation of Peptides and Proteins.

Structurally, butelase 1 is a cysteine protease of the asparaginyl endoprotease (AEP) family, but functionally, it displays intense Asn/Asp-specific (Asx) ligase activity and is virtually devoid of protease activity. Butelase 1 recognizes specifically a C-terminal Asx-containing tripeptide motif, Asx-His-Val, to form an Asx-Xaa peptide bond (Xaa = any amino acid), either intramolecularly or intermolecularly, resulting in cyclic peptides or site-specific modified peptides/proteins, respectively. Our work in the past 4 years has validated that butelase 1 is a potent and versatile tool for peptide and protein modification. Here we describe our protocols using butelase 1 for efficient and site-specific peptide and protein ligation, N-terminal labeling, preparation of thioesters, and bioconjugation of dendrimers. Additionally, we provide an example using butelase 1 for protein cyclization in combination with genetic code expansion in order to incorporate unnatural building blocks.

Peptidomic Identification of Cysteine-Rich Peptides from Plants.

Plant cysteine-rich peptides (CRPs) constitute a majority of plant-derived peptides with high molecular diversity. This protocol describes a rapid and efficient peptidomic approach to identify a whole spectrum of CRPs in a plant extract and decipher their molecular diversity and bioprocessing mechanism. Cyclotides from C. ternatea are used as the model CRPs to demonstrate our methodology. Cyclotides exist naturally in both cyclic and linear forms, although the linear forms (acyclotide) are generally present at much lower concentrations. Both cyclotides and acyclotides require linearization of their backbone prior to fragmentation and sequencing. A novel and practical three-step chemoenzymatic treatment was developed to linearize and distinguish both forms: (1) N-terminal acetylation that pre-labels the acyclotides; (2) conversion of Cys into pseudo-Lys through aziridine-mediated S-alkylation to reduce disulfide bonds and to increase the net charge of peptides; and (3) opening of cyclic backbones by the novel asparaginyl endopeptidase butelase 2 that cleaves at the native bioprocessing site. The treated peptides are subsequently analyzed by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry using electron transfer dissociation fragmentation and sequences are identified by matching the MS/MS spectra directly with the transcriptomic database.

Macrocyclic Antimicrobial Peptides Engineered from ω-Conotoxin.

The potent calcium channel blocker ω-conotoxin MVIIA is a linear cystine-knot peptide with multiple basic amino acids at both termini. This work shows that macrocyclization of MVIIA linking two positive-charge terminal clusters as a contiguous segment converts a conotoxin into an antimicrobial peptide. In addition, conversion of disulfide bonds to amino butyric acids improved the antimicrobial activity of the cyclic analogs. Ten macrocyclic analogs, with or without disulfide bonds, were prepared by both Boc and Fmoc chemistry using native chemical ligation. All cyclic analogs were active against selected Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria with minimal inhibitory concentrations in a low µM range. In contrast, MVIIA and its linear analog were inactive at concentrations up to 0.5 mM. The cyclic analogs also showed 2 to 3-fold improved chemotactic activity against human monocytes THP-1 compared with MVIIA. Reduction of molecular stability against thermal and acid treatment due to the reduced number of disulfide crosslinks can be partly restored by backbone cyclization. Together, these results show that macrocyclization and side chain modification of a linear conopeptide lead to a gain-of-function, which brings a new perspective in designing and engineering of peptidyl therapeutics.